Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutStreet Light Installation U - 86 - 040 Augusta Richmond GA DOCUMENT NAME: D l'r(7 AR,fj' "''''T o-t IhJ\). TS 1'1'" 0 fJc CO () oJ,s. ~, I; d 1,/991 DOCUMENT TYPE: ee.p" IGT S YEAR: ) C\ q9 BOX NUMBER: '1 FILE NUMBER: 1 ~ } 9 it, NUMBER OF PAGES: I to 1 _~..-,~....-.-...-,:..........___..-;ua"al :m.~~:,!,~~:~~~1,J~'" .- . t, e' .....-: ,. 17 " D ~TMENT OF AUDITS AND ACCOUNTS SALFS RATIo DMSION 254 Washington Street, S.W':, Suite 214 Atlanta, Georgia 30334-8400 JAMES v: lIARMON DIRECTOR (404) 65&0492 CLAUDE L VlacERS STATE AUDITOR (404) 656-2174 April 21, 1999 The followin report includes the state wide equalized 100% digest for school tax purposes from the ttiO study for calendar year 1998. Each digest is computed by school district and includer a sale assessment ratio and adjusted 100% digest of each district. These digests are s bject to change resulting from hearings, arbitration or legal actions. \ .~ 1998 SAI,ES RATIO STIllY STATEWIDE EQUAI~IZF.D ADJlJSTED SCHOOL PROPERTY TAX DIGEST APRn~ 21, 1999 SALES ASSESSMENT ADJUSTED CODE SCHOOL DISTRICT RATIO 100% DIGEST 001 APPLING 37.80 $ 1,574,930,088 002 A TK.INSON 38.10 267,229,701 003 BACON 34.82 412,351,664 004 BAKER 39.28 252,673,564 005 ' BALDWIN 36.77 1,493,899,167 006 BANKS 39.09 901,684,269 007 BARROW 39.32 2,209,106,489 008 BARTOW 38.34 2,988,793,194 009 BEN HILL 36.38 698,333,645 010 BERRIEN 31.20 736,313,430 011 BmB 34.74 8,860,945,286 012 BLECKLEY 35.28 413,241,922 013 BRANTLEY 38.98 430,742,607 014 BROOKS 37.99 628,547,056 015 BRYAN 37.95 1,050,227,025 016 BULLOCH 37.00 2,473,723,900 017 BURKE 40.19 4,364,647,230 018 BUTTS 39.62 834,125,991 019 CALHOUN 32.71 296,695,437 020 CAMDEN 39.99 1,662,307,223 021 CANDLER 39.82 374,790,279 022 CARROLL 37.13 2,628,405,839 023 CATOOSA 31. 75 2,425,678,177 024 CHARLTON 35.75 471,429,034 025 CHATIIAM 38.98 14,235,917,564 026 CHATIAHOOCHEE 37.81 98,253,084 027 CHAITOOGA 36.66 805,880,685 028 CHEROKEE 39.31 8,182,224,167 029 CLARKE 39.11 4,887,557,177 030 CLAY 39.10 170,164,242 031 CLAYTON Estimated 14,211,232,269 032 CLINCH 37.70 382,335,289 033 COBB 36.20 39,238,264,568 034 COFFEE 39.05 1,554,828,780 035 COLQUITI 40.00 1,485,316,470 036 COLUMBIA 38.40 4,879,362,707 037 COOK 36.95 642,227,398 , 038 COWETA 36.33 4,882,175,794 039 CRAWFORD 35.99 400,418,659 040 CRISP 35.09 1,027,237,252 'f 1998 SAIJES RATIO STIIDV STATEWIDE EQlJAI,IZED ADnrSTED SCHOOL PROPERTY TAX DIGEST APRll.. 21, 1999 SALES ASSESSMENT ADJUSTED CODE SCHOOL DISTRICT RATIO 100% DIGEST 041 DADE ' 32.07 $ 547,896,281 042 DAWSON 28.54 1,282,453,469 043 DECATUR 35.07 1,586,077,658 044 DEKALB 37.28 .37,048,272,064 045 DODGE 32.82 677,908,615 046 DOOLY 40.00 522,812,465 047 DOUGHERTY 38.72 4,675,201,222 048 DOUGLAS 35.16 4,929,721,812 049 EARLY 36.79 807,220,370 050 ECHOLS 37.03 178,408,503 ,051 EFFINGHAM 39.52 1,732, III ,529 052 ELBERT 35.13 918,832,383 053 EMANUEL 38.54 784,440,489 054 EVANS 38.78 397,719,762 055 FANNIN 37.20 1,085,299,462 056 FA YETIE 38.36 6,846,084,415 057 FLOYD 36.59 3,585,140,709 058 FORSYTH 36.98 8,122,142,034 059 FRANKLIN 35.03 1,065,897,935 060 FULTON 37.83 40,922,058,535 061 GILMER 33.67 1,461,195,819 062 GLASCOCK. 38.47 138,221,089 063 GLYNN 36.94 5,870,908,720 064 GORDON 37.34 1,412,206,004 065 GRADY 38.35 1,074,541,500 066 GREENE 40.00 1,118,858,000 067 GWINNEIT 34.90 37,755,958,911 068 HABERSHAM 35.18 1,966,219,888 069 HALL 34.27 6,129,483,369 070 HANCOCK 40.25 435,431,388 071 HARALSON 38.06 796,038,067 072 HARRIS 39.75 1,364,276,119 073 HART 36.96 1,458,004,626 074 HEARD 34.39 650,103,090 075 HENRY 37.63 6,779,448,277 076 HOUSTON 38.16 4,575,693,295 077 IRWIN 38.26 425,962,453 078 JACKSON Estimated 1,711,133,179 079 JASPER 39.08 657,968,137 080 JEFF DAVIS 40.00 622,965,394 :. 1998 SALRS RATIO STIllY STATEWIDE EQUAI,IZED ADnJSTED SCHOOL PROPERTY TAX DIGEST APRIL 21, 1999 SALES ASSESSMENT ADJUSTED CODE SCHOOL DISTRICT RATIO 100% DIGEST 081 JEFFERSON 40.00 $ 760,496,405 082 JENKINS 36.52 341,832,184 083 JOHNSON 32.18 289,853,878 084 JONES 37.18 984,488,378 085 LAMAR 36.19 743,923,329 086 LANIER 39.74 193,508,248 087 LAURENS 38.13 1,328,054,260 088 LEE 39.56 1,088,427,604 089 LffiERTY 37.01 1,547,556,493 090 LINCOLN 35.00 335,846,808 091 LONG 37.77 275,060,811 092 LOWNDES 35.48 2,023,483,844 093 LUMPKIN 34.33 1,216,767,190 094 MACON 38.93 651,858,202 095 MADISON 37.69 1,019,498,310 096 MARION 37.84 291,070,846 097 MCDUFFIE 35.06 986,921,543 098 MCINTOSH 37.12 479,626,496 099 MERIWETHER 31.61 867,260,980 100 MILLER 32.38 331,404,670 101 MITCHELL 34.80 1,121,790,759 102 MONROE 37.73 2,230,703,439 103 MONTGOMERY 36.82 239,677,437 104 MORGAN 35.10 1,257,632,672 105 MURRAY 38.87 1,424,749,942 106 MUSCOGEE 37.72 8,792,051,351 107 NEWTON 38.49 3,225,772,846 108 OCONEE 40.22 1,584,272,301 109 OGLETHORPE 39.36 5,62,708,655 110 PAULDING 33.13 3,147,761,678 III PEACH 36.36 878,463,864 ll2 PICKENS 39.19 1,403,383,422 ll3 PIERCE 35.59 580,918,138 ll4 PIKE 32.75 652,591,575 ll5 POLK 41.98 1,396,589,802 ll6 PULASKI 33.10 408,110,927 ll7 PUlNAM 39.00 1,464,828,134 ll8 QUTIMAN 40.00 109,670,145 ll9 RABUN 35.61 1,861,351,056 120 RANDOLPH 34.46 321,067,204 , 1998 SAI,ES RATIO STUDY STATEWIDE EQUAI,IZED ADJUSTED SCHOOI~ PROPERTY TAX DIGEST APRn~ 21, 1999 SALES ASSESSMENT ADJUSTED CODE SCHOOL DISTRICT RATIO 100% DIGEST 121 RICHMOND 38.98 $ 8,976,381,437 122 ROCKDALE 38.08 4,450,425,229 123 SCHLEY 33.87 165,985,194 124 SCREVEN 35.62 613,701,652 125 SEMINOLE 35.42 433,144,922 126 SPALDING 32.27 2,861,449,225 127 STEPHENS 39.17 1,398,390,029 128 STEWART 38.74 227,269,784 129 SUMTER 39.96 1,397,112,635 130 TALBOT 37.95 311,460,498 131 TALIAFERRO 35.51 114,695,260 132 TATINALL 36.99 632,039,714 133 TAYLOR 39.21 338,922,098 134 TELFAIR 37.03 488,823,717 135 TERRELL 37.68 463,179,134 136 THOMAS 36.10 1,214,724,252 137 TIFf 39.78 1,965,195,117 138 TOOMBS 37.75 511,277,901 139 TOWNS 37.66 826,904,406 140 TREUTLEN 37.83 165,659,547 141 lROUP 39.06 3,309,539,566 142 TIJRNER 39.98 441,141,323 143 TWIGGS 33.70 593,440,893 144 UNION 38.98 1,208,036,450 145 UPSON 31.37 1,334,377,070 146 WALKER 40.00 2,472,575,701 147 WALTON 36.63 2,789,139,614 148 WARE 36.36 1,401,593,684 149 WARREN 32.70 300,299,645 150 WASHINGTON 38.00 1,127,~9,869 151 WAYNE 36.59 1,405,066,760 152 WEBSTER 39.81 130,202,688 153 WHEELER 39.51 196,736,403 154 WlllTE 36.74 1,280,305,740. 155 WInTFIELD 36.89 3,051,297,499 156 WILCOX 35.36 301,811,548. 157 WILKES 38.76 625,454,276 I 158 WILKINSON 36.30 755,218,167 159 WORTH 40.00 969,773,223 i 1998 SALES RATIO STIllY STATEWIDE EQUAI,IZRD ADJUSTED SCHOOL PROPRRTY TAX DIGEST APRIL 21,1999 SALES ASSESSMENT ADJUSTED CODE SCHOOL DISTRICT RATIO 100% DIGEST 202 ATLANTA(DEKALB) 37.28 $ 1,352,188,218 203 ATLANTA(FUL TON) 37.83 32,308,094,975 204 BREMEN(CARROLL) 92.83 19,352,320 205 BREMEN(HARALSON) 95.15 181,845,221 206 BUFORD(GWINNETT) 34.90 741,708,022 207 BUFORD(HALL) 34.27 20,372,170 208 CALHOUN 37.34 1,163,565,902 209 CARROLLTON , 37.13 1,171,067,518 210 CARTERSVILLE 38.34 1,676,033,668 211 ClllCKAMAUGA 40.00 97,386,066 212 COMMERCE Estimated 250,816,299 213 DALTON 92.23 2,630,563,820 214 DECATUR 46.60 1,131,344,428 215 DUBLIN 44.80 888,230,928 216 GAINESVILLE 85.68 2,345,168,874 218 JEFFERSON Estimated 320,765,343 220 MARIEIT A 36.20 4,770,664,966 221 PELHAM 34.80 91,012,495 222 ROME 36.59 2,126,963,335 223 SOCIAL CIRCLE(W ALTON) 36.63 214,252,486 224 THOMASVILLE 36.10 1,058,547,309 225 TRION 36.66 223,468,687 226 V ALDOSTA 35.48 2,460,263,205 227 VIDALIA(MONTGOMERY) 36.82 19,424,362 228 VIDALIA(TOOMBS) 37.75 566,765,510 229 SOCIAL CIRCLE (NEWTON) 38.49 924,344 SUB-TOTAL - CITIES $ 57,830,790,471 SUB-TOTAL - COUNTIES 429,326,203,055 100% STATE DIGEST $ 487,156,993,526 . . . COUNTY: RICHMOND . 5 ALE 5 RAT I 0 5 T U D Y 1 998 . . . . - - . . DEPARTMENT OF AUDITS AND ACCOUNTS SALES RATIo DMSION 254 Washington Street, S.~, Suite 214 Adanta, Georgia 30334.8400 JAMES V; fuRMON DIRECTOR (404) 656-0492 . CLAUDE 1.. VICKERS STATE AUDITOR (404) 656-2174 April 21, 1999 . As required by Georgia Code 48-5-274, the State Auditor hereby delivers to each county and independent school system, the sum of the current equalized adjusted school property tax digest. These digests are subject to changes resulting from hearings, arbitration's, or legal requirements. . The study was based on property transfers during 1997. These transfers were supplemented by appraisals. The values of these sales and appraisals were matched to assessments on the 1998 county tax digest. The following information contains the detailed data covering the complete listing of all parcels used in the study for each particular jurisdiction. The following page portrays. a statistical summary of all classes of property. . Each county governing authority, each governing authority of a municipality having an independent school system, and each local board of education, will have a right, upon written request made within 30 days after receipt of the digest information, to refer the question of correctness of the current equalized adjusted school property tax digest of the local school system to: . Department of Audits and Accounts James V. Harmon, Director 254 Washington Street, S.W., Room 214 Atlanta, Georgia 30334-8400 . A hearing will be scheduled within 15 days of receipt of request. If you have any questions concerning your right for a hearing please contact our office at (404) 656-0492. If there are any adjustments made due to hearings or arbitration, a finalized report will be delivered on or about November 15th. Any counties that have not requested a hearing should consider this their final report. . Weare aware of discrepancies in digest data from various counties. Corrections to this data should be re-certified to the Department of Audits and Department of Revenue. . . County: 121 RICHMOND . 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY TOTAL NUMBER OF SAMPLES: 2,236 RATIO FOR COUNTY: 38.98 . PROPERTY TYPE TOTAL NUMBER RATIO . AGRICULTURAL SALES 25 35.62 AGRICULTURAL APPRAISALS . RESIDENTIAL SALES 2,072 38.99 RESIDENTIAL APPRAISALS . COMMERCIAL SALES 103 38.81 COMMERCIAL APPRAISALS 34 38.85 INDUSTRIAL SALES 1 33.38 . INDUSTRIAL APPRAISALS 1 47.66 . TOTAL NUMBER RATIO . SALES 2,201 38.98 APPRAISALS 35 38.97 TOTAL 2,236 38.98 . - - . CODE: 121 COUNTY: RICHMOND . 1. SALES RATIO STUDY: NUMBER OF PROPERTIES IN STUDY. ....................... .... MEDIAN RATIO............................................ 2,236 38.98 . . 2. ASSESSMENT DATA FROM 1998 COUNTY DIGEST: REAL PROPERTY............................................ 2,201,415,941 PERSONAL PROPERTy........................................ 862 ,409,087 MOTOR VEHICLES........................................... 310,222,760 GROSS DIGEST FOR LOCALLY ASSESSED........................ 3,374,047,788 . . 3. ADJUSTED 100% DIGEST COMPUTATIONS: REAL PROPERTY = 2,201 ,415,941 38.98% = 5,647,552,440 PERSONAL PROPERTY = 862,409,087 38.98% = 2,212,439,936 . MOTOR VEHICLES = 310,222,760 40.00% = 775,556,900 100% VALUE FOR LOCALLY ASSESSED PROPERTY................. 8,635,549,276 . *4. 100% VALUE OF PUBLIC UTILITY PROPERTY................ .... 339,332,161 100% VALUE OF TIMBER..................................... 1,500,000 TOTAL 100% ADJUSTED COUNTY DIGEST........................ 8,976,381,437 . * INFORMATION SUPPLIED BY THE STATE REVENUE DEPARTMENT - -. -- - - . . . . . . . . . (') o c = r+ '< ~ ~ ~ :D ... (') = ~ o = CI ~ 10 10 lD I/) > I"'" m I/) :D > -I ... o I/) -I e CI -< ~ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 I/) 0 ~ ~ 0 ~ ~ ~ 0 0 ~ ~ ~ ~ 0 ~ .. ~ 0 0 0 UI ~ ~ W 01 10 ~ 10 01 ~ UI = EI 01 ~ ~ ~ UI ~ ~ W UI UI ~ UI UI UI 0'0 0 Q 0 W ~ ~ W - - lD W ~ - 10 10 .... CD >-1 >1"'" >= >= > III >:D >:D >c:. > ::e > 0 >1/) >1:) >1"'" ~~ ~> -II/) CI > Clm ClO Clm ClO CI> CI> CI> CI > tII m ~p~ tIIO tIIO _e .. CD ~: ~m ~~ ~~ ~~ ~~ ~g ~~ ~~ :D> m:D CI< ClI/) :i!g >C .... ~ I/) me :DI/) e... ml/) 'a .... I/) 1/)'" 1/)> -< m oe 1"'"= I"'"m I/) .. CD (') < ~ I"'" :D I"'" I"'" :D -< 1/)> I"'" (') I"'" >1"'" 1/)-1 '< "'I ~= ~;;; c:.1"'" c:. c:. m m tII > e ~I/) ~= >m -II"'" ;> CD 0> 0 om ~~ em em 0= =(') I:)CI I"'" ... "'I :D :D :D 1/)= = I:) = I:) = = 0 == :D:D :DtII -I." 1/)1"'" "'1"'" m... :DI"'" -ItII mo =c:. m I"'" m-l m-l ...:D ...> >m -<... :D:D 0> > m:D 0 ...m =:D .,,~ :D I/) I"'" =m =m -ICI m:D CI-< I"'" ~~ = ~~ -10 = I/) I/) >> = m tII ... ...:D ...:D >> I"'" -< :DI"'" >1"'" = - - I:) "'1/) m~ m." >." = ."m -I -< ...~ ...m == ." CI ." I/) c:.I:) = ... :D :D (') I"'" I/) > 1"'"> (') :Dill .... m-< I/) m... ... (')... (')... - CI = = Nm 0 ca I:) I"'" = - > 01/) 01/) :DtII I"'" >- CI "'1/) CD 1:)< (') (') om om e e m I/) -> :D ... m-l coo -<... > c:. ~I/) ~I/) ."... m :D 3~ > ... :Dm r+ > -I :D "'1"'" - ... -1m CI = - ... ... ...CI ." tII "'1"'" m ::e = = =m ... om e m :D ... (') (') :D I"'" = -I I/) ::e ... I"'" I"'" I/) 0 m~ I"'" 0 = I"'" 0 ~ m ...:D m ... e... m (') :D =~ , ~ ...= = (') I/) CI 1/)(') > I/) m ... = - W - 2 N ~ ~ - ~ ~ ~ 0 - ~I"'" 0 ~ W ~ ~ ~ ~ Q ~ ~ CD ~ .. .. CD ~ ~ 10 ~ ~ 10 Q - Q CD 'a = ~ I"'" ~ - - Q, 0 UI N 01 0 0 ~ 0 ~ - ." - - 01 ~ - - ~ .. CI ~~ ~UI ~ W o~ ~ ~ QW ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~-I Q "'I .... lD UI 0 W lD~ ~ lDW CD ~ ~~ 0 UI ~Q 0 W n coo UI 0 ~ - - UI~ 1"'"0 UlW UI~ ~ W ~ IO~ III Q CD r+ ~ <D I"'"Q ~ - 01 Q ~ 1"'"0 1"'"> ....~ ~ 0 ~ tllUI 0 (') m ~ CI ... -(') O~ -I/) 1"'"1/) ." I"'" ." UI> 01:) tII(') I"'" I"'" m r- -0 (') 0 UI~ > ::0 ... = 0 0 m I/) .. )( I"'" _ tII OCl tile -I CI> = tII CI 0::0 < r- = -I m >tII 0 1"'"-1 CI :D I"'" m 1"'"0 CI :D m tIIQ, m CI I"'" ~ = till"'" ... m :D 0 0 = :D I:) m (,)CI I"'"m (') ... I/) >:D = > -I I"'" m I/) I"'" > tII ~ I:) -I 0 CI = 0 CI -I I"'" 1/)1"'" c:.:D = = r+ :D :D 0 mm 0 > CI ... I/) ~ CI = I/) (') 0 < CI :D I:) -I m -I CI ~ m :D = :D I/) :D ...:D = ~ m r+ (') m ... CI e m "'I 0 m < :D m -< -I CD e -I m ... CD :D < r+ -I m 0 0 0 0 - ~o ~o 0 0 0 ~ 0 0 00 0 >CI W UI UI - ~ ~ ~ ~ W 10 0 CD lD W Q n .. - - - - - 10- 10 - - - - - - - ~- - "'I r+ 0 N ~ ~ ~ 10 0 10 0 ~ ~ 0 ~ ~ 0 QO ~ CD CD Q 0 Q 0 0 - - CD Q UI ~ 10 ~ ~ ~ .. - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ca I/) 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 10 CD 0 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ .... Q, CICI CD CD CD CD ~UI QUI -UI ~~ ~UI ~g: UIUI ~UI ~UI ~UI WUI ~UI -UI ~UI UIUI Q,Q, UIUI CD UI IOUI UI~ ~ 01 ~UI CD UI ~ 01 ~~ ~Q ~Q ~UI IO~ 00 UlQ ~lD UIUI ~ 01 CD ~ UI~ ~ - QW ~IO WUI OlD ~UI ~o ." tII 0 10 0 Q 0 W 10 0 ~ .. 0 ca 0 CD ~ :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D (') :D :D "'-1 m m m m m m m m m m m m 0 m m "'1'< I/) I/) I/) I/) I/) I/) I/) I/) I/) I/) I/) I/) ~ I/) I/) 0'0 'a CD "'1/) "'I .. tit tit tit ........ tit tit tit W tit tit tit tit tit tit tit tit ~ tit W n CD CD W Q CD UI ~ - ~ UI 01 W Q UI W 01 CD ~OI ~UI ~ ~o - UI en - UI W ~o ~ 0 ~IO ~o ~ 10 0 10 0 10 0 0 CD 10 10 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 > coo > coo tit tit tit a CD tit tit tit ~ tit tit tit tit tit tit ~ tit - o coo W - ~ W ~ tit tit W ~ ~ - ~ ~ - ~ c coo ~ ~ CD 0 ~ CD CD 0 ~ ~ 0 ~ - 01 ~ = a ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ r+ CD ~ Q 0 ~ ~ Q 01 0 ~ 01 ~ 10 W ~ 0 = ~ CD 0 ~ 0 0 0 0 0 CD Q Q ~ 0 r+ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 W ~ ~ ~ W UI UI ~ ~ W W W ~ ~ ~ :D CD - - W ~ ~ - 0 CD Q ~ ~ - 0 .. . r+ ~ 10 ~ ~ UI W W ~ 0 01 ~ ~ UI W 0 .... 0 ~ .,. 0 W W W ~ ~ ~ W UI ~ W 0 0 o o c =' .. "< ~ N ~ :a 104 o :c 3: o Z Q ~ CO CO CID Ul > r- m Ul :a > -I ... o Ul -I C CI < N 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Ul ~ N N 0 ~ 0 ~ N 0 N ~ 0 N 0 ~ III CO ...... N 0) ~ CII 0) N 0 CID 0 ...... CO CO 0) Z 9 CO CII 0 0 CoI CID W CoI 0) ...... CID N CID CO ~ O'U 0 ...... CoI ~ N ~ 0 0) CoI N CO CII 0) 0 ...... . .... CD >C1 >"'Ol >:a >:a ~~ >Z > c.. >t:l > m >Q >"'Ol >:a >:a >Z >> -IUl r-... r-> r- r-... r- 0 r- > r- :a r- r-:a r-c r-... r- t:l 0 Q t:l III CD r- Z r-c r-C1 r-O m -I m:a m 0 mm llIlllll llIl> llIlr- llIl "Il >llIl O:a QZ )C .... m~ mr- m m :c ~~ ~~ ~ ~ :::em :ar- :a~ :ao mr- "Il UlQ ...m 'U .... <... Z~ ZlIO Z> ...Z ... > ...m >:c :am >-1 -I> Ul :a III CD Z :a z:a z:c z:a Z -I t:l~ t:l zm -I < ... O:c 0 "< , r- Ul Ulm c..Q "'OlQ Q... Qr- Q m :a :c llIl :cc.. Q:a :a r- Zllll CD ... ~~ m :a m Z m mz m -Ie -I~ -I c..Q t:l m 0 , Ulr- :a... mllll :a t:l :a:c :a 0 c..m :a llIl 0> m... Q :c "Illlll >... ...m 3:Z Q... -I 0 :a > QZ llIlm 3: 0 :c< oz :::eo >llIl 0 Z m-l ...0 :a 31::0 r-3: ;Il;Q Z r- > ... Ul >llIl Z... :ao ...3: c< =' >Q -I > r- Q ...Z 104m m> ... > "IlO r- :allll Q t:l zm r- > :::e> :c :a r-Ul <:c o Z :co r-:a ~< "'Ol m Ul _ r- Q llIl > :a r- ...r- mQ >Z < - r- m .... m :a c zm ... ... z ZUl "'Olt:l - :c ... < ca ... Q i:: mz llIl :co m-l :a 0 ~ z > CD r- >m 0 c ...0 - Ul Ul 0 OJ Q :a 0 104 r- t:l 0 Q Ul:a :a ~ r+ m r- r- 0 0 ... :a m Q z m > :a Ul Q m ... z r- z ... :::e :a z > > m ... 104 Ul 0 ... 0 z z > z 0 ... m c.. z :a 0 ~ 010 ~ ...... ~ ~ N co CoI N CII N ~ i::r- 010 N CD 010 N 0)- 0 0 ...... CID CoI III III 0 ~ 0 CoI co CII~ 0) ~ N 'U =' ~ r- - ~ CoI N ~ - - Q. 0) N CII 0) ON ~ CID 0 ...... CII "Il 010 ...... CID ~ CII 0) N N ~ ~ 0 III Q CoI ~ N o)N W CID CoI 0) - ~ ~CoI CoI CD N CID CID CoI ~ , .... 0) 010 0 UI 0 CoI ClDCoI ~ 0 ~ ~ CoI CoI N N CII ~ CII n .. r-N r-N r-oIO llIlO r- 0 ~ ~C11 CII r-N co CD N 0 ClDN ~ ~ CD .. N CoI 0) r-oIO CD r-o 0 CoI W 0 010 0) ~> r- ....~ CID 010 ~ N o CID- ~ ~ 0 - 0 0 ~ D NUl CDt:l :C"ll ~Ul oIO:C 0 010 ~-I NllIl "Il i:: ...... CID CID 0 c r- llIlC < :a m --I ~~ Ul 0 :a > m 0 N CII >llIl :a Ul III r-> 0 m Ul:a llIlm 0'" > 0-1 > Z N llIl :a r- =' ... ~ m m 0 r- :a Q > Q :c 0 -I llIl r- < llIlQ. llIlr- z o -I r- m m Q :c 0 m 0 r- 0... z llIlUl 0 "Il r- llIl Ul Ul r- :c :a > ... 0 z r-> 0 0 > 0 > m -I -I 0 0 m z ... 0 t:l Ul Q 0 0 -I :a ... z 0 .. r- Q C -I :CQ r- C -I 0 :a z z ~ r- Q :a :a r- Ul :a m :c 0 m 0 :a :a -I Q Ulm llIl -I :a > Ul 0 Ul :::e Q m < Ul :a -I ~ 0 r+ 00 0 Q 0 , Q -I 0 :a z i:: C CD :a C Q Ul ... :a CD ~:a :a -I r- -I .. -I Q r- :a Q 0 ~ ~ ~ 0 0 0 0 0)0 0 00 0 0 ~ ~ 0 0 >Q CID ~ 0 CoI 0) CoI ...... co ~ 010 CII 010 ~ CII ...... n III - - 0)- - - - - 0- - co - - - 0- - - , .. ~ N ~ ~ N N 0 N CoI0 ~ oIO~ N N CoI0 0 CoI CD CD CoI 0) W ...... CoI CoI CD CD CII 010 CD CID ...... ~ 0 III - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ca Ul co CD CO CO CO CD CO CD CO CO CD CD CD CD CO CD 0 ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... .... Q. CI CI III CD CD CD ~C11 CD CII CID CII ......C11 N CII ......C11 ~C11 ~ UI ~i: CID CII NCII NCII N CII NCII ~ CII Q. Q. CoI 0) co...... ~...... N CII OCID OCII WCID CID ...... CID CII oIOCII NCII 010 CD N CII CoI 0) CllCO CII CID COW W CID ~ 0 o CII CON co CII ...... co oIOCII ~ 0 oIOCID ~C11 "Illlll CID CII CoI CoI CoI ...... CO co III 0 ca 0 CD ~ :a :a :a :a :a :a :a :a :a :a 0 :a :a :a :a "Il-l m m m m m m m m m m 0 m m m m ,"< Ul Ul Ul Ul Ul Ul Ul Ul Ul Ul i:: Ul Ul Ul Ul o'U 'U CD "IlUl , III Q .. <<It .... .... .. .. .. .. .. ~ .. .. ~ .. N .. .. .. .. n CD CID CII ~ CD CID N ...... 010 CoI CII ~ ...... ~ ...... CoI CD ~CoI ~ CID 010 CII CII CII 0 CII ...... N ~ 010 ~ CID ~ ~ CD CII CD CD 0 ...... CID 0 0 CII CII CII CoI co 0 0 0 CII 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 > .. > .. 9 CD .. .. .. .. <<It <<It .. .. <<It <<It .. <<It .. 0 .. N N .. CoI N CII CoI ~ CII ~ CID N <<It N ~ C OJ N ~ CII ...... CID CoI 0 ~ 010 0 N 010 CII CID 010 =' a ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ :... ~ .. CD 010 0 ~ N 0 N N N 0 ~ ~ co CD N =' 0 0 N 0 0 0 0 0 0 N N N N 0 010 r+ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 CoI 010 N CoI 010 010 CoI N 010 ~ CoI ~ 010 010 CoI :a CII 0 ...... CD 0 N co CID 0 ...... CD 0 0 CO III r+ 0 ...... ~ N 0 CoI CD 0 0 CID CID CD 0 0 CII .... CII CID CID 0 0 N CII 0 0 0 010 CII 0 CID CID 0 .. . . . . . . . . . . - - - - - - - . . . . . . (') o C :J r+ 'C . N . = ... (') = ~ z a . co co co en . ,... m en = . -I ... o en -I c a < w 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 en . 0 N N 0 . . N 0 0 . 0 . . 0 .. . co w . co 0 ...... ~ ~ co . 0 ...... Ul . z. ~ w co 0 . N ~ ~ co 01 Ul co N W N 0'1:1 . W 01 . ~ Ul N N 0 . . W 01 Ul ~ . .... CD .z .(') .m ~~ ~c: ~~ i~ ~~ .m .,... .~ . en .< .al .~ -I en zm z z. ,...,... ,.... ,...= ,...~ ,.... ,.... ,...... .. CD a,... a3: a= oa o. ~~ -I,... -IZ i~ enm ,...... ,...= ,...Z >C .... men m m t:l ... e. ena enz o 3: 0... o a -IZ t:la t:l= t:l... '1:1 .... =0 =en =,... zm 0 zen en,... zen z= 00 om om O;lll: .. CD enz en enm ;Ill: < en." ao ,... 0,... 0 c zm o z 0-1 om 'C ., 0 o t:l 0 . -1= m ~~ z t:lZ t:l3: = = a a-l a= CD z m z= zo ~o mm ~~ e. . . 3: ~en ,... ., a 0 . ... <a = enm i:~ =0 ...= ~~ -I~ -I en az oc .= ,...... ma =)( <~ =." =. 00 == =. =m 0 .. .~ zo ,...::a z... .... ... .." m= m = = al -I. ma m-l ;!!~ :J < = z,... ... ... m =3: t:l,... ~~ -1< -I 0 m m == ,.... ,...= "'3: 0... m ~en ,... ... -. ,... -I -I,... ,...= .0 ~en ' ~ ~ ~g a a ,...z -Ia -. 0 .z =... < e. ==~ ""-1 Z .... <0 -I -I t:l-. 0 ~~ .::I!! ~~ m . -. ... = CCI ;Ill: z me. ,... ,... ,... -. ,... 3: a =. = CD 0 -. om e. . -. ~m aal ;Ill:'" -. < .-. III 0 =~ e. =... ,.... ~ o. 0 e. 0 <al r+ m ...,... c.. a ::a == z m = 0 = z .. = c.. = 0 o z m = m . en z -. ,...= m ... -1m ,... = en ~ ... ;Ill: 3: c.. z . = en < ." C < al m a a 3: ,... ~ ... = < ~ t:l al = = == . -I = . t:l W W . . . . 0 W N 3: . N W ~ 3:,... N N W ~ ~ ~ 0 0 Ul W W ...... .. .. w . . 0 ...... 0 . '1:1 :J ~ 0 . N N. . W N -. a- 01 0 0 0 0 01 Ul co 0 co ~ 0 Ul 0 01 co 'co N . .. a ow . .N ow .w Ul N N . W N ......Ul ,... NN co o co UlN ., .... .N N co~ COOl ~...... co ~ N ...... 0 co 0 N CON co 0 CON n III 0 ,...~ co N coo 01 0 0 0 ....... ,...N 01 ~co ow ,... 0 Ul 01 CD r+ CO N co . Ul 01 ...... CO ,... . . 0 0 0 ....- ,... 01 0 0 co = .N .z Ul:D - a .... o ~ en ,... ~ a al o~ .= .m 01 ,...~ W... ... t:l ,... Ul:D ,... ... ~ ... m c ... w::a co= ... ." < :D en .. -. m ~ a OZ . CO Z 0 n Ot:l llII,... Z !; COZ llII m m . ,... :J llIIen =m en z . a ;Ill: m ,...,... llIIa en ,...= = a llIIa- ,...a z -I ... llIIn 0 ... ~ (') ,...m l:ll~ al-l Z m ~a 0 en ,...,... = z 0= = ,...en ,... 0 ."en ~ m ,... ."z z = ;Ill:m . t:l m .en = ;Ill:Z g ~ = 0 0= :z: en m 0 t:l... C r+ ~ ~ -I llII~ a ~ -I ;Ill: enz = en~ . 0 en - = ,... = = m m m. = m -I < < . en . m a na 0< m = en 0 mn m = -1= a m r+ m nm -I ... = . m ., < ... llII -I CD a ...a m CD = = r+ . 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 0 2 . 0 0 0 0 .a N ~ co co Ul co ...... N N . co ...... ... n .. -. -. -. -. -. -. -. -. -. -. -. -. -. -. -. ., r+ 0 N W N W N 0 N ... N 0 . . . N CD CD Ul co 0 w 0 . co Ul w co Ul ...... N 0 co .. -. -. -. -. -. -. -. -. -. -. -. -. -. -. -. CCI en co co co co co co co co co co co co co co co CD 0 ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... .... a- aa CD CD CD CD ~Ul COUl NUl UlUl UlUl OIUl .Ul ~Ul . Ul .Ul NUl NUl .Ul .U1 .U1 a- a- ~...... 01 Ul ~...... 01 ...... Ul Ul ......U1 co 01 co 01 OI~ UlUl . ...... U1~ ,01 01 UI 01 OI~ co 001 o. ....... 01 01 co co ......01 Wul ......co W 01 ...... co WOl ul 01 ~w 01 01 ~l:ll co 0 01 01 co co N .. 0 CCI 0 CD ~ = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = ~-I m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m "'C en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en 0'1:1 '1:1 CD ~en ., .. 4It 4It 4It 4It 4It ........ N 4It 4It 4It 4It 4It 4It . . 4It 4It N . 4It n CD N 4It W ...... co ...... co co ul 0 co co N N W CD ul co _ul w ~ N 0 co co UI co ~ ul . ul 0 co UI N co 0 0 ~ CO co co 0 0 ul 0 0 0 0 ul 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 . en . en 51 CD 4It 4It 4It 4It 4It 4It 4It 4It 4It 4It 4It 4It 4It 4It o en CO 4It ... N ~ N N N ul ~ W W ...... ~ ... C III W ~ ~ ell ~ co co ...... UI W N CO N W :J B - - - - - r+ CD ...... 0 co ul co ~ ...... N ell ~ N UI ~ ~ ...... :J N 0 0 ell 0 CO N 0 0 0 0 01 0 01 r+ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ~ ~ ~ w ~ ~ w w ~ w w w w w w = . 0 ... ell ...... 0 ul co N 01 co ~ UI co .. N ~ ~ ~ Cu r+ ell ~ ell N ~ co ...... co 0 w .... ul 0 CO ell . 0 ...... ...... CO W CO ~ CO . 0 n o C :I r+ '< .. N .. :II ... n : 3: o z CI .. CD CD CD en . r- m en :II . -I ... o en -I C CI < 4> 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 en 0 N N N 0 0 .. 0 .. N .. 0 .. N N lit CD UI CD CD 4> ..... W W N W N N ..... CD CD za 0 ..... W W 0 CD CD 4> CD CD CD N 4> N N o "0 CD N W 0 N CD CD W .. CD CD CD UI 4> CD ... (II . en .." .m ...... . n .-1 . ,0; .n .:11 .n .en .m .,0; .:e .:11 ,-I en :11-1 :II. :113: :11:11 :II . :11m :11m :II .". Z 0 z... z zm z... zm lit (II :II Z-l Z CD Z < ~~ ~ ~ " z n3: 0'" -I 0 " 3: ClCD CI < CI r- CI. )C ... ...,0; o -I m :II mm <Z : en." r-,o; C,o; :IIr- men mr- mCl "0 ... z... r-m -I m -I -10 -I ... r-m men -I. m ... ... m. :11-1 :II... :11< lit (II ,,-I CI:II -1m -1-1 :IIC :IIZ m-l :II o :II <en r-z :e n en 0 en. en '< ., -1-1 en 0 oz 00 : " r-CI n r-C/l C/l,o; o z 03: ~q~ (II 0 .0 t.. t.. "'3: z z t.. .:11 r-o . CD zm z en ., zr- CI z g ~ z " -I " CI ~~ Z 0 n" "'-1 r- n C :II r- :II .< : . ClC :m Z-l ."m ::11 :II: t..CI .....< 0 " n ... CI zm - ~. t..r- m... :II'" :II 0 CI :11:11 .z 00 ~~ :II. :I . .m en 3:t.. mCl mm C/l -I m ...:11 <:II 00 :II CD 3: .z ... zr- -I ... 0 Z z : :e... C/l " - .,,< r- n mm m ... zz CI r- 0 _n r-: zt.. z. m z -1m r--I m m 0 :II en C/lm ,0; .... ... t..- r-z m:ll ... : :IIn 0_ -. :II: enz -I r- ea :&: C/l :IIr- en en -I ..... 0 ." Z CDZ -I en ... -I :II (II 0 0 : m 3: :. .. ... .....-1 -IZ _ :II .. ~~ Z :II m mz :II m - n ~"::i r+ r- CD :IIn CD:&: en Cln t.. :11-1 3: r- C < . ...0 :II :II. m-l ... ... t.. :II r- . <z z. n r- . r- z... m : CI n z z :z CD : m m ,0; mn CD r- :II . m C/l r- C 3: m ... z t.. 0 N 0 CD 0 .. w 0 .. .. ~ 0 4> 0 3:r- w ..... N CD 0 CD W .. CD UI UI 4> .. lit lit 0 4> UI CD UI CD 4> ..... ." N CD "0 :I .. 0 .. - a. 0 .. .. 0 CD 0 0 .. N 0 W ." .. N W CD W CD W .. lit CI NN CD 4> "N ....... W.. .. ON .....N .....N en .. UlN CDN ON ., .... 4>N W 4> .. CD CD W N .. "0 4> CD CD . .,,4> Ul UI .. W 4> CD n .. NCD 0 -I 0 CD .. Ul CD 0 r-N "0 0 0 -1< . CDN .. ON II r+ :II CD 4> r-o CD ..... UI r- CD :II :11m .. o Ul .. ...~ 0,0; en 0 W 0 N 0 r- . lID n. 0 .. 0 ~ W'" ... ......" o en ",0; O:&: ..... O. "CI . n m " o :e n oen r- -I CD m -I ... 0'" CDO r- Ulm ..... -1-1 r-r- ... m -I en lit 0-1 r- . 0:11 ."en z r->< o CI 0 . 0 m o z z 0:11 r-:I m n . -IC/l CI m CDCI ~ .CD N -I -I . CD a. CI < : -I ... en n CI z r-. . CD'" m :II -I r-:II ..... r-z 0 m r- :II -I n CD 0 :II . r-..... r- en 0 0 " z z n CD. -I n ... < r- 0 0 W -I :II :II WCD " CD 0 m 0 z ... CD:II r+ .. n CI N 0 :II UlC "'CI r--I r- . - CI ~ : : (;;~ n CI :II ::11 CI :II .m r- < m :II CI ... "'-1 :II CI 4> m m CI en . :II W:II :II : ... C/l CI :II r+ CI ... :II CI ., CD:II N ... :II (II :II r-CI < (II CI r- m r+ CD m :&: ... en n 0 0 CD .. 0 0 .. 0 0 0 .. NO 0 0 .. 0 .CI W CD N UI .. 0 CD mw CD 0 CD W ..... 0 UI n lit - - W - - - - - - - - 4> _ - - - - ., r+ W .. .. .. .. W N 0 .. 0 .. NO 0 W W .. (II (II .. ..... CD CD .. CD CD CD N ..... N ..... .. .. UI lit - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ea en CD CD CD CD CD CD CD CD CD CD CD CD CD CD CD (II 0 ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ... a. CI co (II (II (II (II UlUl "Ul CD UI NUl "UI NUl NUl "UI .. UI NUl CD UI "UI NUl .. Ul "UI a. a. CD Ul N..... CD CD o UI .....4> ~~ "CD UIUI OUl ....... CD Ul CD UI OCD 0..... .....UI o W o CD CDO 4>..... ....... .. CD" ..... CD .....W OCD UlO N CD CDUI CD..... "'CD UI W 4> CD W .. W N CD CD 0 lit 0 ea 0 (II ~ :II :II :II :II n :II :II :II :II :II n :II :II n :II "'-1 m m m m 0 m m m m m 0 m m 0 m .,'< en en en C/l 3: en C/l en en en 3: C/l C/l 3: C/l 0"0 "0 (II ."C/l ., lit (It (It 4It 4It 4It (It ....... (It 4It 4It (It 4It 4It .. (It .. N .. .. .. 4It n (II UI W N CD CD 4> N 4It ~ N CD ..... 0 CD CD (II ;>> N ..... ~CD ~UI N ~UI CD ~CD ~ ~Ul ~O UI UI CD 0 Ul 0 0 CD UI CD UI CD 0 CD CD 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 . .. . .. B (II 4It (It 4It 4It (It (It 4It 4It (It (It 4It (It o .. N (It 4It W .. .. 4> 4It W 4> CD CD W UI ~ C .. N CD CD ..... CD CD W 4> N CD W N CD ..... :I a ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ r+ (II CD CD CD W N CD N 0 N CD W 4> CD 0 CD :I 0 4> CD CD CD 0 0 0 0 0 CD 0 0 0 0 r+ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 W W N 4> N W W 4> W W W W W ~ 4> :II CD 0 4> W CD CD 4> 0 CD ..... N UI CD 0 lit ~ ~ . r+ ..... .. N 4> CD .. .. 4> 0 4> N UI CD .... .. W CD 4> CD CD N 0 .. .. CD ..... CD UI 4> 0 - - . . . . . . . . . . - - - - - . . . . . . . n o C ::I r+ '< ~ N ~ :D ... n ::c ~ ::c CI ... .0 .0 CXI o > r- m o :D > -I ... o o -I C CI < UI 0 0 0 0 0 ~ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 N N N ~ N 0 N 0 0 N N 0 0 N N III ~ ... .0 0 i 0 N CXI ...... ...... ... N ~ CXI 0 ::c a ...... (I) ... ~ N ...... ~ ~ ... 0 ~ CD N (I) 0"1:1 ~ UI ~ 0 .0 ~ N ... (I) ~ ~ 0 ...... Col Col .... CD lllIlllI >r- >lllI >~ >CI > >> >n >e.. >lllI >::e >3: >:Il: >lllI >n -10 >:D <... cr- c... gi C cc ;:~ -I' 0m CIl > 0n 0m :DC :DO III CD no m..... -IC '" Z '" '" '" g~ :Il:r- :Il:CIl ::cz ::cz :DCI :Dr- >C .... ::C0 :D0 :D3: c'" = CIl= "'-1 ...> m::c 3:> mz ...::e ... r- "1:1 .... m::c CIl m <m CIlr- o CIl CIl CCIl zm zz <... 0'" r-m z... zm III CD m < -1m -In -I -1-1 0:D 00 '" z == <-I ",n "'< '< ., -10 e.. lllICI >CI >= > >> 0 0... ='" m ::c -I:Il: -I CD mc 0'" m> 0 CIl 3:-1 Zllll > 0-1 e.. n 0 03: ., z ::c= -Ir- "'= m lllI m> ... ... C ..... lllIO ~~ C0 z." z< z~ zo ::;!f; ::D..... ~~ 0 CIlCll n 3: ."... =::i! ...z ::D3: m = 0 C 0..... ~ -ICIl ::co >r- ~;::! z -I'" ~n:I .,,0 ::I >-1 3:'" CIl C - m 0 > 0 >-1 CCI ::D Cl0 "'-1 ::c z -- -I. ... "'CIl r-CI CI -I n m::c r-m :Il:r- 3:CI > 0::C 0= ... CI ~i:i r- 0 m r-< ::D r-... = -- 'z r- ~ r- r-... ." 0 0 ::e0 ;~ CI e..::c me.. r- ea -I::e m r-z ::Dr- ..... CI... -- m ... >0 >= ... CD ::c ::D nn o -I r- -- '" go < ... Z3: ." .. <-I -- "'CI = r- lllI 0 e..::D m -- m m lllI -- r+ ~ m m n ::D ::D0 = r- > -IlllI ::e > ::D > m Clm -- 0 z -IC ... = -I r- z 0= ::e ." '" m ... ~ < ... -I CI z< m m m r- lllI m 0 > ... r- = r- mCl m > CIl = -In r- CIl > m = z 0 r- mm 0 ::D r- z ... ::D0 r- = 0 < m m r- r- 0... -I n ... 3: >z > Z Col ... ~ ~ ...... ~ N 0 0 ~ ... CJI ~ 3:r- N ~ N N ... ~ ~ ... ... N (I) ...... III III UI 0 .0 N ... N UI 0 ... "1:1 ::I ~ Col ~ -- g, ~ 0 UI 0 0 0 0 N 0 N .0 ." N ... .0 ~ .0 UI III CI CI ~ ON ~ o ~ N ~ ~~ ...~ N'" N ... o ~ O~ "'(1) ., ~ ~O ~ ~~ CJI CJI~ CJI ~2 ~CJ1 CXlO N ColN ......~ 0 n w oz ... CXI~ ... N 0 ...... UlCol o UI Nn UI'" CXlO ...... r- CD r+ Col ... CXI N Col ... UI CXI ::c ~ CXI ....- ::D 0 0 0 lII' 0> E Col - 0 ." ......-1 ;i CI n ~ 0'" o CIl C::D ... = r-< r- ..... ... -- r- lllI ... ::D i 0 ... -I z> r- 0 0 z lII' 011I m z > ... ~ 0 o z 00 z om ... C ...)( CI r- r- ::I = Z r-< '" ~ z = nCl 0 UlZ ~ CIl lllIg, > ... ::c 0 0 N > m lllI~ -I '" CI 0 n = n "'0 -I n z r- n r-< r-o lllI lllIm z -- r- CI :Il: , 0 C 0 r- r- ... (I) ~ r- ..... r-z '" 0 0 ......= lllI CIl CXlm ......3: ClZ 0 m r+ ~ __ CI 0 lllI ... m Nm lllI= lllI ~ n - lllI ::D ::D r- lllI:::I! CIlr- ... -- m < r- 0 CI < r-> -Ir- >CI 0 < ... 0 CI < 0 = -I r+ '" = CI ::D= ., CI lllI mo CI CD , CIl <~ ::D CD ~ m ... r+ n 3: < ... m ... r- ... r- ... c O~ ... ... ... ~ ~ 0 "'0 2 0 ~ 0 0 0 0 00 >CI 0 0 N 0 NN UI...... ~ N .0 Col Col UI .0 n III CJI-- -- -- -- -- ~ -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- N__ ., r+ ......... ... ... ~ ~... ~ "'0 N 2 N N ... ... ... Col'" CD CD ...... 0 CXI Col lit CXI ......CXI UI CD N ... N ~ CXI III -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- ea 0 .0 .0 .0 .0 .0 .0 .0 .0 .0 .0 .0 .0 .0 .0 CD 0 ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... ...... .... g, CICI CD CD NUl CD CD ~UI NUl NUl "'U1 ~UI "'UI "'UI ......UI UIUI ~UI "'UI "'UI "'UI g,g, ......... ...... ...... ... CXI N...... OCXI C ...... CJI UI ~~ u)CXI CD...... ColUl OUl UIUI CXI...... ~Col ~~ 00 ~UI o c ... N "'UI CXI'" 0'" UlN (I)'" CXI...... ......0 "'lllI N 0 N CXI .0 N 0 ~ ...... (I) ... III 0 ea 0 CD ~ = = ::D n n n n = ::D = ::D ::D = ::D = "'-1 m m m 0 0 0 0 m m m m m m m m .,'< 0 0 0 3: 3: 3: 3: 0 CIl 0 CIl 0 0 CIl 0 0"1:1 "1:1 CD > "1:1 "1:1 ., . III . "'0 N ~ ... ., III . - .. . - . ~.... . . ...... (I) III N ~ . . . . . ~ . n CD . .0 ... ... 0 ....N 0 .0 .0 ~ UI CJI ... ~ . CD CXI ...... ~ UI 0 0 0 CXI N N ~ _.0 III N ...... UI .0 0 0 0 0 0 .0 Col 0 0 0 .0 UI UI 0 0 0 0 0 ...... 0 0 UI 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 > . w ... >w . . . CD . N N . ... . . . . . . . o .. . ~ . ~ UI ...... CXI ~ ~ ... N N ~ ... . c .. N CXI Col 0 ... ~ N ... ...... UI ...... .0 III ... ::I a - - - - - - r+ CD ~ 0 .0 0 ~ ... CXI 0 ...... 0 0 III (I) CXI (I) ::I 0 0 N 0 N ~ O' N ~ 0 0 0 0 0 r+ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 N Col N Col ~ ~ ... ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ Col N = CXI CXI CXI .0 CXI N III N UI 0 ...... 0 N .0 ... III ~ . ~ :.. :". :.. . 0 :". r+ CXI 0 Col CXI UI ... UI Col ~ ~ N 0 N 0 N 0 ...... CXI ...... ...... 0 Col Col Col 0 " o c :s .. '< ~ N ~ ::u ... " = == o Z o ~ CO CO aI en Joo I"'" m en ::u Joo -4 ... o en -4 e o < aI 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 en N 0 ~ 0 0 N 0 0 N 0 0 N ~ N ~ 110 ~ 0 ". UI CO aI .... UI .... .... 0 0 UI ~ .... Z a co ~ UI .... aI Co) N Cll Co) N Co) 0 UI Co) ~ o"C co .... Co) 0 0 .... co ell Co) .... Co) ". .... Cll ". .... GI all"'" !:~ ale:.. aI::U aI" alO alO ale:.. ale:.. aI 0 !: ~ aI= alen alZ aI ~ -4 en Joo 0 Joo m Joo 0 JooJoo Joom Joo::U Joom Joom Joo m Joom J00-4 Joo'" Joo'" 110 GI I"'"::U 1"'"'" I"'"::U ~~ I"'"Z :l'l::l'l: :l'l:< ...Z ...Z ...1lO ...::u ...::u ...Joo j;~ G) I"'" )( .... :l'l:'" o G) OZ aI-4 ml"'" men ::U:l'l: ::U:l'l: I"'"IlO I"'":l'l: I"'"::U 1"'""11 G)I"'" "C .... "Z ~= ~... ::u Joo::U ::um ::u 0 0'" 0'" mm men m... m"ll 0 en... 110 GI eG) "'-4 ... G) ...::u G)m Joo Z Z <Z < <z <0 I"'"Z ~~ '< ., 3 Z ZJoo 0'" I"'" e:..o 01"'" -4 en oen . = G) ::u ...en GI 0 m Z G)" 01"'" OJoo mm ::u ... en I"'" enm e:.. "0 en ., ::u 0 G)Joo " m= m Z< aI 0-4 Joo'" ~~ =Z 0-4 = JooJoo I"'" "'1"'" Joo::U ~~ Joo Jooe:.. ... ... 01"'" < m Z= m::u == ::UZ I"'" I"'"e:.. 0 " 0 "'1"'" G)::U Z:O 0 ::u< 0 m... I"'"Z: I"'" < ZO ... 0 e:..aI ...e :s =::u I"'" ::u ::u I"'" 0 m = Jooz I"'" -4 -t ~~ en ::u m ~:: Joom G) ...< m Jool"'" -- ", =0 ::u G) I"'" o Joo 03 a~ ::u 0 ::uen m __ Z:Joo aI -- > -- -- ... Z z: __en -4 m .... 0 " I"'" en z: __ ::u Joo ", 1"'"1"'" "II ==", ... I"'" ",Z: =-4 Ull Joo en ... ::UJoo <I"'" m ... ... ... ... ...== = 0 e-4 GI I"'" ::u ~e " Z:-4 Z I"'" :l'l:aI z: Z:... z: m~ Joo z:m III 0 ~~ = ~::u Z:Joo ... m __ " " 0 ::u < -t .. I"'" Joo m... I"'" " 3 Joo __ e:.. ... mJoo m ::u 1"'"" Joo ... G)m ~~ 0 ::UZ: JooZ: 0 1"'"'" z: Joo I"'" ~ z: 3: z:m Joo -- -t <aI e:.. ... z: ::u I"'" 0 __ ::u ::u ... = =", e z: ::um ... " m " ...z: -- -4 ... Joo " 0 m -4 Joo =Joo 0 Joo ::u ::Ul"'" 0 Co) 0 ~ ~ N ". 0 ~ ~ ". Co) ". 3:1"'" Co) ~ Cll UI ~ ". ". Co) ~ co ". ~ Co) 110 110 N Co) N Co) aI "C :s e Co) Co) ". ". Co) ". N -- g, Z N 0 0 ~ ". 0 0 ", ~ N ". N Cll ~". Co) 110 0 N ~ Co) ~N 0.... N Co)~ Co) co Co) N~ ~ ~ ", o~ ......~ Cll N ., .... NO I"'"~ Cll ~N I"'" ". NN 0 N ~". ". Joo ~aI ". ....Cll aI n .. ~ ~ ". N CllN N Co) N 0 N Cll ".::U o .... N ". Co) GI .. .... ~o I"'" Co) Cll aI ~ .... :l'l: 0 CD aI l"'"aI ....~ aI 0 ::u 0 I"'"G) 0 ~ ... N CD "II ~ I"'" en aI~ ....1"'" ... aim Joo en = -4 0 Co) Z COG) en 0 NI"'" I"'" -4 0 < I"'"m N::U -4 e ::u ".en 0 -4 ::u U10 en 110 ~m I"'" en aI e m ::u Co) 0 m )( 0 0 o en 0 m 3 I"'" :s ~< "i! 1"'"'" ::u 0"11 z: ::u I"'" e O::U = < en aI aI alg, m en "II ... aim I"'" m ", 0 m Joo -4 I"'"Joo Z ... aI ::u enm I"'"::U ... < m ~ z: I"'" ::u I"'" z: aI 0 ml"'" en z: I"'" = alO 0 " en eno z: "0 I"'" G) 0 en UI ::u ... < .. ::u -4 me -4 0 3: ::u -4 0 en I"'" ~ m m " I"'" Z:I"'" en... ::u Joo -4 I"'" " m ::u m 0 OJoo ml"'" 0 0 en 0 en :l'l: ...< ::u z: "I"'" Joo e .. 0 Joo en m 0 m 0 ::u ., ::u ::u ::u m ...::u ::u -4 GI 0 0 " <0 ". GI -4 .. ~ 0 0 0 0 ~ 0 0 ~ 0 0 0 0 0 0 JooO 0 ~ .... Co) UI 0 ". Co) ~ ". ~ ell .... co .... n 110 -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- ., .. ~ 0 0 ~ 0 Co) 0 0 N N 0 ~ ~ N N GI GI 0 Cll Co) ~ Cll ~ ~ Co) aI CD .... UI aI UI ~ 110 -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- Ull en CO ell ell CO ell ell CO ell ell CO ell CO ell ell CO GI 0 .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... g, 00 GI GI GI GI ....U1 NUl ~UI NUl NUl CD UI ~U1 ....U1 NUl N UI ~U1 ~U1 NUl ~ UI ellUl g,g, Cll .... ~". UlCll CDUI o Ul CO).... ~~ "'U1 U1.... Co) Ul at". CD .... ~~ Ul.... CO Cll "'Co) 0'" Cll N Cll~ ....aI atUl U1~ ....aI o Ul NUl ~O Co) ~ ~aI "'aI N .... ". ". 0 UI 110 0 Ull 0 GI ~ ::u ::u ::u ::u ::u ::u ::u ::u ::u " " ::u ::u ::u ::u "'-4 m m m m m m m m m 0 0 m m m m .,'< en en en en en en en en en 3: 3: en en en en o"C "C GI ",en ., 110 fit fit fit fit fit fit .... .... fit ~ fit ~ fit fit fit ~ fit ~ ~ fit fit fit ~ n GI ". N UI 0 CD ell CD CO at UI aI UI aI UI ~ GI ~ell ell CO .... .... ~ 0 ~CO ". 0 0 Ul ~O ~ CD 0 CO CO 0 CO .... Ul CO 0 0 0 0 ell 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Joo III Joo .. I!I GI fit fit fit fit fit fit fit fit fit fit fit fit fit fit fit 0 III ~ Ul N ". ~ Co) Co) aI N aI ell ~ Co) N ". C .. Cll 0 Co) at Co) N Co) UI Co) 0 .... Co) Co) Cll :s a ~ ~ ~ ~ ....,. ~ .. GI .... ". ell Cll CD N aI ". .... N N ". 0 ". :s N 0 Cll 0 0 0 0 aI ". N ". 0 0 CD aI .. 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ~ Co) ". ". Co) Co) ". ". Co) ". Ul Co) ". ". Co) ::u CD 0 Co) ell Gl 0 ~ CO N 0 ~ ~ UI ell 110 .. ~ CD 0 Ul UI N N ell .... ". ~ N N N Co) .... N 0 0 Ul ell ~ UI Cll UI CD Co) .... ell UI CO 0 - - ... - . . . . . . . . . - - - - . . . . . . . . (') o C ::I ... '< ... I\.) ... :a ... (') = ~ Z CI ... CO CO CD en . r- m en :a . -I ... o en -I e CI < ~ 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 en ... I\.) I\.) ... ... 0 I\.) ... 0 ... ... I\.) I\.) ... 0 III CD CD W CD W CD 0 CO Cl) I\.) ~ CD CO W CD za ~ ~ W W ~ ~ 0 ... III ~ III W W 0 O"CI CD CD ... W ~ W III ~ CD CO I\.) ~ CO III CO .... Gl CD~ CD:a CD~ CD CD CDr- CDen CD CD CDm CD CD CD CD CD= CD CD CD-I CD= CD~ -I en .. .... .... .:a . ... .m .. .... .m ~> .... .0 .e .0 .... III Gl :a-l :a(') :a I:) :a< :az :a. :a... :a 3: :ar- :a Z zen z:a r- r- r- r- >C .... -I~ -1= :i!:i :a. :a CI :ar- zr- zm zr- 1:)(') I:) m ~~ ClZ r--I r-en "CI .... 0... 0 mz mm mm mm m:a m. m~ men en. .m 0 0 III Gl ZZ ZCl 0 -I .... -IZ -1< en< en en :a CD :a < :a -IZ e:..z '< ., en m r-." -I .... -I e:.. .... oe 0= -I e:.. :a ~-I Gl ~~ "'IIZ 3::a CI CD (') ~ me:.. (') 0 .:z: z:a Z 0 .e:.. .." m:a ., .Z mm .,,0 ('):a ~~ r-= : 0 : "'II :a 0 .... en. m= r- ... e... ~CI :az o e =.... ...: ~~ < <m ... = 1fi~ en: eno 0 r-r- r-en m :a(') .= :: ." -- ...:z: ... ('): mCl (')~ ::I ... en . (')e:.. CI~ : m :a 0 m ." en m en :ao (')3: .3: ... r-< ~g = m m r-: en~ 0= ~. 1:)3: ~. :am __ en CI 3: ~ :a r-. m< -1-- :a. ...m ...:a CD mm CD .... ... ... -- : ...r- CI:a ~z : ... ~ CI :am ca .,,== r- (') .~ m< :... 0 -I ... CD Clm ~ < Gl -- m ~ . mz :l!Z e:..= .r- m .... III (') en CI-I .-1 CI -- :ao CI :a :... ... = m = m . en : .:a CI -I'" m -- r- en < < en :a 1fi m ., r- en < m < ... -I r- r- : ... : m ... . (') < 3: en 3: m en e:.. : . . 0 ~ ... 0 w ... ... 0 0 ... ... 0 3:r- III III ... W III W ~ 0 ~ w w e III III I\.) CD co 0 0 CD ~ ... ... -I "CI ::I r- ~ ... w r- CD . -- a. 0 0 00 0 0 0 ~ I\.) 0 0 , "'II .... 0 ... CD ... .,,1\.) III CI CD III OW CO'" ww ... WI\.) ... ...." I\.)~ I\.) 1\.)'" CD I\.) ... 1\.)1\.) ., .... W CD CD CD~ W 01 01\.) CD 0 CD o. ~~ ... ~~ W ~ WW 0 n III CD'" 01\.) ~... CO CO I\.) W ~... ... 0'" 01 I\.) CD OI~ Gl ... r- 0 01 N N 0 :a 0 CD CDO ... N CD. ....w . 0 0 0 ... o~ 0 r- r- w (')en OCD CI 03: r- en r- r-: 0'" ~ 0= CI:I! =;; "'II=;; ~CI r- = m :D 0 CD ;! I:) :z: ... 1:)... ... = ... m en.. r- O~ e O:D CDm ... "'-1 OCl :a 0(') : r- : ... z r-::I ~ ... ~ r- :a N 010 en ~ ~i =en CI ...en ~ CD a. ... CI ~ : -- : 0 en -I m "'-1 CDCI CI :a : 0 m CD CD :z: "'110 :a 0 :a r- "'II 0 en r- r- I:) (') =: en: 0 CI :a . :a CI -I en m ... :a CI :a CI en en . ~ CD:a ...=;; -I (') ~ w ~ CI -I CI .... . :a :a en en < < ...< en . m m m en ... < m (') (') m ., m -I (') Gl I\.) ... Gl ... ... . ... 0 ... ... 00 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ... 0 0 .CI CD N 0 CD CD ~ CO CD ~ 01 01 ~ I\.) CD I\.) n III -- -- -- ~-- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- ., ... ... W I\.) 0'" ... ... ... I\.) ... W W I\.) ... 0 ... Gl Gl 01 ... W 01 N ~ 01 N ~ 0 0 ... ~ CD CD III -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- ca en CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO Gl 0 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ .... a. ClCI Gl Gl Gl Gl ~OI "'01 "'01 "'01 "'01 ... 01 1\.)01 "'01 "'01 ... 01 ~OI WOI ~OI ~OI "'01 a. a. W CD WCD ...~ ~~ 01 CD CO 01 ~~ ~CD ~~ o 01 01 CD CIlCD ~CD CIlCD "'CIl CD CD 01\.) CD ~ NO ~CIl CD 0 CO CD CIlCO ~O ~W CIlO COO "'0 "'II CD 0 CD W W CD 0 ~ CD III 0 ca 0 Gl ~ :a :a (') :a :a :a :a :a :a :a :a :a :a :a (') "'11-1 m m 0 m m m m m m m m m m m 0 .,'< en en 3: en en en en en en en en en en en 3: O"CI "CI Gl "'lien ., III ~ .... .... ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ... ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ n Gl CO CD CD N CD ~ CD ~ ~ ~ ~ W ~ W ~ Gl ... wO ~ CIl CD ~ ... N 0 N wCD wcll ... CO wO w w w CO 0 cIl ~ CO CO CO CO I\.) CO CO CO cIl CO 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 CD 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 CD 0 0 0 0 0 0 . .. . III a Gl ~ ~ ~ * ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ - 0 .. W ... I\.) - N ... N N ... cIl W ... ... ... ... C III CD CO CD cIl cIl W ~ ~ CD CO 0 ~ W 01 ~ ::I a w w w w w W ... Gl 0 ~ N I\.) ~ ~ ~ CD CD I\.) ~ CD cIl CD ~ ::I 0 0 0 0 0 CD 0 ~ 0 0 CD 0 CD 0 I\.) ... 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ~ W W N W W W W ~ ~ ~ ~ W W ~ :a ... I\.) CD 0 CD 0 CO CD ... ... 0 ... N CO ~ III ~ . ... W W CD CD CD ~ ... ~ ~ 0 N CD ... W .... cIl W ... ~ ~ cIl I\.) CO 0 W 0 W ~ 0 0 0 n o c = rt '< . ~ . :a ... n ::e 3: o z e . o o m en ~ r- m en :a ~ .... ... o en .... e e < m 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 en ~ ~ . ~ 0 . 0 0 0 ~ . 0 ~ ~ . II m ~ ~ m Cll 0 ~ Cll UI ~ ~ m . ~ m z 9 . UI W ~ 0 Cll ~ ~ m ..... m UI UI Cll Cll 0"1:1 ~ 0 0 m 0 0 w ~ 0 0 UI 0 w m . . .... CD III en lIIe 1II::e 11I3: III en 1II::e 11Im lilt.. lIIen IIIn III.... III..... 1II:a 11I11I III en ....en m::e ~ ~e ~ ... ~ .... ~... ~ ~~ ~< ~o ~::e ~:a ~... ~ 0 ~3: II CD ~~ ><110 ><..... er- e e r- ....11I ....~ ....0 ....... ....m ....n ....< en ... >C .... :ae .... ......... en r- ~~ gr- ....r- ....m mm m ~ mg mz m~ m~ en.... "1:1 .... e< m::e m mm ::en r-~ r-en en en en enJlO en n en m ~;r; ::e II CD III :a :a g :a:a z.... ~~ mn m ::e m ::e .... ::e '< "'I 1II:a e m ~n z.... ~ g eng :a ... t..z t.. e.... z ...g CD mo :am ~ ~ - z e CIl n ~ ....m m r- m III .~ en -v~ r-m "'I .... 0 0< z::e ~en g oe ::e:a m:a g r- en n z:a < r-o ....~ 11Im :ar- :a nm :a:a :a.... <~ ... ... eno m 0 :;~ ::ee ...:a 0 <~ mr- ....e t..... :ar- ::eo oz ...::e mr- ~~ ...:a ~~ <:a ~~ = :ao ::e... ... en ....r- :a:a .... enr- ze m~ :a r- ... ~"V ...."V ~z i!~ ::e n ... g ::en ....m -- 0 ~ ~ r- n e --.... 3: m ~ enm <0 0.... e r- r-.... 3::a Zlll ...m t..~ ... r- en <m ::e ..."V .... Z "V.... -- ::e ~ :a e en c m __ z __ n m::e ~ oe en en ::e m t.. m III t.. e -- t..t.. CD m... ~.... III m "V __ --.... m m r- e :a... r- :a:a .. z ~ r-:a ::elll -v :a ~ ~ z r- ... -- rt zn :a... :a -- m~ ~n z e z g <z z < :a:a ....0 m e 0 m n m m III en .... r- :a ~ 0 .... ... m :a ::e~ <... -- en e z :a z -v r- ::e ~ n m ~ N n ~ ... ... r- e z z ~ r- n "V ::e 3: w . w . 0 0 0 . 0 . 0 0 . UI 3:r- ..... ~ ~ ..... w . w . UI w m ~ ~ W II II 0 0 . 0 0 ..... ~ ..... w . "1:1 = W . ~ -- . . -- a. .....~ 0 w 0 UI . 0 . ~ . ..... "V ~ 0 0 UI 0 ~ UI II e .:a ow ow ~~ .~ ~. ~~ . . ww ow o ~ w w W "'I ... ........ 0 W~ W ~~ .....0 m 0 0 Cll..... o UI ~ 0 o m Cll 0 m n .. < ~ 0 11Im ~ w Cll ~ ...... w ~ w ~~ U1m U1~ r- w m ....~ CD rt om r- w r-~ w r-o UI ~ ~ UI :aCll ....~ w:a ~ w o ~ 00 0 0 0 011I 0 ..... III ~ ~ ~r- n III W'" or- 0.... ~ e 011I o en o~ or- __en ~ nlll r- "V w n ~ 3: .... e :a ~~ m .... :a o~ III "V :a ....m en II er- 0 z ... 0.... 0 o~ ::e o :a 00 o:a r-~ III r- r-= z~ ::en e n - n e 1IIr- ~ z 0 III Z ~ III~ ilia. n e~ ~ 0 en ::e e r-... m m ::e 0 ~... :a ... ~ m e n r- r- r-e r- ~ r-r- r-< r- :a en ~ :a r- ..... en::e m r- e ~~ n n m e e ::e 0 o~ o~ .:a .0 e ~< ~III ~:a < :a :a rt w.... z< e e ~... ::e Ole :a ..... ~:a ~... .... e e ~ :a :a --< III :a ... :a 0 , < n :a "V .... nm r-n .... < e 11I0 .....m .... ~ en 0 :a .... m r-~ n rt :a ~ m m "'I .... n me CD m en :a e CD :a m en :a rt 0 n m < n ~ w .... r- w 0 . 0 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 . 00 ~e UI 0 ..... ~ 0 w ~ ~ 0 ..... w 0 0 m n II -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- ~-- "'I rt ~ W 0 W ~ 0 2 ~ ~ ~ 0 w ~ ~ ~~ CD CD ~ 0 ~ 0 ..... UI UI m 0 m . UI ..... . II -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- c en 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 II) 0 0 0 0 0 0 CD 0 ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... .... a. ee CD CD CD CD ~UI ~U1 .U1 .U1 ~~ WUl UI UI .U1 ~ UI m UI ~ UI ~ UI .U1 ~UI ~U1 a. a. .U1 w..... .01 m UI .....01 . UI ~U1 .~ .......... ~ 01 W UI m..... U1..... ~ 01 w..... o~ ~~ 0..... ~o 00 ~ 0 ~U1 ~o U1~ ~~ U1W ...... m~ m..... "VIII 01 ~ m ..... 0 ~ ..... 0 UI W 01 ..... II 0 C 0 CD ~ :a :a :a :a :a :a :a :a :a :a :a :a :a :a :a -v.... m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m "'1'< en en en en en en en en en en en en en en en 0"1:1 "1:1 CD "V en "'I II - - tit - ....... ~ - . - tit . . tit tit tit - - - - - n CD ~ 0 0 01 UI 0 UI 01 01 ..... W m 01 ~ 01 CD 0 ~W ~U1 ~U1 m ..... m W UI UI ~ . 0 UI UI ~ 0 0 0 0 0 ..... UI 01 ~ 0 0 UI 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 W 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 UI 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ~ .. ~ .. B CD - - - - - tit - - - - - - tit - 0 .. m . m ~ ~ ~ ell ~ ~ W ~ ~ ~ - ~ c .. ~ 0 0 W ~ ~ W W ell ell ~ m ..... m m = a ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ - ~ N ~ rt CD 01 ~ ~ m Q) m ~ . 0 0 m 0 ell ~ = 0 m 0 0 0 0 0 01 m 0 0 ell 0 0 ~ rt 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ~ ~ ~ W W W W W W ~ ~ W W . ~ :a 0 0 . ell m 0 0 ell 0 m ~ UI cD ..... W II . rt ~ UI ~ . ..... ..... m ~ m 0 ~ UI ~ m ~ ... cD W W ~ . ~ ..... 0 m 0 . W m 01 ell 0 .- - . . . . . . . . . . - - .- - - - - - . . . . . . (') o C ::I ... '< .... I\) .... :a ... (') = 3: o Z e -' U) CD QI en . r- m en :a . -t ... o en a e < U) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 en 0 I\) I\) 0 0 I\) I\) .... .... I\) .... 0 0 0 I\) . UI QI .... I\) I\) .... CD .... ~ ~ 0 CD QI W QI Z &I CD UI I\) ~ QI .... CD W .... W QI 0 : .... U) O"CI UI W .... .... .... .... U) QI QI I\) QI .... CD "'" CD QlZ 1llI. lllIen 1llI= ~!; 1llI:a 1llI. 1llI= 1llI"V 1llI= 1llI:a 1llI3: IllIIllI 1llIr- 1llI::e -ten m... m en m3: mo m. mz mo m. mm m. m ... m:a m. m... . CD Z, )( Z:II: Z... r-::e r-::e r-en r-o r-r- r--t e Z (') en (')r- .0 .:a .en )C "'" Z e..... m-t r-. r-en r- (') r-:a er- (')-t ee oo4llll :ll:r- en (') :ae :am "CI "'" m. ~Z .,,= ~~ 0 . m ...0 =m ... :a om en r-:II: em e . CD -tr- ... e..z =r- e::e z::e m:a Z ... z:a (') m m '< ., IllI ...0 m m ~~ e :::een G'). :a en G'))( :a =r- <:a :am (')0 CD em Zoo4 r-< G') em . < 0 ." 004< me 0 .< =e ., m:a ... em 3:... enz <"V 0 "VZ ...(') m :aoo4 :::ee <m .... (') -t men r- mr- en-t o-t Z. ." . m:a :a." <= .Z r- :am 0 . r- :am r-1llI -t zm me :::eo -t= r-m mr- r-m Z m .< m ::I :a:::e ...." OZ -tm =... :a r- en :ao een eno :a e< ZZ z:::e !;r- ~ 1llI. o:a m r-"V m "'004 ...::e .< e.. .::e -t (') - e m Z-t :a -:E ...m ('). mr- e :a =en m~ .... - :a en - e..... (')- ...:a ...:a r- en. 0 a:l .(') -t me.. :a en o e .e ~ ::e ... < Z m... CD ~g - r-:a m Z. = - < Z < _:a .. :a ... en z:a < z en m e... ... r-z 0 ~ ...r- m e mm IllI ... m. G') r- em mr- m IllI z m ... ... :a m (') -t= z -t . -t -t . = . = . 3: r- ." QI ....QI 0 ~ I\) QI .... ~ I\) 0 0 ~ W I\) 3:r- UI I\) QI UI I\) QI CD UI W UI CD W W W . . U) U) "V I\) .... W .... QI QI I\) "CI ::I W UI .... I\) I\) - Q. ~ W .... UI UI 0 0 ~ .... 0 .... "V I\) I\) . QI I\) I\) .... ~ . e 1\)1\) W-' -':a -' ow 0-' -'en -'en -'I\) 1\)-' -' -' I\) ........ ., .... OCD (') .... .... UlO ~QI QI UI ........ UI~ 0 ~QI ~~ ....UI 0 en n III 0 r- r- ....1\) r- UI r- QlO N QI 0 UI." U)o W U)QI QI .... CD ... .... 0 ~ "Vr- "VQI QI QI ~ r- UI W I\) 0 r-QI ""'~ N< 0 r- ... . W 0 00 0 0 ~ :a .... m 0(') .% :D """ '" o en """ r- :a O:D 0< G') 0:11: G') ...."V r- 0 ::a o ~ -ten (')0 "'" :D ... ... m r- m "'" CXI ... en . (') lllIe me o e e ....e 0",," O:D m o::a r- % r- ::I :II: r-. ... ~:a r- G') 004 ... QI G') . z z 0 e IllI m 1llIQ. < r- r- ....0 UI!; = e m 0 z z m r- em r- UI. r-m lllIe . r-z r- z :a r- (') m _ e ....en :a "V r-. < . :E ."... 0 :a en .... I\)Z . r- m I\)e < ~. :a e ... m - en QI en W :a IllI m Z ....:a m W< . enG') ~ m e -t QI -t (') :II: e - ... e mm ;IIi ~ :a :a (') m 1llI< IllI (') en en m 0 > 0 r-m r- en e ... :a m m en < e 004 ...:Il ., e (') -t en m :a e..z . ... CD ... -t 0 ...m CD ... % ::a en ... ... G') -t m = (') ... 0 0.... 0 UlO 0 ....0 .... .... 0 0 0 0 0 0 .... >e I\) 0 U) W W QI I\) I\) .... .... UI ~ ~ I\) I\) n . - ~- - 0- - UI- - - - - - - - - - ., ... I\) QlI\) 0 UlI\) 0 ....0 -' 0 0 I\) I\) W .... I\) W CD CD QI W UI .... W .... UI QI .... W W 0 0 QI -' . - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - a:l en CD CD U) U) U) U) U) U) U) CD U) U) U) U) U) CD 0 .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... .... "'" Q. ee CD CD CD CD ....UI ....'" ....UI ~g: U) UI ....UI ....UI WUI I\)UI WUI ....UI QI UI ~UI WUI ....UI Q.Q. U)~ UlQI QI.... ....UI W.... QI QI QI.... o QI UI QI ....UI UI'" UIUI UlUI I\) CXI I\)U) UlW CD.... U) I\) QI 0 ow I\) .... U) ~I\) QlUI UlQI ....QI OUl ....0 ........ "Villi U) UI 0 UI I\) . 0 a:l 0 CD ~ :a :a = = = . = (') = = = = = = = "V-t m m m m m G') m 0 m m m m m m m .,'< en en en en en :Il en :!: en en en en en en en 0"0 "0 CD "V en ., . .. ...."'" .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .... .. .. .. n CD QI .... .. UI I\) .... QI QI .... .... ~ .... W I\) CD CD U) W U) QI W .... U) 0 I\) QI ~ .... U) UI UI U) U) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 U) 0 UI 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 . .. . .. II CD .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. 0 .. I\) (,It .. .... .. .. W I\) W .. .... ~ .. .. W C .. .... UI W QI QI UI I\) W I\) QI U) .... QI QI UI ::I B ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ... CD W I\) CD .... .... 0 QI .... I\) .... QI QI QI 0 I\) ::I QI 0 QI I\) QI 0 0 QI 0 QI 0 0 QI QI ~ ... 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 W W ~ W I\) ~ W W ~ ~ ~ W I\) I\) W = CD .... ~ .... U) UI QI QI ~ QI UI UI I\) ~ QI . . :.. . :., N ... .... ~ 0 I\) W QI QI QI 0 UI W U) .... ~ -' 0 ~ CD UI UI 0 I\) .... 0 QI QI I\) 0 0 o o C ::I ... '< .. I\) .. ~ ... o % 3 o Z 1::1 .. CO co CD en ~ I"'" m en :D ~ -4 ... o en -4 e o -< .. o 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 en N N N N .. .. N N .. N .. 0 0 N .. III c.l ..... .. 410 ..... c.l 0 0 410 UI 0 ..... .. ..... .. za CD N .. 0 410 UI c.l CD N 410 0 c.l CD N CD O"l:l CD CO N CD ..... UI 0 ..... .. CO c.l 410 N N. c.l . .... . 1IlI~ 1IlI0 1IlI% 1IlIt.. lIlIZ 1IlI0 1IlI~ lIlIZ ~~ 1IlI% 1IlI1::1 1IlI% lIlIm 1IlI0 1IlI~ -4 en ...~ ... 0 mm m 0 m 0 m~ ml::l m m mm m m 0 m ml"'" m~ III . Z-4 ~I"'" <=e :D% :D:D :D:D :D :D::E :D en :D:D Z 110 Z=e ZlIlI zm zen )( .... ...en enm m... :DZ :DI::I .~ -4 :D 110 ~en ~O O~ -4 -4~ ZI"'" Z < Z% "l:I .... 00 ~~ :D-4 -< <~ -<m < en 0 mo 1"'"% I"'":D m~ mm m... III . ZZ 1"'"-4 , 0 % :D 1::1 -43 I"'" ~Z m ml::l -40 -41"'" -4Z '< ., ~Z < -4 :DI"'" 3 1::1 mm m... <1::1 < -4~ -4 ~ -4 G'l . 1IlI 3 I"'" < ~~ ... ... t.. m... ... <Z Zt.. m 1::1 1IlI Z -4 ., :D'" I"'"~ me 0% ~~ 3Z zt.. 0 t..< t..o ."e 1"'"1::1 1"'"0 "'-4 ~Z ellll I"'"~ % 0 00 m 0 G'l G'll::l em OZ %:D ~ ~Z 0 1::1 0 o Z G'l~ 0< ~3 om Z :Dm ~ :D 0 1::11"'" %~ ...Z ~~ en ::I G'l% m m :D m :Dm Z en 1::1 :D me ...0 ZI"'" I"'" %:D mm ." Zt.. :D 1::1 en I::I~ :D m G'l -4'" 1::1 1"'"0 m~ 00 1::1 -41"'" 0 m~ G'l 3m 3 ~ < ZI"'" %3 I"'" ...0 Z:D Z~ .... -41"'" Z ~E 1::1'" 1::1 -- Z ~ m t.. ."z 01"'" 1::1 CCI I::Im Z t..~ c.. ... ~ I"'" en t..Z 1IlI -- en m m :D . en % -- Z3 0 :D~ 0 m -- I"'" -4 en Z-4 en ml::l ... 0 m I::Im ::D Z I"'" ~ 0 % -- 3 zm ... 3 1::1 o 1IlI 1::1 m ::D ... ~ ... 0 -- % m< m ~ I"'"e en 3 G'l Z ::D ::DO 0__ mm 0 <... ... m 0 0 m %en I"'" 1IlI Z ZI"'" ... -4 I"'" Z z... me 0 e ... 1::1 ... < ... mz ::D en ." ... ~ <m en en I"'" 0 < ~ m I"'" ::D I"'" < I"'" Z ::D 1::1 en en m 3 Z en m < -4~ ::D ... en Z -4 ." ~ .. N I\) ~ 3 ~ .. ~ N 0 0 =:1"'" CD UI ..... .. co co c.l c.l .. III III UI c.l 0 c.l .. .. ." ." .. .. "l:I ::I I"'" N c.l" ..... I"'" N c.l .-- Q, 0 0 0 .. c.l4lo NCD ~ c.l N N 0 ." c.l ..... c.l 410 UI c.l III 1::1 0" N N __ c.l 0" CD" .. N c.l N N N c.l N o ~ o~ N" ., .... CD .. 410 UI CD~ ON ~ 0 N ~~ N 0 0 410..... NCD UI c.l N CD n ... co c.l c.l4lo I"'"N 410410 c.l 0 "'410 co .. .. o .. N . ... 0 CD CD ..... I"'"c.l ~ UI U1N ~ 0 .,,410 m 410 0 ....- 0 0 CD .. CD UIU1 ::D 1IlI ~ ~ ~ 0% - 0." 01"'" ." co 0 CDO ~ 0'" m I"'" ::D% G'l 1IlI3 ..~ I"'" 0 ... ... ~ ~m -- G'l 3 mm ::D 0 om I"'" I"'"~ ::D en III 0)( o Z m O~ 0 N :D lIlIm 1"'"'" 0 0 mz m ::D 01"'" I"'" ::I 0 I"'" ::D ~ m I"'"::D ." ~ 0 I"'"::D 0-4 m 1IlIQ, 0 0 0 ... ::D .. m :D CD m ~ < ." ... en I"'"m I"'" en 1"'"0 < c.l Z 1IlI... co ::D .. 0 Z 1"'"-4 I"'" Z Z -4 G'l ... -4 I"'" ~ .. ... ~ UI en ... ... 0 0 c.l -4 0 c.lm m % ~ 0 ~ -4 Z II:) ~~ ... lIlI::D 0 Z ~ Z 0 G'l ::D < ::D -4 e - 1::1 Z m ." en 0 I"'"m 0 m m m ~m I"'" 0 -4 ~ ~ m en ." 0 -4 ... :D < CD 1::1 1::1 -4 0 1::1 0 ... ~ ... Z ::D 0 m ::D ::D :D ::D ., ::D 1IlI... ... . ::D 1"'"< < . 0 m m ... ~ 1IlI 0 en m 0 ~ 0 .. 0 0 0 0 .. 0 0 0 .. 0 0 0 ~ ~ ~I::I co .. ..... ..... ..... CD co CD CD .. N c.l ~ .. N n III -- -- -- -- -- -- N-- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- ., ... N N .. N c.l 0 U10 N N .. N c.l c.l N .. . . CO 410 CD UI .. 410 UI CD ..... I\) CD .. .. UI UI III -- -- -- -- -- - - - - - - - - - - CCI en CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CO CD CD CD . 0 ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... ..... .... Q, 1::11::1 . . . . NUl 4IoUl CDUI NUl NUl "U1 CDUI NUl .....U1 "U1 NUl ~U1 4IoUl N UI ~U1 Q,Q, c.l..... CD..... 0..... o CD ~CD ~g N..... N..... CII CD .......... "410 UIU1 410410 ....... c.l ..... CD" CD CD" .....410 CD CD U10 NO c.l N CD CD CD CD 410410 CD ..... N..... UI co "'1IlI N ~ 0 N N UI c.l 0 ..... UI III 0 CCI 0 . ~ :D :D ::D ::D :D :D :D :D ::D 0 :D ::D ::D :D :D "'-4 m m m m m m m m m 0 m m m m m .,,< en en en en en en en en en :I: en en en en en O"l:l "l:I . ."en ., III * * * * * .... .... ~ * .. * * * * * .. I\) tit tit ~ ~ tit n . N UI c.l CD ..... .. .. ..... CD UI CD CD CD 0 ..... 411. c.l _CD 410 _CD CD N CD CD _U1 0 ~ CD _CD CD UI 0 CD CD CD CD 0 0 CO CD 0 CO 0 0 CD ..... 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 ~ ... ~ ... 51 . .. .. tit tit * .. tit tit .. tit tit tit tit 0 ... UI N 410 c.l N tit tit c.l c.l CD c.l c.l CD c.l N C ... 0 410 c.l ..... CD 410 CD N CD ..... 410 CD c.l CD UI ::I a - - - - - - - - - - ... . CD N 410 CD CD CD 0 UI N 0 N N CD CD 0 ::I 0 410 0 0 0 0 0 N 0 410 0 410 0 N 0 ... 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 410 410 c.l c.l c.l 410 c.l 410 410 N c.l c.l c.l c.l c.l ::D ~ 0 N ..... ..... 0 .. 0 N CD ..... CD ..... CD c.l III . ... c.l 410 .. CD 410 0 UI ..... .. CD N 0 CD CD 0 .... 0 ..... ..... 410 UI 0 CD 0 410 N .... N CD CD c.l 0 . . . . . . . . . . . ~ I I I o o . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 11 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 02754 CHESER RODNEY/DONNA 2506 PEROT CT 11/25/97 578 RES $101,000 $36,000 35.64 BIRD RICHARD 793 02830 JACK R NORDAHL BLDRS 1402 BOOKSTONE RD 10/31/97 575 RES $77,900 $28,400 38.46 BIRT MILLARD/EMILY 923 01883 WILSON ANGUS HIlI 303 REYNOLDS ST 08/18/97 588 RES $58,500 $18,080 28.48 BISHOP DARIN B/ANGELA 47 2 21 398 02839 WEIGLE JOHN B JR ET AL 42 INNISBROOK DR 10/31/97 575 RES $84,900 $24,000 38.98 BISHOP KIMBERLY 0 18 2 202 L 1 BLDG F 722 02407 C & R HOME BUILDERS INC 2804 AHACUA WAY 07/24/97 584 RES $84,900 $42,200 49.71 BISHOP LARRY R JR 143 0 700 00 0 L 19.H 2081 01069 KAY SANDRA Y/BUNN BRENDA E 22 112 THOMAS CIR OS/23/97 558 RES $23,000 $8,120 35.30 BISHOP TIMOTHY D/SHANNON C 110 4 190 BL E 1904 01440 C J SINGLETON CONST CO INC 2937 ARROWWOOD CIRCLE 08/30/97 582 RES $132,900 $55,800 41.84 BlIZARD ANTHONY JR 139 0 422 L 189 BL B 1152 00972 STEWART OWEN F JR 4315 WOODVALLEY PLACE 05/08/97 556 RES $66,086 $25,000 37.83 BLACK CHI YON 167 o 322 00 0 L lA 1849 00037 WILLIAMS C MURRAY 25 PARK PLACE CIR 01/08/97 545 RES $289,900 $99,600 34.38 BLACKMON JOHN B/CAROLYN A 23 294 L 6 BL B 696 01368 BROWN W L/HAIEL H 2406 COUGAR CT 06/09/97 560 RES $18,000 $5,200 28.89 BLACKSOTN RANDY W/JOYCE R 1272 00008 BENHART ELIZABETH 2402 WINSTON WAY 01/03/97 544 RES $43,000 $15,200 35.35 BLAKELY DIANNE 131 o 192 BLDG B PH 2 1886 03017 FU MICHAEL H/YEH LI T 2921 TOBACCO RD 10/16/97 576 RES $63,500 $28,000 44.09 BLAKNEY JOHN E JR 128 0 033 00 0 312 02349 BRACY PATARICIA 0 1923 GEORGE ST 10/21/97 574 RES $59,000 $16,400 27.80 BLALCOK WILLIAM OREN 071 3 048 00 0 804 01047 COTHRAN WVLEEN E 802 WINDSON COURT OS/22/97 558 RES $116,900 $59,280 50.71 BLANCO MAXIMINO J JR/JUDY M 341 91 L l/BL A 1442 01959 KINGSBURY CUSTOM HOMES INC 2510 WINTERVILLE DR 09/05/97 569 RES $99,000 $40,200 40.61 BLAS JOSEPH T/JUNG L 052 0 586 00 0 L 5 BL M SEC 2 732 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 12 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 01195 GOLLIHUGH ELORA K 2846 WATER WAY UN 17 12/15/97 579 RES $59,000 $21,720 36.81 BLOUNT ALVIN R JR 33 4 060 23 1959 01072 WALTERS ANN S 2202 CASSELL ST 05/09/97 558 RES $52,900 $23,480 44.39 BLOUNT KIMBERLY V 167 o 038 00 0 L 42/F PT L 41/F 1967 00268 LEE JOSH 1812 EMPRESS DRIVE 02/28/97 550 RES $49,852 $20,080 40.28 BLOUNT PATRICIA A 122 4 123 L 11 BL E SEC 3 2390 01706 GRICE OSCAR BRIAN BATH ED IE RD 08/07/97 566 RES $21,000 $7,200 34.29 BLUME DALLAS 224 128 L 474 1429 6.00 649 00822 DOYLE MICHAEL O/RUTH A 3246 SKINNER MILL RD 04/03/97 553 RES $132,900 $56,800 42.74 BOARDMAN MARGARET E 023 0 071 00 0 989 30020 1488 REYNOLDS ST COM $398,120 $150,480 37.80 BOARDMAN PETROLEUM INC 36 1 66 1 0.65 Appraisal 30021 602 SCOTT NIXON MEM DR COM $601,970 $234,600 38.97 BOARDMAN PETROLEUM INC 16 27 7 1.28 Appraisal 02118 MCELROY ROBERT L 2019 AUTUMN CHASE 09/25/97 571 RES $175,000 $72,800 41.60 BODENAMER ROBERT JR/KATHERINE 006 0 223 000 906 02719 CLARK HOMER G 2419 MOHICAN RD 12/16/97 581 RES $82,927 $27,800 33.52 BOHANNON LAURIE L 19 4 82 L 12 BL D 628 02205 WHITE THOMAS G 2330 OVERTON RD 09/29/97 573 RES $95,000 $36,000 37.89 BOLANDER DAVID B/MARY A 26 4 24 09 561 00493 BLACKBURN HOME BUILDERS INC 2203 LARKS COURT 02/17/97 548 RES $141,900 $58,000 40.87 BOLES BERNARD E/MARY M 30 302 L 31 1812 02802 KEY AND KEY 2303 POTEET ST 10/01/97 573 RES $57,000 $16,240 28.49 BOLTON FREDDIE/MARY L 35/BL Q 660 01346 ALLEN VICKIE Q 3535 BILTMORE PL 06/10/97 560 RES $59,057 $23,400 39.62 BOLTON JERRY/VONTRICIA 120 0 509 00 0 L 46 BL A 736 00993 GRIFFIN EARL J 3007 GREEN FOREST DR 04/18/97 556 RES $54,900 $22,160 40.36 BOND JOHN M 118 0 167 00 0 L 15A 2276 02626 CHRISTIAN JOE D JR ET AL 1521 ANTHONY RD/1522 JOHN 11/03/97 575 COM $750,000 $232,920 31.06 BONE REALTY LLC 044 3 257 00 0/0443253000 1288 '. . . . . . . . . . . I l o . . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 13 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 02979 WILLIAMS BETTY JO 938 MERRY ST 12/31/97 580 RES $45,200 $18,080 40.00 BOOKER WILLIAM A JR 2329 03008 BLACKBURN HOME BUILDERS INC 24 EAGLE POINTE DR 12/22/97 581 RES $155,900 $61,200 39.26 BOOTH CLAY R/TERESA L 23 304 L 9 412 02012 GILCHRIST ALVIN L 2511 TEAKWOOD DR 08/19/97 570 RES $55,900 $23,840 42.65 BORRERO WILLIAM/COLLEEN M 153 340 L 21/BL U SEC 6A 379 02088 RICHARD BIRD BUILDERS 2802 STOKER CT ' 09/10/97 571 RES $97,900 $38,400 39.22 BOSTIC JOHNNY/IDEANA 378 00536 FAMBROUGH J HOWARD 2007 EVERGREEN DR 01/28/97 549 RES $63,900 $25,600 40.06 BOSTIC MICHAEL T 55 2 59 L 6/BL B/SEC II 1356 00379 JOHN C WEAVER HOME BLDRS INC 3027 GREY FOX DRIVE 03/10/97 550 RES $125,000 $47,200 37.76 BOSTOCK JAMES A/DEBORAH S 271 o 046 00 0 L 14-B 2159 02694 WILLIAMSON RONALD R 1058 HORSESHOE RD 12/31/97 581 RES $67,900 $20,800 30.63 BOUTTE JOHN B JR 303 031 00 0 L 10 1390 02053 WHIGHAM JOHN A/REBECCA K 1215 B GEORGE C WILSON 09/12/97 570 COM $475,000 $193,200 40.67 BOUTWELL DARRELL/RANDALL 030 0 104 00 0 1638 01480 JOHNSON EMMA DELL 1850 DERBY DRIVE 07/07/97 562 RES $57,500 $20,680 35.97 BOWDRY CONSTANCE M 071 2 144 00 0 L 7 BL C 2079 00157 WALES DIANE M 4355 CREEKVIEW DR 01/31/97 547 RES $129,000 $54,800 42.48 BOWEN MARVIN E 140 0 750 00 0 17G 400 02698 NORDAHL HOMES INC 3405 DANVERS AVE 12/23/97 581 RES $116,900 $41,600 35.59 BOWERS ANTHONY L 143 665 L 1-14 1288 02082 D & H DEVLOPMENT INC 406 JASPER CROSSING 09/22/97 571 RES $89,000 $36,600 41.12 BOWLES BETSY H L 55 245 01300 SMITH KEITH T/OLDKNOW ROBERT 2723 HENRY ST 05/30/97 559 RES $110,000 $38,360 34.87 BOWLES JOSEPH E/SHIVERS SANDR 33 2 329 L A 1546 02411 KENNETH SMITH HOME BUILDERS IN 1117 FOX DEN ROAD 07/24/97 564 RES $120,000 $45,200 37.67 BOWSER BRIAN K/SCHERRY D 165 0 068 L 7 BL C WALTON ACRE 2101 02490 DAVIS CHARLES R/ERLEEN 2603 CASTLETOWN DRIVE 11/21/97 577 RES $63,900 $15,600 24.41 BOYD GREGORY 130 0 175 00 0 L 2 BL R SEC 2A 1447 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 14 Sample SeUer Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 00829 ELIA HANY W 1244 AUGUSTA WEST PKWV 03/31/97 553 COM $124,800 $55,400 44.39 BOYD JOSEPH W/DARLENE S 30 o 210 1408 01412 FORTUNATO MYRA LISA 3205 HILLSVIEW DRIVE 08/27/97 582 RES $87,000 $27,200 40.60 BOYD KERRY M/TRACYE J 039 0 099 L 3 BL C VALLEY VIEW 570 00578 THOMAS JAMES K/JOSEPH M 934 MURPHY ST 03/04/97 550 RES $28,000 $12,800 48.48 BOYD LARRY J 45 1 79 1881 00938 HELTON KATHY P 5 C 2412 MOHICAN RD 04/28/97 558 RES $85,500 $27,400 41. 83 BOYD LARUEL PERRY 1049 01428 CREECH MARY BELL ET AL 18/17 1940 GEORGE ROAD 08/30/97 582 RES $45,000 $18,580 41.24 BOYD MARGARET/TALMADGE 71 3 107 BL C 853 02334 MILLER PEGGY M 803 MeTTCO STREET 10/01/97 574 RES $89,900 $27,200 38.91 BOYDSTUN DENNIS E JR /ELISE 0 8 50 L 8 BLK A 770 02451 FORD SHIRLEY B/RAY F 4398 PEACH ORCHARD RD 10/30/97 574 RES $108,000 $34,800 32.22 BOYETT LYNN R 275 0 008 2224 01258 SKENES DONALD P JR/LINDA LILL 148 GARDNER'S MILL RD 05/30/97 559 RES $91,900 $38,000 41.35 BRABENEC DEIRDRE A 17 1 187 858 00471 R W RENOVATIONS INC 4 02/13/97 548 RES $74,900 $25,720 34.34 BRADHAM WILBUR H 303 0 002 07 0 0.77 1194 00298 LIVELY C MILNER 1010 HUNTERS GLEN 03/25/97 552 RES $129,900 $52,400 40.34 BRADLEY FANNIE/HOLLOWAY SHEIL 178 0 047 00 0 L 5 BL A 1828 00863 BOGLE JOHN WINSTON/MYRTICE H 1113 BROOKWOOD DRIVE 03/21/97 554 RES $87,000 $38,600 42.07 BRADSHAW RICHARD L/BRENDA W 013 1 078 00 0 L 31-C 2223 02333 MADALINSKI BRURE A/TAMI J 1702 HOLLYHILL RD 10/27/97 574 RES $88,900 $32,000 38.00 BRADY RICHARD T 57 2 152 151 02147 PHILANGIAS DEVELOPMENT LC 302 NEVIS DR 09/29/97 571 RES $58,900 $22,800 38.71 BRAGG CHARLES T 030 0 242 04 0 L 34/1 1727 00171 SELEY PETER S 10 RAINTREE PLACE 01/31/97 547 RES $182,000 $72,680 39.93 BRANAN STEVEN M/JANE F 32 3 137 L 9 BLK B 828 02824 WASHINGTON ROAD DEVELOPERS 7 CHARLESTOWNE DR 04/24/97 557 RES $85,900 $25,000 37.94 BRANTLEY HOKE N 1620 . . . . . . . . . . . q u . . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 15 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 01312 WILLIAMSON RAY JR 3911 PEACH ORCHARD RD 06/05/97 559 RES $65,000 $20,440 31.45 BRASHEAR JAMES H/SANDRA L M 180 0 P 017 PAR 24 1969 02058 L P B PROPERTIES INC 3 ZAHCARY PLACE 07/23/97 570 RES $70,900 $28,600 40.34 BRASSELL JACK D/MIRIAM W 12 1 120 L 74 1743 01040 CURRY GREGORY M/BRIDGES M D 106 FOURTH ST OS/21/97 558 RES $62,580 $26,600 42.51 BRASWELL LORI G 47 2/70 1050 01441 DANIEL ANDREA ANDERSON 2558 RHODES DRIVE 06/30/97 562 RES $44,000 $17,000 38.64 BRATTON TYRONE J 098 1 198 L71 1166 01681 LIVELY PROPS INC 3203 PENINSULA DR 08/06/97 566 RES $93,500 $36,400 38.93 BRESNAHAN MICHAEL J 039 0 208 00 0 L 16E 138 01495 WILSON CAROLYN W 3406 RAVENWOOD DRIVE 06/30/97 563 RES $93,797 $34,000 36.25 BREWER DARYL R MAP 16 PARCEL 136 L 27 BL H 129 00481 NEAL RICHARDA G 4 1508 FORT VIEW COURT 02/11/97 548 RES $36,500 $18,720 51.29 BREWTON REGINA G/TRAVIS S 52/5 4 1467 02769 GILLESPIE EDWARD M 801 MONTESANO AVE 12/01/97 578 RES $39,900 $14,840 37.19 BRIDGES ANNETTE 341 383 08 1512 01556 MARK EDWARD K JR/VICKIE J 3067 WALTON WAY 07/17/97 563 RES $225,000 $92,760 41.23 BRIDGES BARRY WADE/DENISE J 33 1 27 L 3/PT 2 BL B 2379 02799 LIVELY C MILNER 1109 WALTONS TRL 12/05/97 578 RES $139,900 $52,000 37.17 BRIMAGE CHA RON 178 0 081 00 0 L 4 BL B 2241 02667 ASKIN ENTERPRISES LTD CO 90 10/23/97 582 AGR $17 ,900 $4,000 22.35 BRINSON LORETTA 305 16 L 13 BL A 1.87 1962 00004 MCCUMBERS BUILDERS INC 1519 PINE RIDGE DR 01/02/97 544 RES $94,000 $41,080 43.70 BRITT DARRELL/JULIA D 232 153 L 10 BL C 1307 02146 E BLACKBURN CONST CO INC 17 EAGLE POINT DR 09/28/97 571 RES $161,600 $62,000 38.37 BRITT J NEIL/CHRISTY T 23 0 328 1675 02704 LANG MARGARET NORTHCUTT 761 MCCLURE DR 12/31/97 581 RES $83,000 $33,360 40.19 BRITTINGHAM PATRICK A 32 2 26 1067 02636 -- ~ 1008 WOODBERRY DR 10/31/97 575 $107,900 PRICE CHARLES PRESTON RES $46,600 43.19 BROADWATER LYNN A 214 244 L 1 BL B SEC I 824 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 16 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 01083 PHILLIPS BETTY JEAN 701 WRIGHTS AVE OS/22/97 558 RES $28,600 $10,320 36.08 BROADWATER VERNON 35 4 549 2250 00591 STROZ MARC B/CAROLYN D 2009 BARTON COURT 02/18/97 549 RES $85,000 $34,000 40.00 BROCKINGTON JOSEPH/ELIGIE B 145 175 L 35/BL C/SEC IV 1812 00798 REYNOLDS GERALD D/LEWIS RONAL 1250 MARKS CHURCH RD 10/23/97 574 COM $82,000 $17 ,600 21.46 BROCKMAN SHANON C 031 0 007 00 0 2379 01542 GRIFFIN REID W 1212 SANDE HILL PLACE 07/15/97 563 RES $78,000 $27,200 34.87 BROGDEN KYMBRA L 32 4 99 26 1980 01534 SIMONS LINDA S/GARY KENT 2631 RICHMOND HILL ROAD 07/14/97 563 RES $44,500 $18,360 41.26 BROOKS BERNICE 097 2 095 00 0 L 22-N FLEMING H S 1427 01419 VAIDEN JOHN HARRY 7 2614 NATIONAL WOODS 06/30/97 562 RES $80,500 $30,560 37.96 BROOKS JACKIE K/BONNIE J M 013 2 210 00 0 L B 717 01115 SNELLGROVE AARON/AMBER 4302 SEAGO RD 06/20/97 561 RES $62,500 $15,480 24.77 BROOKS ROY DAVID/DONNA SUMMER 232 0 001 28 0 1.72 1508 30018 OLD SAVANNAH RD COM $725,920 $288,480 39.74 BROSIOUS HOLT PROPERTIES L L 123 3 233 0.86 Appraisal 00375 MOODY PETER D/LISHA 2523 BROOKSHIRE ROAD 02/28/97 550 RES $59,900 $21,080 35.19 BROWN ANGELA R 131 o 010 L 12 BL C 2290 01385 R D & D INC 17 2048 GREENLAND RD 06/10/97 560 RES $13,500 $4,000 29.63 BROWN BENJAMIN 191 26 0.63 1856 02930 BOOKER THEODORA D ET AL 1344 STEED ST 10/31/97 580 RES $21,900 $8,640 39.45 BROWN BERNICE N 35 D 154 L 2/BL A 622 01286 THORPE PATRICIA A 960 HEARD AVE 05/30/97 559 RES $138,000 $55,600 40.29 BROWN BRUCE L/RACHEL B 45 1 35 1308 00771 BAGLEY JAMES A 851 LAKE TERRACE DRIVE 03/31/97 553 RES $40,000 $16,800 42.00 BROWN DANIEl P 020 1 207 00 0 L 23 BL Q 414 00294 GREENE DONALD R 4236 WHITE PINE CT 03/24/97 552 RES $84,900 $33,400 39.34 BROWN DARRY LEE 142 44 L 12 BL B PH 1 866 02392 MURPHY CARLENE U 2357 WRIGHTSBORO RD 09/25/97 572 RES $50,000 $18,000 36.00 BROWN DOUGLAS G/LYNIS D 44 3 55 35 '. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 17 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 01717 WIDNER MONROE J/PEARLE J 4440 WINDSOR SPRING RD 08/11/97 566 RES $15,900 $4,800 30.19 BROWN ELIZABETH 1084 00290 MOORE BETTY J 2282 WINSTON WAY 02/24/97 550 RES $40,014 $15,600 38.99 BROWN HAROLD 1065 02161 OWENS LANEY MAE/DRAIDFORT D 14 HALE ST 09/15/97 573 RES $28,000 $13,720 49.00 BROWN HENRY/APRIL 1993 02357 MELVIN BRENDA 3715 MASSOIT DR 10/17/97 574 RES $55,000 $21,440 38.98 BROWN JACQUELINE 94 0 264 121 00125 JACK R NORDAHL BUILDERS INC 1018 WALLIE COURT 01/29/97 546 RES $75,900 $30,400 40.05 BROWN JAQUELINE A 154 0 0327 L 9 BLK B 1778 01176 BOYD ROBERT A 206 BUSBIA AVE 12/09/97 579 RES $57,500 $22,480 39.10 BROWN JOYCE L 1158 01260 MURELL STEPHEN M/DELORES A 05/30/97 559 RES $117,900 $46,800 39.69 BROWN LAMAR JR 25 2 77 688 00765 WHATLEY WILLIAM L 1368 DEWITT ST 04/15/97 554 RES $10,000 $4,200 42.00 BROWN MARTHA J 58 4 307 1058 00740 F&D PROPERTIES INC 2630 HAZEL STREET 04/07/97 554 RES $61,500 $23,000 37.40 BROWN MElVIN 33 2 275 L 90 BL 3 NO HGHLNDS 1500 01603 VARNADO SOLOMON 2559 LINCONTON PARKWAY 07/29/97 565 RES $63,000 $22,240 35.30 BROWN MYRA L 712 01337 THORNTON JUDSON C 3106 HOLLY HAVEN DR 05/16/97 560 RES $127,900 $54,400 42.53 BROWN RANDALL T/COLLEEN D 17 105 491 00136 WATSON MITCHELL HOME BUILDERS 1105 FOX DEN RD 01/14/97 545 RES $138,900 $53,600 38.59 BROWN REGINALD V 165 0 074 00 0 L 13C 1553 01702 D & H DEV INC 410 JASPER CROSSING 08/06/97 566 RES $85,000 $34,200 40.24 BROWN RHONDA J 57HUDSON TRACE 589 02598 CALLAHAN CHARLES A/BARBARA A 3013 HUMMINGBIRD LANE 10/31/97 576 RES $58,900 $25,080 42.58 BROWN ROBIN E 109 1 180 00 0 L 8-G 361 02048 ALLGOODANDREW-R - -- 1838 KISSINGBOWER RD 09/18/97 570 RES $20,000 $11,000 55.00 BROWN ROSCOE/KATHERIN 71 1 130 1336 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 18 Sample Seller Land Diat, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 00012 TEDROW LINDA SANDERS 1836 KISSINGBOWER RD 01/03/97 544 RES $93,000 $34,480 37.08 BROWN ROSCOE/KATHERINE J 071 1 129 2.50 733 02107 DUNAGAN DAVID 1610 FOREST ST 09/25/97 571 RES $22,000 $13,000 59.09 BROWN RUDOLPH L 3/13 756 02364 MITCHUM ANNE/REDDICK LOY 3305 RUSHING RD UNIT 1 10/01/97 573 RES $60,000 $25,160 41.93 BROWN S GRACE 2371 00679 WEST WILLIAM E JR/NANCY F 4115 COUNTRY LANE 04/17/97 555 RES $50,000 $26,000 52.00 BROWN VELMA/CHARLES D 153 o 231 L 10 BL G SEC 3 485 01828 NORWOOD CHARLES W/GLORIA W 2131 WALTON WAY 08/20/97 567 COM $189,000 $70,120 37.10 BROWNING DILLARD 0 34 4 89 1583 02906 CHANNELL CLIFF 2137 WALTON WAY 12/17/97 579 RES $85,000 $36,440 42.87 BROWNING DILLARD 0 034 4 92 00 0 2323 02649 KENNETH SMITH HOMEBUILDERS 2773 SPIRIT CREEK RD 10/31/97 575 RES $129,600 $51,600 39.81 BROWNLEE CURTIS J 338 01422 GRISSOM DAVID JOSEPH 4019 RIO PINAR DRIVE 06/30/97 562 RES $85,900 $32,800 38.18 BRUCE DAYNE S/MICHELLE 787 03046 SHELTON BENNY W/LETA F 1969 LIONEL ST 10/29/97 575 RES $34,986 $8,880 25.38 BRUKER MARJORIE C 87 1/95 L 30/A 1733 02284 CONLEY BARBARA C 156 KERON WAY 09/26/97 572 RES $18,00'0 $6,200 34.44 BRUMITT VINCE E 336 0 156 00 0 L 21 0.67 835 01363 LANE ROGER B JR/CYNTHIA G 2525 CARRIAGE CREEK 06/12/97 560 RES $117,500 $44,200 37.62 BRUNS JEFFREY C 13 1 118 L 13 BL C 1123 01465 BARGERON R WALTER 2105 LARKS COURT 06/30/97 562 RES $129,000 $51,600 40.00 BRUSH LILLIAN H MAP 30 PARCEL 274 L 3 MEADOW/HI L REEK 1696 01985 MURPHY ZANE E/VIVIAN E 1359 BROWN RD 08/29/97 569 RES $110,000 $37,320 33.93 BRYAN RICHARD/DIANA 73 01397 KEYSTONE HOMES INC 2506 WINTERVILLE DR 06/13/97 560 RES $95,000 $38,200 40.21 BRYAN SEVERINE 2245 01573 SKALAK CHRISTY 0 2314 RUTHERFORD AVENUE 06/05/97 564 RES $54,268 $24,000 44.22 BRYANT BERNICE K 121 o 142 L 5 BL A 520 . . . . . . . . . . . u o . . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 19 Sample Seller Land Dlst, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 00457 COLEMAN DOROTHY HARDIN ET AL 703 MILLEDGE RD 01/20/97 548 RES $189,000 $109,520 57.95 BRYANT HENRY GIll 675 01933 AUSTIN PATRICIA J 3813 BEACON DR 08/29/97 568 RES $69,900 $25,400 36.34 BRYANT JAMES C/DORA E L 41 BL D SEC 4A 2073 01965 STRICKLAND PATRICIA L 51 2322 OVERTON DR 08/29/97 569 RES $104,826 $41,600 39.68 BRYANT LILLIAN R/BLACKBURN S 26 4 20 BL 5 0.33 479 01919 WOOD JACK J JR ET AL BRIDGEPORT SEC ,5 08/27/97 568 RES $76,850 $36,400 47.36 BUCKLEY QUINCEY K 52 0 485 L 10 BL A 1816 02606 BLUME KYONG SUK 4607 ETTER LEE RD 09/12/97 569 RES $14,500 $4,440 30.62 BUGGS THOMAS/JANICE 190 0 052 L 5 1.27 2339 03043 ARCHWAY BUILDERS INC 4126 BURNING TREE LN 10/31/97 575 RES $90,400 $30,800 34.07 BUKER KIRK L 214/159 L 14/BL B/PH 1 1983 02962 THOMAS E JR/ROSA L 1210 HEARD AVE 12/23/97 580 RES $77,000 $21,200 27.53 BURDEN MARVIN H/MAYNARD SUSAN 44 4 97 1666 01994 HARLEY JOHN J 1478 GOSHEN RD 09/05/97 569 RES $85,000 $30,000 35.29 BURGESS DENNIS/AMANDA G 1669 01748 WHITE MINNIE LEE 1225 HOLLEY STREET 08/12/97 566 RES $23,000 $6,440 28.00 BURGESS JANET L 2302 02988 WASHINGTON RD DEVELOPERS LLC 16 CHARLESTOWHE DR 12/31/97 581 RES $66,500 $25,000 37.59 BURGESS REBECCA J 011 o 222 01 0 L 8/A 105 00382 DROSS DAVID L 4330 WHITE PINE COURT 02/27/97 550 RES $13,900 $5,400 38.85 BURKE DONALD/MAMIE 155 0 148 L 66 BL A SEC 3 2216 02429 NORDAHL HOMES INC 1741 BROWN ROAD 07/28/97 565 RES $122,400 $50,800 41.50 BURKE FERNANDEZ A SR BL 5 199 00930 JACK R NORDAHL BUILDERS INC 3603 DAYTON STREET 04/30/97 556 RES $76,900 $30,000 39.01 BURKE MELISSA A/RICHARD A 130 0 779 L 1 BL Z PH 2 926 02373 ROBY HUGH/CAROLE 3048 JOHNNY CT 10/17/97 573 RES $49,900 $22,160 44.41 BURKES SHEILA/EVERETT 2246 01570 NORDAHL JACK R 1556 GOSHEN ROAD 07/16/97 564 RES $49,900 $24,880 49.86 BURMEISTER JEFFREY P JR/WENDY 199 0 115 L 11 UNIT B 428 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 20 Sample Seller Land Dht, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 01068 CAMPBELL JOHN F 6 2412 FOREST PARK RD OS/28/97 558 RES $69,900 $28,400 40.63 BURNLEY BOBBY C M 014 3 P 034 BL 0 1878 00448 ALEXANDER HOMES INC 2246 BIRNAM PLACE 02/03/97 548 RES $53,500 $20,800 38.88 BURNS IRIS A 057 3 213 L 24/BL B/PH 2 450 01169 ROBERSON EVELYN H 1151 MERCIER ST 12/11/97 579 RES $6,000 $2,760 46.00 BURROUGHS RUTH J 59 3 295 828 02701 VERDERY ROBERSON JR 827 DANTIGNAC ST 12/10/97 581 RES $9,000 $3,040 33.78 BURROUGHS RUTH J 46 4 181 1209 00606 BRIDGES MARTHA W 2234 BANDLER ROAD 03/28/97 553 RES $28,000 $15,000 53.57 BURTON ALFONSO E MAP 98 1 PARCEL 269 116 00206 WILLIAMS C MURRAY 618 CAMBRIDGE ROAD 02/24/97 549 RES $87,900 $35,360 40.23 BURTON RICHARD T/KATRINA P MAP 25 1 PARCEL 096 L 32 BL G S C II 2334 01311 BARBER JACK T 2104 ELLIS ST OS/27/97 559 RES $27,000 $13,640 50.52 BURTON RICHARD T/KATRINA P L 19 BL B 2082 01740 FARROW JAMES P/JEANETTE K 1297 BROWN RD 08/07/97 566 RES $73,410 $27,920 38.03 BURWELL WILLIAM A 216 0 002 06 0 L 6 BL B SECT I 1915 00135 COOPER CHARLES H 2052/2054 BROAD STREET 01/15/97 545 RES $39,779 $22,320 56.11 BUSH HOWARD S 27 3 142 143 L 491 492 BLK E 1618 01947 TREST YVONNE T 2322 WRIGHTSBORO RD 09/03/97 569 COM $158,000 $60,640 38.38 BUSH LEON HAYS 44 3217 1076 00741 SICILLIANO LARRY F /ELIZABETH 300 GREENE STREET 04/09/97 554 RES $46,500 $21,200 45.59 BUSH MARILINDA MAP 047 4 PARCEL 081 01 UN IT 30 LOG A 1096 01217 DIAMOND TONY 2517 SAND RIDGE CT 06/26/97 562 RES $135,000 $52,800 39.11 BUTLER DARRELL K 139 321 L 33 164 00118 AMMAR TAHAR 2351 PINEWOOD COURT 01/23/97 546 RES $61,900 $25,280 40.84 BUTLER PATRICIA A/ATWELL JOHN 85 1 66 L 18 BL E SECT III 1555 02885 WILLIAMS C MURRAY 520 WINCHESTER DR 05/02/97 557 RES $169,900 $60,000 35.31 BWANALI MOFFATT 24 2 012 L 14/BL D/SEC III 457 02419 ADAMS JOHN A 1749 KING WOODS DR 07/25/97 565 RES $68,000 $26,000 38.24 BYARS T JOEL 57 4 009 70 . . . . . . . . . . . o o . . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 21 Sample Seller Land D1st, land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SlB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 02311 MURRAY DEWAYNE ANTHONY 34 2412 DUBLIN COURT 09/29/97 571 RES $43,000 $19,440 45.21 BYNES JOHNNIE JR Bl I 1981 02908 HURST lINDA 504 MILLEDGE RD 11/21/97 579 RES $70,000 $33,600 48.00 BYRD BEULAH G 2365 02406 MITCHELL MACK C/DOLORES E 07/08/97 564 RES $118,500 $42,800 36.12 BYRD LYNWOOD STEVE MAP 24 2 PARCEL 69 L 28 BL H SE B 2046 01050 CAMPBELL STEVE R/BARBARA J 2609/2609 1/2 CLIFTON ST OS/21/97 558 RES $52,500 $15,600 29.71 BYRD MICHAEL SHANE 43 4 147 l 13/BL E 1413 02409 GERARDOT ROBERT J/LISA S 1209 STOVALL ST 07/25/97 564 RES $89,300 $27,560 30.86 CABLE MARIA M 044 1 126 00 0 2082 02132 LOWE ROBER TDEAN 4 3405 MURA DRIVE 09/26/97 571 RES $79,900 $26,120 32.69 CACERES lUISSETTE M/JESSE J 121 4 097 00 0 1420 00318 SHELLEY CARL JACK 3609 JAMAICAN DRIVE 03/03/97 550 RES $113,000 $43,120 38.16 CALDWELL GERAlD/WYNONA R MAP 31-4 PARCEL 002 l 17 BL I U I 1 366 03001 FOLK TAMMIE N 2390 RICHWOOD DR 12/31/97 581 RES $58,900 $21,400 36.33 CALEB HARRY M 167/269 l 6/C 336 00143 D & H DEV INC 404 JASPER CROSSING 01/10/97 545 RES $88,500 $33,400 37.74 CALHOUN WANDA J 12 1 101 l 54 HUDSON TRACE 830 00882 NORDAHL HOMES INC 1729 BROWN RD 04/03/97 554 RES $101,000 $47,200 46.73 CALTON MARTY W/CYNTHIA J L 2 356 00345 EMDE MARK W/ElIZABETH A 2929 WAKEFIELD COURT 03/17/97 551 RES $64,446 $25,200 39.10 CAMACHO VANDERICK J MAP 141 PARCEL 223 l 12 Bl B-2 1492 02779 THOMPSON MELISSA/FRANK 3334 TOBIN ST 12/01/97 578 RES $67,900 $26,400 38.88 CAMP TANYA/JOHN 1464 02501 BOLTON HUBERT T/AlICE G 2718 HENRY STREET 11/13/97 577 RES $80,000 $33,600 42.00 CAMPBELL CHARLES F/HARRIET M 33 4 14 1044 01771 ASKIN ENTERPRISES LTD CO 86 L 119 MCNUTT ACRES Bl A 05/30/97 567 AGR $12,995 $4,000 30.78 CAMPBELL LAVONDA R 281 123 0.51 472 - - - - - - 01575 LIFSEY GROUP INC 4354 CREEKVIEW DRIVE 07/14/97 564 RES $112,900 $42,800 37.91 CANDELARIA ROBERTO/BRUNILDA 140 0 774 l 12 BL F SEC IV PH3 536 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 22 Sail pIe SeUer Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 01319 CUNNINGHAM AMY AYER/DIXON C 1737 HOLLY HILL RD 08/08/97 559 RES $88,000 $29,200 42.94 CANESTRA ANTHONY F 057 4 050 00 0 L 17/18/19 BL E 2219 03033 HUDSON COMPANY INC 52 EAGLE POINTE COURT 11/05/97 575 RES $157,500 $83,200 40.13 CANNON RICHARD 0 L 22 2170 00998 BRIGHAM MARJORIE BACON 3085 LUMPKIN PARK DR 04/18/97 558 RES $55,600 $23,640 42.52 CANTEEN MELISSA E 096 2 193 00 0 L 51 52 2343 01819 RICHMOND BUILDERS INC 2803 DAVIS MILL CT 08/19/97 581 RES $87,600 $31,200 35.62 CANTY JOHN JR 177 0 035 00 0 L 13" BL J 325 01848 CARPENTER MARY SUE 11 2905 SUSSEX DR 08/15/97 567 RES $97,000 $41,800 43.09 CAPERS JENNIFER LINDLEY 018 3 1 00 00 0 BL B 1981 00451 ALEXANDER HOMES INC 2533 COMMONS TRACE 02/07/97 548 RES $94,000 $38,800 38.94 CAPLAN LEONARD CRAIG 013 1 181 L 7/BL B 499 01174 DOMINION GROUP INC 90 G M AUGUSTA WEST PKWY 12/12/97 579 COM $350,000 $85,000 24.29 CAPTEC NET LEASE REALTY INC 1.22 1124 01234 CARDENAZ MICHAEL S 69 SUNNYVALE LN 08/06/97 561 RES $56,900 $24,000 42.18 CARLSON ANN MARIE 16 2 232 UN 2 BLDG G 836 02431 BROWN TONYA J 2704 BARDAY ST 07/24/97 565 RES $70,900 $26,800 37.80 CARPENTER LEWIS/ALICE M 130 0 277 220 01785 WHISENHUNT CHILDREN INC 7 ZACHARY PLACE 08/15/97 567 RES $88,000 $28,600 42.06 CARPENTER MARY SUE 12 1 1 22 L 76 711 00426 BARLOW & ASSOCIATES INC 4321 CREEKVIEW DR 01/31/97 547 RES $121,900 $48,400 38.06 CARPENTER TROY A 140 734 L 1/BL G/PH II 2197 02106 VAUGHN DALE K 2236 WOODBLUFF WAY 09/25/97 571 RES $100,000 $48,000 48.00 CARPET SHOP INC 018 0 357 00 0 L 32/C/PH II 619 01749 KNOX FOUNDATION 609 FOURTH STREET 07/31/97 566 RES $30,000 $11,520 38.40 CARRIE DAVID 47 4 313 A/B 2324 01291 L L SCRUGGS CONST INC 331 ALEX LN 06/02/97 559 RES $76,000 $30,600 40.26 CARTER CONNIE J 12 2 13 L 8 1278 01754 WASHINGTON RD DEV LLC 222 CHARLESTOWNE WAY 08/13/97 566 RES $70,366 $26,600 37.80 CARTER FRANCES M 11 0222 00 0 L 11B 2372 . . . . . . . . . . . II o tt . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 23 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 01494 BYRD BEULAH C 529 HICKMAN ROAD 06/23/97 563 RES $61,500 $22,360 36.36 CARTER JAY B MAP 35 1 PARCEL 202 127 01369 TRIMMIER ELLEN M 1316 HICKMAN RD 06/09/97 560 RES $75,000 $24,680 32.91 CARTER JAY B/JANET 44 4 147 L C 1397 01866 DAVIS SHIREY H 3311 ASHLEY CT 08/15/97 568 RES $90,500 $39,200 43.31 CARTER JOHN D/MARGARET T 16 2 49 L 31 BL A SEC VI 378 01000 PAGE DAVID 1834 WRIGHTSBORO RD 05/01/97 557 RES $36,000 $14,920 41.44 CARTER SHIRLEY/SANDRA 45 3 349 L 8 28 01276 LIFESEY GROUP INC THE 2504 LENNYS DR 05/30/97 559 RES $101,900 $43,800 42.98 CARTER STANTLEY G/CHERYL F L 71 BL G SEC 3-B 1020 01218 GANDY HARRY T/REGINA 4875 OLD WAYNESBORO RD 06/19/97 562 RES $28,000 $7,880 28.14 CARTLEDGE DEXTER E/MARY D 319 0 002 6.17 195 01914 TILLER TERESA A 3704 DRAYTON DR 08/26/97 568 RES $61,750 $20,800 33.68 CARTWRIGHT ERNEST S JR L 10 BL F SEC IIA 1738 00189 RICHARD BIRD BUILDERS INC 2854 WILLIS FOREMAN RD 01/30/97 547 RES $111,500 $42,000 37.67 CARTWRIGHT REICO R 164 0 124 L 7 996 02800 WASHINGTON ROAD DEVELOPERS IN 2 CHARLESTOWNE DR 12/08/97 578 RES $64,900 $25,000 38.52 CARVER CHARLES T 011 o 222 01 0 L 1 BL A 2251 02680 DEWITT ROBERT L 3317 DAVANT ST 12/30/97 581 RES $69,900 $22,800 32.62 CASEY LEON C JR/BEVERLY F 10 82 L 2 BL C 2047 02522 NORDAHL HOMES INC 3903 RAINSTONE COURT 11/13/97 576 RES $69,900 $28,800 41.20 CASTLEBERRY TERRECE F OUT OF 1430381090 L 10-A 76 00038 NORDAHL HOMES INC 3312 HAMDEN STREET 01/09/97 545 RES $120,900 $46,000 38.05 CASTRO JESUS M L 3-14 710 02051 COLE BRYAN/BRENDA 1019 AZALEA DR 09/17/97 570 RES $62,500 $22,800 36.48 CAUTHEN MARCI B 013 4 105 00 0 1615 03031 AUSTIN ESTELLE 4051 PEACH ORCHARD 10/31/97 575 AGR $64,000 $21,760 34.00 CAWARD INC 195 0 018 00 0 19.43 2228 - - - - - - 00108 WILLIAMS TIMOTHY DAVID 2422 A&RICOT LANE 01/27/97 546 RES $74,000 $29,600 40.00 CAWLEY GEORGE J II 19 2 98 L 18 BL A 1118 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 24 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ra tio 00738 WATKINS WILSON M 1940 1/2 BROAD 03/12/97 554 RES $32,000 $15,360 48.00 CDR PARTNERSHIP 35 2 73 1328 00739 WATKINS WILSON M 1978 BROAD ST 03/12/97 554 RES $50,000 $20,000 40.00 CDR PARTNERSHIP 35 1 009 1330 02569 FERGUSON GEORGE WAYNE/LORI L 2911 CABLE WAY 11/04/97 576 RES $75,500 $24,400 32.32 CEPRESS DENNIS W 52 0 372 L 1 BL D 1161 02021 POOL BRYAN 0 2920 HENRY ST 09/12/97 570 RES $91,900 $36,720 39.96 CHAMBERS JOHN DAVID 033 2 362 00 0 812 01786 CLACK ERVIN JR/KENNETH 1219 KOGER RD 07/21/97 567 RES $24,600 $5,960 24.23 CHANNELL CLIFF 72 1 104 829 02708 MOSS CARY A/ERIKA M 1202 KENDAL CT 12/19/97 581 RES $88,000 $39,200 44.55 CHAPMAN LISA M/CROSBY TONY G 012 1 042 00 0 986 01101 D & H DEVELOPMENT INC 5 251 HUDSON TRACE 06/23/97 561 RES $96,400 $37,800 39.21 CHARITY BRIAN M/HOLLY S 12 1/52 1099 00210 GREENTREE LAND CO 10 GOOLSBY ROAD 02/24/97 550 RES $15,000 $4,760 31.73 CHASTAIN DEBORAH A/ANDREW J 10 00945 MUSGROVE JOYCE ELOISE 110 CURRY STREET 04/30/97 556 RES $33,900 $13,240 39.06 CHAVIS GREGORY A 027 4 08 1562 01347 KNIGHT MELINDA/MELBA 27 1015 STEWART AVE 06/04/97 560 RES $62,900 $24,000 38.16 CHAVOUS RICKY L 020 3 031 00 0 BL C 794 00460 DEGUTES MATHEW J 1308 CABANA COURT 02/12/97 548 RES $56,250 $23,880 42.45 CHEANG CHI P/LAI F 41 1 123 L 9/SEC II 741 02751 PENNINGTON DIANE M/JEFFREY N 2126 TURTLE CT 11/26/97 578 RES $67,900 $22,480 33.11 CHESTER KAREN L 007 3 023 725 00593 DENNIS LOUISE W 1615 GREENWAY DR 02/28/97 549 RES $65,500 $25,200 38.47 CHIKE GARY E/AMY COLMAN 54 2 009 1911 02240 JACKSON ROB THOMAS 120 REYNOLDS ST 10/07/97 572 RES $27,000 $9,560 35.41 CHILDRESS MICHAEL A M 048 1 003 1865 00747 HOFFMAN GRACIELA B 305 VALLEYVUE COURT 02/27/97 554 RES $79,000 $32,000 40.51 CHILDRESS STEPHEN M/CYNTHIA W 18 217 1786 '~. . . . . . . . . . . 4. o . . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 25 Sallple Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 02890 SPEED STEWART R 19/20/21 3113 BRANSFORD RD 05/06/97 557 RES $139,000 $46,880 33.73 CHURCH TRACY A M 032 4 P 079 BL C 504 02577 MORAETES ROBERT T 110 BRANDYWINE PLACE 11 /10/97 576 RES $38,500 $17,040 44.26 CISLO LORI J 012 0 299 00 0 L 4 BL F PHASE I 911 00444 BENTON STEVEN L 211 THREAD NEEDLE RD EAST 02/07/97 548 RES $91,000 $36,000 39.56 CLAFLIN JEFFREY H/GAYLE A 11 3 194 347 02235 FAMBROUGH J HOWARD 3637 BEL AIR RD 09/25/97 572 RES $69,000 $22,240 32.23 CLARK AGNES 53 15 1910 02335 GREEN THOMAS/JANIE B 3027 SUMAC COURT 10/10/97 574 RES $86,000 $33,920 39.44 CLARK ARTHUR L/NITA R 84 2 46 L 13 BL J SECT FOUR 755 01350 WILLIAMS SIDNEY 2634 DRAYTON DR 05/30/97 560 RES $59,000 $20,800 35.25 CLARK CARMEN L L 18 BL B 821 02055 PHILANGIAS DEVELOPMENT L C 304 NEVIS DR 09/17/97 570 RES $59,900 $22,800 38.06 CLARK CAROLE J 030 0 242 04 0 L 36/J 1691 02099 HUMPHREY GERALD F/TERESA 0 3313 BLANCHARD RD 09/05/97 571 RES $54,500 $24,080 44.18 CLARK CHERYL W 108 95 L 8/BL H/SEC 1 505 00901 LIVelY C MILNER 2913 ARROWOOD CIR 04/24/97 556 RES $139,900 $47,600 34.02 CLARK MARYL YNN 139 434 L 181 BL B PH II 307 01854 GLENN RICHARD/NAOMI 121 E WATKINS ST 08/19/97 568 RES $9,500 $5,200 54.74 CLARK THOMAS L SR/AUNDRA G 66 05 l 13 BL C SEC I 29 00364 MCNAIR FAYE/WILSON PARIS 2421 GREENS ROAD 03/26/97 552 RES $49,900 $9,560 19.16 CLARK TONJA M 83 141 l 2 2235 02479 BRASWELL JAMES A JR 2077 FERNWOOD CIRCLE 11 /21 /97 577 RES $64,100 $25,960 40.50 CLARKE ANTONIO L 110 1 145 L 10 Bl A SEC III 1851 02815 ROSS EMILY HILL/WILLIAM C JR 2233 MCDOWELL ST 05/15/97 557 RES $225,000 $87,800 39.02 CLARKE CATHY B 044 2 014 00 0 L A 1313 00342 WILSON THOMAS E III TRACT A-1 02/28/97 551 COM $122,500 $71,120 58.06 CLARKE JAMES III/BERTHA ET AL 8.88 1536 01731 ROGERS JOAN-H /ROBYNS. . . 1102 MERRY STREET 08/12/97 566 RES $36,000 $21,840 60.67 CLARKE JAMES RIll/BERTHA L 045 1 193 00 0 L 80 1768 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 28 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 00085 ADAMS ROBERT J 88 1015 HOLDEN STREET 01/17/97 548 RES $29,500 $20,380 89.02 CLARY SARAH M 045 1 148 00 0 33 02488 FRENCH ROBERT A/JANE A 801 CARRIAGE COURT 11/24/97 577 RES $173,000 $88,000 39.31 CLAUSSEN J C HENRY III 33 1 184 L 17 CARRIAGE HILL 1424 02031 JOHNSON DUNCAN N 935/943 WALKER ST 09/18/97 570 COM $180,000 $40,000 25.00 CLEMENTS RALPH A/JOHN A 48 2 77/48 2 81 935 00810 JAMES THOMAS R/COVINGTON DONN 579 MARTIN LANE 03/08/97 550 RES $100,000 $44,780 44.78 CLIETT RAYMOND O/BARBARA A 033 1 084 00 0 L 12-A 1125 02780 PIERSON WORLEY E JR 3788 BELAIR RD 05/07/97 578 RES $20,000 $8,200 31.00 CLIETT RICHARD/SANDRA S 53 28 1103 03051 DODSON BOBBY 1954 MILTON RD 08/27/97 578 RES $15,000 $7,980 53.07 CLIMER FRED M o 88 1 030 00 0 2273 02013 JOHN C WEAVER HOME BUILDERS IN 4848 STOREY MILL RD 09/12/97 570 RES $98,500 $37,320 37.89 COBURN PATRICIA A 272 o 138 00 0 L 12 409 01834 PARKER ANTHONY O/SANDRA P 3521 JAMAICA DR 07/30/97 585 RES $99,000 $39,400 39.80 CODY MARY A 031 4 008 00 0 L 11 BL B SECT I 1338 01891 BOOTH ROBERT THOMAS 1434 JOHNS RD 07/30/97 588 RES $104,400 $37,200 35.83 COLASANTO JOHN V 44 3 102 458 00112 CAMPBELL MARTHA L 2432 MIKE PADGETT HWY 01/24/97 548 RES $17,990 $8,780 37.58 COLEMAN ALVIN L/VERONIA D 99 1 103 01 L 13 BLK A 1243 00443 BELDING 0 W III 1210 GEROGE C WILSON DR 02/08/97 548 COM $241,309 $74,000 30.87 COLEMAN HENRY R 031 0 158 01 0 323 01522 NORDAHL HOMES INC 3201 MARS STRAND COURT 08/30/97 563 RES $119,500 $47,800 39.83 COLEMAN STANLEY E 184 0217 L 18 BL E SEC IV 1028 01479 BARLOW & ASSOCIATES INC 4517 RIDGE RUN DRIVE 08/27/97 582 RES $136,870 $50,800 37.12 COLEMAN VALERIE D/WAYNE E 140 779 L 19 BL D SEC 4 PH 4 2043 01913 GARDEN CITY HOMES INC 2930 ARROWOOD CIR 08/28/97 568 RES $115,900 $49,600 42.80 COLLAZO EDDIE S 139 398 L 145 BL A PH II 1729 02870 DEAL DAVID A/MARY B 1807 ROSE LANE 04/30/97 557 RES $62,900 $24,280 38.60 COLLINS MOZELLE 71 1/77 L 4/BL B 38 . . . . . . . . . . . l . o . . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 27 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 02718 GARDEN CITY HOMES 13 PARK PLACE CT 12/23/97 581 RES $250,000 $109,200 43.68 COLQUITT WILLIE J/DORIS/IRMA 23 285 L 15 BL B 608 02537 WASHINGTON ROAD DEVELOPERS IN 4 CHARLESTOWNE DRIVE 11/14/97 576 RES $65,250 $25,000 38.31 COLWEll KAREN OUT OF 011 0 222 01 0 L 2 BL A 2178 02756 WASHINGTON ROAD DEVELOPERS LL 202 CHARLESTOWNE WAY 12/01/97 578 RES $86,900 $26,600 30.61 COLWELL MADELINE KNICK 011 o 222 01 0 L 1 BL B 945 00456 DEKALB JAMES E JR 2605 NATIONAL WOODS DR 02/03/97 548 RES $89,900 $35,760 39.78 COMPTON JAMES R 13 2/222 L 4/BL A 662 01784 LOVENTHALL RITA K 2108 GARY PL 08/01/97 567 RES $52,000 $20,200 38.85 COMPU-TEST INC 35 3 439 1182 00371 KENT HELEN K 2361 FRANKLIN STREET 03/27/97 552 RES $49,000 $20,960 42.78 CONKRIGHT WILLIAM J/KAJSE K 97 4 36 L 9 BL K 2329 00732 CARSWELL A SCOTT 2422 WASHINGTON ROAD 04/14/97 554 RES $51,500 $21,400 41.55 CONNELL DENISE 1518 02206 DURDEN LEMUEL L 1110 COLONY PLACE DR 09/29/97 573 RES $37,000 $16,640 44.97 CONNELL VICKI A 12 3 55 549 02417 ARCHWAY BUILDERS INC 4117 BURNING TREE LN 07/25/97 564 RES $96,000 $35,600 37.08 CONOVER KENNETH W/MARGARET J 214 147 L 7 BL C PH 1 2259 00715 RASCAL ENTERPRISES INC 124 PLAT FOR RASCAL 04/17/97 555 RES $20,000 $8,960 44.80 COOK JAMES M SR/GENE L 5.21 993 01126 JACK R NORDAHL BUILDERS INC 3504 SIDESADDLE COURT 06/20/97 561 RES $74,900 $31,200 41.66 COOK JUSTIN C/ANGELA B L 14/BL H/SEC 5 1850 02270 C & R HOME BUILDERS INC 2410 RAMBLEWOOD DR 09/30/97 572 RES $91,900 $35,400 38.52 COOK PAUL/JANICE G 143 0 707 00 0 L 16 994 01923 LIFSEY GROUP THE 3303 BALKCOM DR 08/22/97 568 RES $125,000 $46,600 37.28 COOKE CONRAD 1865 02485 FANCHER CALVIN M 12 4204 BECKMONT DR 11/25/97 577 RES $61,000 $21,880 35.87 COOPER MICHAEL 0 167 246 BECKMONT SUB 1480 02972 GAGNE LIONEL pu - - 2604 WHITTIER PLACE 12/24/97 580 RES $78,700 $29,600 37.61 COOPER NICOLE/JANIE MAE 140 0 268 00 0 L 41/BL A SEC IIA 2110 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 28 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 01655 ADNREWS CAMERON D ET AL 2440 DEODARA DR 07/31/97 565 RES $83,000 $32,280 38.89 COOPER VENESSA S/BETTY S 14 78 1946 02435 JOHNSON BIRNET L 3044 JOHNNY COURT 07/25/97 565 RES $53,950 $19,720 36.55 COPELAND MONICA L 107 690 L 17 BL E SEC 1D 273 00769 BOYCE DAVID P JR/JENNIFER J 3640 CRAWFORDVILLE DRIVE 03/31/97 554 RES $88,000 $37,400 42.50 COPELAND YOLANDA F MAP 53 PARCEL 259 L 9 BL G SEC - 1606 02780 ROSENGREN YOUNG 0 2861 GLENN HILLS CIR 06/30/97 578 RES $43,500 $18,960 43.59 COPING BARBARA S 84 3 195 L 13 BL D SEC V 1479 02790 HOLLIMAN ROY L/MARY 2854 GLENN HILLS CIR 12/05/97 578 RES $46,000 $19,360 42.09 COPING BARBARA S 1797 00060 PERROW DANIEL M/ET AL 1730 DREXEL AVE 01/16/97 545 RES $75,900 $30,080 39.63 CORBITT STETSON K 57 1 194 1788 01523 JACK R NORDAHL BUILDERS INC 3409 SADDLE HORN RUN 07/09/97 563 RES $71,900 $30,800 42.84 CORBO ROBERT L 129 0 658 L 29 BL J PH IV 1038 02822 HOGARTH ARTHUR L/HIROKA I 411 BROOKSIDE DR 05/15/97 557 RES $145,000 $52,520 36.22 CORLEY JENNY W 44 2 151 1573 00847 MILLS DEANNE MARIE 5 2921 WOLF COURT 04/03/97 553 RES $88,500 $28,400 32.09 COSNOHA MARTHA B M 015 P 106 M 2151 01393 MOHR MARY G/EPPS HELEN J 836 RIVERFRONT DR 05/30/97 560 RES $114,000 $45,800 40.18 COULTER DONALD A/ELIZABETH 076 0 028 00 0 2207 02992 NORDAHL HOMES INC 3408 DANVERS AVE 12/19/97 581 RES $114,900 $43,600 37.95 COUNCIL DONZELL/CATHYE E 143/680 L 4-13 172 01510 NORDAHL HOMES INC 3440 MONTE CARLO DRIVE 07/11/97 563 RES $84,900 $34,000 40.05 COURTNEY WAYMAN/SHELLIE L L 1-C 554 00820 FOX LESTER A/PHYLLIS J 441 SCOTTS WAY 04/01/97 553 RES $192,000 $77,600 40.42 COWART JOSEPH C 013 2 146 3/G 1029 00123 LEISURE HOMES INC 517 BRENDELL PLACE 01/17/97 546 RES $65,900 $26,200 39.76 COX LISA C 11 2 7 L 5 BRENDELL PLACE 1598 02947 RICHARD BIRD BUILDERS 2111 STOKER PLACE 12/18/97 580 RES $97,000 $38,000 39.18 CRANDALL MARK ROSS 977 '. . . . . . . . . . . u o . . . . . . . . . County: 121 RicHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 29 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 02786 MOSS GLORIA DAVIS 1550 A DOUG BERNARD PKWV 12/03/97 578 RES $40,000 $8,040 20.10 CRAVEN DONNIE A SR 099 0 072 00 0 1578 02681 SALTER BOBBY K JR/HELOISE 4760 E WAYNESBORO RD 11/20/97 577 RES $105,000 $32,920 31.35 CRAWFORD ALVIN A/JANICE K 320 1 8 7.29 2251 00567 RAY FREDERICKS PROPERTIES INC 3603 STURNIDAE DR 03/13/97 551 RES $59,900 $20,280 33.86 CRAWFORD DIANE/LEVOR HENRY 120 0 57900 0 L 23/A 647 00232 NORDAHL HOMES INC 3541 CRAWFORDVILLE DRIVE 03/14/97 552 RES $108,100 $42,600 39.41 CRAWFORD JAMES H 052 o 518 00 0 L 51-B 606 00336 ALEXANDER HOMES INC 2250 BIRNAM PLACE 03/12/97 551 RES $54,900 $20,800 37.89 CRAWFORD NICOLE E 057 3 215 L 26 BL B PH 2 1023 02674 FERRER JIMMY 3709 TEAKWOOD CT 12/31/97 582 RES $66,500 $25,440 38.26 CRAWFORD TERANCE 153 0 502 L 60 BL B 987 01692 KNOX FOUNDATION 337 WALKER STREET 08/01/97 566 RES $31,000 $17,320 55.87 CRAWFORD YOLANDA 47 4 182 510 02759 CANADY WILLIAM R 3030 LOUISVILLE RD 11/28/97 578 RES $18,000 $7,000 38.89 CREASY LORENZO 111 3 055 00 0 1038 01225 MOHR MARY GEORGIA/EPPS HELEN 809 AUMOND PLACE WEST 06/27/97 562 RES $228,000 $83,200 36.49 CREECH LANE T SR/MOSS ANNE H 032 1 045 00 0 L 15 BL A 250 02758 BARLOW & ASSOCIATES INC 4526 RIDGE RUN DR 11/21/97 578 RES $113,900 $45,200 39.68 CRENSHAW GLYNN/JUDITH D 140 798 L 13 BL E SEC IV 1024 01431 ISDELL RICHARD 250 GREENE ST 06/30/97 562 RES $151,500 $59,480 39.26 CRESCI ANTHONY B II /GAIL A 047 4 125 00 0 1224 02472 RASCAL ENTERPRISES INC 124 KRISTIN LANDING SECT II 10/06/97 577 RES $18,500 $4,920 29.82 CRIDER KEN/DARLENE L 46 BL B 2.06 1734 02915 KINGSBURY CUSTOM HOMES INC 2712 CULVERTON DR 12/16/97 580 RES $109,900 $39,400 35.85 CRISPELL AUDREY 52/650 L 6/N SEC 3A 235 01375 LIVELY C MILNER 1002 HUNTERS GLEN 06/13/97 560 RES $129,900 $49,200 37.88 CROMER DONNIE G/MARY A 178 0 043 00 0 L 1 BL A 1557 01869 DRAGON TREE PROPERTIES INC 2677 BARCLAY ST 08/25/97 568 RES $65,200 $24,800 38.04 CROSSON BRIAN M 130 0 367 00 0 L 46 BL A 431 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 30 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 00969 BRUKER CO 21 301 ALIX LANE 04/14/97 558 RES $78,500 $29,800 37.96 CRUMBLEY TAMMY/CHARLES 012 2 028 00 0 1726 01449 MILLER MICHAEL R/JANET S 3025 SILVERWOOD DRIVE 07/01/97 582 RES $77,900 $32,800 42.11 CRUTCHFIELD DORIS 0 MAP 7 0 PARCEL 040 L 14 BL B 1272 01111 SUNTREE REAL ESTATE CO INC 1898 NEPTUNE DRIVE 06/24/97 581 RES $59,600 $20,880 34.70 CUBIlLOS JOSE V 123 3 220 00 0 L 18/B 1303 01381 DAVIS PARMA CHARLTON/BARBARA 8 TAll PINE CT 08/13/97 580 RES $299,900 $106,400 35.48 CUDD E PARKER 23 0 159 1805 01770 WARTHEN JAMES C 2840 APRIL DR 08/11/97 587 RES $8,500 $2,800 43.08 CULBREATH GENE 94 348 298 02745 THOMAS CHARLES/SAEKO 2090 BROWN RD 11/28/97 578 RES $85,000 $28,200 33.18 CULBRETH MARK/DIANNA 608 02432 TOWNER CHARLES E JR/SUSAN B 3243 RAMS GATE RD 07/25/97 585 RES $139,000 $57,200 41.15 CUMISKY WILLIAM P/NICOLA D 24 1 057 232 01043 SCAVULLO CHARLES J/ALICE J 807 POINDEXTER DR OS/23/97 558 RES $253,500 $92,000 38.29 CUNDEY PAUL III 032 2 144 00 0 L 8/E 1090 01087 MALONE HARODL LEE/BESSIE M 810 POINDEXTER DR OS/27/97 558 RES $154,900 $72,380 48.71 CUNDEY RICHARD D/NEISHA B 32 2 153 L 10/BL D 2357 01213 HOGAN JULIA 16 LAKE SHORE LOOP 08/25/97 562 RES $49,900 $16,400 32.87 CURTIS KENNY R 020 3 284 00 0 82 01667 SCOTT RAYMOND E 3834 PAMPONA DR 08/05/97 565 RES $82,500 $23,280 37.25 D'AVILAR VICTOR G/SHAWN K 141 0 077 00 0 L 37C 2194 01285 RADFORD ELVA BABBITT 1429 STOVAll ST 08/02/97 559 RES $55,000 $34,400 62.55 DALE MARGARET SIBLEY 44 3 077 1221 02342 ALEXANDER HOMES INC 2525 COMMONS TRACE 10/08/97 573 RES $93,900 $38,200 40.68 DALTON LEAH 651 02592 STEWART JOHNNY E JR WEST SIDE CITATION ROAD 09/26/97 576 RES $22,500 $8,000 35.56 DALZELL MARK K/PENNY L 233 o 158 03 0 482 02593 FLAHERTY JEFFREY A/PATRICIA S WEST SIDE CITATION ROAD 09/28/97 578 RES $22,500 $8,000 35.56 DALZELL MARK K/PENNY L 233 o 158 04 0 8.00 463 . . . . . . . . . . . q u tt . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 31 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 02946 MCCAFERTY TERESA 0 1529 SANTA ROSA DRIVE 12/19/97 580 RES $65,000 $23,600 36.31 DANIEL HERBERT LOUIS 184/96 L 4/BL C 965 01686 KENNETH SMITH HOMEBUILDERS IN 4516 RIDGE RUN RD 08/05/97 566 RES $130,000 $46,800 36.00 DARDEN LOIS Y/JOHN 235 03002 SHOWMAN LONNIE J/JULIA A 2212 MORNINGSIDE DR 12/30/97 581 RES $151,000 $62,400 41.32 DASHER PAULA W 026 4 132 00 0 L 11/C 348 01513 SHEPHERD ROSE A SETON 3003 WRIGHTSBORO RD 06/25/97 563 RES $56,300 $23,920 42.49 DAVENPORT DONNA B 43 1 142 PT L 138/L 139 ET AL 589 01713 WASHINGTON RD DEV LLC 3 CHARLESTOWN DR 08/08/97 566 RES $59,900 $25,000 41.74 DAVIDSON RONNIE G II/RONNIE L 61A 985 01357 VAUGHN DALE K 2250 WOODBLUFF WAY 06/11/97 560 RES $92,500 $50,000 54.05 DAVIS A M III 18 343 L 46 BL C PH II 1008 02931 FAURE MIGUEL E 3640 CRANBROOK DR 11/26/97 580 RES $64,000 $25,600 40.00 DAVIS ALLEN/SHEREKA M L 32/BL R/SEC 2/B 640 01794 GRABENDIKE STEVEN E 2513 HANOVER STREET 08/15/97 567 RES $59,900 $25,600 42.74 DAVIS DENISE J 131 o 165 00 0 L 7 BL B SECT I 1077 01206 SCHMIDEL JUDITH S 1964 BATTLE ROW 06/26/97 562 RES $32,000 $13,560 42.38 DAVIS JACK 35 1 404 L 6 BL J 173 01144 ARCH J FREEMON BUILDERS 2319 BRADfORD COURT 12/17/97 579 RES $67,900 $28,000 41.24 DAVIS JENNIFER L/ROBERT C JR 119 492 L 83/BL X/SEC 2 C 91 01353 THOMAS ROBERT P/KATHRYN A 2910 LAKE FOREST DR OS/23/97 560 RES $249,900 $76,480 30.60 DAVIS JOHN R JR/NANCY L 33 4 85 L 6 BL 3 857 02860 CANTRELL WILLIAM DAVID 22 3305 QUAKER SPRINGS RD 05/16/97 558 RES $69,370 $31,600 45.55 DAVIS JOSE&H W 016 0 181 00 0 BL A 238 01493 THOMPSON GREGG E/BEVERLY 2414 FOREST PARK ROAD 06/23/97 563 RES $79,900 $31,200 39.05 DAVIS SCOTT A/PAM S MAP 14 3 PARCEL 33 L 5 BL 0 SEC I 117 02218 ISADOOST SHAHROKH 2530 PATE AVE 09/30/97 573 RES $70,000 $26,160 37.37 DAVIS WILLIE L 97 2 106 24 02210 WELCH MARGARETTE F- 126 EVE ST 10/09/97 573 RES $24,500 $10,000 40.82 DAVISON MARK A/ENNIS LARRY G 035 2 007 00 0 440 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 32 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 02770 MOORE THOMAS A SR 1850 WATKINS ST 12/04/97 578 RES $25,000 $12,840 51.36 DAVISON MARK A/ENNIS LARRY G 1532 02647 LIFSEY GROUP THE 2701 BLOSSOM DR 10/31/97 575 RES $84,900 $25,600 39.45 DAWSON ETHELYN 0 314 00352 HARRIS GLEN 0 1775 TAYLOR ROAD 02/13/97 551 AGR $42,000 $22,980 54.67 DAWSON GREGORY S 183 o 20 3 12.73 1785 00094 KENNETH SMITH HOMESBUILDERS I 1055 FOX DEN RD, 01/15/97 546 RES $124,900 $49,200 39.39 DEAN ERIC M 185 0 059 L 3 BLK A PH 2 274 01752 PARRISH CLIFTON WADE 3235 W WIMBLEDON DR 08/13/97 568 RES $45,000 $16,320 36.27 DEAN EUGENE F/MARIE J 31 4 047 69 UNIT C 2316 02084 CLARK CHARLES A/CAROLE J 9 3016 LANGFORD DR 09/15/97 570 RES $89,900 $35,520 39.51 DEAS AUDREY T M 033 1 067 BL A 1985 00446 LIFSEY GROUP INC 3404 CHARING CROSS COURT 02/10/97 548 RES $49,995 $19,520 39.04 DEBERRY LEON W/KINZER SHANTEL 107 0 303 L 38/BL C SEC I 378 00843 TEMPLE 0 ROY 2339 MONCRIEFF STREET 03/28/97 553 RES $72,900 $25,600 35.12 DEDNAM CARL 167 o 613 L 19 1884 01837 RODGERS RONALD LAVARN 3650 PEBBLE CREEK DR 07/25/97 565 RES $51,400 $21,800 42.41 DEES BETTYE L 129026 4000 L 4C 1374 02938 MORANT DONALD 12/18/97 580 RES $47,500 $16,200 34.11 DEKLE TILDA D 731 02494 WIGGINS JAN G 1527 SCHLEY ST 11/24/97 577 RES $73,500 $26,120 35.54 DElLUMO JAMES JOSEPH M 044 1 P 202 1371 02040 FULTON elROY C 2290 BASSWOOD DR OS/23/97 570 RES $64,900 $25,120 38.71 DelOACH JAMES 167 380 L 6/BL K/SEC 3 B 1016 00178 CARPENTER ROY C JR 103 CHURCH STREET 01/30/97 547 RES $25,000 $9,720 38.88 DELOACHE MICHAEL K 267 0 008 711 00720 COFER ROBERT H LUCKEY STREET 02/17/97 555 COM $12,000 $3,440 28.67 DEMelLO ROBERT L 11/12/13 BL 3 2302 02159 KENNETH SMITH HOMBUILDERS 1120 FOX DEN RD 10/15/97 573 RES $125,900 $50,800 40.35 DEMMING HELENA 2000 . . . . . . . . . . . 4. . . . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 33 Sample Seller Land Dlst, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 01871 RANDOLPH PHYLLIS F 2908 RUNNING CREEK LN 08/20/97 568 RES $88,400 $33,800 38.24 DENIS ALBERT J/LINDA 016 2 089 00 0 L 4 BL B 457 01268 WEST WENDELL SWAIN 4311 WHITE PINE CT 05/30/97 559 RES $87,290 $33,400 38.26 DENNIS PATRICK D/ELIZABETH M 142 0 033 00 L 33 BL A PH I 935 02884 LIVELY C MILNER 2922 ARROWWOOD CIR 05/06/97 557 RES $139,900 $56,400 40.31 DENSON LAWYER SR 139 402 L 149/BL A/PH II 449 01594 HORVATH TIBOR 3634 MEADOWGROVE DR 07/15/97 564 RES $52,000 $20,800 40.00 DENT HORACE B 1297 01698 HALL MARION H 3105 EDINBURGH DR 07/30/97 566 RES $89,500 $34,720 38.79 DENT LAURA ELLEN 24 2 61 L 20 BL H SECT III 499 02550 HOBBINS SARA M 822 JOHNS RD 11/14/97 576 RES $156,400 $59,200 37.85 DEROLLER HILLIS B/COOKE ALAN 34 4 085 1884 01249 SID BECKUM CONST INC 38 7 EAGLE POINTE DR OS/28/97 559 RES $155,900 $58,800 37.72 DESTEFANO JAMIE A 426 01084 HENDERSON PHILIP S 1403 HABERSHAM DR OS/28/97 558 RES $65,000 $28,560 43.94 DEVORE GUY S 41 1 11 L 33/BL A 2282 00588 BENTON LARRY WHEELER 1209 MONTE SANO AVE 02/28/97 549 RES $65,000 $25,800 39.69 DEWBERRY HILSMAN A JR/HAlEL P 034 3 164 00 0 APT 17 BLD 3 2060 01521 BLACK RUDI A 3614 SEELYE DRIVE 07/14/97 563 RES $79,900 $30,800 38.55 DEWEY MARVIN C 132 o 434 L 7 BL P SEC 3-D 1020 02078 TROTTER OFFICE BUILDING L P 1227 AUGUSTA WEST PKWY 09/18/97 571 COM $565,000 $180,800 32.00 DIANATI M HASSAN/BEHJAT F 30 216 23 00182 TROTTER BUILDERS INC 233 DAVIS RD 01/28/97 547 COM $312,500 $114,840 36.75 DIANATI M HASSAN/REHJAT F TR 2 0.20 811 01797 GROUP LIFESEY 4537 RIDGE RUN DR 08/07/97 567 RES $130,900 $48,400 36.97 DIAl LUIS A L 28A BL D 115 01468 BRACKEN ROY D 22 3217 CHILTON LANE 06/30/97 562 RES $125,000 $41,600 33.28 DICKERSON DOROTHY F 40 118 BL C 1788 01908 TUTTLE BOBBY W1KATHLEEN H 834 HEARD AVE 08/29/97 568 RES $54,000 $25,600 47.41 DICKEY JAMES A/BRENDA J 035 3 352 1694 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 34 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 01278 WOODS DENNIS M/TERRY JAN 2911 WESTCHESTER DR 08/02/97 559 RES $129,900 $80,780 48.77 DINGES EMILY J 018 0 150 00 0 L 22 BL C 1044 02353 LARUSSA JASON B502 3504 BRYON PL 10/23/97 574 RES $18,000 $8,180 45.33 DINKINS TERRIE 53 194 431 30031 3013 PEACH ORCHARD RD COM $247,010 $103,800 41.94 DIVALL INS INC PROP 110 1 70 0.77 Appraisal 00195 FREDERICKS RAY 3050JOHNNY COUIH 02/04/97 547 RES $54,900 $21,840 39.78 DIXON CHANDRA D 107 0 887 L 14 BLK E SECT 1D 1249 02918 HYDRICK JIMMIE LEE ET AL 1745 OLD SAVANNAH RD 10/27/97 580 COM $15,000 $5,880 37.87 DIXON GEORGE N 59 3 319 582 02182 GODIVA OF GEORGIA 3720 LEXINGTON DR 10/17/97 573 RES $84,900 $33,380 39.29 DIXON JACQUELINE 1971 02578 HOMESITES LTD 2703 CULVERTON DRIVE 11/07/97 578 RES $15,950 $8,200 38.87 DIXON NANCY L 52 823 L 39 BM M SEC 3A 1003 01251 HUGHES FRANCES H/WILLIAM H 1748 DAVIDSON DR OS/29/97 559 RES $34,500 $13,440 38.98 DIXON RUDOLPH S JR/CHERYL T 57 3 100 513 00292 BLUME DALLAS 880 B BENNOCK MILL RD 03/24/97 552 RES $11,500 $3,180 27.48 DO JAN CATHY/DONNY VAN 281 0 078 00 0 1050 00092 JAMES LEROY/LADORIS K 1822 WYLDS RD 01/17/97 548 RES $88,900 $33,800 38.67 DOBBS GWENEVER W 054 2 185 L 15 BLK F SEC 3 212 00724 FRANK A CALHOUN & CO INC CENTRAL AVENUE 04/28/97 555 COM $85,000 $35,880 55.20 DOLYNIUK HARRY J 44 1 217 2217 01525 SHELL KENNETH W/JEAN T 2729 RABORN ROAD 07/10/97 583 RES $89,900 $31,400 44.92 DOOLITTLE HENRY D/JUDY L MAP 192 PARCEL 013 2.00 1087 00233 DUNAGAN DONALD 3809 CAMERON DRIVE 03/21/97 552 RES $58,000 $22,840 40.43 DORCELUS ADA M 107 0 704 00 0 L 14-B 588 00748 MURRAY ESTHER B MAGNOLIA VILLAS CONDO PH2 04/18/97 554 RES $185,000 $51,720 31.35 DORIS MAUDE GARY 034 4 078 31 0 L B-1 1775 00830 JAMES VINSON RALEY 2384 TRAVIS PINES 04/24/97 555 RES $58,500 $23,840 40.75 DORSEY RICO/YOLANDA 154 0 121 L 20 BL B 1805 . . . . . . . . . . . I ~ u ~. . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 35 Sallple Seller land Dist, Land lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assess_ent No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SlB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 00401 HOLMES lARRY 17 3669 WOODCOCK DRIVE 01/31/97 547 RES $77 , 000 $29,600 38.44 DORSEY SAMUEL B M 130 0683 Bl F 1691 01290 COWART JOSEPH C 2707 SMITH CREEK RD OS/29/97 559 RES $125,900 $47,800 37.97 DOSS W TRAVIS JR/KATHERINE C 13 3 59 l 22 Bl II SEC 2 1269 00965 HUDSON VALERA l 2010 SUMMER RIDGE DR 04/30/97 556 RES $94,000 $34,400 36.60 DOSTER THOMAS D/ERIKA D 045 1 379 00 0 l17 1666 02329 ABELMAN HARRIS M/GLORIA F 3104 SHEllEY COURT 10/27/97 574 RES $87,200 $32,200 36.93 DOUGLAS ALBERT W/KATHERINE C l 6 WOODSIDE TERRACE 1015 01448 WASHINGTON ROAD DEVELOPERS II 218 CHARlESTOWNE WAY 07/01/97 562 RES $82,900 $25,000 39.75 DOWNEY JOHN M NEW FOR 1998 OUT OF 1263 02846 MARION LUlA MAUDE P 3040 PINE NEEDLE RD 05/15/97 557 RES $125,000 $59,840 47.87 DOWNING MICHAEL l/ROBINSON D 43 1 79 2299 00091 COOPER CHARLES H/JANICE F 3427 MORGAN RD 01/21/97 546 RES $54,900 $20,120 38.65 DOWNS JUNE CARTER/EMMA 118159 l 7 BL A 205 00928 FRONT-LINE HOMES INC 2608 SPIRIT CREEK RD 05/01/97 556 RES $77,900 $30,400 39.02 DOYLE CARlETHA SMITH l 24 BLK A PH I 897 02502 HARRISON JESSIE M/SUSAN l 1917 ROZELLA STREET 11/13/97 577 RES $45,000 $15,440 34.31 DOYLE RENEE L 1152 01562 SID BECKUM CONSTRUCTION INC 2919 ARROWWOOD CIRCLE 07/15/97 564 RES $128,900 $50,400 39.10 DOZIER JEAN E MAP 139 PARCEL 431 L 178 Bl B P A E II 230 01167 HISTORIC AUGUSTA INC 982 BROAD ST 12/12/97 579 COM $45,000 $18,920 42.04 DOZIER MARY PAULINE 37 3 164 819 00726 ALTON GARRETT M/DOROTHY W 3105 BRANSFORD ROAD 04/28/97 555 RES $116,000 $40,000 34.48 DOZIER THOMAS MIll/CHANDLER MAP 33 3 PARCEL 105 2258 02941 SNYDER EUGENE 2938 ROLlINGWOOD DR 12/15/97 580 RES $37,000 $20,480 55.35 DRAGON TREE PROPERTIES IC 107 0 593 00 0 L 26/D 779 02332 CAMPBELL STEVE R 4241 WINDSOR SPRING RD 10/23/97 574 RES $61,900 $20,520 33.15 DRAKE MARK E 824 02665 RASCAL ENTERPRISES INC 86 11/10/97 582 AGR $13,500 $5,880 43.56 DRAKE MORRIS W JR/GIBBS MElIS l 30 1.34 1951 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 36 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 00275 SIMMONS GEORGE J JR 3143 CORNER STREET 03/20/97 551 RES $22,000 $9,120 41.45 DRASHER ROBERT G/ESTHER J 069 4 047 00 0 BL 75 1953 01587 ROYAL CLIFFORD E/MARGARET A WINDSOR SPRING RD 07/18/97 564 RES $38,000 $22,080 58.11 DRAYTON RONALD W 209 o 015 01 0 984 02803 SAMS LARRY OCTAVIOUS 2311 ROUNDUP DR 05/01/97 557 RES $71,900 $30,000 41.72 DRAYTON WILBERT 129 553 L 34/BL B/PH II 814 01648 ARRINGTON AMELIA 7 3023 LONSDALE DR 08/01/97 565 RES $66,900 $26,080 38.98 DRENNAN SHERR I M 110 3 197 L C 1718 03050 ADAMS JAMES D/PRODEN WANDA L 53 3308 WINN DR 12/08/97 578 RES $58,000 $23,720 40.90 DRIGGERS GREG 69 3/63 2265 02700 BEAUDIN GENE E/LINDA 0 2422 SOUTH DALE DR 12/31/97 581 RES $56,200 $21,000 37.37 DUARTE NORBERTO D/SHELIA 249 056 L 11 BL C SEC I 1281 00214 ALEXANDER HOMES INC 2518 CARRIAGE CREEK 03/13/97 552 RES $103,300 $41,000 39.69 DUCOTE CECIL A/CYNTHIA E 013 1 199 L 25 BL B 1285 00337 MCKNIGHT VIVIAN J 1758 DAVIDSON DRIVE 03/14/97 551 RES $40,900 $16,360 40.00 DUDLEY CHARLES 57 3 94 L 13 1149 00568 ASKIN 0 FRANKLIN JR/SPENCE J 3 3775 CLANTON RD 02/25/97 551 RES $18,500 $5, 160 27.89 DUMAS VERONICA M 169 P 005 695 00950 C M S GROUP INC 1262 ALDEN DR 05/05/97 556 RES $12,900 $4,000 31.01 DUNBAR WILLIAM R/CHRISTV B 323 0 058 L 54 PH II 1310 02061 HOLL MILDRED S 1312 MURPHY ST 08/29/97 570 RES $49,500 $20,760 41.94 DUNCAN TRACY V 45 3 149 L 18/BL D 1789 02319 MILES GLENN V 2030 YOUNGBLOOD DR 10/24/97 574 RES $83,000 $26,320 31.71 DUNCAN WIL C/STEPHINE 230 o 005 1171 00306 WOOD ISAAC C L JR 3301 TATE RD 02/27/97 550 RES $91,500 $33,200 36.28 DUNN ABRAM 84 1 28 403 30012 2474 WRIGHTSBORO RD COM $423,820 $177,800 41.95 DUNN/VAIDEN INC 44 3 139 0.65 Appraisal 00047 MCMCHWN JOHN P SR/ET AL 1542 WALTON WAY 01/14/97 545 COM $150,000 $59,920 39.95 DURANT EDWARD W 35/4/609 1417 . . . . . . . . . . . u . . . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 37 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Allount Ratio 00672 GARRIS CORINEE DANFORTH 3015 LAKE FOREST DR 04/16/97 554 RES $235,000 $70,880 30.16 DURKEE WILLIAM J P 033 3 169 00 0 2286 01601 o l H DEV INC 256 HUDSON TRACE 08/01/97 565 RES $71,509 $34,200 47.83 DYE SYLVIA E 48 HUDSON TRACE 692 02247 RICHMOND BUILDERS INC 3112 CONNER COURT 10/07/97 572 RES $72,900 $24,800 34.02 DYER GEORGE C JR 085 2 187 00 0 L 35A 1597 01884 PHILANGIAS DEVELOPMENT LC 306 NEVIS DR 08/22/97 568 RES $58,900 $22,800 38.71 DYER PAUL N/R DORIS 030 0 242 03 0 L 38 BL J 922 03045 SOUTHERN REGION IND REALTY IN 10/20/97 575 COM $70,950 $29,120 41. 04 E-Z GO PT 123 0 14 5.20 2038 01621 JACKSON J G III/TERRI M 3408 WALTON WAY EXTENSON 07/31/97 565 RES $490,000 $114,000 23.27 EAKER J RON 32 1 11 1147 01413 JONES STEPHEN WESLEY/YOLANDA 251 GREENE STREET 06/27/97 562 RES $102,800 $29,680 28.87 EAlICK JO ANN C/FREDERICK J MAP 047 4 PARCEL 014 608 00941 RICHMOND BUILDERS INC 2760 DAVIS MIll RD 04/30/97 556 RES $91,900 $32,800 35.69 EARtEY ARLETHA 177 o 37 00 0 15 J 1108 01846 SIBLEY SAM B JR 86 GMD 5020 MIKE PADGETT WAY 08/20/97 567 AGR $134,000 $35,200 26.27 EASLER ROBERT B/SON MI 338 0 072 10.00 1942 02982 NVA PARTNERS lLC 1520-1522 WALTON WAY 12/19/97 581 COM $1,161,666 $287,760 24.77 EASTVIEW APARTMENTS LTD 48 1 11 2 323 00276 lANDERS KENNETH H 2416 PONDEROSA COURT 03/20/97 552 RES $74,000 $28,800 38.92 EDENFIELD RICHARD A/DIANE R 014 3 024 00 0 L 9 BL F SEC I 639 01134 HERNDON TERRI E 1988 FENWICK ST 12/04/97 578 RES $20,000 $13,800 69.00 EDGE PUALA K 35 3 94 l 22/BL H 2340 01995 CAHOON DELWIN 0 1406 WINDSONG WAY 09/02/97 569 RES $36,000 $16,800 46.67 EDMONDS KEITH 1712 01725 COOPER CHARLES H/JANICE F 2001 VIRIGNIA AVE 08/11/97 566 RES $52,500 $19,520 37.18 EDWARDS FRNAK M JR 98 4 97 l lOG 1456 01960 RICHMOND BUILDERS INC 2785 DAVIS MILL RD 09/04/97 589 RES $94,900 $37,200 39.20 EDWARDS ~ARVEY l/THERESA A 177 048 L 2 BL K 763 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 38 Sample Seller land Dist, Land lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 01599 WEEKS THOMAS 0 07/23/97 564 RES $61,670 $18,480 29.97 EDWARDS JERRY E JR/KIMBERLY 246 0 003 00 0 30.84 1478 00,905 lIGON JOHN P/FRANCES K 3107 SUSSEX RD 04/30/97 556 RES $112,500 $38,800 34.49 EIDSON LINDA W L 35 BLK J SEC II 377 00121 FRANKLIN 0 ETTERlE CONST CO 17 PARK PLACE CIR 01/23/97 546 RES $241,000 $90,800 37.68 ElAM TERRY D/PATRICIA A 23 282 L 2 Bl B 1577 00583 MADDOX CALVIN 2402 MIMS RD 02/28/97 550 RES $52,000 $20,600 39.62 ELKINS WANDA L 249 0 086 00 0 L 15/B 86 00841 lIFSEY GROUP INC 4119 PINNACLE WAY 04/02/97 553 RES $109,900 $44,000 40.04 ELLERBEE EllIS JR/DOROTHEA 140 0 0775 L 13 BlK F SEC IV 1900 00632 JOHNSON MARY J 3006 MIRANDA ROAD 04/24/97 555 RES $75,400 $26,800 35.54 ELLICK JOSEPH/FRANCINE l 143 o 448 L 79 BL L SEC 8 1621 00299 PETERSEN TONNI 3717 FAIRINGTON DRIVE 03/25/97 552 RES $72,000 $27,440 38.11 ELLIOTT JOHN P/DEBORAH l 140 0 098 00 0 L 6.A 1578 00165 NORDAHL HOMES INC 3474 MONTE CARLO DR 01/30/97 547 RES $71,900 $28,800 40.06 ELLIS EDWARD R/WENDY F 132/531 l 120 483 02688 C M S GROUP INC 1218 ALDEN DR 12/19/97 581 RES $12,900 $6,400 49.61 ELLIS ELLEN R/KERRY B 339 22 1780 02554 LIFSEY GROUP 4527 RIDGE RUN DR 11/13/97 576 RES $125,500 $48,400 38.57 ELLIS WESLEY G/MAXINE 1483 01039 MAYBERRY JULIUS EUGENE 2950 JACKSON AVE 05/19/97 558 RES $23,509 $9,680 41.18 ELMORE COREY GARY/HAZEL DINAH 109 2 061 00 0 927 02302 HANCOCK KIM L/SUSAN S 2028 MCDOWELL STREET 09/24/97 572 RES $58,000 $28,680 49.45 ELMY MARY A 045 1 330 00 0 l 29 266 00722 WATSON MITCHELL HOME BlDRS IN 1128 FOX DEN ROAD 04/28/97 555 RES $133,600 $51,200 38.32 ELTZROTH ROBERT L/KYONG SUN l 4-B 2232 00937 KEMP LAURA B 14 2268 DARLINGTON DR 04/30/97 558 RES $58,900 $22,600 38.37 ENGLAND KEITH/EDITH 071 1 196 00 0 L A 1041 01639 HARDEN GLADYS LOU SMITH 2612 POLO COURT 07/28/97 565 RES $69,900 $27,320 39.08 ENGLAND MARLIN l 71 1 232 l 6 BlK A 1408 . . . . . . . . . . . ~ I ~ t o o u . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 39 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SlB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 01860 WARREN HOWARD P 3604 JONATHAN DR 08/18/97 568 RES $54,900 $22,040 40.15 ENGLISH EARNEST L/DIANA B 123 3 142 l 23 BL F SEC IV 16 02731 BISHOP JOYCE K 2202 SANDRA CT 11/25/97 578 RES $63,000 $20,880 33.14 ENGLISH JUDY J 098 1 296 00 0 71 02980 COOPER EDGAR EVANS/MARY T 504 HEARD AVE 12/29/97 581 RES $40,305 $20,880 51.80 ENNIS lARRY G/DAVISON MARK A 35 1 285 47 01209 CUDD E PARKER H/MElISSA PALME 67 2622 CHAUCER DR 06/27/97 561 RES $145,000 $50,800 35.03 EPPS HELEN J 030 0 152 00 0 L C 2395 02452 GROUP LIFSEY 2503 BLOSSOM CT 10/30/97 574 RES $72,800 $22,800 31.32 EPTING TAMIKO/APRIL 2179 00491 ALTON MARCIA M/GARRETT W 814 AUMOND PLACE EAST 02/13/97 548 RES $225,000 $89,160 39.63 ERRAMUZPE PHILIPPE/LAUREN 32 4 24 L 7?BL C 1691 01920 JACK R NORDAHL BLDRS INC 3505 SADESADDLE CT 08/29/97 568 RES $67,900 $28,400 41.83 ESPINO DANIEL H/REBECCA 129 0 677 00 0 L 8 BL H SEC I 1825 00427 LIVELY C MILNER 2917 ARROWWOOD CIR 02/06/97 547 RES $134,500 $54,000 40.15 ESPIRITU ROMUlO M/MARIlYN C 139 432 L 179/BL B/PH II 2206 03032 WARD ELIZABETH/NATHAN 3632 ALENE CIR 09/12/97 575 RES $31,000 $19,880 64.13 ESTROFF MALCOLM C ET Al 107 0 349 2216 00204 JOHNSON DONALD W/CAROL J 254 E VINE LAND DRIVE 02/27/97 549 RES $80,000 $31,000 38.75 ETTERLE ANDREW 0 MAP 26 2 PARCEL 080 l 12 Bl G 2316 00335 SEALEY MONA 2007 BATTLE ROAD 03/13/97 551 RES $39,000 $12,120 31.08 EUBANKS CECIL M JR 35 1 325 1006 02582 CLIMER FRED M 2503 PORTER ST 11/05/97 576 RES $28,000 $11,920 42.57 EVANS FLEMING JR/CLARA E 341 133 953 00431 MCKINNEY BETTY M 3835 ROYAL STREET 02/03/97 548 RES $36,900 $13,600 36.86 EVANS FRANCES MAE/ENGLAND B S 33 2 87 L 11/BL 0 54 00133 SHELTER SOLUTIONS INC 2360 SHILO STREET 01/30/97 546 RES $49,900 $20,200 40.48 EVANS GLORIA H 120 0 424 00 0 L 3F SEC 3 SHIlO 2256 01184 COLWELL VINCIENT J 3013 MABUS DR 12/05/97 579 RES $82,900 $33,600 40.53 EVANS MARTHA J 52 486 L 11 BL A/SEC 5 1506 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 40 Sample Seller Land Dist, land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 02378 SCHAFER SUSAN H 1415 SPRINGFIELD CIR 09/26/97 572 RES $69,900 $25,960 37.14 EVANS PAMELA 041 091 00 0 143 01145 WILLIAMS JOE CALVIN 1989 PIEDMONT DR 11/28/97 579 RES $52,800 $21,200 40.15 EVANS PHILLIP J 98 2215 l 15/BL C 101 00130 BOSLEY ALFRED 0 JR 1678 GOSHEN RD C3 01/27/97 546 , RES $49,900 $20,600 41.28 EVERETT WAYNE G 198 0 010 20 0 1847 02050 WHISENHUNT CHILDREN INC ET AL 8 ZACHARY PlACAE 09/02/97 570 RES $74,900 $29,800 39.79 EZYKOWSKI MARGUERITE l 12 1 128 l 82 1421 01171 FARRELL MARY F 4119 PINNACE PINES COURT 12/05/97 579 RES $83,000 $35,200 42.41 FAGGANS ALICE l 140 237 l 64/Bl B 1035 00113 TEBOW DENA GREINER 124 952 HORSESHOE RD 01/27/97 546 RES $40,000 $10,920 27.30 FAIRCLOTH DARLYNN G/G EDDIE 304 o 013 00 0 9.28 1268 02958 lESTER JAMES 12/27/97 580 RES $27,500 $3,560 12.95 FAIRCLOTH GEORGE EIDIANE 0 87 3 175/176 99 1 030 1620 01882 BLAKEY ANITA H 1 HEPHZIBAH-MCBEAN RD 08/21/97 568 RES $20,000 $2,800 14.00 FAIRCLOTH RICHARD 0 354 0 005 02 0 1.43 791 00248 LEON GHITTER REAL ESTATE PTRN 3013 STORY DRIVE 03/21/97 552 RES $16,500 '8,000 48.48 FAMBROUGH J HOWARD 070 3 007 l 2 1429 01677 BEll WOODROW ALTON 3509 EVANGELINE DR OS/27/97 565 RES $22,000 $8,960 40.73 FAMBROUGH J HOWARD 108 19 2405 00892 HOOD CAROLYN 1010 HICKMAN RD 04/30/97 555 RES $42,000 $22,520 53.62 FARR CLYDE P 044 2 063 15 0 2407 01735 YARID CHARLES M 2105 SOUTH LAKE PARKWAY 08/07/97 566 RES $139,200 $58,800 42.24 FARROW JAMES P/JEANETTE K 198 o 400 00 0 l 9 BL A PH I 1856 02168 BRUKER COMPANY 317 ALEX lANE 10/15/97 573 RES $80,400 $30,200 37.56 FAUGHNAN MARGARET E 12 2 20 L 13 1644 00644 MOORE CHERYL M/RONAlD L 4202 CEDARWOOD DRIVE 04/23/97 555 RES $96,000 $36,720 38.25 FAULKNER MICHAEL l/RHETA l MAP 232 PARCEL 52/53 L 1/2 BL A S C I 1931 02510 SHEFFIELD GENE E/CATHERINE E 3118 WHALEY ROAD 10/02/97 577 RES $69,900 $25,440 36.39 FAZEKAS ROBERT L JR/MARY P MAP 11 PARCEL 166 l 4 BL F 598 o o n .I~ tt . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 41 Sample Seller land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SlB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 00543 WON YONG NAM/BONG HUI 3040 MEADOWBROOK DR 02/25/97 549 COM $145,000 $47,280 32.61 FEDOR JAMES D/HYO SUK 107 o 030 02 1552 02673 RASCAL ENTERPRISES INC 86 11/01/97 582 AGR $11,900 $3,640 30.59 FELAN ROMAN JR/BYCE LEONA L 11 SEC 1 0.57 1192 00906 HUGHES DORIS G 638 CRAWFORD AVE 04/29/97 556 RES $42,000 $16,120 38.38 FELLOWS TIMOTHY/CATHERINE K 35 4 166 820 01437 JENKINS TIMOTHY W/MICHELlE H 210 EAST VINELAND RD 06/26/97 562 RES $78,500 $30,200 38.47 FENNIG DIANE M 19 4 148 1090 00854 DALLY JAMES D/DEBORAH A 2622 CARRINGTON DR 03/31/97 554 RES $65,700 $27,040 41.16 FERGUSON KATHERINE l 152 0 262 L 46 BL I SECT 9B 26 00013 . FREEMAN BEVERLY H 1007 HOGAN ST 01/08/97 544 RES $39,900 $12,280 30.78 FERNANDES MICHAEL/SUSAN 045 1 271 00 0 2133 00781 FREEMAN THEODORE M JR 2261 DARLINGTON DRIVE 03/31/97 553 RES $69,000 $26,240 38.03 FIELDS DAVID l 071 1 172 00 0 L 13 BL E 744 00237 AARON HAYWARD III/CARRIE L 2520 BANBURY ST 03/20/97 552 RES $47,762 $19,360 40.53 FIELDS DIANE 108 339 L 26 BL G SEC II 338 00680 RICHARD BIRD BUILDERS INC 2310 PEROT DRIVE 04/17/97 555 RES $94,900 $36,800 38.78 FIELDS JAMES A/SABINE 177 0 043 L 21 Bl J SEC 2 486 01781 BECTON JAMES l 1401 WATER EDGE DR 06/20/97 567 RES $245,000 $85,600 34.94 FIELDS THOMAS 0 JRISHERRY A 036 2 051 00 0 1129 01056 JACK R NORDAHL BUILDERS INC 3342 SADDLEBROOK DR OS/27/97 558 RES $67,900 $30,000 44.18 FIGUEROA LINDA I/FREDDY 129 0 691 00 0 l 11/BL J/SEC 1/ H V 1637 02060 HERBERT HOMES INC 3877 CREST DRIVE 08/29/97 570 RES $70,900 $27,200 38.36 FIKES KEVIN E 140 198 L 17 BL H/SEC II B 1777 01712 WASHINGTON RD DEV lLC 25 CHARLESTOWNE DR 08/05/97 566 RES $79,900 $23,400 29.29 FINCH ANDREW HEWITT/JENNIFER 11 o 222 00 0 956 00370 NEWSOME NORMAN lESTER/lESLIE 1908 PINE HAVEN ROAD 03/28/97 552 RES $63,000 $25,040 39.75 FINCH CLIFTON A/MELISSA M 133 1 16 L 18 BL F 2322 01199 BURCH RUTH-MAY - -- - -- ---- 2201 BOYKIN RD 12/15/97 579 RES $41,900 $19,240 45.92 FINCH FARNCIS A 167 o 039 1938 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 42 Sample Seller land Dist, Land lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 01168 TEMPLETON HUDSON 501 MILLEDGE RD 12/10/97 579 RES $31,500 $14,680 46.60 FINCHER EMILY T 34 2 17 43 L 11/C 988 02368 BAUER ROBERT 0 2904 FERNWOOD DR 10/10/97 573 RES $60,000 $23,400 39.00 FINDLEY JOH~ H JR 110 2 124 00 0 2161 01253 DUNN CHARLES R 2045 BATTLE ROW 05/30/97 559 RES $46,000 $13,600 29.57 FINORE CARL/EVERS SHANNON 035 1 295 00 0 674 00079 HALL BARRY 25 2619 SPRINGWOQD DR 01/13/97 545 RES $84,900 $29,400 34.63 FISKE JULIAN C/JOY A M013 2 P 019 l 25 2205 00213 VARNADO SOLOMON 3042 COLLIER RD 03/27/97 552 RES $24,000 $6,440 26.83 FITTS BERTHA 1346 01684 RUPP MARJORIE RITA 1929 HARRISTON RD 07/08/97 566 RES $24,300 $13,620 56.05 FITZGERALD JAMES/PAMELA 71 3 161 202 01831 JOHN C WEAVER HOMEBUIlDERS IN 3023 GREY FOX DR 08/15/97 567 RES $135,315 $53,600 39.61 FITZGERALD ROBERT E/lINDA W 272 0 109 00 0 1636 00929 HARRISON JANNIE lEE 8B DOGWOOD LANE 05/02/97 556 RES $375,000 $114,000 30.40 FITZPATRICK THOMAS HENRY 32 1 15 916 01289 HOWARD lEE C JR/JEANIA C 3252 SUMMERCHASE CIR 05/30/97 559 RES $80,000 $34,880 43.60 FLANDERS EMMIE S 42 4 147 L 26 SEC III 1262 01271 NORDAHL HOMES INC 2005 EWART CT 05/30/97 559 RES $70,900 $27,200 38.36 FLETCHER JOE ANN 130 0 771 00 0 L 3 BL A PH I 960 01991 DICKSON MARY CANON 2808 PALMER Pl 08/27/97 569 RES $109,900 $44,400 40.40 FORAN BERNARD CICAROlE F 25Z 88 l 5 PT 4 BL F SEC lA 1371 02441 WARNER MELVIN J VICTORIA STATION 07/29/97 565 RES $124,900 $48,400 38.75 FORD GWENDOLYN B 017 2 015 00 0 l 15 463 02862 BAXTER BARNEE C 2706 WELLINGTON DR 05/14/97 558 RES $139,900 $49,200 35.17 FORTSON WESTON M JR 25 4 127 254 00462 COOK ROBERT W 02/11/97 548 RES $16,400 $5,480 33.41 FOSTER BRUCE/MARIE 196 0 004 02 0 TR6 6.99 770 01298 ADAMS JOYCE G 1804 VERDERY ST OS/29/97 559 RES $53,900 $20,400 37.85 FOSTER PATRICIA A 4B 220 1576 '. . . . . . . . . . . o o . . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 43 Sample Seller land Dist, Lind Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Allount Ratio 00303 JACK R NORDAHL BUILDERS INC 1020 WALLIE COURT 02/28/97 550 RES $69,900 $28,000 40.06 FOSTER TRACEY 0 154 328 L 10 BL B 2347 01894 VARNADO SOLOMON G 89 2454-B WINDSOR SPG RD 08/28/97 568 COM $52,500 $23,680 45.10 FOSTER WILLIAM M 131 o 026 09 0 PARCEL B 0.18 1061 01687 HEWITT MARIE P 08/01/97 561 RES $20,000 $3,400 17.00 FOUNTAIN MARCUS L l 16 1718 19 252 02493 NEAL JOHN RICHARD 217 CRAWFORD AVENUE 11/22/97 577 RES $15,000 $7,400 49.33 FOWLER JOHN/TONYA 1471 02557 GROKE CHRISTOPHER V/ANNA M 1106 WINTER STREET 11/05/97 576 RES $126,000 $37,760 29.97 FOX VIRGINIA G/RICHARD S 44 2 98 1532 30030 2809 WASHINGTON RD COM $378,990 $164,400 43.38 FRANCHISE RLTY INT CORP 12 69 0.69 Appraisal 02105 J-MAR BUILDERS & SERVICES INC 4636 STOREY MILL RD 09/23/97 571 RES $94,000 $38,520 40.98 FRANCIS DENNIS A 272/130 L 6 610 01746 SMILEY DUNCAN E/MONTICA R 2735 MAYO RD 07/31/97 566 RES $93,700 $36,600 39.06 FRANTOM BRIAN T 2040 00988 LAFAVOR SAMPSON W 1921 THOMAS LANE 05/01/97 556 RES $42,600 $10,680 25.07 FRAZIER KRIBY E 071 3 038 00 0 2211 02712 MACHOVEC RICHARD A/ANN P 1017 STEVENS CREEK RD 12/31/97 587 RES $52,000 $16,720 32.15 FRAZIER MICHAEL R 012 0 228 UN 191 BLD 8 762 02286 RAYBURN BURT 1252 BLODEN ST 09/30/97 572 RES $39,000 $8,920 22.87 FRAZIER PATRICIA S 045 3 071 001 984 01330 STEWART lURA 0 2472 REESE AVE 06/10/97 560 RES $28,000 $15,600 55.71 FREDERICKS RAY 098 2 203 00 0 l 3 Bl C 264 02172 DOYLE FRANCIS I/ELIZABETH ETA 2010 PENNSYLVANIA AVE 10/15/97 573 RES $59,000 $21,400 36.27 FREEMAN DAVID R 056 2 069 00 0 L 18/BL G 1720 00273 BROWN GLENN L PORT 7 2019 BROAD STREET 03/14/97 551 RES $25,900 $6,920 26.72 FREEMAN JAMES/PHYLLIS 027 3 094 00 0 2150 - 00552 KEYSTONE HOMES INC 2504 WINTERVILLE DR 03/14/97 551 RES $98,900 $40,200 40.65 FREEMAN JOHNNY W JR 052 0 583 00 0 L 2/M 2160 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 44 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SlB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 01880 OGIlIVIE MARIANN 2 1415 JACKSON RD 08/21/97 568 RES $45,000 $22,000 48.89 FREEMAN NATHANIEL 041 2 027 00 0 Bl A 772 00621 KITCHEN BRUCE G JR/CAROlYN W 11 SUMMERVILLE LANE 04/24/97 555 RES $315,000 $119,240 37.85 FRENCH ROBERT A/JANE S 032 0 015 00 0 1294 00029 JOHN C WEAVER HOMBUIlDERS INC 1434 4640 STOREY MILL RD 01/08/97 545 RES $96,900 $34,920 36.04 FRENCH WIllIAM E/DEBRA A 272 0 005 04 0 l 8 0.53 86 02124 WITTKE LYNN DIGRACEP 3122 CRANE FERRY RD 09/26/97 571 RES $93,900 $39,600 42.17 FRY GEORGE JIll 171 04 1272 01048 l P B PROPERTIES INC ET Al 12 MACAULAY PLACE 04/30/97 558 RES $76,900 $31,400 40.83 FULCHER GRACE R 12 1 113 l 67 1387 02747 KENNETH SMITH HOME BUILDERS 2009 TEAL CT 12/01/97 578 RES $131,500 $54 , 800 41.67 FUllER FREDERICK/FREDREALEA 681 02929 WATSON MITCHELL HOMEBUILDERS 1125 FOX DEN RD 12/19/97 580 RES $138,450 $50,400 36.40 FUllER KENNETH l SR/JOYCE F 165 0 064 00 0 L 3/C 593 00867 MAYBERRY JULIUS E 2426 lENNOX RD 03/10/97 554 RES $39,126 $12,000 30.67 FUNKHOUSER ROBERT DIAMRERZENE 1310 054 l 4 BlK B 217 30009 1815 WALTON WAY COM $318,270 $123,240 38.72 FUQUA DOROTHY C 35 4 460 0.51 Appraisal 01528 NATIONAL SVC INDUSTRIES INC 1825 SAVANNAH ROAD 07/10/97 563 COM $504,000 $241,440 47.90 G&K SERVICES CO 2.79 1437 02874 ST KITT 0 S LLC 217 KITT' S DR 05/09/97 557 RES $59,900 $22,800 38.06 GADD DAVID M/HElEN T 030 242 03 0 L 9/C 127 01045 MEARS NAN L 46 4106 PINNACLE PINES OS/22/97 558 RES $87,961 $36,000 40.93 GAINES CECILIA 140 255 Bl B 1123 00896 MOCK CAMILLA P 2012/2012 WRIGHTSBORO RD 04/30/97 556 RES $65,800 $22,320 33.92 GAITOR NICOLA THERESA 45 3 328 l 13/14 BLK B 356 01741 FRY ROCK IE L/SUSANNA 2219 GLYNN ARVEN COURT 08/08/97 566 RES $54,000 $20,640 38.22 GALLOWAY AUSTRA l 132 o 287 00 0 L 5 Bl A 1924 01031 YANG SHING K/SEON J 2812 SPRINGWOOD lANE 05/16/97 558 RES $80,000 $35,600 44.50 GALLOWAY RAMONA H 08 3 017 697 '. . . . . . . . . . . 4 . j. 4U o . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 45 Sample Seller land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ra tio 02140 RICHARD BIRD BUILDERS 2505 PEROT CT 09/24/97 571 RES $93,900 $36,800 39.19 GAMBLE THELMA/MORRIS 1603 02730 SMITH MILDRED F 3215 YELLOW PINE DR 11/17/97 578 RES $71,655 $26,800 37.40 GANGAROSA LOUIS P/CLARA A 052 04 04 00 0 61 02807 SANDERS KATHLEEN B 4050 BURNINGTREE LANE 03/21/97 557 RES $70,150 $31,200 4'l.48 GANTT SAMUEL S 198 261 L 37/0 915 02894 JOHN C WEAVER HOMEBUILDERS IN 13 STOREY MILL PLANTATION 05/09/97 557 RES $138,750 $55,200 39.78 GARDNER WINSTON/PAMEAl M 2710 037 Bl C 641 00587 lYlE JAMES R 609-611 FIFTEENTH ST 02/28/97 549 COM $222,000 $77,080 34.72 GARG MURIRI l 36 3 205 1966 00145 HIGHTOWER CALLIE SUE/ET AL 408 ASHLAND DR 01/07/97 545 RES $21,275 $7,600 35.72 GARREN JAMES T 018 4 001 00 0 L 29 BRENCKMAN H L S 819 00750 HARLEY JOHN J WALTON WAY EXTENSION 04/14/97 554 RES $18,000 $4,560 25.33 GARREN JAMES T 032 1 032 01 0 1745 00334 DAVIS JAMES 0 4213 STONE STREET 01/07/97 551 RES $10,000 $3,840 38.40 GARRETT DIANA L/ERBY G 167 1 17 756 01327 HUTCHESON HENRY SIWANDA G 1563 BROWN RD 06/09/97 560 RES $77,000 $27,000 35.06 GARRETT WIllIAM 0 214 074 l 13 200 01377 HENSON PAUL E III 2155 KINGS WAY 06/16/97 560 RES $118,000 $37,800 32.03 GARRETT WILLIAM TIKElLY P 44 2 119 1863 01414 MASON ELIZABETH 0 24 GEORGETOWN CONDO 07/02/97 562 RES $41,500 $21,320 51.37 GARRIS CORINEE 0 712 01989 DAVIS JAMES E JR 1211 REID RD 08/15/97 569 RES $47,900 $17 , 000 35.49 GARRISON AMANDA L l 3 1330 01038 MEEKS TERRY l 10 DOMINION WAY OS/20/97 558 RES $59,900 $24,880 41. 54 GARRISON JIM M JR 017 3 019 00 0 919 01911 VETERANS REALTY DEV CORP 7 PARK PLACE CIR 08/28/97 568 RES $225,000 $98,800 43.91 GAUSE FRANK AISHIRLEY F 23 288 L 12 BL B 1727 01473 L P B PROPERTIES INC ET AL 5 MACAULAY PLACE 06/30/97 562 RES $69,900 $29,000 41.49 GAY TRACY W/DELYNN C MAP 12 1 PARCEL 109 L 63 HUDSON T ACE SO 1916 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 46 Sample Seller land Dist, Land lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ra tio 01060 WILSON JOHN D/SHEILA M 3418 WHEELER RD OS/27/97 558 RES $188,000 $60,840 32.36 GAYTAN RAFAEL J/DESIREE E 24 148 L 87BL A 1727 00185 MILLER LARRY 0 2407 APRICOT LANE 01/31/97 547 RES $61,900 $24,000 38.77 GEARHART DEBRA ANN 020 1 032 L 9 BlK F 967 02927 SID BECKUM CONST INC 3 337 ALEX LANE 12/19/97 580 RES $74,900 $29,800 39.79 GEISDMAN RICHARD DIDOROTHY A 7 012 2 POlO 557 30032 WASHINGTON RD COM $916,210 $353,240 38.55 GENERAL MILLS RESTAURANT 13 22 1 1.91 Appraisal 01452 MIllER JOHN CLIFFORD JR 2837 lOMBARDY COURT 07/02/97 562 RES $93,000 $40,080 43.10 GENTRY N SHANNON MAP 43 2 PARCEL 7 1327 02892 MITCHELL WILLIAM F/MYONG 2378 RICHWOOD DR 05/08/97 557 RES $59,900 $23,800 39.73 GEORGE FRANK F 167 275 l 12/Bl C 562 00987 GATLIN MARGARET C 3913 LAKE ERIE DR 04/15/97 556 RES $10,000 $3,600 36.00 GEORGE MITCHELL W 151 66 4A 0.46 2225 01640 REDINGTON STEPHANIE MICHELE 2918 SHELBY DR 07/25/97 565 RES $38,900 $15,160 38.97 GEORGIA FRANKLIN J 1419 30035 GOSHEN IND BLVD IND $667,790 $318,240 47.66 GEORGIA WASTE SYSTEMS INC 185 4 8.33 Appraisal 02615 BYNUM SHELDON C 2502 SHERBOURNE DR 10/31/97 575 RES $64,900 $25,600 39.45 GERALD lAWRENCE K/CINDY l 130 0752 1531 02418 BLACK JEFFERY REUBEN/ROBYN H 1215 HICKMAN RD 07/25197 564 RES $144,900 $44,480 30.70 GERARDOT ROBERT JllISA S 0444 071 01 0 2349 02589 NORDAHL HOMES INC 3442 MONTE CARLO DRIVE 10/14/97 576 RES $78,900 $32,000 40.56 GERMANY JAMES R OUT OF 1430381090 l 5-B 428 02558 NEWMAN CORNELIA S/DUCHSCHER J 1019 CHAFEE STREET 11/05/97 576 RES $33,000 $11,160 33.82 GERRITY ROSS G/WENDY F 1594 00673 TURNER PAUL C 246 EAST VINE LAND ROAD 04/16/97 555 RES $79,500 $30,600 38.49 GIAMMONA STEVEN/FITZGERALD K MAP 26 2 PARCEL 84 L 24 Bl G 84 02467 JORDAN JAMES B III/DEBOftAH A 3912 WIllOWOOD RD 10/27/97 574 RES $77,000 $31,200 40.52 GIARDINA CAROL l 015 0 078 00 0 1622 '. . . . . . . . . . . ~ . o o . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 47 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 02126 LEWIS VICTORIA F 3308 SADDLE BROOK DR 09/22/97 571 RES $69,900 $26,800 38.34 GIBBONS HELEN K 129 0 533 L 30/BL I/PH I 1338 01461 NORDAHL HOMES INC 3412 DANVERS AVENUE 07/01/97 562 RES $121,900 $46,800 38.39 GIBBS CHALRES 143 682 L 6-13 1673 00825 SHERMANIHEMSTREET INC 1 GEORGE C WILSON 04/01197 553 COM $118,000 $62,000 52.54 GIBSON JIM E/NANCY 0 ~ 031 P 160 E 1516 00357 REDMON SUZANNE LOUISE 3104 CLARENDON .CT 03/26/97 553 RES $147,500 $53,200 36.07 GILBERT JERRI K 40 131 L 35 BL C HILLCREEK 33 02746 FRONT LINE HOMES 2603 ANAQUA WAY 11/26/97 578 RES $91,900 $34,600 37.65 GILCHRIST BEATRICE 672 02128 FRONT lINE HOMES 2619 SPRIT CREEK RD 09/26/97 571 RES $77,900 $30,000 38.51 GILCHRIST JIMMIE L 1352 01424 CROCKER REBECCA ANN 8 2726 BARRY DRIVE 06/27/97 562 RES $61,500 $24,200 39.35 GILDEA ELIZABETH CHRISTIE/SEA 071 1 082 00 0 L C 836 01550 GREENTREE LAND CO INC 6 3140-C GOOLSBY ROAD 07/14/97 563 RES $23,000 $5,960 25.91 GIll GARY C/MARGIE P M 265 POlO 2242 00031 CENTER WEST SERVICES 2059 GREENLAND RD 01/03/97 545 RES $12,500 $4,560 36.48 GILLENWATER WIlLIAM/HYOSUN 176 2 2 100 00484 MAYBERTY JULIUS/JORDAN LOUISE 61 2407 AMSTERDAM DR 02/13/97 548 RES $26,950 $12,320 45.71 GILLILAND JAMES L 082 0 382 00 0 BL F 1533 02588 VARNADO SOLOMON G 9 2406 BAYWOOD DRIVE 11/07/97 576 RES $63,000 $24,160 38.35 GILMORE BISA L 85 3 274 00 0 BL 0 493 02282 FOWLER STEPHEN HUGHEY 2312 SALEM WEST DR 09/29/97 572 RES $78,900 $27,320 34.63 GILMORE WILLIE 850 01250 MOORE RANDAll S II/NANCIE P 3405 RAVENWOOD DR 05/30/97 559 RES $84,000 $31,600 37.62 GING WENDELL A 016 0 116 00 0 L 33 Bl A SEC 1 464 02242 ROOKS JAMES M/VIRIGNIA W 2030 DUNHAM COURT 10/07/97 572 RES $41,900 $15,360 36.66 GIVENS BERGETTIA ANNE 110 3 70 L 7 BL A 1659 01359 ROUSE PERVIS/SHIRLEY M 2176 PEPPERIDGE DR 05/16/97 560 RES $78,900 $31,600 40.05 GIVENS BOBBY l/EDROS lOWANDA 143 245 L 9 BL M SEC IV 1060 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 48 Sample Seller land Dist, land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SlB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 00403 COTE JACQUES G/CHAEHYON 3015 JEANNE RD 01/31/97 547 RES $54,900 $21,640 39.42 GIVENS DORIS J 96 1 54 l 3/Bl F SEC III 1733 02447 SANTOS WAYNE A/ANNETTE 2907 NElLS COURT 07/21/97 565 RES $105,000 $41,000 39.05 GLASPER JERRY 95 034 L 58 Bl G 592 30014 3409 WRIGHTSBORO RD COM $912,090 $329,720 36.15 GLASS SHERWIN 41 4 7 2.33 Appraisal 01503 STARNES CHARLES L 1023 HORSESHOE ROAD 07/09/97 563 RES $24,400 $8,200 33.61 GLASSCOCK DWIGHT W/LINDA M 303 011 TRACT 28 271 02877 C M S GROUP INC 2026 ALDEN COURT 05/08/97 557 RES $35,000 $14,000 40.00 GLOVER PHIllIP K/AMY H 339 o 016 l 70/PH II 156 00869 RASCAL ENTERPRISES INC 124 6 03/04/97 554 RES $25,900 $9,600 37.07 GLOVER RICHARDICAROlYN CARTER 6.01 170 01435 JUTCO INC 4118 BURNING TREE lN 07/01/97 562 RES $79,900 $30,000 37.55 GLOVER SCOTT/AMANDA J 214 163 L 10 BL B PH 1 1065 01486 RD&D INC 3 2022A GREENLAND RD 06/18/97 562 RES $18,350 $5,320 28.99 GLOVES SCOTT/DAWN 1.91 2263 01092 SAlKIND HllDEGARD 3552 GARDENBROOK DR 05/30/97 559 RES $68,000 $26,200 38.53 GLYNN JEFFREY P 120 0 439 00 0 l 6/C 63 02863 BARTON ELIZABETH 2884 LUMPKIN RD 09/19/97 585 RES $79,900 $26,000 32.54 GODWIN MATHEW/CHRISTIE 131 00686 HAMBY BOBBY l JR/ANDREA 2624 CORNING STREET 04/18/97 555 RES $59,000 $29,880 50.64 GOLATT GWENDOLYN 0 141 387 L 19 BL F SEC 4B 353 30017 LUMPKIN RD COM $289,940 $108,800 37.53 GOLDEN PANTRY FOOD STORES INC 109 2 12 0.55 Appraisal 00711 WILLIAMS C MURRAY 11 EAGLE POINTE DR 04/22/97 RES $156,900 $58,000 36.97 GOOD FREDERICK A/MARY B 23 0 331 02975 KENNETH SMTIH HOMEBUILDERS 2005 TEAL CT 12/22/97 580 RES $127,500 $43,200 33.88 GOODE CHARLES CIELLEN A 2175 02038 NORDAHL HOMES INC 1004 CEDARVIEW CIR 09/12/97 570 RES $79,900 $30,800 38.55 GOODROE DOUGLAS S/SUN T 213/205 l 6/B 979 411~ . . . . . . . . . . o o . . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 49 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SlB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 02194 PORTT JAMES C 32 2005 BATTLE ROW 10/10/97 573 RES $32,900 $12,440 37.81 GOODWIN KENNETH L 035 1 324 00 0 1089 01538 NORTHWOOD APARTMENT PROP LLC 124 1671 GOSHEN ROAD 07/10/97 563 COM $2,380,408 $1,005,680 42.25 GOSHEN CCA LLC 198 10 34 6.88 1626 00792 ALEXANDER HOMES INC 2538 CARRIAGE CREEK 03/31/97 553 RES $131,900 $44,200 33.51 GOULD FRANK L/PAMElA W 013 1 189 00 0 L 15 BL B SEC 2 828 02381 MANFIRD DAVIDISIGG KAREN BATE 09/26/97 572 RES $97,600 $30,080 30.82 GRACEY HAZEL BRAND JR/GLYNDA 018 4 031 00 0 L14 SECT II 177 01733 COVENANT PARTNERS INC 4301 ASCOT RD 08/07/97 566 RES $109,900 $43,400 39.49 GRAHAM lORA L 254 o 038 00 0 lAl 1780 01595 JACK R NORDANl BUILDERS INC 3502 SIDESADDLE COURT 07/25/97 564 RES $73,833 $31,200 42.26 GRAHAM NZINGA 129 0 684 00 0 1885 00708 FOSTER DEBORAH M 2138 MCDOWEll ST 04/23/97 555 RES $136,000 $46,280 34.03 GRANADE DEBORRAH J 044 2 1 00 00 0 820 02568 STURGIS FRANCES W 2275 HAMPTON CT 11/10/97 576 RES $69,900 $29,400 42.06 GRANT MARY l/WEST CHEERRYL B 71 1 138 1150 01492 GREEN CYNTHIA ELAINE 3613 SEELYE DRIVE 06/30/97 563 RES $66,000 $27,200 41.21 GRANT MAURICE/MALOYD SHANTE 111 02375 WRIGHT RONALD SAVANNAH RIVER ISLAND 10/14/97 573 RES $5,000 $1,800 36.00 GRAVES J S 2133 02456 LEWIS THERESA J 2008 BEECHWOOD DR 10/29/97 574 RES $63,900 $25,480 39.87 GRAVES VINNIE M 56 2 261 2234 02289 HOLLEY ANGELA 2126 HARDING RD 09/05/97 572 RES $52,600 $20,000 38.02 GRAVITT CHARLES A/JUNE MARIE 580 02446 BYNUM BEN JR/EVElYN R 3017 BRAMBlEWOOD TRAIL 07/23/97 565 RES $78,500 $31,720 40.41 GRAY EARLENE A MAP 42 4 PARCEL 64 L 5 BL K PH I 577 01438 BARANOWSKI THOMAS A/JANICE C 2711 BUTLER PLACE 06/19/97 562 RES $109,900 $34,120 31.05 GRAY JENNIFER K 25 2 152 1096 00221 LIFSEY GROUP INC 4535 RIDGE RUN DRIVE 02/24/97 550 RES $133,900 $49,200 36.74 GRAY MILTON 140 0 788 L 28 BL 0 493 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 50 Sample Seller Land Dist, land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SlB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 01791 KENNTH SMITH HOMEBUILDERS INC 1908 WOODCHUCK WAY 08/14/97 567 RES $130,900 $48,800 37.28 GREEN MARK S/KAREN M l 45 BL E SECT III 1048 02905 WATSON FRANCHIE MAE 1605 CHESTNUT ST 12/10/97 579 RES $4,500 $2,280 50.67 GREEN PINK l 2 2123 01010 C J SINGLETON CONST CO INC 2383 BASSWOOD DR 05/16/97 558 RES $75,900 $29,200 38.47 GREEN RICHARD P 166 o 292 L 18/BL G 276 02971 NEW FRANCES F 9 12/29/97 580 RES $68,300 $27,360 40.06 GREEN STEVIE l Bl B SEC IV 2099 01811 EVANS FLEMING JR 1303 CHERRY AVE 05/30/97 561 RES $19,500 $8,520 43.69 GREEN TIMOTHY 061 3 179 00 183 02990 NORDAHL HOMES INC 3606 FAWN COURT 12/11/97 581 RES $61,900 $25,520 41.23 GREENE PHYLLIS 120 0 385 00 0 L 12/B 145 02297 NORDAHL HOMES INC 3468 MONTE CARLO DR 09/26/97 572 RES $72,900 $29,200 40.05 GREENE REGINALD E 132 528 L 90 395 00584 ROUANE lAURIE J 3003 EAGLE DR 02/28/97 550 RES $73,000 $25, HIO 34.47 GREENE TIMOTHY M/KAREN 0 109 1 143 00 0 L 16/C 96 01247 FRAZIER JAMES L/MARY G 1861 HEPHZIBAH-MCBEAN RD 05/29/97 559 RES $68,475 $23,800 34.76 GREENWAY JEFFERY W 317 8 L 7 407 01474 TAYLOR ARTHUR M 544 MARTIN lANE 06/27/97 562 RES $74,900 $33,720 45.02 GREGG DANIEL F MAP 25-3 PARCEL 91 L 35 BL A 1927 02835 RASCAL ENTERPRISES INC 124 KRISTIN lANDING 03/10/97 557 RES $7,500 $4,920 65.60 GREGORY JOYCE L 40/Bl A/SEC I 1.77 2117 02836 RASCAL ENTERPRISES INC 124 KRISTIN lANDING 03/10/97 557 RES $7,500 $5,040 67.20 GREGORY JOYCE L 41/BL A/SEC I 1.41 2121 00105 RICHMOND BUILDERS INC 2764 DAVIS MILL RO 01/24/97 546 RES $92,900 $34,000 36.60 GREGORY-WILLIAMS lAVERNE 1770 030 00 0 8J 990 02996 NORDAHL HOMES INC 3471 MONTE CARLO DR 12/08/97 581 RES $84,900 $31,200 36.75 GRIFFIN DAVID C 1430381090 L lllA 253 01707 WALKER CHARLES W 46 3243 SUMMERCHASE CIR 08/08/97 566 RES $76,900 $29,680 38.60 GRIFFIN HELEN W 42 4 139 1050 '. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 51 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ra tio 01443 RICHARD BIRD BUILDERS INC 2808 STOCKER COURT 07/01/97 562 RES $94,475 $37,200 39.38 GRIFFIN JEANETTE/JAMES 0 L 13 BL F 1196 02343 ALEXANDER HOMES 1128 END ST 10/23/97 574 RES $59,900 $20,040 33.46 GRIFFIN MARY ANNE 644 01418 MENA JOSE/NICOLA A 2811 LOMBARDY COURT 06/30/97 562 RES $169,000 $66,120 39.12 GRIFFIN REID W 43 2 18 L 9 703 02365 JUTCO INC 2002 PENNSYLVANIA 10/22/97 574 RES $42,000 $16,600 39.52 GRIFFIN STEPHEN 0 56 2 73 L22 BL G 84 01420 MILOVICH MARK M/LORRI B 7 244 OEERFIELO lANE 06/27/97 562 RES $91,900 $35,600 38.74 GRIFFITH MICHAEL T/ROSEMARIE M 015 0 P 032 L 9 729 00602 DOUGLAS JAMES E 2124 SHAMROC~ DRIVE 03/27/97 553 RES $55,900 $20,040 35.85 GRISSETT MINNIE L 056 2 158 L 3 Bl C HIGHLAND PK 81 01118 BLALOCK CLARENCE A III/WILLIA 403 ASHLAND DR 06116/97 561 RES $94,000 $33,600 35.74 GROSS NED JAY/BARRETT BARBARA 018 3 070 PT 33/34 1538 02531 MARKS HENRIETTA E 3025 PARK AVENUE 11/18/97 576 RES $236,500 $98,960 41.84 GULLEY ANN KERR MAP 43 1 PARCEL 26 l 12 Bl 8 2279 00477 SINGFIELD RALPH 02/10/97 548 RES $15,000 $6,120 40.80 GUllEY PRUDENCE 0 059 2 793 00 0 L 12 1559 01371 HERBERT HOMES INC 3871 CREST DR 05/30/97 560 RES $72,300 $28,000 38.73 GUNSCH DUANE JR 146 501 L 20 BL H SEC II-B 1436 02239 TOMPKINS GEOFFREY R 1002 ADRIAN STREET 10/07/97 572 RES $110,500 $41,280 37.36 GUREVITCH LEON/TINA MARIE 1900 02120 ANDERSON JAMES T 16 2477 WRIGHTSBORO RD 09/15/97 571 RES $45,000 $18,160 40.36 HA BAO CHAU 044 3 011 00 0 L 6 941 00719 BLUME BRUCE 1810 BELMONT AVENUE 04/25/97 555 RES $45,000 $17 , 800 39.56 HADDEN DONALD A 2284 02855 LILES JOHN EARL ET AL SILVEROAlE RD 05/16/97 558 RES $90,000 $36,360 40.40 HADDOCK JULIAN Q/GAIL G 121 2/90 L 25/BL 2 56 01552 FARTHING DEBRA A/WILLIAM J 15 3131 EDINBURGH DRIVE 07/15/97 563 RES $110,000 $40,480 36.80 HAFFNER BRIAN K/DEBORAH E 024 2 084 00 0 L J 2309 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 52 Sample Seller land Dist, land lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SlB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 01238 KNIGHT ALTON WAYNE/ANNETTE S 1269GMD 3206 CANDACE DR 06/20/97 561 RES $275,000 $102,400 37.24 HAGLER ROBERT C 032 4 008 00 0 l 16 Bl G 902 01157 RAMIREZ ALICE M/ALFREDO C 3014 PARK AVE 12/09/97 579 RES $200,000 $83,760 41.88 HAGLER STEPHEN H/AlICE M 043 1 044 00 0 680 01795 ALEXANDER HOMES INC 2523 COMMONS TRACE 08/15/97 567 RES $104,600 $40,600 38.81 HAGOOD KEITH l 013 1 176 00 0 l 2 BL B 1100 00479 THOMAS lESLIE R 3624 GIBRAlTER .DR 02/12/97 548 RES $65,568 $24,880 37.95 HAGOOD SAMUEL JR 141 303 l 74/C SEC III 1385 01517 HOGAN DAFFA J 1700 CENTRAL AVENUE 07/10/97 563 RES $59,000 $22,920 38.85 HAILEY ANISA L MAP 43 4 PARCEL 44 L 6 Bl B 854 01187 BARNES JAMES/MARTIN 166 MURROW ST 11/10/97 579 RES $101,000 $36,240 35.88 HALBERT DUANEIJAMIE 1570 00612 ORTIZ HECTORIBRENDA 3455 POSTEll DRIVE 03/05197 550 RES $54,619 $21 ,840 39.99 HALE BOB 107 0 798 00 0 l 7 BL H 1052 01316 CARREll DAVID W/VICTORIA 1619 NORTHERN SPY TRl 06/05/97 559 RES $36,900 $14,240 38.59 HALE DARREN K 134 2 61 L 27 BL J 2108 01241 FISHOFF FAMILY FOUNDATION THE RIVER Pl AT PT ROYAL OS/29/97 559 RES $140,000 $62,480 44.63 HALL JAMES W/MARY 0 37 3 209 02 275 00598 BAUMANN MARTHA A 2411 CASTlEWOOD DR 02/27/97 549 RES $87,900 $35,040 39.86 HAll MICHAEL 014 o 003 00 0 2010 02278 MERTINS FRIEDCH/ElAINE 100 STONE CT 10/01/97 572 RES $89,900 $28,720 31.95 HALL MYRTLE 908 00952 SPEIGHTS RUBY M 3115 MKE PADGETT HWY 04/16/97 556 RES $20,000 $6,840 34.20 HALL ROBERT 111 3 PARCEL 65 1403 01014 YARID CHARLES M 2205 SPEER POINT 05/15/97 558 RES $121,000 $48,400 40.00 HAM l RICHARD 198 o 423 00 0 l 9/Bl C/PH I 327 02506 PHILLIPS J JAYSON 3129 BRANSFORD ROAD 10/31/97 577 RES $99,500 $34,040 34.21 HAMMARlUND ERIK P II MAP 32 4 PARCEL 87 L 43/44 Bl C 668 00594 HEGGIE JOHN 3801 ENGLEWOOD CT 02/24/97 549 RES $60,000 $24,200 40.33 HAMMETT RUDY A 170 0 159 1922 . . . . . . . . . . . q u . . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 53 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 00861 BOBBY JONES BUSINESS PARK 90 6 0 1017 FRANKE IND DR 04/04/97 553 COM $45,000 $15,120 33.60 HAMMETT STEVEN W 54 97 Bl A 1.16 2292 00551 GARRISON CUSTOM HOMES 2517 WINTERVIlLE DR 03/14/97 551 RES $107,525 $44,200 41.11 HAMMOND DEBRA J 052 o 561 00 0 L 37/J 2141 01690 GEPFERT FLORIAN 2678 CROSSCREEK RD 07/31/97 566 RES $54,900 $24,400 44.44 HAMMOND TRAVIS A/BARBARA J 130 0 244 00 0 L 5 BL Z SECT 2A 290 00918 BLACKBURN HOME BUIDERS INC 7 EAGLE POINTE SO 04/25/97 556 RES $165,000 $63,600 38.55 HAN YONG 023 0 302 00 0 711 01143 FARMER GEROGE 0 JR/ANN DUKES 1654 PENDLETON RD 12/01/97 579 RES $76,000 $29,600 38.95 HANCOCK DONALD C/FINETTA G 57 1 124 l 2/BL R/SEC IV 80 00674 GARREN CONSTRUCTION INC 2468 MCDOWELL STREET 04/14/97 555 RES $288,000 $86,640 30.08 HAND ROBERT A/MARYANNE 44 1 78 PARCEL 78 61 01341 GAUGHF CLAUDIA 2050 MCDOWELL ST 06/02/97 560 RES $79,900 $21,400 26.78 HAND ROBERT A/MARYANNE KELLY 44 2 148 l 24 681 02965 MEALING HENRY G IIIIAMY S 520 HENDERSON DR 12122/97 580 RES $103,900 $44,000 42.35 HANKINSON BENJAMIN C 025 4 100 00 6 l 25/BL C 1895 02328 WARREN CHARLES TIll/DEBORAH 506 SCOTTS WAY 10/27/97 574 RES $214,900 $73,600 34.25 HANKINSON WHITNER W/JUDITH I 24 1 6 L 35 BlK E 1082 02553 BALDWIN NANCY R 4349 SEAGO RD 11/13/97 576 RES $12,500 $3,720 29.76 HARDIGREE KIMBERLY 1508 02304 HOllEY CHARLES S 2422 BASS AVE 09/29/97 571 RES $52,900 $21,680 40.98 HARDIN GENETHIE A 86 4 004 l 24A lAKESIDE SO 2197 02644 CHANDLER ARTHUR BLEAKLEY 742 RIVERFRONT DR 10/31/97 575 RES $112,000 $48,600 43.39 HARGETT CHRISTINE M 76 49 523 02152 HOOVER JOHN E/MARY JO 1815 EMPRESS AVE 09/26/97 571 RES $59,900 $22,800 38.06 HARKINS TIMOTHY L 122 4 126 L 4/BL C/SEC III 1848 00255 BUSH HOWARD S 2523 NORTHVIEW AVENUE 03/01/97 550 RES $50,300 $14,960 29.74 HARMON COYLE JR 34 1 406 L 40 1173 01032 GIBBONS KATHERINE A/PENMAN L 510 BEAUFORT DR OS/20/97 558 RES $62,000 $16,720 26.97 HARMON J DOUGLAS 35 1 205 799 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 54 Sample Seller land Dist, land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 03003 LUPO JEANNE PARSONS 1723 GOSEHN RD 12/30/97 581 RES $84,460 $36,400 43.10 HARMS DAVID P/MARY S 198 0 040 00 0 L 13/H SEC 2A 355 02618 HERBERT FUMIKO 2547 TOBACCO RD 10/31/97 575 RES $72,000 $28,080 39.00 HARPER BOBBY/PINKIE l 141 o 032 L 17 BL B 1119 01232 SHARMA V P/KUMARI RAJ 3052 ANGELA ST 06/19/97 561 RES $65,400 $25,600 39.14 HARPER HOLLY J 7 120 L 21 BL H SEC I 719 00217 JENNINGS HELGA 4108 MICHAEL PLACE 03/19/97 552 RES $68,900 $26,000 37.74 HARRELL MARY LILLIE 153 0 102 L 3 BL B SEC 2A 1203 01765 NORDAHL HOMES INC 3314 HAMDEN ST 07/16/97 567 RES $115,900 $42,400 36.58 HARRELL PATRICIA CORINE l 1-13 209 01670 PHILANGIAS DEV lC 301 NEVIS DR 08/05/97 565 RES $58,900 $22,800 38.71 HARRIS BETTY C 030 o 242 03 0 L 331 2238 00571 NEAL CINTHIA M 2130 HOLT ST 03/10/97 551 RES $78,000 $31,480 40.36 HARRIS JAMES 044 4 264 00 0 L 10/A 407 02231 HERBERT HOMES INC 3867 CREST DR 09/29/97 572 RES $67,900 $28,000 41.24 HARRIS JOSEPH l 140 503 L 22 Bl H SECT lIB 1971 01059 SMITH BARRY DWAYNEIKIRA MARIE 2730 EDWARDS DR 05/23197 558 RES $64,900 $22,320 34.39 HARRIS KATHLEEN A 71 1 042 1719 00428 COMBS NAOMI 1912 MELROSE DR 01/09/97 547 RES $66,000 $21,600 32.73 HARRIS ROSE 122 3 94 L 3/PT L 2/BL F 2242 01275 LIFESEY GROUP INC THE 4533 RIDGE RUN DR 05/30/97 559 RES $119,900 $46,000 38.37 HARRIS WIllIAM C 140 o 787 00 0 L 27 Bl 0 SEC IV 1008 01629 PFIFFNER TRINH T/RICHARD C 4193 KEVIN DR 07/31/97 565 RES $61,600 $22,400 36.36 HARRISON ELISE R 153 o 139 00 0 L 7 Bl E SECT II 1281 00502 SCHWINDT MARK ALLEN 974 BROAD ST 02/20/97 548 COM $20,000 $8,480 42.40 HARRISON GEORGE S 37 3 161 01 2266 00557 ST KITT' S LLC 211 KITT'S DRIVE 03/17/97 551 RES $56,900 $22,800 40.07 HARRISON LOWELL RIELAINE N 030 o 242 03 0 L 6/B 1220 00480 HIGHTOWER ROBERT S 406 ASHLAND DR 02/14/97 548 RES $108,500 $44,800 41.29 HARSHFIELD GREGORY A/JUDITH H 18 3 69 1450 4~ . . . . . . . . . . l. . . . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 55 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SlB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price AlIlount Ratio 01585 HORNE KENNETH R 3201 OARWOOD DRIVE 07/18/97 564 RES $104,026 $42,800 41.14 HARTLEY JOHN 0 143 0 506 00 0 l 14-2 972 02264 JOHNSON RICHARD L 2046 WHARTON DR 04/25/97 K072 RES $40,000 $19,000 47.50 HARVEY POLLY LEE/JERRY M 1254 01378 CALHOUN EDITH A 1613 12TH ST 06/05/97 560 RES $37,900 $11,400 30.08 HASAN A K 059 3 153 00 0 1974 01569 CONNELL JOHNNIE H 1407 MERRY STREET 07/16/97 564 RES $48,900 $19,240 39.35 HASAN A K 45 3 361 L 33 410 01006 KUHlKI PROPERTIES 3302 COMMERCE DR 03/07/97 350 COM $220,000 $66,120 30.05 HASKINS ROLAND A/CAROLINE N 69 5 6 1878 00473 ~OOKER NORMAN TODD/KIMBERLY D 36 3107 JULIA AVE 02/14/97 548 RES $65,000 $21,800 33.54 HATCHER JAMES T/ANGELA M M 121 2 P 115 1226 01104 CAREY CLIFFORD L 9 2704 KIPLING DR 06/20/97 561 RES $132,000 $52,000 39.39 HATCHER ROBERT F/MARION B 018 0 256 00 0 1188 00010 ALEXANDER HOMES INC 2546 CARRIAGE CREEK 01/03/97 544 RES $103,400 $37,800 36.56 HAVARD STEVEN HENRY/PAULINE 013 1 187 L 13 BlK B 1714 02139 WALLER DAVID A/DIANNE 3105 H VILLAGE CT 09/26/97 571 RES $67,900 $23,800 35.05 HAWES ALICE 011 o 257 000 1592 01348 ROll 0 INC 128 2066 GREENLAND RD 06/09/97 560 RES $15,000 $5,880 39.20 HAWKINS DEL/JACQUELINE 1.23 805 01520 FRONT-LINE HOMES INC 1412 BROOKSTONE ROAD 07/11/97 563 RES $79,900 $28,000 35.04 HAWTHORNE ANDRELL F 152 0 001 02 L 7 Bl C PH I 1013 01273 JACK R NORDAHL BLDRS INC 3341 SADDLE BROOK DR 05/30/97 559 RES $73,900 $30,400 41.14 HAYES GEORGE A JR 129 0 690 00 0 L 10 Bl J 988 02724 BROWNING SUE S 2952 ARROWHEAD DR 08/06/97 577 RES $44,000 $17,880 40.64 HAYES TERESA 18 1 9 l C BL II 2226 00944 BERRINGAN ANN BEE 1428 GLENN AVE . 04/30/97 556 RES $75,000 $24,000 32.00 HAYMAN E J 43 2 139 1472 01124 SHARKEY TATSUKO SUNAGAWA 2521 WELDON DRIVE 06/20/97 561 RES $61,900 $22,640 36.58 HAYNES JOHNNY lEE/MARY A 096 0 026 l 8/BL F/SEC I 1810 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 56 Sample Seller land Dist, Land lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SlB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 01403 TOLIVER lESTER R 4627/4629 WINDSOR SPGS RD 06/30/97 562 RES $11,500 $4,640 40.35 HAZEL CHARLES 0 193 15/193 14 L 4/5 380 02149 GUY HENRIETTA HOWELL 2012 CARP DR 09/29/97 571 RES $51,000 $20,600 40.39 HAZEl IDA L 086 2 078 00 0 l 6/A 1755 00550 KUHlKE PROPERTIES COMMERCE DR 02/14/97 550 COM $256,000 $117,760 46.00 HEBBARD JOHN H JR 69/12 01 2.43 1774 01345 DRIGGERS HERSH ELL JR/ELIZABET 1820 FAIR VIEW AVE 05/30/97 560 RES $33,974 $18,040 53.10 HEBBARD JOHN H SR 70 1 69 L 59 BL 0 684 02213 WHITTINGTON HASKELL S JRIJUll 2326 REDWOOD DR 09/05/97 573 RES $42,000 $20,800 49.52 HEGLER DIANE 26 2 158 00 0 246 01142 BEAIRD C WESLEY/ROXANE R 120 KINGS CHAPEL RD 11/28/97 579 RES $95,000 $40,000 42.11 HEITZENROEDER TRACY L 11 3 93 l 62/BL ~/SEC I 58 00492 WATSON MITCHELL HOME BUILDERS 1040 FOX DEN RD 02/18/97 548 RES $142,200 $56,800 39.94 HENDERSON CHARNER/COREATHA 165 0 090 00 0 l 2/B 1775 02263 GAllUPO DEBORAH COLEMAN 2945 HILLCREEK DR 09/29/97 K072 RES $139,000 $50,800 36.55 HENDRIX WIllIAM L/JOY ANN 30 114 l 2 Bl A 1235 02444 MCCARTHY-MCGEE ANITA F 2419 BRISTOL PLACE CT 07/28/97 565 RES $64,000 $23,240 36.31 HENRY JOHN T MAP 166 PARCEL 341 L 11 BL C SE 533 00749 o a H DEVELOPMENT INC 56 408 JASPER CROSS 04/14/97 554 RES $86,500 $37,000 42.77 HENRY-KAIlEY HELEN K 012 1 103 00 0 1772 01456 NORDAHL HOMES INC 3472 MONTE CARLO DRIVE 07/02/97 562 RES $76,900 $29,600 38.49 HERBERT FREDERICK J 132 530 L 11-0 1626 00979 ERRAMPUZPE PHIlIPPE/lAUREN 2220 EDGEWOOD DR 04/30/97 556 RES $124,500 $48,000 38.55 HERMUS RONALD J 26 4 64 l 24 BL F 2030 00840 ROSADO NELSON R/PAUlA 2691 BARCLAY STREET 03/28/97 553 RES $55,000 $23,600 42.91 HERNANDEZ ARACELIS 130 0 360 l 17 BlK Z SEC I 1917 02833 RASCAL ENTERPRISES INC 124 KRISTIN lANDING 04/03/97 557 RES $14,500 $5,200 35.86 HERNDON EARL G L 35/Bl A 1.45 2072 00269 ALEXANDER HOMES INC 2719 BRICK RUN PLACE 03/04/97 550 RES $110,000 $40,600 36.91 HERRICK LILIANA M 013 1 168 L 17 BL 0 2354 , .1. . . . . . . '. . . . l I l I l . u .. . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 57 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 01801 ALBERT GEORGE M 3422 BLACKSTONE ST 06/13/97 561 RES $58,900 $25,520 43.33 HERRINGTON LUlA 0 108 0 3 76 L 51 BL 0 SEC 2 39 02367 LOGAN KENNETH WAYNE/JULIE J 2725 LAKEWOOD DR 10/20/97 573 RES $88,900 $36,960 41.57 HERRINGTON STERLING R 71 1 0006 L 10 11 2150 00746 OKEAGU JONAS/FELICIA 15 3910 CREEKWOOD LN 04/15/97 554 RES $78,200 $29,600 37.85 HERRON RICHARD H 015 0 049 00 0 L 5 1888 01927 DALE MARGARET SLOTT 2434 MCDOWELL ST 08/29/97 568 RES $265,000 $58,320 22.01 HESTER JAMES R/SUSAN C 044 1 122 2079 02656 TANG LIN S 3614 STURNIDAE DR 12/29/97 583 RES $45,000 $20,920 46.49 HEWITT ALBERT JR/JOCELYN V 119 0 299 00 0 L 8 BL K 451 01761 RUTKOWSKI MARTIN 0 1726 OAK DR 08/14/97 567 RES $72,000 $28,800 40.00 HEYS JENNIFER J SMITH 057 4 052 00 0 130 02047 CARSWELL JONATHAN PAUL 1106 MILLEDGE RD 09/19/97 570 RES $162,500 $55,720 34.29 HICKEY JUDSON S/CATHERINE l 44 2/110 0.26 1856 02850 GRAHAM DARYL/SMITH BOBBIE W 22 1715 FOREST CREEK DR 05/15/97 557 RES $65,000 $29,040 44.68 HICKEY NOLA D 054 2 088 00 0 l G 2 2397 02943 MCLEOD ETTA B 13/14 1519 CRESENT DR 10/03/97 580 RES $55,000 $11,360 20.65 HICKEY NOLA 0 SEC A 843 01204 SOUTH PARK COMMONS LlC SOUTH PARK COMMONS SID 06/26/97 561 RES $56,400 $22,600 40.07 HICKS JO ESTER 140 0 005 00 0 l 21 2182 02084 SNYDER EUGENE 3922/3924 MURRAY ST 09/24/97 571 RES $19,500 $10,400 53.33 HICKS WILLIAM A III/DEBORAH J 65 33 34 01 L 3/4/BL F/SEC I 320 01715 TUCKER RHETT RIDIANA l 2506 SADDlEHORN COURT 06/27/97 566 RES $69,900 $26,800 38.34 HICKSON VALERIA M/MCClENDON 129 571 L 48 Bl J 1061 01067 TRIMMIER NORMAN P JR/CAROL 0 OS/28/97 558 RES $55,600 $21,160 38.06 HIGGINS JOHN ALEXANDER 045 3 154 00 0 L 13/0 2029 01138 RICHARD BIRD BUILDERS 2806STOKER CT 12/01/97 579 RES $91,900 $35,600 38.74 HIGGINS ROBBIN C 28 01700 HEARD LANCE-/PAUlINE- H-. -- 3658 CAWFORDVIlLE DR 07/30/97 566 RES $96,500 $41,000 42.49 HIGHTOWER LARRY/lESLAINE J 53 250 L 18 BL G 574 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 58 Sample Seller Land Dist, land lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SlB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 02207 GRAHAM RALPH l/JODIE M 4207 CHAP CHAT STREET 10/08/97 573 RES $47,900 $18,920 39.50 HILL BLANCHE 0 166 241 l 15 BL 0 541 01202 L P B PROPERTIES INC ET AL 1 MACAULAY DR 06/24/97 561 RES $76,900 $30,600 39.79 HIll BOB R/BEN A 12 1 107 L 61 2142 00055 RASCAL ENTERPRSES INC 2483 2487 HOODS CHAPEL RD 01/09/97 545 RES $14,500 $10,120 69.79 HIll DEBORAH SIRICHARD L 222 o 063 222 0 062 L 25 26 27 1334 00291 PUETZ BRIAN RICHARD 1404 WINDSONG ~IRClE 03/03/97 550 RES $42,000 $16,800 40.00 HILL T MICHELE MAP 006 PARCEL 352 UNIT 1404 Bl 1 PH 3 1091 02237 SPERRCY KEVIN A/TRACEY B 19 4446 WINDSON SPRING 09/30/97 572 RES $58,400 $25,200 43.15 HILLIS GLENN/CORRIE M 179 0 P 105 M 1888 01297 KAY SANDRA H 2635 RICHMOND HILL RD 06/04/97 559 RES $44,565 $14,760 33.12 HITT THOMAS W 097 4 128 00 0 L 24 Bl N 1463 00807 TROTTER WILLIAM A III 201 WINDSONG CIR 04/01/97 553 RES $35,000 $16,800 48.00 HITT THOMAS W/RUTH J L 201 576 01317 COLE JOY l 50 SUNNYVALE 05/30/97 559 RES $60,000 $24,000 40.00 HIXON DONALD G M 016 2 P 215 UN 1 BLDG A 2163 01837 SOUTH PARK COMMONS llC 306 ClEARVIEW CT 08/20/97 567 RES $57,000 $21,800 38.25 HIXON GERALD W SR 140 1 013 00 0 L 29 1694 00688 POLLARD NETTIE SMITH 1027 TWELFTH AVENUE 04/21/97 555 RES $22,100 $8,080 36.56 HOBBS CARRIE HIMIRA J 72 2 430 373 01751 BRUKER CO 303 ALEX lANE 08/08/97 566 RES $77 , 900 $29,800 38.25 HOBBS R HAROLD SR/JR 12 2 27 l 20 2283 02275 SOOSAIPIlLAI ANTON M 9 3432 HEATHER DR 09/30/97 572 RES $130,000 $49,600 38.15 HOCKETT PAUL CLIFTONILINDA S 032 3 060 00 00 l A 931 02886 MADDOX VIRGINIA E 2922 POINTWEST DR 05/05/97 557 RES $114,900 $42,800 37.25 HOCKMAN lUCIEN JIGERTRUD l 18 396 l 7/BL B/PH I 461 00821 KELLEY J WILLIAM 2443 DICKEY DR 03/31/97 553 RES $53,900 $21,800 40.45 HODGE SAMMY/GRANT JOYCE 85 3 186 l 5 BlK A 1023 02771 MCNEELY JAMES BYRON/MARY E 3522 STONEY BROOK RD 12/04/97 578 RES $60,476 $30,800 50.93 HODGES ELOISE A/GARY T 132 0 393 l 23 BL E SEC III-C 1252 41t . . . . . . . . . . o . . County: 121 RICHMOND Sample No. 00852 02854 00295 01820 01354 02384 01164 00633 00706 02838 02587 02792 01937 02705 01236 Seller Taxpayer on Digest WATKINS WILSON M HODGES JOHNNY BITRUDY R FREEMAN CHARLES JR HOGARTH ARTHUR L/HIROKO HOW-LOU lTD HOGUES SAUNDERS JR PANTOJA MANUEL HOHMANN BRIAN R TIMMERMAN DANIEL L HOHN JEFFREY A/TALIN K BROWN HELEN K HOLIDAY JESSIE L o & H DEVELOPMENT INC HOLLAND WIllIAM AIMARY N RICHARD BIRD BUILDERS INC HOLLAWAY DWIGHT/SANDRA L HUGUENIN DAVID HOLLEY JAMES R RASCAL ENTERPRISES INC HOllOWAY DENNIS NORDAHL HOMES INC HOLLOWAY FREDRICK/PENNY A KENNETH SMITH HOMEBUllDERS IN HOLLOWAY GLEASON lIVELY C MILNER HOLMES BIllY 0 AMlI AUGUSTA PROPERTIES lP HOLMES MEREDITH l/TOBY L HANCOCK DONALD C/FINETTA G HOLSOMBACK JOHN E . . 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY . Land Dist, Lind Lot, Street Map/Parcel, SLB 926 MOORE AVE 45 2 143 L 26 26 2 207 823 FORSYTHE STREET 60 2 PARCEL 53 4227 CAP CHAT ST 166 0 251 1128 MAGNOLIA DR 13 4 230 L 15 BL F 121 2615 WHITECHRUCH CT l 23 BLK A SEC I 245 HUDSON TRACE 121/49 L2 2503 PEROT COURT 177 0 016 L 19 BL H PH II 13/14 1003 B~DFORD DR 020 3 134 00 0 ~ 86 169 60 l 12 3429 MONTE CARLO DRIVE OUT OF 97A1430381090 L 6-0 2007 TEAL CT 165 93 L 16 BL E 3204 PENINSULA DR 039 0 219 00 0 L 20 BL F AUGUSTA WEST 30 0 308 2379 BOYKIN RD 166 11 03 L 3 . Date Sold Acreage 04/04/97 05/15/97 03/21/97 06/17/97 OS/29/97 09/30/97 12/11/97 03/31/97 04/04/97 04/07/97 3.00 10/31/97 12/05/97 08/28/97 12/30/97 2.00 06/18/97 Deed Book Deed Page 553 2116 558 263 552 1014 561 335 560 866 572 20 579 753 555 1633 555 619 557 2132 576 476 578 1835 568 2145 581 1079 561 882 Type Prop RES RES RES RES RES RES RES RES RES RES RES RES RES COM RES . Sale Price $24,000 $96,000 $29,900 $53,900 $72,900 $86,900 $91,000 $93,900 $67,000 $16,500 $85,900 $130,650 $98,000 $200,000 $49,900 . . Assessment Amount $8,840 $42,880 $7,000 $20,120 $26,800 $32,400 $35,400 $38,400 $26,800 $6,000 $34,000 $47,200 $36,000 $83,600 $20,680 . 59 Ratio 36.83 44.67 23.41 37.33 36.76 37.28 38.90 40.89 40.00 36.36 39.58 36.13 36.73 41.80 41.44 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 60 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ra tio 00289 ST KITTS LLC 231 KITTS DRIVE 03/05/97 550 RES $64,900 $22,800 35.13 HOLT JIMMY W OUT OF 030 0 242 03 0 L 16 Bl 0 2 1214 02121 JOHNSON MARY W ANDERSON 2510 COMMON TRACE 09/26/97 571 RES $114,000 $46,200 40.53 HOMEN BAR BAR ANNE 013 1 126 00 0 L 5/A 1182 00925 NORDAHL HOMES INC 04/30/97 556 RES $92,500 $36,000 38.92 HOOVER DAVID M 184 0 0186 00 0 l 11 Bl 0 SECT I 840 01360 LAZENBY WIllIS D/SUSAN A 699 BENNOCK MILL RD 05/16/97 560 RES $82,900 $27,800 33.53 HOPE DANNY E 325 0 004 00 0 1091 01998 CHEEK ROBERT/JANET 1915 VIRGINIA AVE 08/29/97 569 RES $42,000 $16,840 40.10 HOPE lOUISEISTEPHANIE 1804 00499 SHORT KENNETH EDWARD 3532 RICHMOND HIll RD 02/18/97 548 RES $67,000 $26,960 40.24 HOPSON ANITA M ET Al 132 2 009 L 17/Bl F SEC IV 2059 02052 PROCELL JERRY L/IlA M 3109 EVERGREEN 09/19/97 570 RES $56,000 $23,600 42.14 HORDGE ROBERT 055 4 183 000 l 31/B 1626 02434 DEMARCUS JUllY L 07/28/97 565 RES $57,900 $21,280 36.75 HORN BEVERLY W 110 1 002 267 01472 WATKINS CHARLES E III 3140 VIllAGE WEST DRIVE 06/30/97 562 RES $59,900 $26,400 44.07 HORRES DEBORAH J MAP 11 PARCEL 266 l 34 PH IV 1906 01018 BARTON ANN H/BYRNES JUNE H 2882 lUMP KIN RD 05/14/97 558 RES $20,000 $12,000 60.00 HORTENSTINE MICHAEL l/DEBORAH 083 2 007 l 2/Bl C 352 00056 JACK R NORDAHL BUILDERS INC 3329 SADDlEBROOK DR 01/09/97 545 RES $72,900 $30,000 41.15 HORTON ROBERT l/SANDRA R 129 0 523 L4J 1344 02422 POLLARD DAVID E/MARY J 10 418 GOLDFINCH DRIVE 07/24/97 565 RES $69,500 $29,200 42.01 HORTON WADE T 016 0 073 00 0 L H 103 01631 JACK R NORDAHL BUILDERS INC 3604 DAYTON STREET 07/25/97 565 RES $82,600 $31,200 37.77 HOUSTON LARRY/TONIA 130 0 793 00 0 1310 01239 FRONT-lINE HOMES INC 1403 BROOKSTONE RD 06/20/97 561 RES $74,500 $29,600 39.73 HOWARD BRENDA 0 L 2 BL B PH 1 912 01451 MAGUIRE ALFRED J JR 2846 WALTON WAY APT 2 07/01/97 562 RES $51,900 $18,920 36.45 HOWARD HELEN E 33 4 60 8 1310 . . . . . . . . . . . o u . . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 61 Suple Seller land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale. Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 00653 MARSINGIlL J CHESTER/FUMIYO K 901 HORSESHOE ROAD 04/04/97 553 RES $21,900 $5,120 23.38 HOWARD TERRY ROY 281 o 111 L 10-H HORSESHOE FMS 1836 00309 HAWKINS FRANCES R 3435 PEACH ORCHARD ROAD 02/21/97 550 RES $32,000 $10,160 31.75 HOWELL JAMES A JR 133 0 008 L 2 459 00718 MATHENY DAN P 3805 HOLLOW KEG DRIVE 04/18/97 555 RES $9,900 $3,600 36.36 HOWELL LOIS V L 2 BL C 1662 . 01114 EAGLE ILDRED 06/25/97 561 RES $14,000 $6,720 48.00 HUA QUANG THAI 175 17 L 26 2.81 1488 00573 BUSH JUDY BIERVIN L 5054 ODl SAVANNAH RD 03/12/97 551 RES $50,000 $5,080 10.16 HUBATCH TODD G - 339 9 L 1 6.35 211 01722 HICKS HEATHERLY A 207 WINDSONG CIR 08/01/97 566 RES $42,300 $16,800 39.72 HUDLOW KENNETH M 7 223 UNIT 207 BLK 62 1278 01840 REGEl LAURA J 3018 STERLING RD 08/01/97 567 RES $60,000 $26,800 44.67 HUDSON LOIS Q l 13 BL F SEC I 1758 02176 CARTER GERALD M SR 1764 PINETREE RD 10/15/97 573 RES $63,000 $19,680 31.24 HUFF RICKY E/TORI L 57 4 74 L 31/32/33/BL I 1332 00361 ST KITTS LLC 224 KITTS DRIVE 03/27/97 552 RES $60,200 $22,800 37.87 HUFF SHIRLEY ANN OUT OF 030 0 242 03 0 l 29 BL H 2348 02512 MCCHESNEY SCOTT A 1808 CHERYL DRIVE 10/31/97 577 RES $57,000 $22,400 39.30 HUGHES B SCOTT/ROSSI ANGELA 0 122 2 277 L 23 Bl A 639 01509 JOHNSON SHIRLEY MAE SINCLAIR 4568 ETTER lEE DRIVE 07/10/97 563 RES $62,000 $25,440 41.03 HULSE LEWIN C/SHARON 190 0 021 00 0 L 44 2.44 506 02454 ECKHOFF JAMES THEODORE 44 2207 KIMBERLY DR 10/30/97 574 RES $69,900 $27,680 39.60 HUMMEL KATHRYN L 2293 01041 BROYLES 0 SCOTT/ANN MARIE 3004 WALTON WAY 05/16/97 558 RES $121,000 $46,120 38.12 HUMPHRIES ARTHUR L JR 33 1 173 1065 02266 GROSS SHAUNE E/MICHAEl C 7 2288 BASSWOOD PR 09/30/97 K072 RES $60,000 $28,680 47.80 HUNT CARMEN 0 167 0 379 00 0 L K 1206 00625 VARNADO SOtOMON. G 35 3462 POSTELL DRIVE 04/25/97 555 RES $60,000 $21,720 36.20 HUNTER RONALD L Bl A 1551 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 62 Sample Seller Land Dist, land lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 00895 MCCUMBERS BUILDERS INC 1517 PINE RIDGE DR EAST 04/30/97 556 RES $99,900 $38,240 38.28 HURT CHARLES M/INGER J 232 154 l 9 BL C SECT 3 157 01803 DAVIS TERRI l SMITH 1017 STEVENS CREEK RD 04/25/97 561 RES $39,500 $15,520 39.29 HUSAIN SHAHID M 012 P 252 UN 215 BLD 10 79 02664 RASCAL ENTERPRISES INC 86 11/24/97 582 RES $7,500 $2,720 36.27 HUTCHINSON BENJAMIN F 222 48 l 21 0.38 1945 01416 FENNIG DIANE M COUNTRY CLUB HILLS APT 3 06/26/97 562 RES $40,000 $16,280 40.70 HYMAN RONALD A 34 2 17 68 BLDG 17 816 01918 PHIllIPS GUS R/DORA MONTCLAIR 08/26/97 568 RES $98,900 $39,600 40.04 HYSOM DENNIS E/LENORA 17 1 051 l 19 BL N 1805 00806 DUGAN CHATE/DUGAN ELEANOR C 3413 KERRY PLACE 03/31/97 553 RES $114,000 $54,160 47.51 INGRAM JOHN G SR/DONNA 0 31 4 118 L 11 Bl F SECT II 629 00976 GRAVES JOHN D/SANDRA C 26 TIBURON TRAIL 04/30/97 556 RES $63,500 $24,800 39.06 INGRAM JOSEPH E SR 010 4 120 00 0 2003 01613 SHOWMAN CHRISTOPHER D/TRACY 06/30/97 565 RES $63,200 $24,800 39.24 INGVOlDSTOD DAVID D/JAMES 57 4 044 l 16 17 18 KING WOOD 1198 02190 TILLER HARRELL S 1269 2823 JOY RD 10/16/97 573 COM $75,000 $19,320 25.76 INTELLICOM INC 0.37 1061 00386 BARNES JOHN N 2711 OLD SAVANNAH ROAD 02/27/97 550 COM $110,000 $44,200 40.18 INTERIOR EXTERIOR ASSOCIATES 111 1 039 0.44 2078 01540 TROTTER BUILDERS INC 3 EAGLE POINtE DRIVE 06/30/97 563 RES $169,900 $61,600 36.26 ISDELL RICHARD G/CATHY R L 40 1757 02276 BRYANT ANGELIA P 2124 SIBLEY RD 09/30/97 572 RES $52,500 $19,760 37.64 ISHEE HARRIETT R 055 4 006 00 0 Ll Bl A 882 02180 RASCAL ENTERPRISES INC 124 KRISTIN LANDING 08/20/97 573 RES $15,200 $5,040 33.16 ISHMAN WOODROW/ALEXANDRIA 336 136 l 29/BL BISEC I 1.41 1294 02115 RICHMOND BUILDERS INC 2779 DAVIS MILL RD 09/25/97 571 RES $86,900 $34,000 39.13 IVY KEITH E 177 051 L 5/K 869 02389 DEVANEY CHARLES A/NANCY P 2624 WALTON WAY 10/01/97 572 RES $455,000 $129,800 28.53 IYER SHYAM S/KAMAL 34 3 097 123 '. . . . . . . . . . . II . . . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 63 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 02009 TORRES JUANA 3031 MABUS DR 09/05/97 570 RES $88,300 $38,800 43.94 JACKSON CLAYTON C 52 477 L 2/BL A/SEC V 316 01952 JOHNSON THOMAS/MARY 16 STATE HWY 88 09/03/97 569 AGR $31,400 $9,200 29.30 JACKSON DONALD/FLORNE 223 2 10 15.37 1162 02500 SMITH HAROLD C/GERRY J 2737 BARRY DRIVE 11/21/97 577 RES $69,900 $27,120 38.80 JACKSON KELVIN P L 9 BL A PINE VALLEY 1000 01827 BRUKER CO THE 313 ALEX LN 08/15/97 567 RES $79,900 $30,200 37.80 JACKSON lYNDA C 12 2 22 L 15 1386 01432 MIMS WILMA A 1017 STEVENS CRK RD #199 06/24/97 562 RES $45,000 $12,320 27.38 JACKSON lYNNETTE W 12 0 236 959 00006 J-MAR BUIDERS l SERVICES INC 4026 STORY MILL RD 01/03/97 544 RES $86,900 $36,920 42.49 JACKSON MALTON TODD/JOY CHERY 249/139 l 1 1527 02377 MANNEL WIllIAM M/LEAH P 3622 JAMAICA DR 09/30/97 572 RES $117 ,000 $59,320 50.70 JACKSON MILDRED H 31 3 17 l 11 J 113 01536 MAYSON WILLIAM P JR/SYLVIA M LUMPKIN PARK SUBDIVISION 07/10/97 563 RES $10,000 $3,000 30.00 JACKSON MITCHELL 097 072010 L 3.J 1555 01971 MARUCA ROSS M 2521 MEADOWBROOK DR 08/28/97 569 RES $59,900 $27,040 45.14 JACKSON PATRICIA A 120 0 222 00 0 L 23 Bl A 406 02062 SHADDIX LINDSEY l 1135 BROOKWOOD DR 08/29/97 570 RES $85,250 $37,400 43.87 JACKSON RONALD T/MAE G 13 1 67 L 20 BL C/SEC V 1817 00884 WILSON JACKIE L 2627 CAIRO DR 04/10/97 554 RES $57,900 $20,800 35.92 JACKSON WILLIAM T 106 0 056 L 29 BlK K 760 00391 E BLACKBURN CONST CO INC 1021 TRADD COURT 03/10/97 551 RES $144,787 $60,000 41.44 JACOBS KENNETH J/EVA MAP 30 PARCEL 283 L 12 962 01090 SHELTON GARY E/INGRID M 1805 MAVIS ST 05/01/97 559 RES $57,700 $22,440 38.89 JALBERT RAYMOND/MCNEELY ETTA 111 1 5 L 30/BL C 32 01189 GOODIN JOHN W 12/03/97 579 RES $12,000 $4,200 35.00 JAMES GARY 0 164 1 11 TR 2/A 2.45 1596 01022 WHITLOCK SARAH H - - 377 CHURCH ST 04/30/97 558 RES $89,900 $28,760 31.99 JAMES RICHARD AINANCY V H 267 0 042 6.01 393 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 64 Sample Seller Land Dist, land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 01188 GOODIN JOHN W lACE RD 12/03/97 579 RES $12,000 $4,080 34.00 JAMES RICHARD E TR 2/B 2.39 1590 01219 HALL JEFFERY PICARMEN M 2915 TOWER PINES DR 05/30/97 562 RES $62,643 $29,200 46.61 JAMES THOMAS RIDESIREE M 052 0 398 l 20 Bl A 202 01230 BROWN lEANORE FRANKLIN COV CHURCH RD 08/20/97 561 RES $17 ,500 $4,000 22.86 JARNAGIN PHILLIP M 317 0 028 5.86 820 01211 CROWE JOHN E JR 15 623 CARLTON DR 06/26/97 581 RES $93,900 $34,000 36.21 JARRELL BARBARA J M 025 11 245 Bl B 2412 00096 JONES GREGORY A/CLEVELAND R 2088 WALTON WAY SUITE 401 01/23/97 546 RES $68,500 $24,800 37.29 JARRELL ROBERT H 35 3 460 UNIT 40 704 01077 HENNESSEY KEVIN/LAURA/BRIAN 1522 CRAIG ST 05/30/97 558 COM $115,000 $36,800 32.00 JEFFCOAT TANYA WIClIFF H 44 1 226 0.38 2413 00450 RICHARD BIRD BUILDERS INC 2856 WIllIS FOREMAN RD 02/07/97 548 RES $115,900 $42,800 36.93 JEFFERSON FRANK L/SONYA 0 164 0 125 TR 6 490 01007 BAKER WALTER 1345 PENNY BANK ST 02/26/97 549 RES $1,300 $840 64.62 JEFFERSON PATRICIA A 058 4 159 l 6/BL A 2175 01457 NORDAHL HOMES INC 1737 BROWN ROAD 06/30/97 582 RES $115,900 $49,200 42.45 JENKINS ALVIN 0 L 4 1835 02994 LANDALE JAMES B/JOSEY SUSAN T 4010 RIO PINAR DR 12/08/97 581 RES $79,800 $30,000 37.59 JENKINS ANDREW L/HAZEL l 198 0 207 00 0 L 7/C 200 01932 RICHARD BIRD BUILDERS INC 2804 STOKER CT 08/28/97 568 RES $92,900 $36,800 39.81 JENKINS JAMES A JR L 11 Bl F 2067 02401 RANDOLPH TERRY 28 2423 BAYWOOO DR 07/18/97 564 RES $59,000 $21,200 35.93 JENKINS JERRY l M 085 2 262 l C 1415 02350 VARNADO SOLOMON G 3017 MISTLETOE AVE 10/24/97 574 RES $55,300 $21,360 38.63 JENKINS REMONA A 118 0 222 00 0 Bl C 594 01001 ROSENZWEIG PAUL JR 3117 VASSAR DR 02/28/97 549 RES $123,900 $46,120 37.22 JENKINS TED B JR 24 4 93 L 8/Bl F/SEC III 2112 03044 SCOTT RONALD l/GAYlE C 1849 OHIO AVE 10/30/97 575 RES $79,900 $31,920 39.95 JENKINS TERRI 43 4 31 1992 '.It . . . . . . . . . . ~ , 4 . 4' . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 65 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 02957 HERBERT MARK B 2930 MEADOWBROOK DR 11/14/97 580 RES $60,000 $24,760 41.27 JENKINS VALERIE L 119 4 1570 00518 RHODES TAMMY PICONI 4219 ROSE HILL DR 02/21/97 549 RES $79,900 $33,000 41.30 JENNINGE THERESA lYNN 194 o 091 L 7/BL G SE CI 489 00687 FRONT-lINE HOMES INC 4114 BIG OAK DRIVE 04/18/97 555 RES $147,700 $54,800 37.10 JENSENCHRISTIAN A/PATRICIA Y 196 0 094 L 17 BIG OAK 364 30024 2501 WASHINGTON COM $345,760 $139,600 40.37 JERATH RAVINDER 19 4 157 0.92 Appraisal 02910 ADAMS JAMES E JR 1465-67 REYNOLDS ST 12/17/97 580 COM $230,000 $69,480 30.21 JERATH RAVINDER/SETHI YOGESH 36 1 40 218 02104 RICHMOND BUILDERS INC 2781 DAVIS MILL RD 09/24/97 571 RES $86,900 $32,000 36.82 JETT NATHANIEL J 177 0 050 00 0 L 4/K 596 02195 GILLESPIE MAX H 2208 TRAVIS RD 10/10/97 573 RES $55,000 $20,800 37.82 JILES GREG A l 14/BL 0 925 00627 DAVIS IRA IV 21 2416 SPARKS RD 04/24/97 555 RES $48,900 $20,080 41.06 JIMENEZ ALBERTITROIA ANGELA 085 1 246 00 0 L 0 1575 01215 JONES JOSEPH/WALKER CHARLES W 2314 TUBMAN HOME RD 06/26/97 562 RES $38,900 $13,240 34.04 JIMPERSON HORACE 87 3 91 125 01954 STATE FURNITURE INC 1'16-1118 BROAD ST 09/02/97 569 COM $150,000 $77,120 51.41 JOHANNSEN A PATRICK 036 4 236 00 0 741 01254 BANKS CHARLES MIl/ELIZABETH 1703 HOLLY HILL RD 06/02/97 559 RES $65,000 $24,400 37.54 JOHANNSEN KIMBERLY A ET Al 057 2 166 00 0 L 41 BL A 698 02430 NORDAHL HOMES INC 1001 CEDARVIEW CIRCLE 07/28/97 565 RES $69,900 $27,200 38.91 JOHNSON ADAM K L 29-A 210 00940 LIVELY PROPS INC 3206 PENINSULA DR 05/03/97 556 RES $93,900 $34,400 36.63 JOHNSON ALESIA G 039 0 220 00 0 L 21F 1098 01558 PATCHEN JOSEF C/LAURIE A 2724 HENRY ST 07/18/97 564 RES $174,225 $71,600 41.10 JOHNSON ANNE T 334 12 280 02089 NORDAHL HOMES 2003 EWART CT 09/10/97 571 RES $69,900 $26,400 37.77 JOHNSON ANTON 394 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 66 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 02212 SAYLORS DONNA JEAN 30 1702 INDIAN HILL CT 10/03/97 573 RES $96,000 $38,400 40.00 JOHNSON ARDRIANNE/SAMMIE M198 OP 341 L C 226 00258 JOHN C WEAVER HOMEBUIlDERS IN 4644 STOREY MILL ROAD 03/07/97 550 RES $89,900 $33,320 37.06 JOHNSON BARRY lAMAR/LABORD S l 10 1477 01121 SMITH MARK T 2630 NATIONAL WOODS DR 06/23/97 561 RES $79,000 $30,960 39.19 JOHNSON CARL D 13 2 218 l 15/BL B 1585 00064 WIllIAMS C MURRAY 2503 SPRINGWOOD DR 01/15/97 545 RES $86,000 $33,600 39.07 JOHNSON CASEY LEE/ET AL 14-3 067 l22 BL A 1704 02460 BROSIOUS ALAN 0 2967 HIllCREEK DRIVE 10/30/97 574 RES $129,000 $52,000 40.31 JOHNSON CELESTE JANE 30 0 130 00 0 1923 00842 MCLAUGHLIN WLLIAM H/BABARA R 2210 PLEASANT DR 03/31/97 553 RES $85,900 $34,000 39.58 JOHNSON CHRIS J 010 0 243 l 25 1891 01822 STEINBERG HENRY/STEPHEN H 2563 lINCOlNTON PKWY 05/08/97 561 RES $65,900 $25,440 38.60 JOHNSON DANA B 349 00203 GARDEN CITY HOMES INC 15 EAGLE POINTE DRIVE 02/27/97 549 RES $146,900 $54,400 37.03 JOHNSON DONALD WICAROl J MAP 23 PARCEL 329 l 34 2306 02602 GASKINS W F 09/10/97 569 RES $250,000 $111,800 44.72 JOHNSON EDDIE P/GLADYS A 032 3 071 03 0 2035 01620 LIFSEY GROUP INC 3454 TOMS DR 07/30/97 565 RES $148,900 $48,600 32.64 JOHNSON EGUENE/RUBY 095 o 252 03 0 941 01668 PHILANGIAS DEV LC 300 NEVIS DR 07/30/97 565 RES $59,900 $22,800 38.06 JOHNSON EMMA 0 030 o 242 03 0 l 32 BlOG 1 2234 01949 ADAMS WILLIAM B JR/GAYlE M 3124 RAMS GATE RD 09/08/97 569 RES $90,200 $36,800 40.80 JOHNSON GARNETTEITONI SEALS 24 2 049 1107 00913 COOPER lESTER RIGlORIA FAY 2821 APRIL DR 05/02/97 556 RES $6,500 $2,800 43.08 JOHNSON GLENN R 94 397 476 00774 ABBOTT WALTER F JRIMARY lOU 330 HEMLOCK HILL ROAD 03/28/97 553 RES $117,900 $33,040 28.02 JOHNSON JAMES M 19 55 l 23 BERCKMAR RD GDN 224 02937 LIFSEY GROUP 3012 GREEN FOREST DR 12/17/97 580 RES $56,900 $22,040 38.73 JOHNSON JAMES O/SANDRA 718 '0 . . . . . . . . . . o 4t . . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 67 Sample Seller land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 02675 COLLIER MARY JOHNSON 86 BROWN RD 08/29/97 582 RES $7,000 $2,800 40.00 JOHNSON JULIETTE 213 9 5 1.26 482 01648 BRUKER CO 307 ALEX LANE 08/01/97 585 RES $76,000 $29,800 39.21 JOHNSON KATHIE l 12 2 25 L 18 1862 01242 EDWARDS BIllY C/LINDA 2764 WICKLOW DR OS/29/97 559 RES $79,900 $29,880 37.40 JOHNSON KEITH/NANCY N 18 0 205 L 32 SEC 2.A 219 01501 FAMBROUGH J HOWARD 2606 MEADOWBROOK DRIVE 07/03/97 563 RES $63,900 $22,000 34.43 JOHNSON LARRY B/MARY F 120 289 L 1 BL A 239 02108 WARD LAURENCE J JR/ROASANNE G 2007 SUMMER RIDGE DR 09/24/97 571 RES $105,750 $47,200 44.63 JOHNSON LAURA J 45 1 371 784 02995 NORDAHL HOMES INC 3469 MONTE CARLO DR 11/26/97 581 RES $69,900 $28,000 40.06 JOHNSON MARY B/PARRISH VICKIE 1430381090 L 2/A 232 02961 KIGHT DENNIS l 3089 QUIST DR 12/24/97 580 RES $63,100 $20,040 31.76 JOHNSON PHYLLIS A 97 1 087 1657 02827 HADDOCK GAIL G/JULIAN 3512 RUSHING RD 05/15/97 557 RES $80,000 $31,600 39.50 JOHNSON RONALD G 132 1 013 00 0 L 4/E 1792 00992 NORDAHL HOMES INC 3706 MILLSTONE RUN 04/30/97 556 RES $72,900 $29,800 40.60 JOHNSON STEVEM/LIlLY R 143 568 L 2C 2266 02716 JACK R NORDAHL BUILDERS 3405 SADDLE HORN RUN 12/31/97 581 RES $66,900 $28,000 41.85 JOHNSON TREVIS A 716 00856 KANE MICKEY 540 HILLWOOD CIRCLE 04/08/97 554 RES $110,900 $42,000 37.87 JOHNSON WESLEY/TRAMMELL SHERR 025 3 140 00 0 L 6 BL C 3 01583 HOWARTH WILLIAM J 935 DUGAS STREET 07/11/97 564 RES $3,000 $1,800 53.33 JOHNSON WILLIE M 46 4 328 855 02200 GAY CARSWEll E 2008 FENWICK ST 10/13/97 573 RES $47,000 $18,440 39.23 JOHNSON-CROWDER JANIE N 035 3 045 00 0 937 00742 WILSON DENNIS 1934 GAY DRIVE 04/15/97 554 RES $40,000 $16,000 40.00 JOINER JOSEPH R 122 2 119 00 0 L 1 BL I 1928 01881 KENNEDY DONSE- - 18 230 EAST VINE lAND RD 07/31/97 565 RES $80,000 $30,600 38.25 JOINER ROBERT B/LAURA lEE 026 2 092 00 0 L G 2100 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 68 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SlB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 02781 BUXTON SHIRLEY J 2635 CHAUCER DR 12/01/97 578 RES $119,500 $49,600 41.51 JOLLEY DONAlDILINDA H 030 o 190 1128 01970 KEYSTONE HOMES 3004 WINTERVIllE CT 09/04/97 569 RES $103,900 $41,400 39.85 JONES ALBERT L/VICKIE 0 052 0 599 00 0 L 18 Bl M SEC 2 389 01825 WARD JESSICA LEIGH ST~VENS CREEK RD 08/18/97 587 RES $40,000 $15,120 37.80 JONES BENNETT ET Al UN 182 BLDG 7 1336 02613 MAlECK JASON DAVID 2427 CASTLEWOOQ DR 11/04/97 575 RES $75,000 $35,600 47.47 JONES BRIAN K 1722 00935 CARMICHAEL MARLEITA R 3619 LEXINGTON DR 04/23/97 556 RES $84,900 $33,560 39.53 JOtlES CHARLENE 132 1 057 00 0 L 15 BL l 995 00995 CLAXTON HOLLIS lEE 3519 JAMICA DR 04/18/97 558 RES $84,000 $32,640 38.86 JONES CLYMONTEEN L 031 4 009 00 0 lOB 2307 02727 SH~RIDAN JOHN G/CONSTANCE 1058 FOX DEN RD 11/26/97 577 RES $115,500 $48,400 41.90 JONES CYNTHIA/JOSEPH 2353 01378 STURKEY ELAINE NORMAN 1444 FOREST ST 06/12/97 560 RES $39,900 $15,000 37.59 JONES DORIS l 59 1 425 1821 01500 HOOK ARTHUR 3044 HAWTHORNE DRIVE 07/03/97 563 RES $48,900 $14,120 28.88 JONES FANNIE MAE 097 1 006 L 11 BL B 226 01274 MAll GHADAM K 3513 TRUDYSHIRE DR 05/30/97 559 RES $62,500 $22,400 35.84 JONES FREEMAN JRIANITRA I 107 0 563 00 0 L 1 Bl G 997 00951 STILL TERAlD l 5 3025 ANGEL ST 04/28/97 556 RES $74,900 $28,400 37.92 JONES HARRY N/MARY M M 007 P 181 1376 30019 3546 DEANS BRIDGE COM $374,530 $151,720 40.51 JONES HENRY/ANDERSON B 106 13 2 0.77 Appraisal 01326 PORTER RONALD E II/DARCEE J 206 TREMONT WAY 06/06/97 560 RES $79,000 $29,200 36.96 JONES HURLEY M/JUlIE B 11 o 216 149 00506 VOlARTH OUDONEISOON TREE 02/13/97 548 RES $13,000 $5,440 41.85 JONES JAMES 0 175 44 l 13/SEC III/PT I 1.72 2334 00205 BRUKER COMPANY 526 BRIANS WAY 02/25/97 549 RES $68,000 $29,000 42.65 JONES JAMES PATRICK MAP 11 2 PARCEL 28 L 15 2322 '41t . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 69 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 02742 SAINE JEAN M 2100 LAKE AVE 11/26/97 578 RES $26,000 $10,920 42.00 JONES JESSIE MAE/GREEN JOHN 027 3 020 00 0 750 01767 NORDAHL HOMES INC 3466 MONTE CARLO DR 07/28/97 567 RES $68,900 $28,000 40.64 JONES JOANNE 0 L 80 259 02193 STEINBERG HENRY/STEPHEN H 1021 MILLER ST 10/10/97 573 RES $10,000 $6,040 60.40 JONES JOSEPH C 46/4/209 1081 01845 HAMMOND TOM VINCENT 1650 OLIVE RD 08/21/97 567 COM $55,000 $23,440 42.62 JONES LARRY L 1907 00090 MOORE DAVID/CATHERINE R BENNOCK MILL RD 01/16/97 546 AGR $42,000 $12,980 30.90 JONES LOUIS W/DARlENE A 325 0 023 00 0 TR C 18.00 199 02895 WALKER ROBERT L/YVONNE G 14 4107 COUNTRY LANE 04/30/97 557 RES $56,500 $22,000 38.94 JONES MARVIN JR 153 0 235 00 0 BL G 670 00903 ARNOLD RICHARD A 1217 HEMLOCK DR 04/30/97 556 RES $47,600 $20,200 42.44 JONES MICHAEL H/lISA M 031 4 096 00 0 321 01526 DOOLITTLE HENRY D/JUDY L S 2339 HENRY CIRCLE 07/10/97 563 RES $41,900 $13,960 33.32 JONES MICHAEL R MAP 97 2 PARCEL 41 l 22 BL Q 1076 00111 GARRISON CUSTOM HOMES INC 54 3535 CRAWFORDVIllE DR 01/15/97 546 RES $95,275 $39,400 41.35 JONES NATHANIEL JR 052 0 521 00 0 L B 1205 02583 WADE JOHN 42 TIMBERON TRAIL 10/15/97 576 RES $67,000 $25,600 38.21 JONES ROBERT S/RITA H 010 4 112 00 0 L 1 BL 1 599 02244 JACK R NORDAHL BUILDERS 1022 WALLIE CT 10/03/97 572 RES $68,900 $27,200 39.48 JONES ROOSEVELT F 1614 01832 FITZGERALD ROBERT E 2519 LYMAN ST 08/15/97 567 RES $74,000 $17 , 800 24.05 JONES SANDRA F 097 1 134 00 0 L 42/43/44 1637 02075 RASCAL ENTERPRISES INC 124 08/13/97 570 RES $22,500 $8,800 39.11 JONES STEVEN 0 322 40 L 32 5.13 2422 02871 DHAB INC 124 GMD ROLLINS RD 04/29/97 557 RES $15,455 $5,080 32.87 JONES STEVEN G 2.31 49 00086 WILSON PARISiMCNAIR FAYE - 517 EVE STREET 01/14/97 546 RES $18,000 $7,200 40.00 JORDAN FRANK/AMY 35 2 469 163 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 70 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 02953 llFSEY GROUP 4371 CREEKVIEW DR 12/19/97 580 RES $125,500 $48,400 38.57 JOSEPH VANESSA G/CHA~AZ K 1208 01695 BEDELL TERRENCE MIROSA l 12 2913 FOXHAll CIRCLE 07/31/97 566 RES $115,000 $43,600 37.91 JOSEY DAVID E/MYRA 0 M 016 0 250 00 0 L A 422 02782 HAMMOND GEORGE SR 2 3115 SWITZER DR 12/02/97 578 RES $58,400 $22,360 38.29 JOURNIETTE FRANKLIN 1803 01699 NORMAN DOUGLAS L/DEBBIE P 3622 BYRD RD 07/31/97 566 RES $52,000 $18,400 35.38 JOYE MICHAEL 0 168 38 547 01053 BARLOW JOHN R II 5406 RIDGEDAlE CORUT OS/22/97 558 RES $64,900 $29,400 45.30 KAHLER STEPHEN R SR/JEANA M 233 0 155 00 L 17/BL B 1521 02652 CLEARY KAREN S/MARK A 723 HICKMAN RD 10/31/97 575 RES $128,000 $33,560 26.22 KAMPMANN KATHLEEN K 035 3 010 00 0 L 2 491 00775 USRY BRADLEY H 2927 LAKE FOREST DRIVE 03/31/97 553 RES $178,000 $74,080 41.62 KATTINE TARA A 447 02113 GAY GREGORY l 58 CONIFER CIR 09/24/97 571 RES $380,000 $141,600 37.26 KAUFMANN ROBERT A 023 0 230 00 0 L 38/A 822 01356 NORDAHL HOMES INC 3268 SUMMERCHASE CIR 05/30/97 560 RES $108,900 $43,800 40.22 KAY ANN W 042 4 1 65 00 0 L 3 1082 01597 o l H DEVELOPMENT INC 255 HUDSON TRACE 07/25/97 564 RES $91,900 $35,000 38.08 KEATHLEY CLIFTON W JR/LISA 0 12 1 54 l 7 HUDSON TRACE 1502 01666 PERRY JOHN R JRISUSAN RENEE 1948 HEPHZIBAH/MCBEAN RD 08/01/97 565 RES $140,000 $47,760 34.11 KELLEY TIMOTHY G/DONNA E 316 0 012 00 0 2160 00423 ST KITTS 206 KITT' S DRIVE 01/31/97 547 RES $58,900 $22,800 38.71 KELlICHNER JEWELL A 030 0 242 03 0 l 20 E 2181 01358 INDIGO PROPERTIES l P 4205 RHENEY RD 06/06/97 560 RES $90,000 $38,160 42.40 KElLIGAN JIMMIE 0 211 o 001 01 0 6.20 1031 01476 GREENTREE LAND CO INC 5 GOOLSBY ROAD 06/30/97 562 RES $23,000 $5,720 24.87 KELLY CHESTER E SR/QUINELLE 265 9 2.81 1962 01643 TUCKER MICHAEL C 1723 BERKELEY RD 07/31/97 565 RES $64,900 $24,480 37.72 KELLY JASON/MICHEAl P 57 1 156 00 0 L 33 1514 'e . . . . . . . . . . o o . . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 71 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessllent No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 02484 SCOTT JOYCE E 1128 BEMAN STREET 10/03/97 577 RES $27,500 $14,200 51.64 KELLY JOHN L 045 2 027 00 0 L 19 1760 01410 MADEWELL JAMES C/RUBY N 3811 BEACON DRIVE 06/27/97 562 RES $63,900 $25,800 40.38 KEMP DAISY M 170 0 134 L 40 BL 0 SEC IV-A 551 02968 SULLIVAN KIMBERLEE K/ANTHONY 2415 BRENTWOOD Pl 12/19/97 580 RES $64,800 $25,200 38.89 KENNEDY J FRANKLIN H M 014 3 P 037 2055 01082 GARRISON CUSTOM HOMES INC 2015 CLARKSTON .DR OS/23/97 558 RES $89,900 $38,200 42.49 KENNEY JOHN A/SHAUNA L 052 0 581 00 0 l 8/l 2169 01547 HOLLINS ARTHUR H JR/EDITH M 2400 COMANCHE ROAD 07/15/97 563 RES $83,750 $33,800 40.36 KENNON KELSEY L 026 2 055 00 0 L 7 BL B 2058 00478 BROWN ROBERT W JR/DONA P 1986 MCDADE RD 01/23/97 548 RES $61,000 $16,400 26.89 KENT PAULA 196 70 L 11 1317 02336 l P B PORPS INC 8MACAULAY PLACE 10/17/97 574 RES $65,000 $29,000 44.62 KERNAGHAN ANGELA 0 12 2 L 69 739 02262 HERBERT HOMES INC 2301 MARBRISA COURT 09/29/97 572 RES $165,000 $59,200 35.88 KERNODlE JUNE FISUN H 198 419 l 5 BL C 1223 01984 NORDAHL HOMES INC 3438 MONTE CARLO DR 08/29/97 569 RES $79,900 $32,000 40.05 KERR AUDREY M l 2 Bl C 63 00487 MATSCHE MAURA A 1202 HIGHLAND AVE 02/17/97 548 RES $103,400 $43,080 41.66 KESTING THOMAS L 033 4 198 1802 02232 CECCHINE MEL D 3046 WHEELER RD 10/03/97 572 RES $83,500 $34,920 41.82 KETTERMAN PETER 25 3 l 6 BL A 1955 02617 MURDOCH FRANCIS J/J CAROLYN 1266-1268 MERRY ST 10/24/97 575 COM $27,900 $15,040 53.91 KEY JAMES R 45 3 60 8 45 3 60 11 1349 02595 JONES DAVID R 3232 RAMS GATE ROAD 10/15/97 576 RES $160,000 $58,800 36.75 KEY JANET P 24 1 70 l 46 BL 3 SEC IV 415 01889 RICHMOND BUILDERS INC 3107 CONNER CT 08/27/97 568 RES $78,600 $30,400 38.68 KEYS FREDDIE VASHON 085 2 181 00 0 L 27 BL A 1021 - -. - - -- - - 00376 KENNETH SMITH HOMEBUIlDERS IN 2409 RAMBLEWOOD DRIVE 02/27/97 550 RES $87,363 $35,800 40.98 KHALIL ABDULLAH S 143 0 725 L 8 BL J SEC I 2300 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 72 Sample Seller Land Dist, land lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 00890 lESHER JACK L JR/CATHERINE K 976 HEARD AVE 04/30/97 556 RES $96,400 $37,200 38.59 KILPATRICK ROBERT MCCORD/MARY 045 1 240 00 0 125 01591 HAUSER PAUL G 3819 PARWOOD DRIVE 07/22/97 564 RES $22,000 $6,920 31.45 KILPATRICK THOMAS A 205 0 001 08 5.77 1255 30028 2324 lUMPKIN RD COM $169,950 $61,080 35.94 KIM YOUNG W 109 2 3 9 0.55 Appraisal 01482 WASHINGTON ROAD DEVELOPERS II 224 CHARlESTOWNE WAY 07/01/97 562 RES $62,167 $25,000 40.21 KIMBERLY MARIAN E NEW FOR 1998 OUT OF L 12 BL B 2182 01823 TANNER MARTHA H 4 TAll PINE CIR 05/23/97 561 RES $245,000 $89,200 36.41 KIMMEL RICHARD GIVAlERIE S 23 0 162 368 00655 STEWART ALTON E JR 3034 CAMP JOSEY ROAD 04/03/97 553 RES $32,000 $9,240 28.88 KIMMEY JEDON B MAP 176 PARCEL 19 05 1728 02256 WESCO INC 2423 RAMBlEWOOD DR 10/06/97 572 RES $92,000 $38,600 41.96 KINCH THERESA A 143 718 l 15 Bl J SEC 1 1405 01488 HAGLER ROBERT C 1312 BUENA VISTA ROAD 07/10/97 563 RES $162,000 $57,040 35.21 KING DANIEL l/MARY ANNINA 432 71 319 01716 GRACEY STANLEY 2417 RAMBLEWOOD DR 06/30/97 566 RES $96,500 $34,200 35.44 KING KAREN I 143 721 L 12 BL J 1073 00713 MCCUMBERS BUILDERS INC 1525 PINE RIDGE DRIVE E 04/23/97 555 RES $91,000 $34,680 38.11 KING MICHAEL AICATANNA L 232 150 L 13 Bl C SEC 3 1063 00704 MARK MIMS HOMEBUIlDERS INC 1031 CADDEN WOODS DRIVE 04/22/97 555 RES $101,900 $42,400 41.61 KING SAN J l 16-A 744 02201 F & 0 PROPS INC 3009 LONSDALE DR 10/10/97 573 RES $69,900 $24,480 35.02 KINSEY ALVIN V/JUNE E 110 4 202 l 14 Bl C 637 01028 VICK HEYWARD RUSSELL 2919 TOWER PINES DR OS/20/97 558 RES $73,900 $28,800 38.97 KINZEL ERIC J/STEPHANIE A 052 396 L 18/Bl A 655 00083 PROCTOR JULIAN L/LUCIlLE 3449 WINSAP WAY 01/08/97 545 RES $65,900 $26,200 39.76 KIRK JULIETTE L 25 BL B 2319 01992 SID BECKUM CONST INC 1 341 ALEX LN 09/08/97 569 RES $77,900 $29,800 38.25 KIRKENDOHL SIDNEY R 012 2 08 1383 . . . . . . . . . . . l I ~ . .. . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 73 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SlB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ra tio 00419 ST KITT'S INC 200 KITT'S DRIVE 01/30/97 547 RES $57,900 $22,800 39.38 KIRKLAND JACK C SR/ENNID S 030 0 242 03 0 L 17/E 2145 00700 MILLS JAMES H 8/9 2114 STEVENS RD 04/02/97 555 RES $29,550 $11,240 38.04 KIRKPATRICK EUlA S 087 1 159 00 0 l C 642 00717 INMAN GEORGE H/NINA B 74 BRISTLECONE WAY 04/24/97 555 RES $300,000 $110,000 36.67 KITCHEN CAROLYN W 023 0 146 00 0 978 02955 ENELOW JAMES 0 1200 HOLDEN DR. 12/29/97 580 RES $19,900 $7,640 38.39 KITCHENS CHRISTOPHER l 045 1 202 00 0 1871 02309 BARKER JACK D/ANN B 09/29/97 571 RES $75,000 $11,760 15.68 KITCHENS HAROLD l/GAIL S 76 0 012 16 26 TR LIL 1 2083 02156 POINTS F M 3216 SYCAMORE DR 09/18/97 571 RES $67,500 $27,840 41.24 KLINGEL DANIEL B 041 2 083 00 0 1922 00613 CROFT JANETTE P 658 CENTER COURT DRIVE 03/24/97 552 RES $64,900 $24,680 38.03 KNAPP JOHN P 31 4 47 33 L A-FOREST HIllS 1028 01916 POTEET ANNA M FOREST HILLS SO 08/28/97 568 RES $64,900 $26,280 40.49 KNIGHT GWENDOLYN Y 31 4 47 85 BL XXXX UN 0 1784 02208 FAST FARE INC 1902 WINDSOR SPRING RD 10/09/97 573 COM $40,000 $20,000 50.00 KNIGHT SUN H 1104 160 01 514 01793 HOOPER ROY WARREN/MYRTLE R 1995 FENWICK STREET 08/14/97 567 RES $37,100 $16,560 44.64 KNOX BENJAMIN M 035 1 429 00 0 l 2 BL I 1064 02732 BECTON MARY BETH C 88 1101-1103 PEACHTREE RD 11/26/97 578 RES $135,000 $47,440 35.14 KNOX BOONE A/HOPKINS ELIZABET 96 278 61 148 01710 EAKER JAMES RONALD/SUSAN S 2816 HILLCREST AVE 08/08/97 566 RES $379,900 $121,400 31.96 KNOX CHARLES ElI/KIMBERLY N 33 4 120 00 0 0.46 864 00117 BURKE VICKY L 1843 OHIO AVE 01/14/97 546 RES $42,000 $16,320 38.86 KNOX RONI M 43 4 28 L 12 BL A 1529 02080 WEAVER JOHN N SR/GAIL C 2005 BRIDGEWATER DR 09/19/97 571 RES $104,000 $43,000 41.35 KODAMA SUSAN W 006 0 200 000 65 01851 SMITH ALFRED K/CHA PUN 3 1706 FOREST CREEK RD 08/12/97 567 RES $65,000 $24,400 37.54 KOSCHENE PAUL A/MARY A 054 2 077 00 0 BL H 2024 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 74 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 01324 WILLIAMS C MURRAY 3340 FASHION DR 05/30/97 560 RES $67,900 $26,080 38.41 KOURIK BRIAN K 122 4 063 l 5 Bl H SEC I 124 00068 WIllIS CHARLES E JR 1788 PINE lONG ROAD 01/16/97 545 RES $40,000 $17 ,200 43.00 KRAUSE TONY L 183 0 016 17 0 1754 00912 SMITH HELEN BREDENBERG 2738 HENRY STREET 04/30/97 556 RES $124,500 $46,640 37.46 KRAUSS JOAN THAN S 033 4 007 00 0 1074 00201 LORD JOHN LARRY 22 531 TUB MAN ST 02/26/97 550 RES $28,000 $10,960 39.14 KRIS HARDY INC M 035 1 221 16 02532 JONES KENNETH 0 2058 CENTRAL AVENUE 11/19/97 577 COM $150,000 $59,200 39.47 KROUSE ASHBY RIll/DONNA C 044 4 093 00 0 l 1-4 MONTE SANO S 0 86 02057 BRITT MARION 0 09/12/97 570 COM $53,000 $20,120 37.96 KUHlKE PROPERTIES 12 4 0.21 1740 00087 HENRY LISA C/BRYANT 1141 GLENN AVE 01/17/97 546 RES $280,000 $80,800 28.86 KUHlKE WILLIAM BIll 33 4 156 281 00733 HERBERT HOMES INC 3869 CREST DRIVE 03/31/97 554 RES $72,900 $29,200 40.05 KUNDE MATTHEW S MAP 140 PARCEL 502 L 21 BL H SE B 1531 01904 JUMPER BILLY JR/HICKS JUDITH DEEN AVE 05/16/97 568 RES $4,300 $1,680 39.07 KURUNSAARI GERALD/META 084 3 1 56 00 0 2.51 1438 01265 WILLIAMS C MURRAY 3706 lEXINGTON DR 06/02/97 559 RES $74,900 $29,560 39.47 KYLES NELLIE 132 1 100 00 0 L 14 Bl R SEC V 781 02085 JACK R NORDAHL BUILDERS 3510 SIDESADDLE CT 09/22/97 571 RES $66,900 $27,200 40.66 lAFUENTE lUISITO M/PETE M 328 02251 BISHOP ROBERT S 3531 SPRING GLEN LANE 10/01/97 572 RES $59,900 $24,120 40.27 LAMB DOROTHY E/BRYON 119 0 603 00 0 L 4/5 BlK B 1539 00054 HAWK CARL 0 2015 CARP DR 01/10/97 545 RES $52,900 $25,600 48.39 lAMB JAMES P 086 2 100 L 2 BLK B 1319 02428 WILLIAMS JOANN B 2428 BOYKIN ROAD 07/28/97 565 RES $52,900 $20,640 39.02 LAMB SANDRA R 190 01962 NEWTON JERRY M/WANDA G 2 3003 ANGELA ST 08/28/97 569 RES $66,400 $25,600 38.55 lAMB SHANNON C 007 161 BL F 785 o . . . . . . . e . . II o . . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 75 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 02191 GRAY DONNA HIGHSMITH 10/16/97 573 RES $20,000 $6,400 32.00 LAMBACK FREDERICK III/DONNA L 323 25 L22/SEC 1 983 00731 HERBERT HOMES INC 2701 LOREN PARKWAY 03/28/97 554 RES $68,900 $28,400 41.22 LAMBERT KEVIN MAP L 18 BL B PH 2 1558 02404 FOLDS VIRGINIA C 3126 TRAFALGAR DRIVE 07/17/97 564 RES $95,000 $36,800 38.74 lAMBERT SHERYL 24 2 209 L 14 BL P 1959 01849 DELOACH M PATRICK/CAROL M 7 3512 RICHMOND HILL RD 08/15/97 567 RES $78,900 $31,480 39.90 lAMP KIN VICTORIA A/LUCILLE 121 4 085 00 0 BL F 2005 00178 MCLENDON PHILIP L 2416 MCDOWELL STREET 01/30/97 547 RES $186,900 $67,960 36.36 LANDRUM JOSEPH H JR/CAROlYN B 44 1 PARCEL 141 729 00184 ELX DEV INC 2202 BIRNAM PLACE 01/31/97 547 RES $59,999 $24,000 40.00 lANDRUM TRACEY 57 3 196 L 10 Bl B 955 03021 o l H DEVELOPMENT 413 JASPER CROSSING 11/03/97 576 RES $102,700 $38,600 37.59 LANE ANN R 012 1 103 000 40 01487 CURRY TANYA L/KERNAN 3323 KENNY ROAD 07/07/97 562 RES $39,900 $10,920 27.37 lANGNER ANGELA E/WIlSON JOHNN 2290 01657 HERBERT HOMES INC 2921 FOXHALL CIR 07/30/97 565 RES $118,000 $39,200 33.22 lANGOllS CARL A 16 260 L 16 Bl A SECT 1 B 2040 02837 WHISNANT HUBERT M 05/09/97 557 RES $14,520 $5,800 39.94 LANIER JAMS 0 206 34 2.42 2128 01323 CARPENTER LARRY 0 1303 WINDSONG DIR 06/02/97 560 RES $40,500 $16,800 41.48 lAPP RHODA M 006 343 UN 1303 BlDG 13 PH 3 106 00288 JUTCO INC 2413 RAMBlEWOOD DR 03/05/97 550 RES $79,900 $32,800 41.05 LARSEN ERIK D L 143 723 1164 01759 HORNING WIllIAM J JR 513 HUNTINGTON STREET 06/27/97 567 RES $14,000 $7,280 52.00' LASTER CINDY 035 4 050 00 0 287 01853 KEYSTONE HOMES INC 4 3493 CRAWFORDVIlLE DR 07/31/97 567 RES $98,900 $39,800 40.24 LA TIMORE ERIC 0 052 0 573 00 0 BL K 2039 00293 PERALTA ANA ANGELICA ESPINAL 3412 WEBSTER ROAD 03/21/97 552 RES $55,900 $21,400 38.28 LATIMORE JOANN E MAP 108 PARCEL 228 l 6 BL K SEC 2 915 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 76 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SlB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 00461 MAYBERRY JULIUS/JORDAN LOUISE 2518 COLEMAN AVE 02/06/97 548 RES $31,428 $12,160 38.69 lATTIMORE JOHNNY 098 2 178 00 0 l 9/C 765 02530 CASSElS WALLACE B 1017 STEVENS CREEK 11/14/97 576 RES $28,900 $12,320 42.63 lAUBE HARRIETTE B 012 o 240 00 0 FOUNTAINHEAD 203 9 2265 01551 JACK SCOTT BUILDER INC 1 EAGLE POINTE DRIVE 07/14/97 563 RES $159,900 $64,000 40.03 LAWHORNE DIANE W/NElSON TRUOI 23 336 L 21 2291 00760 GIBBONS HARTlY JR OLD MCDUTFIE RD 04/04/97 544 RES $7,500 $4,400 58.67 LAWRENCE REGINALD/GLORIA l 3 0.21 924 00953 GLOVER EMANUEL/BRENDA 3009 GEORGIA RD 05/01/97 556 RES $83,000 $31,640 50.22 lAWRY MARK 0 107 675 L 13 Bl G SECT 10 147 02926 MCKIE BETTIE M 2722 DARLING DR 12/12/97 580 RES $57,133 $21,440 37.53 LAWSON ERIC 071 1 194 00 0 547 01334 STAMM DAVID L/LINDA J 3915 CREST DR 06/06/97 560 RES $99,900 $40,000 40.04 lAWSON JAMES A 140 0 325 L 4 BL H SEC 2-A 452 02423 WASHINGTON ROAD DEVELOPERS LL 5 CHARlESTOWHE DRIVE 07/29/97 565 RES $59,900 $25,000 41.74 LAWSON MARY ANNE OUT OF 011 0 222 00 0 l 60 BL A 131 00011 JACK RNORDAHL BUILDERS INC 1016 WALLIE COURT 01/03/97 544 RES $73,900 $39,200 53.04 lE CLAIRE MARK EUGENE 154 0 326 l 8 BlK B 1725 02789 FRONT LINE HOMES INC 1407 BROOKSTONE RD 12/03/97 578 RES $84,900 $29,200 34.39 LEACH WILLIE E l 4 BL B 1786 01127 KENNETH SMITH HOMEBUILDERS IN 2405 RAMBLEWOOD DR 06/20/97 561 RES $95,000 $38,200 40.21 lEE ALBERT JR/DORIS 143 o 727 l 6/Bl J/SEC 1 1857 02507 RASMUSSEN ORVAL ARTHUR 901 EISENHOWER DRIVE 10/31/97 577 RES $108,000 $45,600 42.22 LEE CHONG SUK MAP 19 2 PARCEL 38 l 10 GAINES o RTS 683 02788 NORDAHL HOMES 3014 JOHN PAUL CROSSING 12/04/97 578 RES $112,900 $43,600 38.62 lEE HAROLD 1771 01704 NORDAHL HOMES INC 3314 COBBLESTONE COURT 08/01/97 586 RES $70,900 $29,200 41.18 lEE KIM 0 132 512 L 12A 607 02973 EASTER ROBERT/SON MI 2540 PINE VIEW DR 12/17/97 580 RES $32,500 $13,760 42.34 lEE lOIS E 2142 .. . . . . . . . . . . u . . . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 77 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 01619 E BLACKBURN CONST CO INC 27 EAGLE POINTE DR 07/31/97 565 RES $182,300 $65,600 35.98 LEE OSWEN G/KATHRYNE J 23 323 l 28 EAGLE POINTE 894 01229 NASH DONALD A ADD TO DUNBAR TON 06/20/97 561 RES $6,000 $2,200 36.67 LEE WILLIAM 249 136 L 18 613 00942 HAMIL TON BRIAN L 4 2708 EDWARD DR 04/30/97 556 RES $67,900 $26,120 38.47 LEEGAN TERENCE P M 071 P 53 L A 1132 01709 HUNT ROBERT F 1436 SPRING HILL TERRACE 08/01/97 566 RES $52,000 $21,800 41.92 LEFERVERS HOWARD R 44 4 316 853 00728 ROBERTS JULIAN HIlI 2230 GLENDALE ROAD 04/29/97 555 RES $95,900 $40,000 41.71 lEGGIO SCOTT A/LISA E 026 4 032 00 0 L 8 BL I 2306 00899 MCELVEEN GEORGE S/HAZEL ANN 2804 INGLES IDE DR 04/28/97 556 RES $100,000 $32,480 32.48 LEIDA STANLEY R/DONNA B 25 2 61 285 00209 GUlYBAN MARK P 3 2905 PLEASANT COVE 02/28/97 549 RES $110,000 $48,400 44.00 LEJEUNE JEAN PAUL/BETTY J M 016 2 P 124 2402 02954 STUCKART PAUL G 2317 PARKWAY DR 12/02/97 580 RES $48,000 $19,960 41.58 LEONARD JOHN G 56 2 090 L 33 Bl H SEC III 1589 00607 HUGHES HARRY F/WITHROW WENDY 817 BARRETT LANE 03/27/97 553 RES $179,900 $60,960 33.89 LESHER JACK l JRICATHREINE K 033 3 085 00 0 l 10 124 01739 MCDOWELL MELVIN L 4329 PARKWOOD DR 08/06/97 566 RES $73,900 $28,320 38.32 LEVAINE ANTHONY 1906 00027 HOKE DAVID T 1738 FOREST CREEK DR 01/03/97 545 RES $74,600 $23,600 31.64 lEVERETT THADEUS 054 2 061 00 27H 60 01277 BOSTON WILLIE BOB 2611 BROOKSHIRE RD 06/02/97 559 RES $54,900 $19,600 35.70 LEWIS BRENDA L 120 0 336 00 0 L 10 Bl B 1027 01310 GRAY WILLIAM T/JULIE M 3011 EAGLE DR 06/05/97 559 RES $94,900 $35,160 37.05 LEWIS CHERYL L L 12 BL E SEC 2 1739 00887 RASCAL ENTERPRSES INC 86 01/30/97 554 AGR $9,995 $3,560 35.62 LEWIS DARNUM/JACQUElINE 222 30 L 3 SECT 1 0.56 708 02370 LYNCH JEAN B 2498 REESE AVE 10/20/V7 573 RES $52,000 $20,400 39.23 LEWIS JOEL T 098 2 263 00 0 L 10E 2193 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 78 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SlB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 01968 MCGOWAN PAMELA L 2556 KAUFMAN DR 08/29/97 569 RES $46,400 $17,800 38.36 lEWIS MilA J 098 1 212 00 0 L 130 2ND ADD 315 01772 ADDINGTON JAMES S/lAURA M 3324 QUAKER SPRING COURT 08/15/97 567 RES $105,000 $39,200 37.33 lEWIS RICHARD C 016 0 217 00 0 L 6 BK C 521 01757 DAVIS DONALD l 608 MONTE SANO AVE 08/13/97 567 RES $24,000 $10,200 42.50 LEWIS RONALD D/GERAlD 0 034 1 294 00 0 99 02225 OSTERMAN NELL B 809 METCALF STREET 10/01/97 572 COM $32,000 $17,600 55.00 lEWIS RONALD D/GERALD 0 2415 01720 MAXWELL JOHN VIVIAN 4 BRANSFORD P L 07/31/97 566 RES $257,000 $95,040 36.98 LEWIS RUTH J 34 4 61 03 l4 1272 02781 lEON GHITTER REAL EST PARTNER 1926 SECOND AVE 09/25/97 578 RES $2,000 $560 28.00 lEWIS SAM JR 72 3 299 1500 00356 CORLEY DOROTHY CHALKER 1531 HEATH ST 03/14/97 552 RES $58,000 $22,880 39.45 lEWIS SHAWN EIKATHY K 044 3 175 974 01763 REEL THOMAS 1704 GOSHEN RD 07/21/97 567 RES $82,000 $33,200 40.49 lEWIS STEPHANIE K 198 99 L 9 Bl C SECT 2A 172 01262 WATKINS WILSON M 1872 CENTRAL AVE/701 TUTT 05/01/97 559 RES $49,200 $27,440 55.77 LEWIS WIllIAM H 45 3 120/35 4 188 1101 01263 WATKINS WILSON M 213-215 PERKINS ST 05/01/97 559 RES $16,200 $6,560 40.49 LEWIS WIllIAM H 36 1 127 1103 02042 HAMM BETTY H 2375/2377 LUMPKIN RD 09/12/97 570 RES $35,000 $14,600 41.71 lEWIS WILLIAM H 97 4 342 l 4/B 1172 02166 ALEXANDER HOMES INC 4817 GOLDEN lEAF lN 10/10/97 573 RES $92,900 $32,600 35.09 lEWIS WILLIE/KIMBERLY 1708 00654 GARRISON CUSTOM HOMES 11 2522 WIRTEVILLE DR 03/28/97 553 RES $123,700 $46,600 37.67 lEWRIGHT WIllIAM A 052 0 592 000 l M 1778 02465 BLACKBURN HOME BUILDERS INC 32 EAGLE POINTE DRIVE 10/29/97 574 RES $160,500 $64,400 40.12 lIAO MEI FENG/JIAN CHAO 023 0 308 00 0 l 13 1787 00007 HARTLEY DORIS SHANNON 2298 OVETON RD 01/03/97 544 RES $70,000 $31,200 44.57 lIBERTI SALVATORE A 26 2 175 L 40 BlK J 1670 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 79 Salllple Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessllent No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ra tio 02935 PINNACLE PROPERTIES 4528 RIDGE RUN DR 12/16/97 580 RES $16,500 $6,400 38.79 LIFSEY GROUP 140 799 695 02936 PINNACLE PROPERTIES 4532 RIDGE RUN DR 12/16/97 580 RES $17 , 300 $6,400 36.99 LIFSEY GROUP 140 801 701 01635 JOHNSON EUGENE AllEN JR/RUBY 2920 OAKLAHOMA AVE 07/30/97 565 RES $50,613 $22,200 43.86 LIFSEY GROUP INC 108 0 036 00 0 L 1 BL A 1347 01458 DINEEN PATRICE M 4041 BURNING TREE lANE 06/30/97 562 RES $76,900 $32,000 41.61 LIGON RICHARD BRIAN 198 0 172 00 0 L 5.B 1644 01401 TAYLOR HARRIET B 2906 HENRY STREET 06/27/97 562 RES $69,900 $30,040 42.98 LINDSEY BEVERLI K 33 2 369 491 00844 ROBINSON EDWARD C 712 SOMERSET WAY 04/02/97 553 RES $208,685 $110,560 52.98 lINDSEY BUFORD/BARBARA 024 0 231 00 0 LT 6 Bl B 1717 02608 CLARK HENRY JIll/CARMEN 9 3618 SEELYE DR 09/10/97 569 RES $60,000 $29,600 49.33 lISENBEE SANDRA 132 0 432 2384 01178 C J SINGLETON CONST CO 4509 RAMBLING ROSE CIR 12/05/97 579 RES $74,900 $27,800 37.12 lITTLE MELISSA A 1189 00485 SOUTH PARK COMMONS SOUTH PARK SID 02/14/97 548 RES $56,400 $21,800 38.65 lITTLE RYAN P/JULIE M L 20 1565 02496 SHETTY RAMI RAMBERG JULIA 1733 KING WOODS DRIVE 11/20/97 577 RES $68,000 $25,680 37.76 lIVINGSTON CLAIRE 54 7 017 1138 00433 WILLIAMS DANIEL J/JOHN C/MARY 1921 ELIZABETH DR 02/11/97 547 RES $58,515 $23,240 39.72 lIVINGSTON JAMES E/MARION A 133 1 013 00 0 L 13/F 2385 02102 WEISS KENNETH lEE/JANE lOUISE 714 WESTMINSTER CT 09/22/97 571 RES $175,000 $71,320 40.75 LIVINGSTON WIllIAM R/MARYlOU 33 1 189 580 01622 WILLIAMS C MURRAY 2145 SARATOGA COURT 07/30/97 565 RES $85,000 $32,640 38.40 LLOYD FRANK/MARITZA 132 1 64 L 22 BL K SEC V 1158 02473 WATSON MITCHELL HOME BLDRS IN 2011 TEAL COURT 11/21/97 577 RES $188,450 $64,800 34.39 lLOYD JAMES F/CAROL W 165 0 212 00 0 L 18 BL E 1738 00482 KIMBERLY C M 1101 AZALEA DR 02/14/97 548 RES $67,000 $27,200 40.60 LOCKE JAMES K SR/lINDA B 13 4 83 1 L 1 B/Bl 0 1475 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 80 Sample Seller land Dist, Land lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 01208 ALEXANDER HOMES INC 2520 CARRIAGE CREEK 06/25/97 561 RES $98,850 $40,200 40.67 lOCKHART HAZEL 013 1 198 L 24 BL B SEC 2 2357 02516 FRAZIER MACK ANDREW JR/CYNTHI 11 4322 FAIRBlUFF RD 11/19/97 577 RES $84,900 $33,240 39.15 lOCKHART RICKEY M/MELINDA A M 233 0 P 081 L A 504 02881 HOWEll W MARK/ALBA NEVES 2919 LAKE FOREST DR 04/30/97 557 RES $188,000 $83,520 44.43 lOEHR SCOTT W/DEBORAH B W 33 4 56 520 00372 ST KITTS LlC 219 KITTS DRIVE 03/27/97 552 RES $56,900 $22,800 40.07 lOFTON lOUISE J OUT OF 030 0 242 03 0 L 10 BL C 2340 01862 NORRIS LARRY 0 2284 PLANTATION RD 08/21/97 567 RES $6,000 $2,560 42.67 lOGAN J GORDON 180 86 l 17 SEC III 2177 03026 ROSSI NANCY O/MARIO F SEVENTH ST 07/24/97 576 COM $65,000 $27,920 42.95 LOGAN JERRY 169 01563 E BLACKBURN CONST CO INC 28 EAGLE POINTE DRIVE 07/15/97 564 RES $164,900 $64,800 39.30 lOH-LOO SHUISHAN MAP 23 PARCEL 306 L 11 240 01390 LIFSEY GROUP INC 3311 BALKCOM DR 06/10/97 560 RES $101,900 $44,600 43.77 LONG HATTIE M 95 0 348 l 8 Bl E 1961 01875 HENTHORN JOYCE ANN WARNING 1039 ALDEN DR 05/10/97 568 RES $8,000 $3,200 40.00 lONG MICHAEL/SANDRA 323 70 01664 lARISCY WILLIAM H SR 15 3301 SYLVESTER DR 07/31/97 565 RES $65,000 $25,flflO 39.82 lOPEZ AlCIDES 122 2 230 L C 2139 I 00516 BISAGNA EVELYN 0 2436 BREAM AVE 02/14/97 549 RES $40,000 $18,200 45.50 lORD LINDA W 86 4 84 l 2/Bl 0 441 00463 COOK ROBERT W 02/11/97 548 RES $11,000 $3,920 35.64 LOREN RACY/lAVONIA 196 004 01 0 TR B 5.00 774 00418 ST KITT'S INC 203 KITT'S DR 01/30/97 547 RES $56,900 $22,800 40.07 LOTT JACQUELINE P 030 0 242 03 0 l 2/A 2133 01546 lIVELY C MILNER 2778 WIllIS FOREMAN ROAD 07/15/97 563 RES $133,500 $55,360 41.47 lOUIS VALERIE 165 o 023 00 0 l 45 2046 01155 WATKINS DAVID A/ANGELA 6 3636 HEIRS BLVD 12/10/97 579 RES $70,900 $28,400 40.06 lOVE-LEE VEftA H 129 0 306 00 0 BL C/PH I 486 e . . . . . . . . . . ~ . o . . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 81 Sample Seller land Dist, Land lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 00691 SPENCER JAMES B JR 3710 LYNCREST DRIVE 01/01/97 555 RES $66,900 $26,240 39.22 LOVER ESTHER N/BONNIE E 152 58 L 23 BL 0 SEC 3 299 00864 EDWARDS ETHEL F 1636 WALTON WAY 04/04/97 553 RES $35,000 $14,000 40.00 LOWE SAMUEL H 035 4 590 00 0 2296 02296 NORDAHL HOMES INC 1002 CEDARVIEW CIRCLE 09/30/97 572 RES $86,900 $32,800 37.74 LUCAS JOHN C JR/TAMMY A 213 206 L 7B 404 02687 COBB THOMAS C 3000 PATTERSON. BRIDGE RD 12/19/97 581 RES $12,500 $5,040 40.32 LUCAS SCOTT A/ALLISON R 224 129 2.80 1770 01656 WHISENHUNT CHILDREN INC 5 ZACHARY PLACE 08/01/97 565 RES $76,900 $29,800 38.75 lUJAN HELEN A 12 1 121 L 75 1999 01459 NORDAHL HOMES INC 1055 CEDARVIEW CIRCLE 06/30/97 562 RES $71,900 $28,400 39.50 LUKE ERIC B 213 172 L 2-A 1654 00358 caR HOME BUILDERS INC 2402 RAMBLEWOOD DRIVE 03/27/97 553 RES $122,771 $48,200 39.26 lUNEY LEANDER L 20- I 8 02315 MALO IN TIMOTHY SRIJUDY N 3804 BEACON DR 10/24/97 574 RES $68,314 $27,800 40.69 lYBRAND ROBERT/SHERYL 170 0 127 00 0 1398 00505 SPENCER OTIS JR 3340 BAR DOT DR 02/21/97 548 RES $45,000 $22,200 49.33 LYMON EMIRA E 041 2 221 00 0 2296 00525 WALKER PATRICIA M 610 BRANSFORD RD 02/21/97 549 RES $25,410 $9,560 37.62 LYNCH VERONICA 727 30013 2045 GORDON HWY COM $360,690 $143,600 39.81 lYONS BRUCE A/MARTHA J 69 3 1 1.07 Appraisal 00907 MENEGHELLO RENA TO/MARGARET G 3013 CARDINAL DR 04/29/97 556 RES $102,000 $48,640 47.69 lYONS MICHAEL J/CYNTHIA K 43 1 096 832 00920 BUDWICK PETER JR 608 WINDSONG WAY 04/29/97 556 RES $42,000 $16,800 40.00 MACCULLOUGH JEFFREY J 06 0 292 797 01554 DEVISH RONALD E/CELINDA M 4 TALL PINE COURT 07/09/97 563 RES $339,000 $120,000 35.40 MACDONELL ALEXANDER III/JUDIT 023 160 L 38 BL C 2339 00871 RASCAl.ENTERPRlSES-INC 86 01/27/97 554 AGR $10,995 $3,440 31.29 MACK HORACE/REBECCA M l 14 SECT I 0.54 162 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 82 Sample Seller land Dist, land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 00947 GAINES VARNElL/GLENNIS B 1920 MORNING DR 04/23/97 556 RES $51,292 $21,720 42.35 MACKLIN R l 1242 02466 SANDERS RUFUS H 2230 LEE ST 10/21/97 574 RES $64,500 $25,960 40.25 MACKLIN ROBERT l 044 4 332 00 0 1962 01614 HYLBERT-KREBS DAVID C/lAURA R 2205 TERRACE RD 07/31/97 565 RES $147,000 $58,800 40.00 MACLEAN JOHN ROSS 26 4 136 1206 02312 CORLEY JERRY W 2044 MCDOWELL ST 09/30/97 571 RES $72,900 $28,160 38.63 MADALINSKI BRUCE A/JAMI J 442 151 2245 00483 GRAHAM THOMAS M ET AL 02/11/97 548 COM $330,000 $81,600 24.73 MADDOX ROBERT A 2.03 1527 01255 ST KITT' S LLC 213 KITT'S DR 06/02/97 559 RES $58,900 $22,800 38.71 MAGUIRE ALFRED J JR 030 0 242 03 0 l 7 BL B 542 01955 HUFF JOSEPH H/JODI G 23 2213 WOODLAWN AVE 08/29/97 569 RES $84,000 $33,560 39.95 MAGUIRE WILLIAM F JR 057 2 004 BL Y 746 00099 WILL HORACE JIll 01/20/97 546 RES $51,500 $20,600 40.00 MAIKE CHRISTINE 35 3 734 02555 ROBERSON BARRY 2148 EAST SIDE CT 11/07/97 576 RES $73,900 $23,320 31.56 MALO IAN GREGORI l 109 4 052 000 1433 00735 SMITH KATHARINE JOPLING HIll 972 HEARD AVENUE 04/14/97 554 RES $78,000 $34,200 43.85 MANGIONE LISA A MAP 45 I PARCEL 238 1485 02594 NORDAHL HOMES INC 1051 CEDARVIEW CIRCLE 10/15/97 576 RES $76,900 $26,600 34.59 MANN ARTHIE MORRIS/SHEILA A 213 174 l 4-A 403 02723 GILBERT VIVIAN L 2529 RICHMOND HILL RD 08/29/97 577 RES $75,500 $29,960 39.68 MANN SHIRLEY B 98 1 9 L 7 Bl C 2218 02037 COOK DAVID MIJUlIE F 3012 MABUS DR 09/12/97 570 RES $81,300 $32,400 39.85 MANNING FELIX III 052 o 457 00 0 L 26/B 967 00999 SCHOLER PATRICE K 22 24 05/05/97 556 RES $146,000 $47,600 32.60 MAPP KATHERINE 2412 01676 SCHOLAR PATRICE K 1325 GLENN AVE 08/06/97 566 RES $127,000 $55,360 43.59 MAPP KATHRINE 043 2 083 00 0 134 41. . . . . . . . . . . o n . . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 83 Sample Seller land Dilt, Land lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 02043 HORTON BETTY TIMMERMAN 2701 WELLINGTON DR 09/17/97 570 RES $192,500 $86,000 44.68 MAPP ROBERT L JR 25 4 124 L l?Bl A/SEC 1 1190 00116 ANDERSON FRANK W/MARTHA E 2213 OVERTON RD 01/24/97 546 RES $111,000 $44,000 39.64 MARKS RAYMOND 0 16 7 481 L 15 Bl B 1487 01926 PEACOCK MARK E/LYNN S 3138 WESTMINSTER DR 08/29/97 568 RES $110,000 $45,000 40.91 MARNELL EUGENE R JR/BEVERLY B 32 2 108 1928 01086 RILEY SANDRA ANN 3209 SYLVAN COURT OS/28/97 558 RES $78,500 $29,000 36.94 MARSH ERIC 0 42 3 44 L 5/Bl D/SEC II 2329 01116 PRATHER LARRY S JR/ROBERT L 14 2929 ALGERNON 06/20/97 561 RES $13,900 $5,200 37.41 MARSH LAMONT Bl B 1518 01161 JEFFERIES PRENTICE D/JANICE M 1209 GLENWOOD DR 12/01/97 579 RES $79,900 $27,400 34.29 MARSH WANDA KAY 013 2 128 00 700 01533 RUFFIN CLARENCE SR 5 OFF DICKERSON RD 07/07/97 563 RES $3,100 $1,240 40.00 MARTIN BETTY R MAP 171 PARCEL 11 06 1415 00737 WHEELER VICKIE B 3708 CLAYBORN DRIVE 03/20/97 554 RES $50,000 $22,240 44.48 MARTIN CYNTHIA E 152 123 L 26 Bl L SEC VII 1283 00845 MORGAN FORREST M/SUSAN F 2210 WOODBlUFF WAY 04/02/97 553 RES $119,000 $49,600 41.68 MARTIN EULALIE M 18 0 297 00 0 l 5 BL C 1688 02287 ElIM GARALD J/DONNA S 2036 JOSEPH STREET 10/03/97 572 RES $36,000 $11,360 31.56 MARTIN INEZ 72 211 10 BL A 972 01235 VETTER JOHN W/LYNN K 3221 YELLOW PINE DR 06/18/97 561 RES $69,200 $26,800 38.73 MARTIN JACK L/JULIE A 52 401 L 23 Bl A 874 00287 DOTTERWEICH WAYNE L JR ET AL 3517 BARKER DR 03/06/97 550 RES $93,300 $37,400 40.09 MARTIN MARVIN A/LYNETTE 0 139 0 258 1155 01683 BREWER VIRGINIA L SMITH 1017 STEVENS CREEK DR 07/01/97 566 RES $39,000 $16,720 42.87 MARTIN PATRICK J JR 12 181 UNIT 1440 BUILDING 4 190 00156 JOHN C WEAVER HOMEBUILDERS IN 3050 GREY FOX DR 01/31/97 547 RES $146,900 $55,600 37.85 MARTIN RONALD LEE/CHERYL l 271 o 032 00 0 L 25A 391 01190 LUXMORE .LORL .. -. - 9 2018 BASSFORD DR 12/09/97 579 RES $92,100 $30,800 33.44 MARTIN SONIA L/CEDRIC T 164 0 082 00 0 BL E 1603 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 84 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SlB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 01024 JENKINS EMORY H 1905 HOPLE RD 05/08/97 558 RES $15,000 $3,920 26.13 r~RTIN STEVE O/ANNETTE 415 02383 DUNAGAN DAVID/DOZIER RICHARD 4145 OLD WAYNSBORO RD 09/30/97 572 RES $61,000 $21,200 34.75 MARTIN STEVEN H/SANDRA 213 o 005 08 59 02403 BECKHAM TWIlA KAY CAWVEY 1903 DUNHAM COURT 07/18/97 564 RES $54,900 $21,320 38.83 MARTINEZ ARNALDO/MERCEDES MAP 110 4 PARCEL 61 l 27 BL 2 1942 01061 GODOWNS JAMES M/MARY E 2429 PEACH ORCHARD RD 05/16/97 558 COM $112,500 $46,560 41.39 MARTINEZ GUILLERMO R/MAUREEN 086 4 006 07 PAR B 1734 01389 C J SINGLETON CONST INC 2325 WOODSMAN DR 06/13/97 560 RES $75,900 $28,960 38.16 MARTINEZ JOSE J/DIGNA I 180 0 045 L 28 Bl G 1906 02056 BLACKSTONE PAUL JR 07/07/97 570 RES $19,360 $6,160 31.82 MARTINEZ MARCOS JR/STACEY 0 350 15 02 L 3 4.40 1713 01035 ASTACIO ALBERTO P 3238 KEVIN DRIVE 05/16/97 558 RES $49,900 $19,240 38.56 MARTINEZ OPTASIANO 122 2 321 00 L 4/Bl CISEC 3/A 804 00159 BASSE HOWARDIHElENE 3125 OXFORD RD 01/31/97 547 RES $95,000 $36,360 38.27 MASSEY GREGORY S/LEANNE H 032 2 045 00 0 L 31 BK B 414 02559 SELBY EDWARD H JR 3643 WALTON WAY EXTENSION 11/05/97 576 COM $260,000 $103,600 39.85 MASSEY JACKSON R/SHERRY Y 023 0 027 05 0 l 1 1255 01850 GREENLEE JOHN W 3 3316 lIMBER TWIG LN 07/30/97 567 RES $51,000 $19,440 38.12 MASSEY LILLIAN P 123 3 185 00 0 BL E 2017 01549 MABIE JAN E/CATHERINE/MATTHEW 3226 W WIMBlEDON 06/30/97 563 RES $49,000 $18,320 37.39 MASSEY SHELBY L III M 031 4 P 047 61 0 UNIT C PARCE 2230 01237 VARNADO SOLOMON G 27 2116 CASSELL ST 06/23/97 561 RES $49,999 $18,000 36.00 MASSIE JOHN M 167 0 088 00 0 BL A 893 01214 TEETS ANN L 2 32 TIBURON TRL 06/27/97 562 RES $56,300 $22,800 40.50 MASTERS RONALD M 010 4 117 00 0 Bl J 73 02436 SILAS lIlLIAN W 602 HEARD AVENUE 07/25/97 565 RES $48,000 $15,280 31.83 MATECHAK GREG 035 1 360 00 0 480 01149 MCCOY DOROTHY G 103 CALVARY DR 12/05/97 578 RES $39,900 $13,400 33.58 MATHIS BARBARA 180 . . . . . . . . . . . u u . . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 85 Sallple Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ra tio 01292 KARAMICHAEL CHRIS C/REIKO 2705 TYRON PL 06/03/97 559 RES $52,500 $23,200 44.19 MATHIS LISA L 120 0 473 00 0 L 10 BL A 1321 02619 RICHARDSON G S/E 0 806 CAMELLIA DR 11/04/97 575 RES $192,000 $80,200 41.77 MATSON WERNER/PAULA 032 1 035 000 1316 01553 KIPPELMANN FREDERICK J/HElENE 42 2502 CASTLEWOOD DRIVE 07/14/97 563 RES $85,000 $31,800 37.18 MATTHEWS WENDY E 014 0 027 00 0 BL A 2321 02341 lOVE WILLIAM G/CHERYl A 2006 MELROSE DR 10/07/97 574 RES $63,900 $27,000 42.25 MAXWEll DAVID H/CHERI 0 863 01442 C M S GROUP INC 1230 ALDEN DRIVE 06/30/97 562 RES $9,900 $4,000 40.40 MAY IRWIN R/MARY S 323 0 066 L 62 PH 2 LEWIS ACRE 1190 02317 DRAGON TREE PROPS INC 2534 KESNINGTON DR E 10/24/97 574 RES $59,900 $19,920 33.26 MAY KENNETH C/BARBARA J 108 285 L 11 BL B SECT 1 1110 00188 ROBINSON JOHNNY/EDWINA G 3807 NEW KARlEEN RD 01/31/97 547 RES $73,900 $30,000 40.60 MAYO GLORIA R S 128 0 072 LT 1 BLK A 987 01555 BRYANT JULIA M MURRAY 810 E BOUNDARY 07/17/97 563 RES $45,900 $19,600 42.70 MAYS WALTER LEE 06110 41000 L 1-R 2353 00311 BLANK BARRY S 411 WAVERLY DRIVE 02/28/97 550 RES $210,000 $94,800 45.14 MCALISTER AlAM/WAYNE 024 0 096 00 0 L J WAVERLY SID 259 01400 STEWART J FRANK 3611 LIBSON CT 06/04/97 581 RES $37,000 $16,080 43.46 MCBRIDE GLENDA 82 80 L 28 BL B SEC 1 33 01977 CLEMENTS GLENN R 1921 MARYLAND AVE 09/04/97 568 RES $48,302 $19,360 40.08 MCBRIDE THOMAS B 056 2046 00 0 L 10 Bl H 2252 01799 BENTLEY ALEXANDER/DElROIS A 3301 ANSLEY CT 08/01/97 567 RES $93,950 $37,200 39.60 MCBRIDE TYRONE/CASSANDRA 16 2 54 1144 00549 ATKINS KENNETH L 2701 GLENN HILLS DR 02/28/97 550 RES $55,900 $23,160 41.43 MCCALL GUENN M JR/BAIlEY 0 J 96 2 129 l 15/BL L SEC I 1762 02527 STAGER LOIS/RAMSEY JOAN H 3031 ANGELA STREET 11/10/97 576 RES $73,000 $28,000 38.38 MCCAll MARY BETH 007 184 00 0 2329 02597 SMITH JOHN-S ~~ -- 1326 HEPHZIBAH-MCBEAN RD 10/31/97 578 RES $10,880 $5,960 54.78 MCCARTHY TIMOTHY 336 0 245 00 0 L 1 2.72 352 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 86 -- Sample Seller land Dist, land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 01395 MCCORMACK PATRICK J/DANA L 2410 MOHICAN RD 06/11/97 560 RES $77,400 $30,600 39.53 MCCLINTOCK PEGGY E 026 2 035 00 0 2185 02489 ALEXANDER HOMES 2006 END ST 11/24/97 577 RES $59,900 $20,000 33.39 MCCLOY VIRGINIA A 1437 01073 LIVELY PROPERTIES INC 3208 PENINSULA DRIVE OS/27/97 558 RES $101,900 $38,400 37.68 MCCORD COREY L/KAREN HUDSON 039 o 221 00 0 L 22/F 2009 00982 FRONT LINE HOMES INC 2765 DAVIS MIl~ RD 05/06/97 556 RES $85,900 $34,400 40.05 MCCOY JOHN E 177 o 058 L 12 BLK K SEC 2 2113 00264 COX DUNCAN L/GERAlDINE 3548 REDO DRIVE 03/07/97 550 RES $38,000 $14,040 36.95 MCDADE JAMES MAP 120 PARCEL 116 1517 01471 MARTIN DAVID ALAN/MELINDA J 1527 JOHNS ROAD 06/27/97 562 RES $92,000 $35,280 38.35 MCDONALD GREGORY PIMARY E 44 3 233 l 23/PT 16 BL 37 1876 30029 3018 WASHINGTON RD COM $760,630 $240,920 31.67 MCDONALDS 12 273 1 1.04 Appraisal 30006 3132 PEACH ORCHARD RD COM $806,920 $274,000 33.96 MCOONAlDS CORP 110 3 188 1 1.03 Appraisal 00574 JONES MARSHALL C/TANYA A 3018 HILLCREEK DR 03/07/97 551 RES $145,000 $50,800 35.03 MCELROY ROBERT L 40 0 140 294 01436 JUTCO INC 4130 BURNING TREE LN 06/30/97 562 RES $82,900 $29,600 35.71 MCENULTY THOMAS/MICHELLE L 214 157 L 16 Bl B PH 1 1074 02202 ROll 0 INC 203l CREBERlAND RD 10/03/97 573 RES $18,500 $6,200 33.51 MCFARLANE SHEKA J 191 23 1.41 626 00434 ST KilT'S llC 207 KITT'S DRIVE 02/07/97 548 RES $58,900 $22,800 38.71 MCGAHEE ANNEE A 030 o 242 03 0 L 4/A 88 01843 LANE ANN R 1 2602 WOODBlFF CIR OS/22/97 567 RES $129,900 $49,200 37.88 MCGAHEE EDNA R 018 0 302 00 0 BL B 1867 01876 PADGETT MILDRED M 21 BIRNAM Pl 08/26/97 568 RES $55,000 $20,000 36.36 MCGAHEE MANUELA 057 3 210 Bl B 0.16 520 02974 TREASTER FREDERICK N/BETH B 3118 HOLLY HAVEN DR 12/17/97 580 RES $117,000 $43,200 36.92 MCGARRA!I PAMELA D/MARK D 170 111 2149 41. . . . . . . . . . . o . . . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 87 S..ple Seller Land Diat, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 00780 HARRISON BONNIE W/WILLIAMS R 324 SIMS AVE 04/01/97 553 RES $20,000 $5,800 29.00 MCGEE ROBERT LAMAR 87 3 62 713 00183 LYON VIRGINIA J/ET AL 2275 WRIGHTSOBOR RD 01/31/97 547 COM $60,000 $24,600 41.00 MCGINLEY KAREN E 44 3 110 1060 02340 KANE JOHN F 2115 BALFOUR DR 10/07/97 574 RES $52,900 $23,000 43.48 MCGOWEN PAMELA l 676 02787 JUTCO INC 1723 HARROGATE DR 12/04/97 578 RES $90,400 $32,400 35.84 MCHENRY BERLYN L 198 389 L 22 BL D PH 1 1762 02808 WOODALL GEORGIA L 1828 COVINGTON DR 05/07/97 557 RES $63,900 $26,600 41.63 MCINTOSH ANGIE 0 170 0 162 00 0 L 52/0 SEC V 954 02819 WATSON MITCHELL HM BlDRS INC 112" FOX DEN RD 05/13/97 557 RES $137,600 $55,200 40.12 MCINTOSH MOSES L 6/B 1334 03048 VARNADO SOLOMON G 3601 JONATHAN CIR 10/31/97 575 RES $45,000 $17 ,040 37.87 MCKIE JOSHUA N 123 3 127 L I5/Bl G/SEC IV 1660 00755 WATTS ROBERT/MARY 0 1539 KERON WAY 04/10/97 554 RES $69,900 $23,400 33.48 MCKIE LEON/JESSIE C 336 129 L 21-23 BL B 1014 00374 KELLER JEFF 2511 IVEY ROAD 03/07/97 550 RES $39,900 $11,640 29.17 MCKINNEY BETTY J 086 3 036 L 8 W C IVEY SID 2264 01983 BANKS JAMES H/MARTHA C 73 MONTE BELLO LN 08/25/97 569 RES $54,500 $21,600 39.63 MCKINZIE JENNIFER S 016 2 171 00 0 L 1 Bl G 7 00436 PERRY MARY JOHNSON 2637 WALTON WAY 02/10/97 548 RES $422,000 $166,360 39.42 MCKNIGHT GEORGE LOCKE 34 4/45 226 02535 J F J ENTERPRISES INC 2220 TRAVIS RD 11/17/97 576 RES $79,900 $30,840 38.60 MCLEMORE ROOSEVELT 2144 02511 WOLF RALPH J 3324 THREAD NEEDLE RD W 08/25/97 577 RES $95,700 $40,000 41.80 MCLENDON HENRY D/SHIRlEY B 10 4 39 L 6 BL B SEC III 625 00404 STEVES SCOTT A/M GAIL 2206 GARDNER ST 01/31/97 547 RES $259,000 $82,240 31.75 MCLENDON PHILIP L 1764 00459 YOUNG DIANAR- --- - 3919 OLD TRAIL RD 01/21/97 548 RES $63,000 $26,000 41.27 MCLEOD BETTY J JACKSON 15 0 13 l 22/BL V 726 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 88 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Alllount Ratio 00770 PROCTER & GAMBLE CO A OH CORP 540 FOlKSTONE CIRCLE 03/31/97 553 RES $125,000 $49,600 39.68 MCLEOD ELIZABETH A 11 3 259 l 12 Bl B 435 01665 NORDAHL HOMES INC 3309 COBLESTONE COURT 08/01/97 565 RES $78,900 $31,400 39.80 MCLEOD STEFAN T 132 507 l 7A 2152 01332 FAMBROUGH J HOWARD 3507 KINGLING DR 06/06/97 560 RES $58,900 $20,240 34.36 MCMIllAN NATHANIEL MIROSA l 108 o 423 l 39 Bl A SEC 2 420 02023 DENT BRYAN A 2902 PLEASANT ~T 08/29/97 570 RES $82,000 $32,000 39.02 MCMILlAND TIMOTHY B/SUSAN R 10 252 686 01922 LUGO ROSAlY JR ET Al 1269 ALDEN DR 08/28/97 568 RES $106,450 $41,600 39.08 MCNAIR JAMES R IIIANGELA R 323 0 055 00 0 L 51 PH II 1840 30016 3510 WALTON WAY COM $613,380 $251,440 40.99 MCNAIR JEPTHA I JR/WILlIAM F 23 20 0.88 Appraisal 00388 REESE &HYLLIS A 802 HICKMAN ROAD 02/28/97 550 RES $130,000 $38,200 29.38 MCNAIR LINDA FAYE 035 3 312 2253 00562 POWERS BARBARA G 523 TUBMAN ST 03/18/97 551 RES $40,000 $15,760 39.40 MCNAIR lINDA FAYE/WILSON PARI 35 1 219 L 24 1389 01623 LEISURE HOMES INC 321 ALEX LANE 07/31/97 565 RES $87,500 $30,200 34.51 MCNEil PETRA 12 2 18 L 11 1168 02068 TURNER EllISON C/JOHANNA E 1321 WINGFIELD ST 09/12/97 570 RES $144,900 $55,560 38.34 MEADOR DIANNE A/WELLNITZ WM R 44 4 026 L 20/21/Bl 29 2404 00455 GEORGIA-LING TRUCK SALES INC HWY 56 02/06/97 548 COM $105,000 $12,000 11.43 MECHANICAL MAINTENANCE INC 184/82 2 PT l 21 658 00919 G M ASSOCIATES 804 SCOTT NIXON MEMORIAL 04/30/97 556 COM $1,000,000 $555,080 55.51 MEDAC INC 22 0 74 3.35 728 01081 LOGUE TAZEWELl JIMERRITT JULI 1713 OAK DRIVE OS/29/97 558 RES $66,000 $27,200 41.21 MEDDERS NELL JIWENDY M 57 2 197 l 45/46/47/BL C 2153 01428 KINNEY WARREN EIVIRGINIA A 1703 SANDALWOOD DRIVE 07/01/97 562 RES $59,500 $24,000 40.34 MEDINA DIANA 0 54 2 48 l 14 Bl H 875 02070 RANCO ANTHONY FIBLANCHE 1029 TURTLE CREEK 09/16/97 570 RES $62,000 $24,200 39.03 MEIGS MARY E 007 3 051 00 0 2357 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 89 Sample Seller Land Dlst, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SlB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 02324 JACKSON SHERI W 224U OVERLOOK RD 10/28/97 574 RES $83,000 $28,880 34.80 MELCHERT DAVID H/MOLlIE C L 5 Bl E 1342 01093 COLE SAMUEl I 2623 BILLINGS RD 05/30/97 559 RES $58,362 $25,600 43.86 MENTIS ANTONIO 130 0 278 00 0 L 12/S SEC 2B PH I 80 02650 MOONEY DAVID W 2618 ANDORRA DR 10/31/97 575 RES $63,500 $25,760 40.57 MERCADO-SANCHEZ SAMUEL/JUANIT 141 o 256 L 9 BL G 469 01159 VINTSON CONST CO INC 309 CHATHAM RD. 12/11/97 579 RES $109,700 $41,200 37.56 MERCER FRANCES B 16 2 246 l 14 631 01387 VASKO TRUMAN/KATHERINE K 2503 CARRIAGE CREEK 06/17/97 560 RES $94,500 $38,200 40.42 MERCHANT HUBERT W 13 1 107 L 2 Bl C 1888 01066 CROCKETT JAMES H III 1212-1214 BROAD ST ET AL OS/29/97 558 COM $64,000 $24,640 38.50 MERRY WILLIAM B 1920 02661 JONES JEFFREY lllORI A 1865 ENGLE CT 12/31/97 582 RES $55,000 $22,600 41.09 MESSIER SHIRLEY A 170 112 l 18 BL 0 SEC IVA 2294 00893 DRAGON TREE PROPS INC 2303 CANBERRA CT 04/30/97 556 RES $44,900 $17 ,200 38.31 MIDDLETON JACK 0 JR 82 277 L llQ 116 00034 WOODS FRANCES P U 222 TUBMAN HOME RD 01/08/97 545 RES $50,000 $17,400 34.80 MIKE TRANSMISSION INC/ET Al 086 4 116 00 0 L B 247 00082 VARMA JAYDEV R/LILAVAIT J 406 SCOTTS WAY 01/15/97 545 RES $214,900 $85,960 40.00 MILAN GIUlIANA G 23/53 L 17 18 BLK H 2311 00885 SPARGUE JONATHAN P/ADELHEID TR8 SMITH RD DEANS BRIDE 04/03/97 554 RES $9,500 $3,160 33.26 MIllER CHARITY M 244 0 038 0.66 759 00494 GAlAMB EDWARD C/DAVIS JACK R WINDSOR SPRING RD EXT 02/14/97 548 RES $43,500 $19,280 44.32 MILLER GERALD L 249 39 12/13/14/15 9.65 1825 00522 GOSSETT HARRY KENNETH 114 WARREN RD 02/20/97 549 RES $45,000 $17,160 38.13 MILLER JEFFREY A 11 o 127 682 01489 WASHINGTON ROAD DEVELOPERS LL 206 CHARLESTOWNE WAY 07/07/97 563 RES $62,900 $25,000 39.75 MILLER KATIE MAE/DOCKAL HARVE l 3 BL B 16 00472 MORGAN ANDREW DALE/TIMMIE LYN 17 4168 KEVIN RD 02/07/97 548 RES $76,900 $25,200 32.77 MILLER LACHERYl ~ M 53 P 161 BL B 1216 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 90 Sample Seller Land Dist, land lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SlB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 02524 FITZGERALD BOBBIE 4001 GOSHEN lAKE DRIVE N 11/17/97 577 RES $125,000 $51,800 41.44 MILLER RODGER A/CAROLE 198 0 010 48 0 57 02909 LINDER CHARLES W 2613 BELLEVUE AVE 12/17/97 580 RES $149,000 $48,680 32.67 MILLER VIRGINIA l 0343106070 19 01688 RICHARD BIRD BUILDERS INC 2312 PEROT DR 08/01/97 566 RES $89,900 $38,400 42.71 MIllER WILLIE G 1770 042 L 20 BL J 257 00540 SMITH MARTHA 0 2028 COOK RD 02/27/97 549 RES $42,500 $10,960 25.79 MIMS CHARLIE 071 2 274 00 0 1487 01829 YEATER DENISE H 08/19/97 567 RES $45,000 $8,200 18.22 MIMS ROBERT/MARY 168 2 2 5.14 1486 02265 STANLEY WILHELMINA 3103 EAGLE ROCK RD 09/29/97. K072 RES $81,900 $32,440 39.61 MIMS SYLVESTER/BESSIE M 55 2 3 l 16 Bl C SECT II 1216 02283 JACK R NORDAHL BUILDERS INC 3335 SADDLEBROOK DR 09/29/97 572 RES $67,500 $26,800 39.70 MIMS WALTER J/ANITA 0 129 0 687 00 0 L 7 Bl J PH 5 843 01732 JOHN C WEAVER HOMEBUIlDERS IN 1434 4642 STOREY MILL RD 08/08/97 566 RES $94,500 $34,120 36.11 MIRACLE GARY D/KIMBERlY A 272 0 133 00 0 L 9 1770 02229 HOUSEHOLD REALTY CORP 2405 RUBY DR 08/25/97 572 RES $32,000 $15,040 47.00 MITCHELL BLANCHE T 97 2 31 L 12 BL Q 1997 00468 STOUT MERELl L JR/BARRY L 3403 WALTON WAY 02/14/97 548 RES $557,500 $153,040 27.45 MITCHELL CRAIG S/LISA L 32 11 1087 02866 HARRIS BETTY COX 3526 REDO DR 08/04/97 567 RES $48,900 $16,760 34.27 MITCHELL FREDDIE V 120 105 l 9/BL F/SEC II 1308 02878 BECKUM LARRY llMARTHA M 2924 BElWOOD DR 05/07/97 557 RES $79,000 $26,200 33.16 MITCHEll JAMES G JR 039 0 111 l 12/Bl B 173 01902 FRONT lINE HOMES 20 2618 SPIRIT CREEK RD 08/25/97 568 RES $84,900 $32,800 38.63 MITCHEll RONALD 0 BL A PH I 1402 00779 W S HARRIS & ASSOCIATES INC 4110 BIG OAK DRIVE 03/31/97 553 RES $139,900 $55,200 39.46 MITCHELL YULE T/BEVERlY W 196 0 090 l 13 BIG OAK SID 888 01934 JAMES ANN W 1434 GMD FULCHER ROAB 08/01/97 568 AGR $18,000 $8,000 44.44 MITCHUM CHRISTIN lANE 270 30 2 TRACT 2 4.00 2096 . . . . . . . . . . . u . . . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 91 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Allount Ratio 00860 JAEMS ANN W/ET Al TR 1 04/03/97 553 AGR $18,000 $8,000 44.44 MITCHUM MICHAEL A/PAMELA A 2351 00114 PEACH WILLIAM FLOYD 1911 PRESTON DR 01/22/97 546 RES $65,000 $26,000 40.00 MOILES MELONY M 123 3 039 1280 01464 FREEMAN DOROTHY S 2130 WALTON WAY 06/30/97 562 RES $265,000 $98,640 37.22 MOLINARO JOHN R MAP 34-4 PARCEL 132 1893 02079 KOEPPEL ROBERT C 3214 RICHMOND HILL RD 09/19/97 571 RES $54,900 $27,280 49.69 MOLLEY DONALD F/WIlMA L 121 1 009 L 8 30 01956 HAYMAN JOY E 1337 WINGFIELD ST 09/02/97 569 RES $143,900 $53,280 37.03 MONDY JOSEPH SHEPPARD III 44 4 22 660 01123 FRONT-lINE HOMES INC 1110 WALTONS TRAIL 06/25/97 561 RES $112,900 $45,600 40.39 MONTAGUE JESSE J/JANICE J 178 0 057 L 15/Bl A/PH 2 1786 01873 NORDAHL HOMES INC 3444 MONTE CARLO DR 08/20/97 568 RES $68,900 $29,200 42.38 MONTANTE RUSSEll T JRIMICHELL L 4 BL B 495 01762 INDUSTRIAL DEV ASSOC ETC 08/06/97 567 COM $70,000 $20,000 28.57 MONUMENT lEASING CORP Fl CORP 134 2 99 1 134 1 99 2.00 154 01897 ZEIT STEVEN H 1983 HIGDON ST 07/18/97 568 RES $52,900 $20,560 38.87 MOODY CYNTHIA MARIA 98 4 86 1293 02174 RUPP NED T/CHARLENE 2256 OVERTON RD 10/17/97 573 RES $147,500 $50,000 33.90 MOODY KENNETH J/CATHERINE F 26 3 18 L 20 J 1563 02248 RICHMOND BUILDERS INC 3109 CONNER COURT 10/07/97 572 RES $71,900 $28,000 38.94 MOODY TIMOTHY C 085 2 182 00 0 L 28A 1587 01269 WEIS STEVEN C/OK CHA 3422 STONEY BROOK RD OS/29/97 559 RES $79,900 $33,200 41.55 MOORE BILLY J SR 132 0 478 L 14 Bl P SEV IV 943 02579 BRUKER COMPANY 309 ALEX lANE 10/31/97 576 RES $79,900 $29,800 37.30 MOORE C MELISSA MAP 12 2 PARCEL 024 L17 850 02090 MERCER FRANCES B 2204 CADDEN RD 09/11/97 571 RES $76,900 $30,280 39.38 MOORE DEBORAH L 400 02346 FRONT LINE HOMES 1411 BROOKSTONE 10/24/97 574 RES $78,300 $31,600 40.36 MOORE JAMES A 629 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 92 Sample Seller land Dist, land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SlB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 00212 DEKALB PATSY G 3 4115 WINDSOR SPRING 02/28/97 550 RES $68,500 $30,880 45.08 MOORE JAMES R M 153 0 049 L B 39 02427 NORDAHL HOMES INC 3822 DORSET STREET 07/25/97 565 RES $129,900 $45,000 34.64 MOORE JERRY NOT AVAILABLE L 9-14 182 02277 HODGE JEOME OISUK CHA 2905 GEBHART DR 09/30/97 572 RES $65,900 $24,200 36.72 MOORE JOEL SR/VIRIGNIA 119 o 563 00 0 l 18 BlK I SEC I 897 01979 ASKIN ENTERPRISES lTD CO 90 05/16/97 568 AGR $15,900 $8,000 50.31 MOORE KEVIN/HALLMAN LISA 304 21 l 4 1.87 2354 01196 SHEVITZ STEWART A 519 FOLKSTONE CIR 12/12/97 579 RES $138,000 $54,400 39.42 MOORE MARTHA W 011 3 290 00 0 L 8/C 1710 00304 NORDAHL HOMES INC 2037 COUNTRY PLACE DRIVE 02/28/97 550 RES $122,900 $49,200 40.03 MOORE RANDY l/GEORGIA l 184 0 o 202 L 4 Bl E PHASE IV 2330 01628 LIFSEY GROUP 4515 RIDGE RUN DR 07/31/97 565 RES $135,900 $52,400 38.56 MOORE RUDOLPH P SR/EVERLEE B 140 o 778 00 0 L 18 Bl o SECT I 1274 02736 HILLIS WILBUR C JR 2401 MIKEY CT 09/29/97 578 RES $44,100 $19,040 43.17 MOORE SOPHIA 153 333 l 14 Bl U SEC VI A 296 01642 WASHINGTON RD DEV LLC 204 CHARlESTOWNE WAY 07/30/97 565 RES $62,900 $25,000 39.75 MOORE THAD THOMAS 011 0 222 00 0 2B 1502 00640 WILLIAMS SIDNEY/SOLOMON G 30 3627 COLUMBINE DRIVE 04/29/97 555 RES $39,000 $18,920 48.51 MOORE WALTER JR L 0 2009 02853 FITE MARY MIXON 1616 PARNEll ST ET AL 05/16/97 558 COM $205,000 $81,200 39.61 MOORE WALTER JR 045 2 230 00 0 ET AL 227 03029 CONNELL JOHNNIE H 7 1933 HECKLE ST 11/03/97 576 RES $35,000 $18,200 52.00 MORANT DONALD R M 035 3 283 BL F 263 02020 FAR FOUR W NEIL ONE SEVENTH ST UN 1005 09/12/97 570 RES $125,450 $42,640 33.99 MORATES ROBERT T/lUTRICK 0 S 037 3 210 05 0 801 00039 BROOME MARION E 2212 BUCKINGHAM DR 01/09/97 545 RES $59,900 $21,520 35.93 MORGAN WILLIAM REGER III 121 3 155 00 0 l23A 720 02006 ASKIN ENTERPRISES lTD CO 86 MCNUTT ACRES 09/11/97 570 RES $6,500 $4,000 61.54 MORRIS BRIAN K 305 8 L17 0.75 264 . . . . . . . . . . . l I 4 I o . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 93 Sample Seller Land Diet, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 01518 PORTWOOD MARY E SR 88 08/25/97 563 RES $22,000 $8,440 38.36 MORRIS EUGENE 0 OUT OF M 266 OP 003 1.72 877 01915 COOPER CLIFFORD E/JOAN M 256 LAFAYETTE DR 08/28/97 588 RES $95,300 $45,800 48.06 MORRIS GAY L 18 377 L 6 BL A 1773 00810 HIGHSMITH AUBREY J/ANDREA B 1958 MCDOWELL STREET 03/28/97 553 RES $78,900 $27,840 36.20 MORRIS SUSAN E 045 1 353 00 0 L 113 753 01609 MIZE JAMES W/HYANG J 2526 CORSSCREEK RD 07/25/97 565 RES $60,000 $22,800 38.00 MOSELEY CECIL 0 813 00983 ISAAC ALBERT/LUVENIA A 3526 PRIMROSE DR 04/29197 558 RES $51,013 $19,640 38.50 MOSES ANTHONY J 08 0 259 00 00 L 24B 2148 00883 lINDSEY STEPHEN L/CARRIE J 2738 ANGLER DR WEST 03/28/97 554 RES $58,500 $19,720 33.71 MOSES lATONIA F 120 0 372 L 15 BL 0 773 01483 COLLINS ARTHUR M/BARBARA C 3338 WEOGEWOOD DR 07/03/97 582 RES $62,000 $25,080 40.45 MOSUCH WILLIAM N/SUSAN 0 41 2 122 2198 02793 DUNAGAN DAVID A 2044 ELLIS ST 12/03/97 578 RES $37,000 $15,000 40.54 MOTTO JOSEPH G/DElORA S 35 1 27 L 9 BL F 2179 02696 NORDAHL HOMES INC 3446 MONTE CARLO DR 12/31/97 581 RES $68,900 $28,000 40.64 MOULTON STEVE A 143 767 L 3 Bl B 1308 01425 GILL SHEILA A 3 4095 OLD WAYNESBORO RD 06/27/97 562 RES $65,500 $27,600 42.14 MOUNTAIN CRAIG E 213 0 079 00 0 846 01398 MOSS ANNE HEATH 214 AVONDALE DR 06/17/97 560 RES $88,500 $37,200 42.03 MUIR MARY V 017 1 170 00 0 L 38 Bl l SEC IV 2377 01961 MEADOR DIANNE A 1015 MAGNOLIA DR 08/29/97 569 RES $84,900 $35,600 41.93 MULDER DAVID W/lINDA W 019 2 005 774 01980 PENCE SUSAN R/BETH 1418 TROUPE ST 08/27/97 568 RES $75,900 $26,080 34.36 MULHERIN BARBARA M 44 4 234 01 L C PAR B 2370 02873 POJE CHRISTOPHER B 2909 SUSSEX RD 05/07/97 557 RES $123,000 $47,400 38.54 MULHERIN JOHN G/DEBORAH C 18 3 98 117 01386 WIDENER GAIL M 17 309 SANDY RUN CT 08/16/97 560 RES $120,350 $48,000 39.88 MULLIS SIDNEY/VIRGINIA 10 4 18 Bl A 1876 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 94 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 00624 DEWITT EDWIN 0 JR 17 810 MITCHELL ST 04/25/97 555 RES $61,900 $24,800 40.06 MUNSON NATHAN BENJAMIN 007 0 176 00 0 L F 1538 01046 HIXON DONALD G 3 3422 SUTTON PLACE OS/22/97 558 RES $83,900 $33,440 39.86 MURDAUGH MILES E 132 2 176 Bl 0 1132 00131 GEORGE ALEC H/JUNE A 2613 TOBACCO RD 01/17/97 546 COM $135,000 $54,360 40.27 MURPHEY WIllARD A/ANITA B 141 o 314 00 0 1862 01351 DOSS W TRAVIS JR/KATHARINE C 1706 KING WOODS DR OS/29/97 560 RES $71,500 $29,520 41.29 MURPHY THOMAS P 57 2 210 l 5/6/7 BL C 836 01445 NORDAHL HOMES INC 2015 EWART COURT 06/30/97 562 RES $67,900 $26,400 38.88 MURRAY DOUGLAS 130 0 776 L 8 1212 00003 TURNER J E/S S 1345 WATERS EDGE DR 01/03/97 544 RES $72,500 $28,000 38.62 MURRAY ESTHER B 036 2 059 00 0 1140 00764 WHATLEY WILLIAM l 1366 1/2 DEWITT ST 04/15/97 554 RES $10,000 $4,400 44.00 MURRAY EUlA B 58 4 306 1063 01652 BLITCH PIERCE GIll 3 504 REGENT PLACE 08/01/97 565 RES $425,000 $131,600 30.96 MURRAY JOHN L III 24 1 44 l B 1745 01128 HUFF KENNETH DEAN 4965 FULCHER ROAD 06/20/97 561 RES $69,900 $27,640 39.54 MURRAY MARY ANN R 347 o 008 1.38 1964 02921 BEASLEY DALE W 2000 GARDNER ST 12/19/97 580 RES $29,900 $12,240 40.94 MURRAY WIllIAM 35 1 322 758 03014 SRIDHARAN MARANDAPAllI R/VIDY 9 3411 SASANGUA DR 11/05/97 576 RES $146,000 $56,000 38.36 MURRY OWEN J/BETTY L M 031 2 P 028 BL C 252 02864 MONK ROBERT 3417 CANNOGATE DR 12/18/97 584 RES $58,600 $22,800 38.91 MUSTIN JULIE E 010 0 161 00 0 1032 02889 BROWN BURL VANNOY/MARGARET P 15 2524 PATE AVE 04/18/97 557 RES $92,000 $36,200 39.35 MUTCH WILL JR M 097 2 P 109 Bl B 496 02268 FOGLE DAVID J 1646 WHITNEY STREET 09/30/97 572 RES $54,900 $19,800 36.07 MYERS AlISHA C/FlORENCE CS 044 3 161 1289 00230 WELLS JEANNETTE C 2827 GLENN HIllS CIRCLE 03/20/97 552 RES $55,000 $22,160 40.29 MYERS DANA D/DANYElL L MAP 84 3 PARCEL 178 l 14 Bl B S C V 624 u . . . . . . . . . . o . . . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 95 SBlIple Seller land D1st, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Dig8S t Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 02989 WASHINGTON RD DEVELOPERS lLC 37 CHARLESTOWNE DR 12/29/97 581 RES $66,500 $20,200 30.38 MYERS JIMMY L/JEANETTE E 011 o 222 01 0 l 52 143 02763 WASHINGTON ROAD DEVELOPERS II 8 CHARLESTOWNE DR 11/26/97 578 RES $63,200 $25,000 39.56 MYERS KATHERINE ANNE 011 o 222 01 0 l 4 BL A 1166 00665 o & H DEVELOPMENT INC 254 HUDSON TRACE 04/18/97 554 RES $86,900 $34,600 39.82 MYERS LETICIA SHAWN L 47 HUDSON TRACE 2132 02778 ATHENS PROPERTIES INC 4313 CREEKVIEW.DR 11/24/97 578 RES $113,900 $45,200 39.68 MYERS MARION M 140 438 L 25 BL C SEC III 1440 01470 JONES ROSS C/CHRISTY M 3109 RAMSGATE ROAD 06/30/97 562 RES $97,800 $38,000 38.85 MYERS MICHAEL D MAP 17 4 PARCEL 27 l 17 BL S SE II-A 1858 01957 CORNETTE SCOTT S 2450 YOUNG DR 09/03/97 569 RES $38,500 $15,960 41.45 MYERS STANLEY AllEN 97 3 141 670 01948 BRUKER CO THE 319 ALEX LN 09/02/97 569 RES $78,495 $29,800 37.98 NAIL BRENT l/MARY lYNN 12 2 19 l 12 1077 02125 LIVEL Y C MILNER 1014 HUNTE~S GLEN 09/26/97 571 RES $134,900 $46,800 34.69 NAPPER-REED STACEY E 178 0 049 00 0 l 7/A 1300 . 00744 BASSINGER JEFFERY M 1836 FORMOSA. DRIVE 04/10/97 554 RES $55,400 $21,520 38.84 NARVARTE JOSEPH M 122 3 149 L 26 BL C 1988 01659 HERBERT HOMES INC 19 PARK PLACE CIR 07/17/97 565 RES $200,000 $89,600 44.80 NATHANSON JONNG SOON 23 283 l 3 BL B 2080 00192 WASHINGTON DEBBIE M 35 2516 CASTLEWOOD DR 01/24/97 547 RES $76,500 $33,600 43.92 NAVARRE SAMUEL PIDENDINGER SH 013 0 034 00 0 BLK A 1089 00076 GORDON WILLIAM NATHAN 7N09 SUMESET WAY 01/21/97 545 RES $235,000 $71,600 30.47 NEAL L E JR 24 0 217 L 21A 2092 02684 PRICE SILLY R 3307 FOREST EST DR 12/31/97 581 RES $73,500 $27,600 37.55 NEAL PHILLIP W III/CINDI G 054 2 018 00 0 1859 01044 o l H DEVELOPMENT INC 261 HUDSON TRACE OS/23/97 558 RES $96,000 $37,800 39.38 NEELY TRACEY L 10 1102 00544 KAPLAN AARON - --- ------- 3660 MADRID DR 02/15/97 549 RES $39,900 $20,840 52.23 NELSON VERNAL 1559 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 96 Sample Seller land Dist, land lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SlB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 00730 RONEY SUSAN/SAMUEL G IV 1900 PENNYSLVANIA AVENUE 04/04/97 554 RES $58,900 $23,240 39.46 NESBITT CHRISTOPHER/STEPHANIE MAP 34 4 PARCEL 157 l 24 BL H 1582 01900 PHILLIPS CHARLES D 2972 SHELBY DR 08/28/97 568 RES $55,000 $22,520 40.95 NETTLES AMBER P 109 1 008 00 0 L 7 Bl C 1324 01976 lAVINE MICHAL 2411 PERSIMMON RD 09/02/97 568 RES $69,900 $27,200 38.91 NEVIllE KRISTIN M 19 2 88 2358 00028 SPIVEY TOBIN W 2409 PONDEROSA DR 01/06/97 545 RES $68,000 $26,800 39.41 NEWMAN RONALD E SR/SANDRA T 014 3 008 00 0 23A 72 03016 YARBROUGH JOANNE MARTHA ET Al 2054 FERNWOOD CIR 11/07/97 576 RES $63,000 $24,400 38.73 NEWSOME LINDA W 110 1 151 l 14/BL D/SEC III 279 00417 ST KITT'S INC 214 KITT'S DRIVE 01/28/97 547 RES $59,200 $22,800 38.51 NEWTON MELANIE DAWN 030 0 242 03 0 L 24/F 2125 02620 PHIllIPS ROBERT E 4606 DUNBAR TON RD 10/31/97 575 RES $51,900 $20,600 39.69 NGUYEN DIEP N 272 o 052 000 1328 01744 MARTIN JACK A/VIVIAN G 3250 SUMMERCHASE CIR 08/08/97 566 RES $85,250 $34,880 40.91 NGUYEN TAO 0424 146 00 0 L 25 2003 01890 o & H DEVELOPMENT INC 253 HUDSON TRACE 08/28/97 568 RES $89,900 $34,200 38.04 NICE EDWARD J 12 1 53 L 6 1035 01645 ALSTON REGINALD J 1017 DUGAS STREET 07/10/97 565 RES $4,200 $1,560 37.14 NICHOLSON WILLIAM C 046 4 307 1649 00119 SHUBERT JOHNNIE L JRIHYONG SI PEPPERDINE DR 01/24/97 546 RES $12,500 $2,920 23.36 NICKERSON MICHAEL 151 161 TR B 2.44 1565 00743 C M S GROUP INC 1229 ALDEN DRIVE 03/04/97 554 RES $20,900 $6,400 30.62 NICKS KEMITT C 323 0 045 L 41 lEWIS ACRES PH2 1944 00339 SHELTON MICHAEL C/PATRICIA M 3002 CARDINAL DR 03/17/97 551 RES $114,000 $40,360 35.40 NIELSEN DONALD/SUSAN l 43 1 132 1514 00424 ST KITT'S 210 KIlT'S DRIVE 01/31/97 547 RES $55,900 $22,800 40.79 NILENA A G 030 0 242 03 0 l 22/F 2193 00425 ST KITT'S 212 KITT'S DRIVE 01/31/97 547 RES $55,900 $28,800 51.52 NIlENA A G 030 o 242 03 0 l 23/F 2195 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 97 Sa..ple Seller Land Dist, Land lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SlB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ra tio 01182 KRIEGEL DAVID L/JUDITH l 3607 MONMOUTH RD 12/12/97 579 RES $50,000 $28,400 56.80 NORDAHL HOMES 1293 01153 MELLINGER NICK J 3413 HAETHER RD 12/05/97 579 RES $17,000 $7,440 43.76 NORDAHL TAMMY 32 3 20 327 00652 ETTER LEE FRANKLIN o /WILMA 0 2201 PEPPER lOGE DRIVE 03/19/97 553 RES $105,000 $42,400 40.38 NORRIS DORIS 143 0 508 L 12 BL 2 SEC 9 1874 01325 THOMPSON BRENDA K 2332 TRAVIS PINES DR 06/06/97 580 RES $45,000 $17,320 38.49 NORRIS JEFFREY B 154 0 137 142 02538 WASHINGTON ROAD DEVELOPERS Ll 212 CHARlESTOWNE WAY 11/12/97 576 RES $63,452 $23,400 36.88 NORRIS W ALAN OUT OF 011 0 222 01 0 l 6 BL B 2189 02612 VINTSON CONST CO INC 3 310 CHATHAM RD 09/12/97 570 RES $115,000 $40,000 34.78 NORSWORTHY JULIE ANNE 016 2 244 00 0 75 30008 DEANS BRIDGE RD COM $225,990 $65,800 29.12 NORTON FRANK 85 3 281 1.52 Appraisal 02682 GODOWN ANGELA BALL 3116 CHELSEA DR 11/26/97 577 RES $91,000 $35,600 39.12 NORWOOD JONATHAN W/LISA B 017 4 049 00 0 l 29 Bl S 2244 02119 GARRETT MARCIA RICHARDS 1009 MONTE SANO AVE 09/26/97 571 RES $138,000 $55,240 40.03 NOWELL AlETHIA E 34 3 37 0.36 920 00761 lOWE JENNIE POlVI 2228 WINSTON WAY APT 3 04/03/97 554 RES $37,630 $14,800 39.33 NUNALEY SONYA M MAP 131 0 PARCEL 281 BlDG Y PH EC 3 928 00984 YARID ABRAHAM G 1549 SOUTH ATL DR 04/25/97 556 RES $47,900 $18,640 38.91 NUNN DANIEL P 171 o 056 00 0 lOA 2151 02011 REDDY T R 08/29/97 570 COM $55,000 $29,240 53.16 NUT' N HONEY INC 30 101 2 TR B 0.56 360 02169 DUNN WILLIAM/JOHNNY 3215 AMANDA CIR 10/14/97 573 RES $6,000 $2,800 46.67 O'BRIAN AlFONZIA 94 418 1591 01544 DRIGGERS GREG L 2118 RICHARDS ROAD 07/11/97 563 RES $70,000 $27,000 38.57 O'BRYAN MICHAEL M/MARCI 098 3 157 00 0 2004 02026 BRUKER COMPANY 311 ALEX LANE 09/15/97 570 RES $79,900 $29,800 37.30 O'KEEFE KATHLEEN H 12 2 023 L16 743 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 98 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 02896 GENTRY H LEON 3903 UNION GROVE CIR 05/09/97 557 RES $20,500 $8,800 33.17 OAKLEY LEE 197 24 800 01872 NORDAHL HOMES INC 3301 COBlBESTONE CT 08/19/97 568 RES $76,950 $30,000 38.99 ODETTE ERIC VIKIRSTEN M 132/503 L 3 Bl A 483 01766 FULCHER BOBBY G SR 2014 BOYKIN RD 07/25/97 567 RES $30,000 $7,720 25.73 ODOM MONTY 188 0 017 11 0 4.34 241 00488 HOLLAWAY DWIGHT 1216 FUllER ST.EXT 02/18/97 548 RES $50,000 $22,040 44.08 ODOM ROOSEVELT 058 4 569 00 0 L 2 1785 02222 GROUP LIFESEY 2506BLOSSOM CT 10/07/97 572 RES $70,700 $25,200 35.64 ODOM SIDNEY H 0 2391 00985 GOODIN RUBY L 250 lINCOlTON PARKWAY 05/07/97 556 RES $74,900 $23,600 31.51 OELlERICH ARLENE K 153 0 061 00 0 L 13B 2165 01423 LANGSTON WIllIAM/JENNIFER KING WOODS 06/23/97 562 RES $69,900 $29,200 41.77 OETJEN JOSEPH A/DENNIS MELISS 57 4 15 l 82-6'l/PT 61 Bl B 827 02123 TYNES MARGARET SMITH 2427/2431 WHEELESS RD 09/23/97 571 COM $195,000 $80,240 41.15 OGLESBY RAYMOND B 1229 02457 WASHINGTON ROAD DEVELOPERS LL 216 CHARlESTOWNE WAY 10/30/97 574 RES $61,200 $25,000 40.85 OHLSON DOUGLAS B OUT OF 011 0 222 01 0 L 8 BL B 1988 02234 MOORE WALTER P/PENNY C 3718 RAINTREE DR 09/25/97 572 RES $67,210 $22,880 34.04 OKHUOMARIYI HELEN 153 385 L 13 BL.B 1946 02045 HELD MARGARET ANN 1014 RUSSELL ST 08/01/97 570 RES $67,200 $24,400 36.31 OLD ERIC/SUSAN 45 1 255 1649 01760 o l H DEV INC 304 ALCOCK WAY 08/14/97 567 RES $96,200 $39,800 41.37 OLDAKER PHYLLIS L 12 1 91 l 44 119 00802 SWANCEY JANIE lEE RUSSELL 1931 KISSINGBOWER RD 03/31/97 553 RES $55,000 $14,160 25.75 OLDHAM JIMMY L/MAMIE 14 15 16C 682 00328 FRONT LINE HOMES INC 2767 DAVIS MIll ROAD 03/12/97 551 RES $92,900 $36,800 39.61 OLDHAM MAURICE LIPAULETTE l 177 o 057 l 11 Bl K SEC II 1090 01303 KATCOFF I GARY/DEBRA B 310 SCOTTS WAY 06/06/97 559 RES $119,000 $48,400 40.87 OLDNETTLE CHRISTOPHER/HEATHER 023 0 067 00 0 L 30 Bl J SEC V- 1639 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 99 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 00668 FOLK TOMMIE N 2728 FAWN DRIVE 04/18/97 555 RES $63,900 $25,120 39.31 OLIVER ERIC A/TANGY A 120 0 419 L 7-C DEERWOOD FRST 126 02461 JACK NORDAHL BUILDERS 3512 SIDESADDLE CT 10/27/97 574 RES $72,900 $30,000 41.15 OLIVER RONALD 1908 02261 EALICK JOANNE CHEElEY 2202 ALBEMARLE DR 10/01/97 572 RES $89,250 $35,360 39.62 OLSON MATTHEW J/MELANIE M 132 0 177 L 1 BL C SECT 1 1270 00971 BRADLEY CHARLES ET AL 3423 KNOLLCRESr RD 05/06/97 556 RES $13,000 $4,200 32.31 OMAR ROBERT/JANE 119 0 266 00 0 1846 01054 FITZGERALD ROBERT E/LINDA W 2517 LYMAN ST 05/23/97 558 RES $34,900 $13,200 37.82 ORTIZ DENNIS J 097 1 135 00 0 L 44/46/47/48/49 A 1533 00279 LIVEL Y C MILNER 3107 OCEAN DRIVE 03/05/97 550 RES $101,900 $41,200 40.43 ORTIZ HECTOR LOUIS/BRENDA K 039 0 203 00 0 l 11 BL E 814 02766 WILSON PARIS/MCNAIR FAYE 2001 STARNES ST 12/03/97 578 RES $66,900 $19,640 29.36 ORZECHOWSKI PATRICIA/S A 35 3 52 1395 00916 BOND JOHN W 329 BERCKMAN RD 04/04/97 556 RES $123,000 $30,800 25.04 OSBON MICHAEL/REGINALD 019 0 043 00 0 1.55 656 01541 WELSH WILLIAM JOSEPH/TERESA 1215 JOHNS ROAD 07/15/97 563 RES $350,000 $146,680 41.91 OSBORNE ROBERT C JR/CAMILE S 044 1 157 00 0 1903 00282 HEALTH ADVANCE INC 502 MILLEDGE RD 02/28/97 550 RES $77,900 $25,600 32.86 OSTEEN GLENN/KIM 035 1 159 00 0 920 02326 HENDRICK ININA B 3527 STONEY BROOK RD 10/24/97 574 RES $83,900 $36,000 42.91 OTERO DAVID/WANDA I 132/339 L 11 Bl Q 1372 02150 l P B PROPERTIS INC ET AL 13 MACAULAY PLACE 09/26/97 571 RES $77,690 $33,400 42.99 OTT LAURIE J L 86 1825 00420 ST KilT'S INC 221 KITT'S DRIVE 01/30/97 547 RES $56,900 $22,800 40.07 OTT RUBY B 030 0 242 03 0 L 11/C 2151 00623 CENTER WEST SERVICES INC 2061 GREENLAND ROAD 04/23/97 555 RES $13,500 $5,080 37.63 OVERTON FRANK l 176 2 3 0.98 1510 02539 KASSNERnCHRISTOPHER ALAH-- 2513 ARGONNE DR 11/14/97 576 RES $37,000 $13,520 36.54 OVERTON LINDA 0 110 2 270 L 15 Bl 0 PINE HGTS 2057 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 100 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 02820 SCREWS ELOISE H 10 2417 DICKEY RD 03/25/97 557 RES $33,350 $13,320 39.94 OWENBY WORTH V III 085 1 195 00 0 BL J 1359 01058 DOXTATER ROBERT J/PEGGY ANN H 1950 SATCHER BLVD OS/23/97 558 RES $72,000 $29,120 40.44 OWENS EDDY 133 3 45 1712 01146 FLETCHER PAMELA R 9 DOMINION WAY 12/03/97 579 RES $61,900 $26,080 42.13 OWENS PAULA S 17 3 18 l 19/5EC 1 135 01508 HADDEN JOSEPH A/AMY M 15 2411 QUAIL COURT WEST 07/08/97 563 RES $13,000 $3,600 27.69 OWENS WILBER 166 54 L A 476 02882 STEEDLEY TIMOTHY F 840 HEARD AVE 05/08/97 557 RES $118,000 $31,800 26.95 PACKARD CHARELS E 35 3 349 542 02848 ROBBINS ANNIE L 2439 YATES DRIVE 05/16/97 557 RES $31,500 $12,280 38.98 PADGETT G~ORGE M II 098 4 166 00 0 l 9/C 2380 02178 ASKIN ENTERPRISES LTD CO 86 MCNETT AC 07/21/97 573 AGR $12,495 $4,000 32.01 PAIGE BENJAMIN F 281 125 l 121/BL A 0.51 1304 00362 ST KITTS lLC 227 KITTS DRIVE 03/27/97 552 RES $64,787 $22,800 35.19 PAINE BRIAN K OUT OF 030 0 242 03 0 L 14 BL 0 2360 02480 MCKIE SADIE 1913 VALLEY SPRING ROAD 11/25/97 577 RES $69,900 $27,800 39.77 PALMER JACQUELYN B 42 4 25 L 29 Bl C SEC 1 1869 01150 RICE AlLINE W 904 WINDSONG CIR 12/09/97 579 RES $42,500 $16,800 39.53 PALMER LAWRENCE E JR 006 0 312 191 02280 BUGGS KUM 0 2118 TROTTER WAY 09/30/97 572 RES $69,900 $27,200 38.91 PALMER MAE PEARL 868 01505 COWELL ROBERT M 18-A 2451 RIVERLOOK DRIVE 06/30/97 563 RES $68,500 $26,600 38.83 PAPE FERMAN P II/MARY E 014 12 060 00 0 L B 308 02323 GARDEN CITY HOMES INC 2928 ARROWWOOD CIRCLE 10/24/97 574 RES $127,900 $52,400 40.97 PARDUBSKY ANNA J/JEFFERY 0 139 399 L 146 Bl A PH II 1295 02651 BARRETT PATRICIA STRONG ONE SEVENTH ST 10/31/97 575 RES $184,500 $54,600 29.59 PARK PYUNG/CHRISTINA 037 3 214 03 0 481 02903 FUTRELlE FAMILY l P 512 SKYVIEW DR 12/15/97 579 COM $125,000 $59,680 47.74 PARK ROAD PROPERTIES INC 59 28 2048 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 101 Sa. pie Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 00766 GAY JACK N 952 HEARD AVE 04/11/97 554 RES $139,000 $53,360 38.39 PARlANTI llNDA J 45 1 031 1026 00226 HARRISON JESSIE M 03/03/97 550 RES $15,000 $6,080 40.53 PARNELL JASON MAP 176 PARCEL 14 01 3.04 1835 02796 HEATH CLEMENT E 2113 CIRCULAR DR 12/05/97 578 RES $70,800 $22,240 31.41 PARRIS NELSON J 98 3 118 PT L 64 2165 02010 PRICE CHARLES PRESTON 1044 WOODBERRY.DR 09/11/97 570 RES $86,825 $34,200 39.39 PARRISH ANTHONY R 214 57 L 4/Bl B 338 00955 RHODES MOLLY M 3320 OAVANT STREET 05/05/97 556 RES $52,000 $22,000 42.31 PARSLEY MATTHIAS JAMES/ROSE S 010 0 073000 L 6 BL A 1454 00072 JIM DAVIS CO INC 3105 CAWLEY COURT 01/20/97 545 RES $77,900 $30,800 39.54 PARSONS JANIS B 033 3 235 00 0 L 10 CAWLEY PLAC 2241 01315 JACKSON RONALD T/MAE G 1133 BROOKWOOD DR 05/30/97 559 RES $107,500 $40,600 37.77 PARSONS SAllY M 13 1 68 l 21 BL C SEC V 2087 01409 HARRIS IRVIN JR 3311 LONG CREEK lANE 06/30/97 562 RES $115,000 $40,800 35.48 PASCHAL MIKE/SONYA M 143 0 513 L 7 Bl 2 SEC 9 542 00836 SIPLE CHARLES B 2 3417 FOREST EST DR 03/28/97 553 RES $63,900 $24,800 38.81 PASTORIZA PHILIP/DIANE N M054 2 037 L J 1299 01384 NORDAHL HOMES INC 3462 MONTE CARLO DR 06/13/97 560 RES $70,600 $28,400 40.23 PATE CLIFFORD L 132 525 L 6 BL 0 1848 01802 CUll DEBORAH J MULHERIN 78/79/80 1727 KINGSWOOD DR 06/18/97 561 RES $71,900 $28,000 38.94 PATEl KRINNA 0 M 057 2 P 179 BL A 63 01734 JOHN C WEAVER HOMEBUILDERS IN 3054 GREY FOX DR 08/08/97 566 RES $115,900 $43,200 37.27 PATTERSON AUROA G/NORWOOD L 271 o 034 00 0 L23A 1788 00981 ERICKSON DAVID TODD 559 MARTIN lANE 04/29/97 556 RES $94,000 $37,000 39.36 PATTERSON BRYAN A/LISA A 25 3 101 L 10 BL C 2104 01775 GARRISON CUSTOM HOMES INC 41 2525 WINTERVILLE DR 08/14/97 567 RES $103,900 $42,600 41.00 PATTERSON OLA MAE 052 0 557 00 0 L J 569 02805 KELLER JEFF 2570 LINCOLNTON PKWY 05/12/97 557 RES $62,900 $23,440 37.27 PATTERSON ROBERT L/PATRICIA A 153 0 255 00 0 L 8/BL Q 942 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 102 Sample Seller land Dist, Land lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 01120 MCCARTHY HENRY P 4103 WANDERING WAY 04/30/97 561 RES $66,000 $27,440 41.58 PATTERSON SHAWN 167 562 L 15/Bl I/SEC 3/F 1565 01192 KINGSBURY CUSTOM HOMES INC 2714 CULVERTON DR 12/18/97 579 RES $111,470 $41,400 37.14 PAULING TAMMY S 52/649 L 7/BL B SEC 3A 1624 02449 STRICKLAND LISA A/EDWARD M 2218 BIRNAM PLACE 07/22/97 585 RES $59,000 $23,200 39.32 PAYNE STACY P/LARRY J MAP 57 3 PARCEL 188 L 2 BL B 611 02233 STOKES WILLIAM RONALD 3517 NORTH PINE DR 09/18/97 572 RES $70,900 $26,000 36.67 PAYTON CHRIS A 145 115 L 10 BL C SECT II 1937 02181 RASCAL ENTERPRISES INC 86 08/18/97 573 AGR $21,000 $8,160 38.86 PEACE ANNTIONETTE 222 54 l 41 4.09 1290 01185 BRINKMAN PAUL 500 SCOTTS WAY 12/11/97 579 RES $220,000 $86,400 39.27 PEACOCK MARK E/lYNN S 156 01481 WARD JAMES B 1750 KINGSWOOD DR 07/08/97 562 RES $71,680 $29,200 40.74 PEACOCK RONALD T 57 4 036 2137 01855 KENNETH SMITH BUILDERS 2107 GROUSE CT 08/18/97 568 RES $123,000 $50,800 41.30 PEACOCK WILLIAM/VANESSA 73 01179 ANDERSON FRANK W/MARTHA E 1913 KISSINGBOWER RO 12/03/97 579 COM $37,500 $5,240 13.97 PEARCE STEVE/CAMPBELL EDGAR 71 3 77 1230 02861 MATSON WERNER III/PAULA C 1132 BROOKWOOD DR 05/18/97 558 RES $98,900 $39,000 39.43 PEARSON DONALD EIPATRICIA A M 13 1 101 246 01212 DALY DOLORES M 2913 DEEB PLACE 06/27/97 562 RES $55,900 $21,920 39.21 PECK DONALD J 110 1 134 00 0 L 5 Bl F 33 01433 lEISURE HOMES INC 327 ALEX lANE 07/01/97 562 RES $76,400 $29,400 38.48 PECK MARY J MAP 12 2 PARCEL 15 l 8 TWNHMS 0 lEX 1045 00278 WALKER CHARLES/BIRD T/OWENS 0 620 CAMBRIDGE ROAD 03/19/97 552 RES $94,900 $36,180 38.10 PEEK RICHARD E 25 1 95 00 0 L 33-G 658 00508 CANALE ALEXANDER 0 2176 KINGS WAY 02/19/97 549 RES $97,700 $55,360 56.66 PEEL THOMAS E JR/SUSAN K 044 2 214 00 0 l 1 221 02086 BYNES JOHNNIE JR 6 3044 GRIGGS CT 09/15/97 570 RES $39,900 $12,840 32.18 PELZER GLADYS J/JONES lANIER M 084 4 P 041 Bl I 2217 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 103 Sample Seller land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 01180 BOND ANN G 1523 JOHNS RD 12/15/97 579 RES $35,000 $14,360 41.03 PENCE COMMUNICATIONS 44 3/235 l 25/PT L 14 Bl 37 1386 01181 BOND ANN G 1519 JOHNS RD 12/15/97 579 RES $35,000 $13,800 39.43 PENCE COMMUNICATIONS INC 44 3/237 L 27/BL 37 1387 02529 BARRENTINE MARY USRY 2126 ANSLEY PLACE WEST 11/14/97 576 RES $94,200 $38,000 40.34 PENCE COMMUNICATIONS INC 44 2 35 TRACT B 0.14 2305 00421 ST KITTS 208 KITT'S DRIVE 01/31/97 547 RES $59,600 $22,800 38.26 PENCILLE JOHN M 030 0 242 03 0 L 21/F 2163 02775 VERNON STEVEN L/CAROL B 5 509 ASHLAND DR 12/03/97 578 RES $120,000 $38,000 31.67 PENDER CARYL M 025 2 050 00 0 BL C 1326 02783 FACEY KENNETH B 2548 CENTRAL AVE 12/04/97 578 RES $155,000 $56,240 36.28 PENDLEY THOMAS L SR 44 1 214 l 2/3 Bl 7 1880 02065 KEY lADDIE C 1809 POWEll RD 09/16/97 570 RES $17,000 $4,200 24.71 PENLEY TOMASA W M 051 o 025 2210 00870 RASCAL ENTERPRISES INC 86 02/04/97 554 RES $8,500 $3,520 41.41 PENNEL JANICE C 222 36 l 9 SECT I 0.55 166 01162 WILLIAMS C MURRAY 3437 HEATHER DR 12/10/97 579 RES $129,900 $38,640 29.75 PENNINGTON PATRICIA A 32 3 032 l 13/Bl B/SEC 2 719 00532 NORDAHL HOMES INC 3021 MIRANDA RD 02/21/97 549 RES $83,096 $33,600 40.44 PENNY ROLAND R/BRIANA L 143 0 535 00 0 l 30-10 1074 00599 ST KITT'S LLC 218 KITT'S DRIVE 02/27/97 549 RES $59,100 $22,800 38.58 PENNY TRACY lYNN 030 0 242 03 0 l 26/G 2025 00805 FRANKLIN 0 ETTERLE CONST CO 3006 YELLOWOOD COURT 03/31/97 553 RES $137,900 $53,600 38.87 PEOPLES JAMES L 139 379 l 126 BL A PH II 619 02591 KENNETH SMITH HOMEBUILDERS 2777 SPIRIT CREEK 11/05/97 576 RES $141,000 $58,000 41.13 PEOPLES WILLIE C JR/JACKIE 447 01137 WASHINGTON ROAD DEVELOPERS 228 CHARLESTOWNE WAY 12/09/97 578 RES $62,900 $25,000 39.75 PERKINS UlDINE N 011 o 222 01 0 L 14/B 2418 02923 SIMOWITZ . SUSAN- 1017 STEVENS CRK RD ET Al 12/02/97 580 RES $27,325 $13,120 48.01 PERRY l SONS lLC 12 0 186 301 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 104 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 00220 KUHLKE WILLIAM BIll/DIANNE 0 3037 FOX SPRING ROAD 03/26/97 552 RES $132,000 $53,840 40.79 PERRY JOHN 0 JR/MARY G 033 3 203 00 0 1327 00527 SMITH T SCOTT 42 CONIFER CIR 02/21/97 549 RES $249,000 $107,600 43.21 PERRY MARY J 023 0 222 00 0 793 - 02027 FORRESTER JOHN/CHARLOTTE 404 CHATHAM COURT 09/15/97 570 RES $83,000 $29,480 35.52 PETERSON GARY R 11 0 091 72 UN 404 754 02840 BROWN COLLEEN 0 142 GARDNERS MILL RD 05/16/97 557 RES $82,000 $33,200 40.49 PETTY NICHOLAS M 11 3 255 2187 02414 FORD HELEN T 517 FOLKSTONE CIRCLE 07/28/97 564 RES $132,000 $52,400 39.70 PHELPS DAISY A/BRUCE BETTY P 011 3 289 00 0 L 7 Bl C 2214 00141 JACK R NORDAHL BUILDERS INC 1007 WAllIE COURT 01/24/97 546 RES $73,900 $29,200 39.51 PHILPOT VERDERE 154 o 332 L 14 BlK B 774 00432 ST KITT'S LLC 215 KITT'S DRIVE 02/10/97 547 RES $58,900 $22,800 38.71 PICKELSIMER FRANK E/lAURA E 030 242 03 0 l 8/B 2374 02148 HORNBROOK MARICA J 1138 BROOKWOOD DR 09/26/97 571 RES $98,000 $36,600 37.35 PICKLESIMER KRISTINE O/RAYMON 13 1 104 L 22/BL 13 1741 01852 ROSIER CHALRES B III/RHONDA A 4024 INDIAN HILLS DR 07/30/97 567 RES $53,000 $13,680 25.81 PIERCE BARBARA S 155 0 003 00 0 0.67 2028 00256 KORN JACK H/JOSEPH W/BISSEll 2354 WASHINGTON ROAD 02/28/97 550 COM $125,000 $48,920 39.14 PIERSON KAIl 19 4 140 01 1566 02440 VERNER BOO NCHU SHADOW lAKE SEC III 07/31/97 565 RES $9,850 $5,200 52.79 PIKE MARVIN B 175 41 2 l 10-B 392 02497 D&H DEVELOPMENT INC 415 JASPER CROSSING 11/21/97 577 RES $102,400 $39,000 38.09 PIMENTEL CARLOS J B 12 1 59 L 12 HUDSON TRACE SO 1146 02654 ASKIN OTIS F 86 CLOVERDALE SID SEC II 10/23/97 583 RES $13,900 $5,200 37.41 PINER LATANYA l 28 BL 0 759 01103 DOWNING MICHAEL L/DOZIER M R 1220 JOHNS RD 06/20/97 561 RES $125,000 $32,040 25.63 PIPKIN WALTER l/BAYLA T 44 1 180 1214 01008 ELX DEVELOPMENT INC 2206 BIRNHAM PLACE 02/21/97 549 RES $59,999 $23,200 38.67 PITCHFORD WILLIAM A 57 3 194 L 8/BL B 2346 . . . . . . . . . . . o o . . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 105 Sa..ple Seller land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 02380 STEWART OWEN F JR 2356 FIELDCREST RD 10/01/97 572 RES $68,272 $26,000 38.08 PITTS WIllIAM O/SHIRlEY ANN 170 0 536 00 0 L 53H 172 00529 RODGERS WILLIAM KIll 11 PINE HILL SID 02/25/97 549 RES $13,000 $6,840 52.62 PLANTATION ACRES INC 139 11 12 SEC II 3.42 957 02642 CHRISTIASEN CLAYTON LEE 660 CENTER CT DR 10/28/97 575 RES $95,550 $37,080 38.81 POLLARD BILLY M/MARY JEAN 31 4 47 24 UN B BL XXVIII 566 02880 HORNSBY PAULINE 0 1528/1530 MILl.ST 05/08/97 557 RES $12,000 $7,400 61.67 POLLARD JAMES 059 1 458 00 0 341 01524 NORDAHL HOMES INC 2009 EWART COURT 07/09/97 563 RES $69,600 $26,800 38.51 PONDER FIlICIA S/RICHARD 130 0 773 L 5 Bl A PHASE 1 1045 00018 OLIVE ROBERT lEE III 3004 SKINNER MIll RD 05/09/97 544 RES $40,000 $18,120 45.30 POSEY ADELLE OLIVE 2067 02294 NORDAHL HOMES INC 3448 MONTE CARLO DR 09/19/97 572 RES $71,900 $29,200 40.61 POTTER GEORGE C SR L 2B 423 01411 JACK R NORDAHL BUILDERS 1014 WALLIE CT 06/30/97 562 RES $74,900 $29,200 38.99 POWELL DALLAS A JR 154 325 l 7B WAllIE PLACE 563 00542 ST KITT'S LlC 222 KITT'S DRIVE 02/27/97 549 RES $58,900 $22,800 38.71 POWELL DIANE H 030 0 242 03 0 l 28/G 1540 00763 WESCO INC 2401 RAMBlEWOOD DRIVE 04/09/97 554 RES $95,000 $38,600 40.63 POWELL DOROTHY M/KENNETH MAP 143 PARCEL 729 l 4 BL J SEC 1 892 01647 BRUKER CO 305 ALEX LANE 08/01/97 565 RES $80,400 $29,800 37.06 POWELL EDGAR H 12 2 26 l 19 1672 02018 MCCUMBERS BUILDERS,INC 1531 PINE RIDGE DR EAST 09/16/97 570 RES $106,000 $41,880 39.51 POWELL TERRY L 232 148 l 15/BL C/SEC 3 491 01301 GOODWIN ISABEllE NORTH 1 1 INDIAN COVE DR 05/30/97 559 RES $131,000 $52,400 40.00 PRATHER STUART H JR/BETTY W 025 4 196 02 0 BL A 1584 01388 NORDAHL HOMES INC 2020 COUNTRY Pl DR 06/13/97 560 RES $97,900 $38,000 38.82 PRESCOTT CLARENCE W 184 0 164 L 12 Bl 0 SEC 2 1891 01507 STRELlNERDENNIS- J/L1NDA 0 9 2324 HENRY CIRCLE 07/03/97 563 RES $39,900 $14,960 37.49 PRESCOTT VIRGINIA M 097 2 P 079 L P 465 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 106 Sample Seller land Dist, land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SlB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 00975 STAFFORD DONALD lEE JR 2016 GARR DR 05/02/97 556 RES $49,959 $23,680 47.40 PRESSLEY JAMES E/BRINSON C 088 2 105 00 0 L 17B 1984 02455 CALHOUN MILDRED M 2012 STARNES STREET 10/31/97 574 RES $35,000 $14,560 41.60 PREWITT GREGORY B 035 3 142 00 0 L 20 Bl C HECKLE E T 2263 00555 HYLTON DAVID M 1734 HOllY HILL RD 03/17/97 551 RES $88,000 $28,000 41.18 PRICE ESTEVAN R/ROBERTSON K L 57 4 090 1304 02728 NOLFGRAM ROGER 2224 BOYKIN RD 11/25/97 578 RES $66,000 $26,960 40.85 PRICE JAMES J/SONG P L 6 BL H 27 00488 SEIGLER JANET C 1301 WINDSONG CIR 02/12/97 548 RES $39,039 $16,800 43.03 PRICE MARY H 6 341 UN 1301/BlDG 13/PH 3 1596 00218 RUDOLPH VIVIAN G 3115 HOllY HAVEN DR 03/17/97 552 RES $127,900 $48,400 37.84 PRICE ROBERT A/SHARON E 17 117 1232 01776 KITCHENS WILLIAM F PEACH ORCHARD RD 08/08/97 567 RES $24,225 $6,000 24.77 PRICE UlYSSEES/JOANNE S 251 0 054 00 0 5.75 582 01543 O'NEILL MICHELLE 0 2209 THICKET CT 07/11/97 563 RES $68,000 $26,880 39.53 PRIDGEN DURWARD B 007 3 042 1992 01270 DYCHES DONALD H 2441 APRICOT lANE 05/30/97 559 RES $62,000 $25,200 40.65 PROCTOR AMY E 019 E2 065 00 0 952 03011 ROSSER ROBERT E/SANDRA M 3410 WENTWORTH PLACE 12/30/97 581 RES $83,500 $33,320 39.90 PROCTOR FRANK C JR/DEBRA S 132 2 145 00 0 l 3/Bl B/SEC IV 446 02096 TOP KEN PETE W 3609 JONATHAN CIR 08/15/97 571 RES $26,000 $16,160 62.15 PROCTOR JULIAN l 123 4 89 L 21/Bl G SEC IV 471 00252 PRITCHETT CHARLES C 3313 CINDY STREET 03/12/97 552 RES $42,000 $21,320 50.76 PRUITT SUSAN J 122 4 226 00 0 L 10-C 1310 00773 DHAB INC ROLLINS RD 03/26/97 553 RES $8,900 $3,120 35.06 PRYE BRETT C/DAWN M 279 98 L 48 0.68 350 30025 215 FURYS FERRY RD COM $334,920 $143,280 42.78 PRYOR CLIFFORD H 11 25 8 0.65 Appraisal 02851 LOUIS TOMIE JR/CARTER BRENDA 2215 SULLIVAN RD 05/16/97 557 RES $16,000 $9,640 60.25 PRYOR NELLIE EVANS 72 3 60 l 33/34/BL F 2407 . . . . . . . . . . . o . . . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 107 Sallple Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 30027 WINDSOR SPRING RD COM $363,310 $139,840 38.44 PRYORS INC ACCOUNTS PAYABLE 153 566 0.81 Appraisal 01529 THIGPEN CARROLL A 1914 KINGS GRANT 07/02/97 563 RES $65,000 $21,600 33.23 PUGH ALBERT B/AMANDA L 110 247 L 7 BL B SEC II 1156 02098 BLACKS CONSTRUCTION 5143 FARMERS BRIDGE RD 08/25/97 571 RES $175,000 $58,700 33.54 PUGH MILTON/DELORES 270 7 06 07 1.39 491 01678 KENNETH SMITH HOMEBUILDERS IN 2013 TEAL COURT 07/31/97 566 RES $131,600 $51,200 38.91 PUGH PAUL JR/WILLIE MAE L19 BL E 87 00934 C M S GROUP INC 1237 ALDEN DR 04/29/97 556 RES $20,900 $6,400 30.62 PULLEY DAVID A 323 47 l 43 PH 2 lEWIS ACRE 988 00058 WATSON MITCHELL HOME BUILDERS 1042 FOX DEN RD 01/10/97 545 RES $151,765 $59,600 39.27 PURDIS JOHNNY C/MARY E 165 0 091 00 0 1453 00693 lIFSEY GROUP INC 2523 LENNYS COURT 04/21/97 555 RES $129,800 $51,800 39.88 PURIFOY RAY P/JUlIA M L 80 BL G SEC 3-B 321 01901 ADDIE GRAEME/JENNIFER 416 SHEFFIELD CIR 08/29/97 568 RES $119,000 $47,800 40.17 PURVIS REESE J JR/TUMM DONNA L 8 Bl C 1331 02631 HERBERT HOMES INC 2633 CORNING ST 10/29/97 575 RES $82,900 $31,480 37.97 PURYEAR NORMA J 141 364 L 126 BL I 864 02310 BOBBY JONES BUSINESS PARK 09/26/97 571 COM $42,500 $22,080 51.95 PUTT LARRY F 54 109 L 3 BL B 2075 02292 DRIGGERSE GREG L 3099 PARRISH RD 10/01/97 572 RES $136,300 $46,800 34.34 QUARTLES lINDA M/TONY V 11 o 73 05 501 02703 GARRISON CUSTOM HOMES INC 2702 CULVERTON DR 12/19/97 581 RES $108,900 $43,000 39.49 QUIllER CLASSIE M 052 0 655 00 0 1127 01818 TRIPLE E HOMEBUllDERS INC 2512 NORTON BLVD 06/19/97 561 RES $64,900 $19,040 29.34 QUITORIANO PIO G JR 097 1 151 00 0 L 3 BL H 316 02298 MALCHOW LELAND M 2643 2845 RAYMON AVE 09/30/97 572 RES $78,565 $32,760 41. 70 R l B PARTNERSHIP 43 2 168 169 526 02299 MALCHOW lElAND M/NORMA E 2622 CENTRAL AVE ET Al 09/30/97 572 RES $275,435 $107,640 39.08 R l B PARTNERSHIP 43 2 162 164 165 166 167 523 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 108 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SlB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 00207 BlOCKES JAMES E 1229 BRANCH STREET 02/28/97 549 RES $12,000 $4,960 41.33 R B T R INC 1 2358 30007 2822 PEACH ORCHARD COM $457,610 $181,120 39.58 R /H MAXXON INC 110 1 16 0.64 Appraisal 30022 3321 WASHINGTON RD COM $454,560 $183,520 40.37 R/H MAXXON INC 10 4 0.79 Appraisal 00280 ST KITTS LLC 225 KITTS DRIVE 03/05/97 550 RES $64,675 $18,400 28.45 RAFOTH CARL W/HYlDA M OUT OF 030 0 242 03 0 L 13 BL 0 710 01663 REDDY T R 3664 WHEELER RD 08/11/97 565 COM $300,000 $112,640 37.55 RALEY GEORGE V 030 0 099 00 0 2129 01672 PHIlANGIAS DEV lC 307 NEVIS DR 07/31/97 565 RES $59,900 $22,800 38.06 RAMBO MARY CAROLE 030 o 242 03 0 l 39J 2253 02607 WARD V JEAN 2226 ALBEMARLE DR 07/31/97 569 RES $54,900 $21,680 39.49 RAMNARINE SHELDON R 131 82 2364 00409 STEINBERG HENRY/STEPHEN H 3665 WOODCOCK DR 01/29/97 547 RES $67,900 $27,600 40.65 RAMSEY BARBARA GARRETT 130 o 685 1815 00685 FIELDS JAMES A/SABINE 3504 GARDENBROOK DRIVE 04/17/97 555 RES $58,900 $20,480 34.77 RAMSEY FRANKLIN 0 120 0 463 L 8 Bl B 462 01055 WHISENHUNT-CHILDREN INC ET AL 81 10 ZACHARY PLACE OS/23/97 558 RES $73,900 $29,000 39.24 RANCO ANTHONY FIBlANCHE R 012 1 127 00 0 1590 02022 RAYNER BRYAN TRACY 831 ANN ST 08/28/97 570 RES $53,900 $16,800 31.17 RANDAll BRUCE E/STACY E 020 1 227 00 l 16/E 666 02695 WHISENHUNT CHILDREN INC ET Al 14 ZACHARY Pl 12/31/97 581 RES $72,500 $29,000 40.00 RANDOL TABITHA M/RICHARD l JR 12 1 125 L 79 1343 00578 SHANKEY RONALD R 1706 RUSK DR 02/27/97 550 RES $62,900 $23,800 37.84 RANGEL DANNY l/CHRISTIE J 213/109 L 6/Bl C 1742 01736 NORDAHL HOMES INC 3104 KAYLON COURT 08/08/97 566 RES $119,900 $46,000 38.37 RASBERRY FLOYD W/SElENA L 184 o 195 00 0 L 19 BL B SECT I I 1869 02513 ALEXANDER HOMES INC 2516 CARRIAGE CREEK 11/20/97 577 RES $93,900 $41,000 43.66 RAY BOBBY D/JUOY P 567 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 109 Sa..ple Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 01625 HILL GARY A 07/31/97 565 RES $75,900 $26,560 34.99 RAY ERIC WILLIAM R/STEPHANIE 55 1 060 L 37 HARWOOD SID 1189 02899 DAVIS JAMES E JR 1217 REID ROAD 12/15/97 579 RES $43,900 $15,000 34.17 RAYBURN W STUART 41 32 4 L 1 0.10 1984 00898 CURRY ETHEl/ET AL 1541 WOOTEN RD 04/28/97 556 RES $30,000 $11 ,240 37.47 REDDICK ANTHONY C/MARY J 58 3 131 282 01669 PHILANGIAS DEV LC 309 NEVIS DR 07/31/97 565 RES $58,900 $22,800 38.71 REDMON JACK R 0300 242 03 0 L 41 K 2236 01945 JOHNSON THOMAS/MARY STATE HWY 88 09/04/97 569 AGR $16,000 $7,640 47.75 REDMOND JERRY B/DARLENE 223 0 002 14 0 L 6 6.39 1017 02865 PRYOR CLIFFORD H 14 2117 LAKE AVE 08/18/97 567 RES $43,900 $12,640 28.79 REED WILLIAM C/E ANN 027 1 056 00 0 Bl A 1399 02841 LOVETT TIMOTHY B 2414 SPARKS RD 05/12/97 557 RES $45,000 $16,920 37.60 REESE ALENE B 85 1 247 L 22/BL 0 2200 00126 WALTOWER PATRICIA A 3652 ALENE CIRCLE 01/28/97 548 RES $67,500 $26,480 39.23 REESE ANDREW 107 o 357 L 32 BLK E 1797 01944 PATTERSON CONSTANCE LOU S ETA 3205 OLD MCDUFFIE RD 09/04/97 569 RES $24,000 $4,640 19.33 REESE FRANKLIN/CATHY H 083 0 044 00 0 1006 03037 WASHINGTON RD DEVELOPERS 220 CHARLESTOWNE WAY 10/15/97 575 RES $73,366 $26,600 38.26 REESE MILDRED L 011 o 222 01 0 L 10lB 2133 01982 PLEMMONS BURNETT JR 2020 CARR DR 09/04/97 588 RES $51,900 $21,280 41.00 REEVES BONNIE 086 2 1 03 00 0 L 19 BL B 2424 03024 DARNELL DEBORAH 6/7 3240 MIllEDGEVIllE RD 11/06/97 575 RES $38,000 $11,440 30.11 REEVES BRENDA 0 069 2 084 00 0 Bl 0 2406 02707 CARROLL WILLIAM J JR/MARTHA G 1760 12/30/97 581 RES $80,000 $25,280 31.60 REEVES CHARLES H/JERRY W 1.96 999 01366 SAUL lOUIS 716 5TH ST 05/18/97 560 RES $18,000 $8,400 48.67 REEVES JOHN 1816 03038 WASHINGTON_RD_DEYELOPERS__ 214 CHARLESTOWNE WAY 11/07/97 575 RES $59,900 $25,000 41. 74 REEVES TERRY M 011 o 222 01 0 L 7/B 2135 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 110 Sample Seller land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 02345 FRONT LINE HOMES 2617 SPIRIT CREEK RD 10/24/97 574 RES $84,900 $30,400 35.81 REGGlER DENEAN A 630 02482 ASKIN ENTERPRISES LTD CO 90 PLAT FOR ASKIN ENTERPRISE 09/03/97 577 AGR $17,900 $8,000 44.69 REID ALBERTA L 5 1.86 1723 02469 JOHNSON RICHARD L/BEATRICE R 1102 PERRY AVE 10/28/97 574 RES $28,000 $4,360 15.57 REID ElLAWEASE S 059 2 512 00 0 l 14 BL 14 1603 02776 WASHINGTON ROAD DEVELOPERS lL 226 CHARLESTOWNE WAY 12/01/97 578 RES $73,366 $26,600 36.26 REID EOlA L 011 o 222 01 0 L 13 BL B 1333 02133 MURRAY DOUGLAS E 1256 HEPHZIBAH MCBEAN RD 09/25/97 571 RES $120,000 $37,320 31.10 RENEAU CHARLES W/MARITZA E 336/45 3.00 1431 01298 LUNCEFORD TERESA B 943 HEPHZIBAH-MCBEAN RD 06/02/97 559 RES $46,251 $32,240 69.71 RENFORE lEON 354 0 093 00 0 L 14/15/16 1484 01606 BAKER WILLIAM OSCAR/DOROTHY C 10 2919 MYRTLE DR 07/25/97 565 RES $60,000 $24,280 40.47 REWIS STEVEN B M 056 3 115 l N 737 00251 DHAB INC 4660 ROLLINS ROAD 03/21/97 552 RES $9,000 $3,680 40.89 REWIS TIMIJENNIFER 279 0 083 00 0 L 32 0.88 1303 02773 HOGAN lEONARD D SR MARK.S CHURCH RD 09/28/97 578 COM $25,000 $12,280 49.12 REYNOLDS GERALD D/REBECCA H 1304 00874 RASCAL ENTERPRISES INC 124 l 10 02/10/97 554 RES $11,900 $2,480 20.84 REYNOLDS IZIllA E 0.48 150 00868 SOUTHERN CONSTRCUTION 7 SPIRIT POINTE SO 04/04/97 554 RES $104,860 $24,800 23.65 RHODES EARNEST G/KIM S 215 01 185 00 0 BlK A SEC 1 175 02573 C M S GROUP INC OLD SAVANNAH ROAD 11/10/97 576 RES $50,000 $24,080 48.16 RHODES HAROLD E 324 41 1 30.11 985 00236 HAYWOOD BRENDA W 1225 GLENNWOOD DRIVE 03/21/97 552 RES $75,900 $23,400 30.83 RHODES MARY E/EDDIE l JR 13 2 136 l 3 BL 21 SEC I 337 02094 BEATTIE lYNNE C/CARlISlE HELE 3519 NASSAU DR 09/08/97 571 RES $89,900 $40,040 44.54 RHODES ROBERT/FELICIA 442 02182 OSADA MARK ROBERT 333 BERKMAN RD 09/05/97 573 RES $93,900 $28,000 29.82 RIBOCK JOHN A 19 45 1275 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 111 Sample Seller Land Db t, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 02768 MYERS LILLIE MAE RACHEL 1918 STARNES ST 12/03/97 578 RES $42,500 $17 , 320 40.75 RIBOCK JOHN A 35 3 182 L 31 BL G 1458 02919 CHILD ENRICHMENT INC 1834 FENWICK ST 12/17/97 580 RES $40,650 $17 , 240 42.41 RIBOCK JOHN A 035 4 360 00 0 602 02610 KELLEY TIMOTHY S/DONNA E 1045 MCCALL ST 09/10/97 570 AGR $85,000 $37,040 43.58 RICE CARSON BRYAN 210 0 14 2.12 6 01460 SHAVER WILLIAM E/OEBORAH S 4014 BURNING TREE lANE 06/30/97 562 RES $125,000 $59,200 47.36 RICE DAVID R 198 0 066 00 0 L 12-E 1664 01444 KENNETH SMITH HOMEBUILDERS IN WALTON ACRES SID PHASE II 07/01/97 562 RES $137,000 $54,800 40.00 RICE WARREN N 178 39 L 18 BL C 1203 01394 NORDAHL HOMES INC 3304 COBBLESTONE CT 06/16/97 560 RES $77,900 $29,600 38.00 RICE WESLEY B/AMANDA P 132 517 l 17 BL A 2172 01950 SHINAULT MARC JIDONNA P 3803 CREIGHTON PL 09/04/97 569 RES $55,000 $20,200 36.73 RICE YVETTE M 170 0 048 1116 02922 POLLARD BILLY M/MARY J 651 CENTER COURT DR 11/03/97 580 RES $68,900 $25,880 38.68 RICH IRVING E/LYNNE 31 4 04 7 38 299 01243 MCKNIGHT MASON HARRIS III 3411 WALTON WAY EXT 05/29/97 559 RES $200,000 $80,000 40.00 RICHARDS ROBERT P JR 32 1 TRACT A 0.69 294 01240 SANDERS GARYI/MORRIS 1817 STARNES ST OS/23/97 559 RES $32,000 $11,760 36.75 RIGDON MARY R/JAMES C 035 4 351 217 01170 LEE JANICE C/THOMAS H/BEATRIC 2703 BUTlERPlACE 12/01/97 579 RES $100,000 $35,400 35.40 RIGGS MICHAEL H 025 2 158 00 0 1002 02327 BARBER GENE L 2420 PONDEROSA COURT 10/01/97 574 RES $74,400 $29,200 39.25 RIMMER JAMES HAROLDISHERRY 1091 01607 SID BECKUM CONST INC 2 339 ALEX LANE 07/25/97 565 RES $76,000 $29,800 39.21 RITCHIE BELINDA 0 749 02114 BOWLES BETSY H 3057 ETON COURT 09/22/97 571 RES $125,000 $45,760 36.61 RIVERS CARY H/MADELINE H 33 1 200 838 01322 HADDAD NADIM1SAD- I( 4 1111 EISENHOWER CT S 06/09/97 559 RES $66,000 $29,200 44.24 ROBERSON DEE KELLY 13 4 209 2335 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 112 SBllple Seller Land Dist, land lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 00439 DAVIS RUFUS 0 B/PRISCIlLA 3418 GARY CIR 02/07/97 548 RES $69,900 $28,000 40.06 ROBERTRS LESLIE A 123 3 58 271 00996 HOlSONBAKE KATHEY V 3745 FAIRINGTON DR 04/24/97 556 RES $61,000 $24,240 39.74 ROBERTS BONNIE/THOMAS F JR 140 0 112 00 00 2312 00191 CO ELMAN DWIGHT 3608 lOFWOOD DR 01/29/97 547 RES $58,500 $20,200 34.53 ROBERTS WALTER III 131 0 016 L 4 BLK 0 1025 00866 MILNER JAMES E/SHElLEY MARTHA 1105/1107 PEAC~TREE RD 02/13/97 554 RES $313,500 $125,440 40.01 ROBERTS-AUGUSTA INC 225 01429 GARREN CONSTRUCTION INC 2846 LOMBARDY COURT 07/01/97 562 RES $90,000 $13,640 15.16 ROBERTS-AUGUSTA INC 43 2 32 1084 02188 HARDY lUMBER COMPANY 10/15/97 573 COM $81,000 $30,200 37.28 ROBERTS.AUGUSTA INC 45 1 71 1286 02437 TROTTER J DAVIS 2919 PROFESSIONAL PKWY 07/30/97 565 COM $271,000 $102,800 37.93 ROBERTS-AUGUSTA INC 18 422 l 6 Bl B 328 03018 MEYBOHM ROBERT L ET AL 2814 HILlCREEK DR 11/05/97 576 COM $85,000 $26,680 31.39 ROBERTS-AUGUSTA INC 30 256 L 2 0.44 224 01405 WILSON JANE QUINN/ROBERT H OLD WAYNESBORO ROAD 06/25/97 562 RES $10,000 $4,440 44.40 ROBERTSON LEROY 335 o 003 12/335 0 003 25 1.01 470 00978 HUGGINS SADA M 2350 MCDOWELL STREET 04/30/97 556 RES $170,000 $53,240 31.32 ROBERTSON STEVEN J/CAROL S 44 1 166 2020 00310 ARCHWAY BUILDERS INC 4119 BURNING TREE lANE 03/03/97 550 RES $96,900 $36,400 37.56 ROBINSON ALBERT A/SUSAN C 214 o 148 L 8 Bl C 381 00144 KINGSBURY CUSTOMHOMES INC 2016 CLAKRSTON DR 01/09/97 545 RES $99,000 $39,400 39.80 ROBINSON CRAIG S/ELLA J 52/582 1 M SEC TWO 821 02842 PRATHER lARRY S JR ET Al 24 2919 ALGERNON CIR 05/16/97 557 RES $13,900 $5,200 37.41 ROBINSON DERRICK A 129-73 BL B 2230 01129 PUGH MILTON 2405 NORTH CAROLINA AVE 06/05/97 561 RES $45,000 $14,600 32.44 ROBINSON EARNESTINE M 84 4 175 l 24 1887 02888 NORMAN ROBERT C 3034 lAKE FOREST DR 05/05/97 557 RES $390,000 $86,960 22.30 ROBINSON EDWARD C ET AL 43 1 004 l 24/PT l 25 494 . . . . . . . . . . . o o u 411~ . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 113 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessllent No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 01627 RAMSEY JAMES F 1909 KRATHA DR 07/28/97 565 RES $46,900 $18,400 39.23 ROBINSON ELLA F 72 3 062 01 1246 00174 SID BECKUM CONST INC 2920 ARROWWOOD CIR 01/31/97 547 RES $129,900 $52,400 40.34 ROBINSON JOHNNY/EDWINA G 139 403 L 150 BL A PH II 683 02669 HERBERT HOMES INC 1017 SEVENS CREEK RD 10/30/97 582 RES $43,500 $12,320 28.32 ROBINSON RENARD ANTONEY 12 244 UN 207 BLDG 9 1698 00387 KEY JANET & 1008 HOLDEN STREET 03/04/97 550 RES $64,000 $25,480 39.81 ROBINSON SYLVIA M 45 1 158 l 74 2399 01888 LIVELY C MILNER 1107 WAL TONS TRl 08/27/97 568 RES $129,900 $49,200 37.88 ROBINSON VINCENT M 178 060 l 3 BL B 1008 00936 MURPHY MICHAEL H/CAROLYN 1295 BROWN RD 04/29/97 556 RES $72,000 $28,720 39.89 ROBINSON W A 216 0 002 07 L 5 BlK B 1005 00122 BRYANT JOHN D/ALBERTA J 3918 CREEKWOOD lANE 01/15/97 546 RES $65,000 $26,800 41.23 ROBY TIFFANY N 15 53 L 11 BL 5 SEC II 1590 00338 BROAD OAKLAND COMPANY 86 8 OAK SOUTH 02/12/97 551 RES $13,050 $5, 160 39.54 RODGERS ANITA N 338 126 L 2 PHASE II 2.16 1509 01259 lIVELY PROPERTIES INC 2923 PILLAR lN 05/30/97 559 RES $96,400 $36,400 37.76 RODGERS KURT A 039 0 214 00 0 L 15 BL F 679 00823 HOWARD RUTH RUSSELL/BETZ JEAN 124 HEPHIZIBAH-MCBEAN RD 03/11/97 553 AGR $74,658 $19,440 26.04 ROGERS CHRIS H/TAMARA 334 12 32.46 1575 01929 BEEBE FRED/DEE ANN 1937 HAYNIE DR 08/27/97 568 RES $59,900 $23,880 39.87 ROGERS HARRY 2046 02187 DUKES JAMES B/TERRYLE 3609 CHUKAR COURT 07/08/97 573 RES $54,253 $24,000 44.24 ROGERS JEAN L 23/BL 0 SEC II 1160 00991 FULCHER PEGGY 4962 OLD WAYNESBORO RD 05/05/97 556 RES $28,000 $7,600 27.14 ROGERS PATSY A 336 0 1 08 00 0 2257 01455 NORDAHL HOMES INC 3312 COBBLESTONE COURT 06/27/97 562 RES $68,900 $29,200 42.38 ROSS ALBERT J SR l 13-A 1616 00911 JOH!lSONBIRNET T - 429 REYNOLDS ST OS/21/97 556 COM $18,950 $8,520 44.96 ROSS MICHON N 47 2 6 956 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 114 _. Sample Seller land Dist, land lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 01352 EXECUTIVE ENTERPRISES 4218 CAP CHAT ST 05/19/97 560 RES $70,000 $26,520 37.89 ROTHE RICHARD A JR 166 224 L 12 Bl B SEC 1 847 01905 SUTTON TYRUS L/SYLVIA A 2557 GRANADA Pl 08/15/97 568 RES $57,900 $22,160 38.27 ROWAN DEANNA 0 141 o 057 00 0 L 17 BL C 1457 00517 MALAVE BENITO/lUX E 2219 RAMBlEWOOD DR 02/21/97 549 RES $92,000 $34,000 36.96 ROYAL EDDIE G/ANNABEllE 143 o 328 l 10lBl 4/SEC 5 C 480 02483 TOOLE WILLIAM F 3036 lAKE FORREST DRIVE 11/24/97 577 RES $157,000 $52,760 33.61 RUBEN MARJORIE G MAP 43 1 PARCEL 003 1693 00437 lAVIGNE WIllIAM E 3027 CARDINAL DR 02/03/97 548 RES $172,000 $76,360 44.40 RUDOLPH VIVIAN THORNTON 43 1 103 281 00838 JACK R NORDAHL BUILDERS INC 3339 SADDLE BROOK DR 03/28/97 553 RES $72,900 $30,000 41.15 RUIZ CARLOS A 129 0 689 l 9 BL J 1939 02852 VARNADO SOLOMON G 3416 CAUTHERN DR 04/30/97 558 RES $46,000 $18,080 39.30 RUIZ CARLOS A/MYRIAM R 7 02734 PARRISH JOSEPHINE A 2224 SILVERDALE RD 11/26/97 578 RES $77,620 $30,760 39.63 RUSSELL THOMAS B . 121 417 L 15 BL I 248 00190 NORDAHL HOMES INC 3005 JOHN PAUL CORSSING 01/31/97 547 RES $116,500 $41,200 35.38 RUTLAND TIMOTHY A/PAULA M 184 o 1936 l 18 BlK B 1002 01336 JONES CHRISTOPHER J/LENORIA 2429 MADRID DR 06/06/97 560 RES $56,000 $19,800 35.00 RYALS JIMMY L JR/SANDRA M 082 0 212 L 3 BL F SEC 2-A 474 00520 WILLIS LORETTA J 844 BROOKFIELD PKWY 02/19/97 549 RES $91,100 $37,840 41.54 RYERSON MARGARET C 6 133 L 11/BL 0 643 30003 2505 WASHINGTON RD COM $475,670 $164,400 34.56 SIA PROP CORP 19 2 186 5 0.70 Appraisal 01638 SMITH CONSTANCE L 2819 RIOGECREST DR 07/24/97 565 RES $63,900 $23,400 36.62 SALL Y MARTIN S 129 0 349 l 67 BlK B PEBBLE CK 1401 02337 STAPLES ELSIE M 618 BENNOCK MIll RD 09/26/97 574 RES $38,500 $6,440 16.73 SAMI ARVIND K 720 02752 KASHANI BETTY KATHRYN 1017 STEWVENS CREEK RD 12/02/97 578 RES $33,900 $13,120 38.70 SAMMONS MARGARET E 012 0 190 00 0 760 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 115 Sample Seller land Dist, Land lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SlB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 01506 HOLLEY KEVIN R/WANDA M 3527 PEBBLE CREEK DRIVE 06/19/97 563 RES $42,680 $17 , 000 39.83 SANCHEZ GARY/TONYA LYNN 129 0 258 00 0 L 14-B 451 01836 HAMRICK GAYLE B 4204 MATCH POINT DR 08/18/97 567 RES $57,900 $22,280 38.48 SANDERS HARVEY JUDSON III 1678 02448 REDMON JACK R 1233 SANDE HILL PLACE 07/30/97 565 RES $75,000 $28,400 37.87 SANDERS J LARRY SR/BRIAN P 032 4 099 31 0 SANDE HILL UNIT - 607 02960 ROLAND EVANS CONST CO 2536 CARRIAGE CREEK 12/16/97 580 RES $100,000 $42,200 42.20 SANDERS L ANNE 13 1 190 L 16/Bl B 1635 00106 CICCIO DANIEL 4433 REYNOLDS STREET 01/24/97 546 RES $50,000 $17 ,000 34.00 SANDERS WILLIAM JEFFERY/ANGEL 249 0 5 1030 00797 ATHENS PROPERTIES INC 2236 PEPPER lOGE DRIVE 04/01/97 553 RES $84,900 $33,000 38.87 SANTIAGO JOSE A MAP 143 PARCEL 689 L 10 BL B SE 866 01579 LIFSEY GROUP INC 3310 BALKCOM DRIVE 07/21/97 564 RES $110,000 $47,400 43.09 SANTOS WAYNE A 095 0 361 L 69 Bl G SEC 3B 740 02474 STOWEll CARLTON A/ELLA M 1513 KERON WAY 10/27/97 577 RES $25,500 $8,240 32.31 SAPP DICK/SUE I 336 0 116 00 0 l 9-B 1759 01023 LAKE ORVILLE N/GEMMA 3744 WOODCOCK DR 05/15/97 588 RES $69,900 $29,200 41.77 SAPP JOHN L/lUCllE Y 140 0 077 00 0 L 57 BL A SEC II 400 00698 o l H DEVELOPMENT INC 401 JASPER CROSSING 04/18/97 555 RES $94,000 $37,800 40.21 SARKHAIL MASOUD l 19 HUDSON TRACE 810 00894 RD/D INC 2034 GREENLAND RD 04/30/97 556 RES $14,000 $4,800 34.29 SAUER AMY/PERRY DIANNE B 191 22 l 13 144 01193 SHAPARD KIMBERLY N/JASON M 749 LANCASTER RD 12/15/97 579 RES $120,000 $43,080 35.90 SAUNDERS ANNE H 024 4 112 00 0 l 10/SEC 1 1633 02599 LECKIE WILLIAM R 1598 C GOSHEN ROAD 11/03/97 576 RES $51,900 $21,800 42.00 SAYlORS DONNA J 199 0 019 00 0 371 00429 lAMB W T RAWLEY RD 02/03/97 547 COM $50,000 $17 ,440 34.88 SCALES SYSTEMS INC 123 8 8 1.00 2255 00537 MERIN ROBERT G/BARBARA R 2709 MCDOWELL ST 02/28/97 549 RES $160,000 $58,240 36.40 SCAVULLO CHARLES J/JOYCE H 043 2 089 00 0 1580 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 116 Sample Seller land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SlB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 02900 FRONT LINE HOMS 1410 BROOKSTONE RD 12/12/97 579 RES $85,900 $31,200 36.32 SCHABERl LUKE/PATRICIA A 5008 02110 JOHNSON LAURA J 2012 SUMMER RIDGE 09/24/97 571 RES $95,500 $39,960 41.84 SCHADE ELAN A R 45 1 380 773 01768 PERRY BILL J 114/117 3003 CARDINAL DR 08/07/97 567 RES $141,000 $55,440 39.32 SCHAFER SUSAN H 043 1 091 00 0 L B 549 02547 WEllS THOMAS W/AMY S 3009 HAMPSHIRE DR 11/14/97 576 RES $91,000 $38,000 41.76 SCHAPPEll JOHN M 25 1 109 1864 01248 HACKETT SHAWN A 66 1027 BEDFORD DR OS/29/97 559 RES $57,900 $21,600 37.31 SCHlAGENHAUSEE NICK N/HEATHER M 020 1 P 147 BL 0 416 00539 BLACKBURN HOME BUILDERS INC 2107 LARKS COURT 02/26/97 549 RES $134,000 $54,000 40.30 SCHlIFKA HENRY/GISELLE 030 0 275 00 0 L 4 1414 00642 LEIDA STANLEY R/DONNA 3924 WRIGHTSBORO RD 04/28/97 555 RES $120,000 $27,920 23.27 SCHMIDT WALTER 039 o 063 03 0 0.59 2002 01252 COLLIER ROBERT R SR 2909 NORGATE DR 05/30/97 559 RES $70,000 $29,400 42.00 SCHOFE KATHY 0 33 1 219 615 00193 KING PAUL G 254 TELFAIR ST 01/28/97 547 RES $109,000 $52,200 47.89 SCHORSCH MARY E/STYLES L 047 4 256 000 1220 00194 IRZECGIWSJU BRENDA GAIL 2383 TURKEY TRAIL DR 02/04/97 547 RES $12,600 $5,840 46.35 SCHRADER ADAM P/ROBERT L 166 0 135 l 9 BLK F SEC 3 1142 01624 MAC CONST INC 4131 FOREMAN WAY 07/31/97 565 RES $88,800 $35,400 39.86 SCOTT DIVINA P 179 136 L 18 Bl A 1180 01887 PHILANGIAS DEVELOPMENT LC 303 NEVIS DR 08/26/97 568 RES $59,900 $22,800 38.06 SCOTT GWENDOLYN H 030 0 242 03 0 L 35 BL I 990 01986 NORDAHL HOMES INC 3416 DANVERS AVE 08/29/97 569 RES $105,300 $36,800 34.95 . SCOTT HILTON T/MABlE 88 143 684 L 8-13 00150 BRITTINGHAM HERMAN 428 CRAWFORD AVE 01/30/97 547 COM $75,000 $23,920 31.89 SCOTT JAMES WESLEY JR 35 2 507 311 01030 QUATTLEBAUM WILLIAM R SR lUMP KIN RD 2376 OS/20/97 558 RES $62,500 $26,800 42.88 SCOTT KENNETH M 097 3 286 00 0 674 . . . . . . . . . . . u o . . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 117 Sa..ple Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 01154 BARTON MELVIN 0 2858 LUMPKIN RD 12/09/97 579 COM $90,175 $32,000 35.49 SCOTT PATRICIA 0.33 469 00198 BLUME DALLAS 4252 WINDSOR SPRING RD 02/08/97 547 COM $70,000 $39,520 56.46 SCOTT PATRICIA ANN 166 0 23 L 1 0.62 1435 02831 RASCAL ENTERPRISES INC 86 03/28/97 557 RES $11,500 $4,200 36.52 SCRITCHFIELD STANLEY W III/R L 4 0.81 2064 00827 WILLIS JOHN H JR/CASI S 36 1207 LUNDALL COURT 03/31/97 553 RES $89,000 $35,600 40.00 SCRUGGS L LANIER III 7 012 1 044 1459 00812 SIMMONS WYMAN B 2244 WADE RD 04/03/97 553 RES $20,000 $8,320 41.80 SEAGO BRIAN KEITH 1221 00927 PAYNE LARRY JOE/lARRY J 2275 ESSER DR 05/02/97 556 RES $59,900 $25,320 42.27 SEALS JEFFREY L 71 1 158 887 01156 BRYSON WESLEY 0 3478 B MORGAN RD 12/10/97 579 RES $88,000 $21,880 33.15 SEALY JOSEPH C/DONNA 514 01148 ALEXANDER HOMES 4803 GREEN lEAF LANE 12/08/97 579 RES $94,900 $31,000 32.67 SELLARS WILSON/JUANITA J 170 00187 WILLIY KIMBERLY A 1738 HOLLY HIll RD 01/31/97 547 RES $66,250 $27,200 41.06 SERFF JEFFREY M/PAUL C 057 4 088 776 01074 SMITH THOMAS PICYNTHIA A 3119 HOLLY HAVEN DR OS/27/97 558 RES $121,000 $50,400 41.65 SERVICE WILLIAM llCAROL H 017 0 115 00 0 l 3 2018 00753 COBB THOMAS C GA HWY 88 04/09/97 554 RES $15,000 $8,240 41.80 SESSIONS ANGELA 0 224 o 002 06 0 1068 01106 BURGE JOHN T/KAREN K 21 3375 WEDGEWOOD DR 08/18/97 561 RES $83,500 $24,160 38.05 SEVERSON KATHIRAE 041 1 032 00 0 BL F 1243 00590 BLACKMON BARBARA C 3493 BRYON Pl 02/28/97 549 RES $8,000 $2,840 35.50 SEXTON CLEO/ROOSEVELT 120 176 0.92 1776 01589 WARD PHYLLIS B 2053 STEINER AVENUE 07/17/97 584 RES $42,900 $19,080 44.48 SEYMORE LAROHANDA D/CLARISSA 58 4 267 L 1/2 BL 0 1052 02143 -- -- -- - - 3410 KAMEL CIR 09/29/97 571 RES $118,500 $52,600 KIRBY HELEN E 44.39 SHACKELFORD J MICHAEL/JOAN H 31 2 23 L 7/BL C/SEC I 1648 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 118 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SlB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 01769 BOND ANN G 1521 JOHN RD 08/04/97 567 RES $42,000 $18,200 43.33 SHADDEN H SPENCER/AMY BLIVEN 044 3 236 00 0 565 01152 THRAILKILL MICHAEL R 916 HEAD AVE 12/08/97 579 RES $110,000 $42,800 38.91 SHAFFNER MICHAEL R 45 1/21 421 02122 MCCAIN DAVID 0 1017 STEVENS CREEK RD 09/26/97 571 RES $30,000 $12,320 41.07 SHAIKH ABDUL HAMID 12 0 213 1223 02117 DENTEL PAUL RIELLEN I 3111 TRAFAlGAR DR 09/24/97 571 RES $126,000 $50,000 39.68 SHAREEF TAlIB M/TAHIRAH M 025 1 045 00 0 896 01293 WILSON OLIVER C JRIBETTY J 12 RAINTREE Pl 06/04/97 559 RES $142,500 $69,120 48.51 SHARKEY BRUCE L 32 31 35 00 0 L 11 BL B 1336 00886 MIXON BILLY R/CYNTNIA W 805 PARKER STREET 04/11/97 554 RES $70,700 $28,000 39.60 SHARP ROSARIO A 7 151 L 10E 719 02325 DAVIS GARY H/DENISE E 1875 KISSINGBOWERN RD 10/22/97 574 RES $45,000 $17,080 37.96 SHARPE SAMANTHA 71 2 122 1354 00585 GLENN H/SUSAN S 2471 COLEMAN AVE 02/24/97 550 RES $47,900 $18,400 38.41 SHEARER CHARLES L 098 2 071 00 0 l 3/A 111 01953 MENGER CUSTOM DOOR & PAINT IN 421 AUGUSTA LAND CO 09/04/97 569 COM $68,500 $13,560 19.80 SHEEHAN JAMES F 35 4 503 714 01079 ATKINS ADElHEID M OS/28/97 558 COM $135,000 $50,720 37.57 SHElNUT PROPERTIES INC 41 1 144 2144 01080 PERRY DAVID W/ELIZABETH W OS/28/97 558 COM $135,000 $50,240 37.21 SHElNUT PROPERTIES INC 41 1 141 2150 00139 SAUNDERS ELWYN A/JEPTHA I JR 2919 RAE CREEK RD 01/14/97 545 COM $134,000 $51,320 38.30 SHElNUT PROPS l L C 41 1 140 1612 00140 SAUNDERS ElWYN AIMCNAIR JEPHI 3004 RAE WOOD DR 01/14/97 545 COM $134,000 . $50,080 37.37 SHElNUT PROPS l L C 41 1 128 1615 02640 ARCHWAY BUILDERS INC 4128 BURNING TREE lN 10/29/97 575 RES $92,900 $32,400 34.88 SHELTON BENNY W/LETA F 214 158 L 15 BL B PH 1 738 02849 THOMAS JOHN B JR 1101 COLONY PLACE 05/13/97 557 RES $51,000 $19,840 38.90 SHELTON SONA K/WINSTON C 012 0 346 00 0 2389 . . . . . . . . . . . j . o ~. . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 119 Sallple Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 02690 KNOX DAVID A/SUSANNE L 742 OBERLIN RD 12/15/97 581 RES $189,900 $82,680 43.54 SHEPARD KIMBERLY N/JASON M 33 1 21 L 7/8 Bl B 1813 01005 WILLIAMS C MURRAY 2906 VANESSA DR 03/05/97 550 RES $62,900 $19,080 30.33 SHERMAN EDDIE F JRIVALERIE E 119 235 l 8/BL D/SEC I B 1859 02596 ROBERTS GLADIS PIJONES DORIS 1015 PREP STREET 10/17/97 576 RES $23,000 $7,240 31.48 SHIELDS JOSEPH 072 186 00 0 L 15-A 329 02806 RICHMOND BUILDERS INC 2768 DAVIS MILL RD 05/09/97 557 RES $95,000 $36,800 38.74 SHIELDS MARVIN L/WANOA Y 177 0 028 00 0 L 6/J 895 02008 JOURNEY JAMES CRAIG/DONNA B 4005 BROWN HURST RD 09/04/97 570 RES $122,500 $47,600 38.86 SHINAULT MARC J 215 13 L 3 280 02267 BLOUNT WILLIAM R 2127 SHAMROCK DR 09/26/97 572 RES $40,650 $15,880 39.07 SHINE PATRICIA A/CRAIG B 1247 02560 NORDAHL HAZEL J 3148 SUMMERCHASE 11/07/97 576 RES $102,000 $48,600 47.65 SHIVER THRISHA G 1244 01584 SHULER HEBERT W/LUCY C 746 MCCLURE DR 07/18/97 564 RES $127,500 $46,400 36.39 SHOWMAN CHRISTOPHER DITRACY G 24 4 114 959 03006 BEASLEY RABUN 3127 SUMMERCHASE PLACE 12/30/97 581 RES $105,000 $41,400 39.43 SHOWMAN LONNIE J/JULIA A 042 4 174 00 0 L 5/SEC III 382 03025 TOWNE ANNA MARIE 3415 1/2 WRIGHTSBORO RD 11/15/97 575 COM $91,000 $43,320 47.60 SHUEY STEVE 2356 01883 KELLAR DOUGLAS JIBETTY H 5225 WOODRIDGE DR 08/25/97 568 RES $98,000 $38,600 39.39 SIDENER JOHN/MCDOWElL WENDY 215 147 796 01925 DESOUZA MARY STEWART 38 510 NORWICH RD 08/28/97 568 RES $130,000 $52,400 40.31 SIGG DAVID M/KAREN B 024 2 215 00 0 Bl K 1917 00053 C J SINGLETON CONST CO INC 2391 BASSWOOD DR 01/10/97 545 RES $74,900 $28,720 38.34 SIGLER NATHAN R 167 0 404 L 22 BLK G 1312 00559 KE ITH JAMES A 123 3156/3158 FLOYD DR 03/17/97 551 RES $49,900 $21,760 43.61 SIMMONS MABEL 0 109 4 094 00 0 1336 00272 HUNTINGTON BEllE F 2 3332 RAVENWOOD DR 03/20/97 552 RES $80,000 $29,600 37.00 SIMMONS NATHANIEL W 010 0 214 00 0 l F 715 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 120 Sample Seller land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parce1, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 00243 SILLS HELEN J 2508 WEST KENSINGTON DR 03/20/97 552 RES $55,900 $21,000 37.57 SIMMONS SYLVESTER l 107 o 296 L 31 BL C SEC 1 1393 01694 WHITTINGTON BOBBY L/CHERYL S 3418 RAVENWOOD DR 08/01/97 566 RES $92,900 $37,600 40.47 SIMMONSON DORIS W/RUSSElL P 16 130 337 00270 HERBERT HOMES INC 2601 GUY COURT 03/18/97 551 RES $67,900 $26,800 39.47 SIMON MARY LOU MAP 129 PARCEL 314 l 16 Bl B PH 2 2096 00579 SMITH FREDERICK I 27 lONDONBERRY LANE 02/28/97 550 RES $59,900 $21,600 36.06 SIMONS ZACHARY G M 016 2 P 141 L 4/C 47 00307 AGUIRRE-SANTOS RAMON 2624 CASTLE TOWN DRIVE 02/25/97 550 RES $63,900 $30,000 46.95 SIMS GRACE W/DIANE 130 o 285 l 19 Bl S SEC 2B PHl 427 00839 TIETENBERG FLORENCE 2606 WEST PARKWAY DR 04/01/97 553 RES $61,000 $20,960 34.36 SIMS PONDA A 056 2 136 l 18 BlK C 1930 00320 SCHRAMM SYBIL J 2442 RIVER lOOK DRIVE 02/28/97 550 RES $79,000 $28,600 36.20 SINGER HEATHER I MAP 14 0 PARCEL 050 L 9 Bl A PH I 356 01333 ALLEN GEORGE S 3721 lYNNCREST DR 06/05/97 560 RES $64,500 $23,440 36.34 SINGFIELD TERRENCE M 152 0 026 00 0 l 4 BL H SEC 3 429 02087 JACK R NORDAHL BUILDERS 3514 SIDESADDLE CT 09/11/97 571 RES $66,900 $27,600 41.26 SINGLETON KENNETH lEROY 358 02424 WASHINGTON ROAD DEVELOPERS LL 234 CHARlESTOWNE WAY 07/29/97 565 RES $62,900 $25,000 39.75 SIRISAB SIRISUDA/KINGKAEW K OUT OF 011 0 222 00 0 L 17 BL B 146 00149 GLASS WILLIAM G/FRANCES S 2655 HENRY STREET 01/24/97 547 RES $114,000 $56,000 49.12 SKAlKO LOUISE M033 2 P 355 296 02869 DEAN WAYNE E 1787 PINE LOG RD 05/07/97 557 RES $59,900 $22,400 37.40 SKELLEY PAUL M 183/16 11 0.45 18 00891 SID BECKUM CONST INC 9 EAGLE POINTE DR 04/30/97 555 RES $149,900 $54,800 36.56 SKINNER BARBARA P 23 332 L 37 2393 01122 BAILEY VIRGINIA I 305 LAKE COURSE DR 06/23/97 561 RES $108,000 $40,120 37.15 SLABY RICHARD A JR/WILKIN S 1780 02127 COBB MARIANNA K 2516 GEORGETOWN DR 09/24/97 571 RES $63,200 $25,040 39.62 SLAUGHTER ALLEN JR 1345 4t . . . . . . . . . . o tit . . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 121 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 01839 WILLIAMS WILLARENA L ET Al 2011 M l KING BLVD 08/15/97 567 RES $20,000 $9,960 49.80 SLAUGHTER ROOSEVELT 58 4 361 1864 01484 DANIELS LEON C 06/27/97 562 RES $68,000 $29,800 43.82 SLAUGHTER-RUSSELL DOROTHY A 107 o 763 TWIN OAKS SEC I-A 2217 01545 PICKETT ALBERT M/DEBORAH W 3 LAKE COURT 07/15/97 563 RES $257,000 $63,160 24.58 SLAYDEN SCOTT M/ELIZABETH MAP 32 1 PARCEL 30 40 L 20 SEC 2031 01826 KOONCE JOCELYN/BROWN WILLIE 3323 TATE RD 08/18/97 567 RES $64,280 $29,600 46.06 SMAllEY EDWARD/CORINE G 84 2 171 L 3 BL E SEC IV 1348 01200 RICE JANET 0 3184 RIVER OAK RD 12/15/97 579 RES $62,500 $23,920 38.27 SMALLS ESTER M 55 1 030 1949 01798 CHANNELL J CLIFF 3224 WARE ERD 06/17/97 567 RES $60,000 $18,440 30.73 SMITH ALAN C 55 1 46 1126 02243 ALEXANDER HOMES 4367 WHITE PINE CT 10/31/97 572 RES $90,900 $32,600 35.86 SMITH ANTHONY C 1607 01787 HARRELL WILLIE l/WRIGHT 713 ALBANY AVE 08/15/97 567 RES $54,000 $21,120 39.11 SMITH CONNIE Y 61 1 169 864 01936 WASHINGTON ROAD DEVELOPERS LL 210 CHARlESTOWNE WAYI 08/29/97 568 RES $59,900 $25,000 41.74 SMITH 0 MELODY 011 o 222 01 0 L 5 BL B 2135 01608 CARRINGTON MARY W 2141 KINGSLEY COURT 07/31/97 565 RES $87,500 $36,000 41.14 SMITH DEBRA A 132 1 023 00 0 801 01034 UPTON HERBERT S JR 05/15/97 558 RES $67,145 $26,080 38.84 SMITH DEE A/SHANE M 107 1 167 789 00824 MClANEY BETTY/ET Al 1924 1924 KISSINGBOWER RD 03/31/97 553 RES $54,000 $18,600 34.44 SMITH DONALD/BRENDA 0 L 7 SEC B 1560 02223 RICHARD BIRD BUILDERS 4981 SOUTHS IDE FULCHER 10/08/97 572 AGR $99,900 $46,800 46.85 SMITH DOUGLAS/SARAH C 10.00 2398 01689 KENNETH SMITH HOMEBUIlDERS IN 2010 TEAL COURT 08/04/97 566 RES $139,700 $50,000 35.79 SMITH EDDISON/MARISA 165 4 5 L 20 BL E 279 02509 RICHMOND BUILDERS INt 2050 BASSFORD DRIVE 11/17/97 577 RES $91,900 $35,600 38.74 SMITH EUGENE JR 177 0 002 00 0 L 25 Bl E 711 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 122 sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SlB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 02907 LIFSEY GROUP 2508 lENNYS DR 12/16/97 579 RES $114,900 $45,800 39.86 SMITH FAYE 2314 01571 PARK PYUNG JUN/CHRISTINA J 2662 BARCLAY STREET 07/18/97 564 RES $64,000 $24,400 38.13 SMITH FELITA W 130 0 566 00 0 L 36 Bl Y 435 01216 BYARS MARY ELIZABETH/GARRETT 85 2937 HILlCREEK DR 06/27/97 562 RES $134,900 $52,800 39.14 SMITH FRANK 0 30 170 Bl C 137 02211 lAINE PATRICIA S 105 105 WINDSONG WAY 10/10/97 573 RES $43,500 $16,800 38.62 SMITH GREGORY K 007 o 213 00 0 214 00327 WALLACE A STEPHENSON/MELANIE 506 WINCHESTER DRIVE 03/14/97 551 RES $194,200 $69,200 35.63 SMITH GREGORY W 024 1 025 00 0 1074 02556 ANDERSON WILLIAM/JANICE 3711 WOODlAKE RD 11/12/97 576 RES $49,673 $26,400 53.15 SMITH ISIAH/PATSY 141 o 197 00 0 1390 01227 JONES CURTIS P 3545 WINDEREMERE DR 06/27/97 562 RES $50,000 $23,000 46.00 SMITH JENETTA A 118 110 L 11 Bl B SEC I 279 01907 FAGlIER BOBBY W/BARBARA G 1811 KARIAN DR 08/25/97 568 RES $58,900 $22,800 38.71 SMITH JERRY M/BARBARA J 122 2 252 00 0 L 15 Bl A SEC 3A 1506 02458 MCMUllEN MARTHA J 3606 lARKSPUR DRIVE 10/29/97 574 RES $49,900 $19,800 39.68 SMITH JOHN H SR/SHIRlEY A 119 115 L 2 Bl A SEC I 1967 30004 3124 WASHINGTON RD COM $430,990 $152,400 35.36 SMITH JOSEPH E 11 115 1 0.45 Appraisal 01537 WILLIAMS C MURRAY 1610 NORTHERN SPY TRAIL 07/11/97 563 RES $45,900 $16,800 36.60 SMITH LIZZIE MAP 134 2 PARCEL 072 L 11 Bl K E III 1809 00069 RABUN LARRY C 5230 STORY MIll RD 01/15/97 545 RES $143,000 $48,960 34.24 SMITH MATTHEW L/JESSICA B 361 01 1 15 361 0 1 18 1772 01654 EWING DOROTHY 15 2112 TRAVIS RD 07/30/97 565 RES $66,900 $24,840 37.13 SMITH MINNIE LEE M 154 0 055 00 0 l C 1935 02625 CAMERON-BERKLEY CO 1119 MIllEDGE RD 10/30/97 575 RES $303,000 $76,280 25.17 SMITH P NEAL JR/BARBARA L 44 2 95 1103 02024 CRAWFORD MARK B/CYNTHIA C 2244 CADDEN RD 09/15/97 570 RES $97,500 $40,560 41.60 SMITH PELBA J 121 3 029 00 0 L 7/B 710 . . . . . . . . . . . ~ I o 411~ . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 123 SBllple Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 00611 ST KITTS lLC 229 KITTS DRIVE 03/07/97 550 RES $62,900 $22,800 36.25 SMITH R lEE JR OUT OF 030 0 242 03 0 L 15 Bl D 1054 01605 GARVER FRED A 54 2424 CASTlEWOOD DR 07/30/97 565 RES $76,900 $30,800 40.05 SMITH ROBERT L SR M 014 o 039 A 727 01946 SANDERS ANDRE D/GLORIA 0 3407 MCALPINE WAY 09/04/97 569 RES $66,000 $23,000 34.85 SMITH RONALD M/MELISSA G 107 0 914 L 62 SEC I 1065 01477 BRUKER COMPANY 14 315 ALEX LANE 07/02/97 562 RES $77 , 900 $29,800 38.25 SMITH STANLEY R/STANLEY RHETT OUT OF M 0122 P 021 1978 30015 2058 WALTON WAY COM $345,250 $153,720 44.52 SMOAK DANIEL B 35 3 396 1 1.35 Appraisal 01166 JACK R NORDAHL BUILDERS 1404 BROOKSTONE RD 12/11/97 579 RES $78,900 $30,400 38.53 SMOLl ERIC TICECllIA E 787 02629 CRANFORD STEPHEN 3603 WRIGHTSBORO RD 10/31/97 . 575 COM $35,000 $9,000 25.71 SOARES GLENDA 917 02517 E BLACKBURN CONST CO INC 36 EAGLE POINTE DR 11/18/97 577 RES $141,000 $60,400 42.84 SODONKA JOSEPH 23 310 419 01406 ELLIOTT EDWARD M GOSHEN LAKE DRIVE NORTH 06/30/97 562 RES $30,000 $10,640 35.47 SOHN YONGSEAK 198 384 3.35 513 01697 BACKBURN HOME BUILDERS INC 07/25/97 566 RES $165,900 $68,000 40.99 SOLANO GUILLERMO l 5 EAGLE POINTE 487 00389 MCCORKLE JAN 2005 COLEMAN COURT 02/28/97 551 RES $64,900 $18,320 28.23 SOLES THURMAN/SOLEX JANICE F 098 4 145 L 7 BUTLER ESTATES 1133 02209 HUGGINS HARYL W/SUSAN K 1716 RUSK DR 10/10/97 573 RES $81,500 $30,600 37.55 SORENSEN CHRISTOPHERIJESSICA 213 0 115 00 0 l1C 503 01879 BUSH HOWARD S ET AL 1434 4084 RUFFIN RD 05/01/97 568 RES $45,000 $18,400 40.89 SORRELLS BONNIE H 195 3 22.50 767 02303 PRICE CHARLES PRESTON 1046 WOODBERRY DR 09/30/97 571 RES $96,400 $40,200 41. 70 SOSEBEE JAMES H SR 214 o 246 L 3 BL B 2257 00396 PIPPINHMARTIN/FAYE H 2239 OVERTON ROAD 03/14/97 551 RES $109,000 $44,800 41.10 SOSNIN BETTY K MAP 26 4 PARCEL 041 L 18 BL I 997 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 124 Sample Seller Land Dist, land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ra tio 30034 2009 WESTS IDE DR COM $148,390 $58,800 39.63 SOUTHEASTERN FAMILY HOMES INC 7 193 1.11 Appraisal 02007 MENGER DUlEE S 2021 NOTTINGHAM DR 09/12/97 570 RES $89,900 $26,240 29.19 SOWELL JERRY W 121 16 l 17/Bl A 265 01938 PHllANGIAS DEVELOPMENT LC 305 NEVIS DR 08/29/97 568 RES $58,900 $22,800 38.71 SOX VERNON l/GEORGETTE F 030 0 242 04 0 l 37 Bl J 2156 02362 PUGH WILLIE MAE 2416 LISBON RD 10/15/97 574 RES $51,400 $19,880 38.68 SPAIN WANDA 0 51 00430 SPRATLIN VALERIE 2119 WRIGHTSBORO RD 02/06/97 547 RES $45,254 $21,360 47.20 SPEARS CHESTER W JR 044 4 136 00 0 2314 00541 SHEPPARD DAN W JR 4035 BURNING TREE lANE 02/27/97 549 RES $64,000 $25,200 39.38 SPEARS CHESTER WILSON JR 198 0 169 00 0 L 2/B SEC I 1527 00383 JOSEY DAVID EIMYRA 0 5220 WOODRIDGE DRIVE 02/28/97 550 RES $84,500 $31,400 37.16 SPENCE GERALD P JRIBARBARA J 215 0 169 L 20 Bl A TIMBER lOGE 2224 01701 lEFlER lEE M/ANNA MARIE 2004 RICHMOND AVE 08/01/97 566 RES $50,241 $16,800 33.44 SPILlAIARDS V S 045 3 211 00 0 588 00048 JOHNSON EUDORA-MOORE 404 NORMANDY PLACE 01/14/97 545 RES $125,100 $46,000 36.77 SPIVEY WALTER P JR/PATSY M 017 o 082 00 00 L 15B 1095 01075 FAHNOE WIllIAM D/CAROL HUDSON 1320 BUENA VISTA RD OS/27/97 558 RES $91,000 $37,480 41.19 SPRAYBERRY DAVID R/AMY E 43 2 68 l 5 2300 02245 SIMPSON RAYFORD A/LORA M 1571 CITATIAN RD 09/30/97 572 RES $64,741 $28,320 43.74 STACK JERRY W JR 233/69 l 6 Bl B SECT 10 1621 01085 JOHNSON KEVIN J/SHERON 0 3211 HIllSVIEW DR OS/23/97 558 RES $68,203 $24,800 36.36 STAFFORD DONALD L JR 52 313 L 6/Bl C 2320 01564 PICKETT PAIGE A/PASTOR R SCOT 2710 HUNTERS CROSSING 07/16/97 564 RES $158,000 $56,800 35.95 STAFFORD NORMAN W JRIBRENDA l 006 0 234 258 00586 ALEWINE PEGGY M ET AL 501 MIllEDGE RD 02/28/97 549 RES $37,000 $15,000 40.54 STAFFORD ROBERT E/MIRIAM A BLDG 5 APT B 1690 01049 STONE HARRY 0 JR/ANNE C 3134 EDINBURGH DR 05/15/97 558 RES $96,800 $32,680 33.76 STAllWORTH CLAY N/lEILA E 24 2 83 l 14/Bl 4/SEC III B 1402 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 125 Sample Seller Land Dist, land lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 02391 GAILLARD PAMELA Y 3129 SUMMERCHASE PLACE 09/29/97 572 RES $103,000 $40,000 38.83 STANLEY WILHELMINA 42 4 173 000 0 L 4 SECT III 46 00227 NA PHILOMELA 2704 GORDON HIGHWAY 03/07/97 550 COM $150,000 $62,560 41. 71 STARKEY THU THI 1.84 1848 02523 NORDAHL HOMES INC 3437 MONTE CARLO DRIVE 11/14/97 576 RES $71,900 $28,800 40.06 STARKS AllCIADINE OUT OF 1430381090 L 2-D 66 02039 NORDAHL HOMES INC 3436 MONTE CARLO DR 09/12/97 570 RES $82,900 $31,200 37.64 STARR MARY L L 3/C 988 30033 2019 WESTSIDE DR COM $110,700 $36,800 33.24 STARRETTE JACK/CAROLYN H 7 188 0.94 Appraisal 00416 ST KITT'S INC 202 KIlT'S DR IVE 01/28/97 547 RES $55,900 $22,800 40.79 STARZEC MADELINE 030 0 242 03 0 l 18/E 2123 02963 YELVERTON TERRELL/STEPHANIE L 4005 RIO PINAR DR 12/23/97 580 RES $77 ,000 $26,800 34.81 STATEN NANCY Y L 3/0 SEC I 1877 01467 ESGRO SAM F III 3329 SUGAR MILL COURT 07/07/97 562 RES $113,565 $44,000 38.74 STATON JOHN T JR/MICHELLE S 016 0 317 00 0 L 15-A SEC 2 1787 02609 SID BECKUM CONST INC 5 333 ALEX LN 09/12/97 569 RES $77,900 $29,800 38.25 STECKER MARllTH A M 012 2 P 012 2391 01906 SUMMERLIN DONALD E 1919 HAYNE ST 08/22/97 568 RES $36,900 $12,200 33.06 STEED EVADNE 1482 01705 BYRD PATRICIA Y/WIELAND DONAl 3810 NICOLL DR 07/29/97 568 RES $64,900 $25,800 39.75 STEIN JOSEPHS C SR/LAURIE A L 14B 618 03042 BURTON GERALDINE F 2410 RIDGE RD 10/02/97 575 RES $51,000 $22,160 43.45 STEINBERG HENRY 1959 01577 MITCHELL DALE A 2534 BROOKSHIRE ROAD 07/03/97 564 RES $33,775 $19,560 57.91 STEINBERG HENRY/ESTROFF M C 648 03035 HUDSON COMPANY INC EAGLE POINTE DR 11/05/97 575 RES $136,676 $59,600 43.61 STEINBERG MARY C L 30 2179 03034 HUDSON COMPANY INC EAGLE POINTE 11/05/97 575 RES $135,738 $46,400 34.18 STEINBERG MAURICE l 24 2177 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 126 Sample Seller Land Dist, land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 01807 WALKER PEARL B 2056 TELFAIR ST 05/14/97 561 RES $25,000 $10,040 40.16 STEINBERG STEPHEN H/ESTROFF M 35 1 245 362 02818 KRAUSS JONATHAN S/ROBIN L 2407 MCDOWELL ST 04/30/97 557 RES $300,000 $111,640 37.21 STElLA RONALD A 044 1 035 00 0 1372 02154 SNOW RUSSEll HISANDRA LEE 3320 QUAKER SPRINGS CT 09/26/97 571 RES $115,900 $40,000 34.51 STELTER THOMAS/MEMORIE 016 0219 000 1899 03007 R l P BUILDERS INC 2916 ARROWWOOD,CIR 12/23/97 581 RES $122,900 $45,200 36.78 STEPHENSON LANCE lOT J 139 405 l 152/Bl'A/PH II 404 02526 CLINE JAMES R 4383 TRAYLOR ST 11/14/97 577 RES $48,200 $16,280 33.78 STEVENS TOMMY E 277 0 122 00 0 22 02184 WIllIAMS BETTY 0 2020 COLONY PARR RD 10/14/97 573 RES $55,900 $20,440 36.57 STEVENSON JERRY T 055 4 157 00 0 1201 00614 HURAYT ANDREW JOSEPH III MIDDLETON CT 03/19/97 552 RES $130,000 $44,800 34.46 STEVES SCOTT A 26 1 ~O L 4 BL C PHASE I 846 02738 NORDAHL HOMES 2011 EWART CT 12/01/97 578 RES $77,900 $29,200 37.48 STEWART APRIL A/FEBONG ANKFIO 398 01576 RAYBURN PATRICIA S/MARJORIE T 22 248 CAMILLIA AVENUE 06/30/97 564 RES $50,000 $17,600 35.20 STEWART lESTER L 016 0 010 00 0 l B 610 02945 COFER MADELINE 3622 MASSO IT DR 12/23/97 580 RES $56,500 $22,400 39.65 STEWART MICHAEL A 95 0 050/010 L 37/B TR C 952 00973 ROBERTSON STEVEN J/CAROl S 608 PEACHTREE RD 04/30/97 556 RES $136,500 $53,560 39.24 STEWART SCOT MORELAND 33 4 31 2093 02748 FERN JOHN E A 3163 FLOYD DR 12/01/97 578 RES $49,900 $19,360 38.80 STIllE KEITH E 688 02689 L P B PROPERTIES INC ET AL 27 MACAULAY PL 12/30/97 581 RES $79,750 $33,000 41.38 STIllWELL RUBY E 12 1 145 l 93 1795 01491 HERBERT HOMES INC 3875 CREST DRIVE 07/01/97 563 RES $73,900 $28,000 37.89 STILWELL DAVID L MAP 140 PARCEL 499 L 18 BL H SE lB 79 02804 REYNOLDS SARAH lAUDERDALE 1700 SUSAN CIR 05/07/97 557 RES $46,000 $13,080 28.43 STIMNAS PEGGY 1102 17 l 6/BL B 824 . . . . . . . . . . . I I 4 I 41 u . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 127 Sample Seller Land Diet, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SlB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 02305 WHISENHUNT E T AL 6 ZACHARY PLACE 09/30/97 571 RES $71,000 $29,000 40.85 STOCKTON KIM B 12 1 129 L 83 HUDSON TRACE 2167 00661 ROBBINS ANNIE LEE 4157 MACK LANE 04/17/97 554 RES $7,000 $2,800 40.00 STOKES MYONG S 154 42 7 L 3-1 2252 00618 WILLIAMS C MURRAY 13 EAGLE POINTE DRIVE 04/04/97 555 RES $149,900 $59,960 40.00 STONE GLADYS B MAP 23 PARCEL 330 L 35 EAGLE PO N E SO 945 02163 MCLEROY BENITA C/RUBEN G 3846 BELAIR RD. 10/17/97 573 RES $91,000 $32,600 35.82 STONE JULIA L/CHRISTOPHER J 052 0 071 00 0 L 6/B 1958 01858 PITTMAN DIANNE M 1133 AZALEA DR 08/22/97 568 RES $69,900 $25,200 38.05 STONE KEVIN SCOTT/TISHA E 013 4 071 00 0 L 13 BL 0 122 00814 ROSANIO EVELYN 2 2903 NORWOOD DR 03/31/97 553 RES $94,900 $38,200 40.25 STONE VICTORIA 053 0 107 00 0 l B 1168 02691 HEFNER KEVIN RIKHERI 257 HUDSON TRACE 12/22/97 581 RES $90,500 $37,000 40.88 STORY BIllY R JR 012 1 055 00 0 1480 02059 CUNNINGHAM GEORGE B JR/MARY F 5 CEDAR OAK lANE 08/29/97 570 RES $69,300 $31,280 45.14 STRELLNER DENNIS J/lINDA 0 137 17 01 L 6 1.13 1745 00445 WILSON ROBERT H/JANE QUINN 4925 OLD WAYNESBORO RD 02/12/97 548 AGR $23,500 $7,160 30.47 STRIGGLES RONNIE S/DEBORAH C 413!-1210 3.59 365 01165 LAMBERT RICHARD A/ENRIQUITA 4172 KEVIN RD 12/11/97 579 RES $79,900 $34 , 800 43.55 STRINGER DON O/ANNETTE 778 02158 BOYKIN MARTIN A 86 5152 HENERSON RD 10/17/97 573 RES $28,000 $4,760 17.00 STRITE KENT LIRHONDA J 347 1 TR CIO 10.68 2016 02142 TOTH TANYA/MICHAEL 3807 OLD WAYNESBORO RD 09/16/97 571 RES $55,900 $23,800 42.58 STUBBLEFIELD RAYMOND/GOLDIE 1636 00650 PALMER FREDERICK C 4014 NUTTE DRIVE 03/31/97 553 RES $92,500 $37,600 40.65 STUCKEY RONNIE L/DEBRA M 140 0 541 00 0 L 6 BL B 1856 01370 FRAZIER FREAl HENRY 3628 JONATHAN CIR 05/30/97 560 RES $53,900 $21,600 40.07 STUDEMIRE LOUIS T 123 4 78 L 35 BL F SEC IV 1422 02025 MARTINEZ EZEQUIEL 2841 WELLS DR 09/10/97 570 RES $91,500 $36,720 40.13 STUMP JAMES B 097 1 178 00 0 720 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 128 Sample Seller land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale. Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SlB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 01133 MCKINNEY LOIS J 2126 SIBLEY RD 05/30/97 561 RES $46,000 $20,560 44.70 STURGIS lINDSEY 55 4 23 l 2/BL A 2094 00702 ROBERTSON MAX V JR/ROSEMARIE 3642 BERMUDA CIRCLE EAST 04/18/97 555 RES $112,900 $42,240 37.41 STURKEY V ELAINE N 31 1 24 685 01064 HARE DOROTHY CAROL 2377 FRANKLIN ST OS/28/97 558 RES $40,000 $16,960 42.40 SUAREZ lUIZ JRIMARY 097 4 028 l 17/BL K 1793 01730 AARON JOSH 30 1583 HOLLEY ST 07/03/97 566 RES $10,000 $5,120 51.20 SUllIVAN LARRY M 058 2 P 271 1762 02764 MCCAIN WILLIAM J 3425 CANNONGATE DR 12/01/97 578 RES $61,900 $23,200 37.48 SUllIVAN MARCUS H/TESA N 010 165 l 13 Bl A 1178 00943 SMITH MARY H 3 4.5 10 3034 CARDINAL DR 04/28/97 556 RES $119,900 $44,120 36.80 SUMNER LEWIS TYLERINANCY 0 M 043 1 P 116 L C 1148 02634 CROUCH JAMES WALLACE 2128 CROSLEY ST 10/31/97 575 RES $63,300 $24,280 38.36 SURRETT RAYMOND P 121 4 158 L 12 BL 0 803 00846 PUCKETT VERNON RILINDA H 04/04/97 553 RES $68,000 $26,200 38.53 SWANSON JOHN O/BETTY J L C 2170 02604 SHACKELFORD BRENDA B 209 LAKEWOOD DR 09/11/97 569 RES $35,000 $10,800 30.86 SWIFT THOMAS R 026 2 124 00 0 0.23 2001 00962 C M S GROUP INC 1217 1221 ALDEN DR 05/05/97 556 RES $40,000 $12,800 32.00 SWINDOL CHARLES E/DORIS M 323 0 42 323 0 043 L 38 39 PH I 1554 00596 MCKENZIE ELIZABETH B 2118 CRESSWELL DR 02/28/97 549 RES $68,900 $27,480 39.88 TABER THOMAS M/CAROl M 57 2 100 1947 02622 HAMBY 0 MAJORS 3 2495-2497 DAMASCUS RD 11/04/97 575 RES $43,001 $18,280 42.51 TAHAN STEVEN/GLENDA 56 3 55 1053 02623 HAMBY 0 MAJORS 1 2956 KELLY ST 11/04/97 575 RES $43,678 $17,320 39.65 TAHAN STEVEN/GLENDA 56 3 054 1055 00332 ELDER EDGAR lEO JR 3644 ALENE CIRCLE 03/14/97 551 RES $48,850 $19,320 39.55 TALBOTT CHARLES E SR 107 o 353 00 0 L 36-E 951 01496 SULLIVAN ANNE K 4247 MATCH POINT DRIVE 06/30/97 563 RES $53,000 $19,480 36.75 TALLEY C ELIZABETH/CAMPBEll C MAP 31 2 PARCEL 102 l A BL LVI 140 n . 411~ . . . . . . . . 4 . o . . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 129 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SlB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 02741 LEISURE HOMES INC 329 ALEX LANE 12/01/97 578 RES $78,900 $29,800 37.77 TANGALO DOMINIC J 12 2 14 L 7 435 00921 BOOKER MARY R 2117 RICHARDS RD 04/29/97 556 RES $41,900 $16,160 38.57 TANKSLEY COREY L 98 3 243 806 01446 MAYER JOHN 3606 BARBADOS DRIVE 06/30/97 562 RES $108,900 $49,640 45.58 TAPPAN CINDY B/MARION J 1234 01817 COFER MADELINE 3620 MASSO IT DR 06/19/97 561 RES $65,900 $21,960 33.32 TAPPER FREDERICK MICHAEL 095 0 051 00 0 l 36 BL B 299 00954 L P B PROPS 11 MACAULAY PLACE 04/30/97 556 RES $76,900 $30,600 39.79 TARLETON VICKI A 12 1 112 L 66 1441 01519 HARTHORNE BARBARA ANN 3911 BOWENS DRIVE 07/11/97 563 RES $69,000 $33,600 48.70 TAYLOR DERRICK l/GAYE S 140 0 592 00 0 L 23-B 885 02934 LIFSEY GROUP 4604 DUNSEN RD 12/17/97 580 RES $125,500 $46,400 36.97 TAYLOR HORACE D/RYNAE 688 02542 F l 0 PROPERTIES INC 1826 FORMOSA DRIVE 11/17/97 576 RES $65,000 $24,000 36.92 TAYLOR JAPONICA L 122 3 154 L 21 BL C SEC III 2117 02086 DANIELS lEON/NONA 2511 GEORGETOWN DR 09/18/97 571 RES $59,900 $21,800 36.39 TAYLOR JENNIFER/CLIFTON 351 02339 BUCK DAVID FIPRISCILLA 2213 WARD DR 10/16/97 574 RES $39,900 $9,000 22.56 TAYLOR JOHNNY 098 1 071 l 7 700 00694 LAFONTAINE EARL JAMES/BETTY J 2614 lUMP KIN ROAD 04/21/97 555 RES $55,900 $18,600 33.27 TAYLOR KAREN M 096 2 150 00 0 L 2 Bl J SEC 1 328 01267 CENTRAL LUMBER CO INC NORTON RD OS/23/97 559 COM $90,000 $15,000 16.67 TAYlOR MARK 87 0 003 03 0 5.00 930 02361 JUTCO INC 4125 BURNINGTREE W 10/17/97 574 RES $83,900 $29,600 35.28 TAYLOR MICHAEL W/YVETTE S 214 151 L 11 BL C 66 00811 DOGGETTE W R/MARY M 3018 PIN NEEDLE RD 03/28/97 553 RES $138,000 $54,320 39.36 TAYLOR RAY C/lILLIAN E 43 1 89 597 01108 BOUTWELL J -RANDALL 1940 KINGS GRANT DR 06/24/97 561 RES $65,900 $31,160 47.28 TAYLOR SANDRA L/DONAlD W 110 4 260 01 L 20/Bl B/SEC II 1268 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 130 Sample Seller land Dist, Land lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 02100 STONE WILLIAM C/DOBBINS C 3040 WESTWOOD RD 09/19/97 571 RES $134,473 $48,400 35.99 TAYLOR SYLVESTER 18 275 L 3/SEC In 556 02578 COllEY MYRON l 3805/3807 SHORELINE COURT 11/10/97 576 RES $15,000 $3,200 21.33 TAYLOR WILLIAM B 184 92/93 L 4/5 Bl C SEC I 943 01835 JOHN C WEAVER HOMEBUILDERS IN 1004 RED OAK TRL 08/15/97 567 RES $89,000 $33,600 37.75 TAYLOR-JOHNSON DEBORAH A 270 0 035 00 0 L 2 1657 00575 BARKWElL DAVID H 2449 YATES DR 03/05/97 550 RES $15,000 $7,960 53.07 TEAGUE MARY ANNE 98 4 171 L 14/Bl C 1674 00014 STODDARD lELAND 0 619 BOURNE PLACE 01/03/97 544 RES $105,000 $49,920 47.54 TEDROW lINDA S 035 1 169 L 3/4 2160 00865 CURTIS BARBARA G 1017 STEVENS CK RD 04/04/97 554 RES $45,000 $15,520 34.49 TEMENAK ROBERT F 012 0 162 00 0 L 125 232 02091 HAll ARLEN/CAROL 2420 PATRICK AVE 09/10/97 571 RES $57,000 $22,800 40.00 TENDER SPROUT LEARNING CENTER 409 01408 JACK R NORDAHL BUILDERS INC 3506 SIDESADDLE CT 06/30/97 562 RES $71,900 $30,000 41.72 TENTION JAMES AIEVA E 129 682 L 13 Bl H SEC 1 PH 5 535 02697 NORDAHL HOMES INC 3203 OAR WOOD DR 12/29/97 581 RES $109,900 $43,200 39.31 TERRELL ALVIN A 143 505 L 15-2 1299 02717 MATHENY DANIEL P 3209 ALPINE RD 12/19/97 581 RES $51,900 $15,480 29.83 TERRELL CHELlA S 42 1 14 l 18 691 00254 MILLER AUGUSTUS/THOMPSON H LAMBERT PLACE 03/05/97 550 RES $6,000 $2,000 33.33 TERREll JOSEPH D/MARY F 058 4 440 00 0 L 18 Bl 4 1046 00910 SMAllEY MABEL CLAYTON 2455 WHEELER RD 04/28/97 556 COM $22,000 $12,560 57.09 TERRELL ROBERTISTEVEN 034 1 364 913 02564 MODTlAND CYNTHIA LENORE 3608 CONCORD CT 09/18/97 576 RES $63,300 $25,000 39.49 TERRY lEON 1212 01891 WARD RICHARD E 2106 GARY ST 08/07/97 568 RES $49,000 $20,600 42.04 TETTERTON SUE R 35 3 438 1082 02044 ANDERSON BRUCE C/KATHlEEN P 2083 YOUNGBLOOD DRIVE 08/28/97 570 RES $37,960 $9,480 24.97 THAMES ALBERT L/DEBBIE B 252 o 016 00 0 L 9 I 1251 41~ . . . . . . . ,. . . o u . . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 131 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 01382 LIVEL Y C MILNER 1009 HUNTERS GLEN 06/16/97 560 RES $122,900 $46,400 37.75 THAMES DONNA R 178 0 052 00 0 L 10 BL A 1828 02155 SELBY EDWARD H JR 7 6018 WALTON WAY WEST 09/26/97 571 COM $78,000 $18,080 23.18 THIELKE FREDERICK L 023 0 027 080/070 l 8 1909 01626 JORDAN YVONNE P/ALEX 3809 BEACON DR 07/30/97 565 RES $70,900 $28,200 39.77 THIMMES JASON P/JORENE J 170 0 133 1232 02809 BROWN CHARLES DUPREE 2032 ROSIER RD. 05/09/97 557 RES $65,900 $19,160 29.07 THOMAS AUDREY L/CARRIE B 132 0 216 L 4/BL B 966 02726 RICHARD BIRD BUILDERS 2311 PEROT DR 11/26/97 577 RES $90,900 $35,200 38.72 THOMAS FLOYD A 2346 02887 STRANGE WIllARD A/YAVALUX S 2633 CHAUCER DR 05/09/97 557 RES $125,000 $51,200 40.96 THOMAS GRADY W/BERTHA 0 l 104/Bl B 480 01532 RHODES ROBERT/FELICIA 3563 CRAWFORDVllLE DR 06/27/97 563 RES $86,500 $34,200 39.54 THOMAS GREGORY OISONYA 0 53 289 1408 00381 FAMBROUGH J HOWARD 1961 NEPTUNE DRIVE 02/28/97 550 RES $55,500 $19,120 34.45 THOMAS JAMES/HELEN B 122 4 179 L 25 Bl A 2189 00062 BRYANT CHARlES/SONHUI 121ST ULM RD 01/16/97 545 RES $29,500 $9,720 32.95 THOMAS L J/ANTONIA 151 9 6.60 1681 00528 HASAN A K 1620 12ST ST 02/21/97 549 RES $48,500 $13,080 26.97 THOMAS MAEDEllA H 059 3 381 00 1051 02632 PRATHER STUART H JR 11/03/97 575 RES $633,750 $178,800 28.21 THOMAS ROBERT P JR/USRY B H 24 3 003 3.70 770 02984 PEARSON GREGORY l 2092 BROWN RD 12/01/97 580 RES $21,934 $6,920 31.55 THOMAS SAEKO Y/SHIRMAN AL 195 0 044 00 0 1.33 2323 00970 ADAMS ARCHIE D/PEGGY J 2618 LUMPKIN RD 05/05/97 556 RES $61,500 $21,840 35.51 THOMAS THRESTON A 084 3 142 00 0 L 33E SECT THREE 1832 01838 FIRST AMERICAN TITLE CO 2633 ROYAL ST 08/04/97 567 RES $20,000 $8,600 43.00 THOMPKIN GEORGE lIlLIAN 034 1 238 00 0 1831 01109 JERNIGAN~CONSTCO~INC - 2350 BERLIN DR 06/25/97 561 RES $47,900 $17,760 37.08 THOMPKINS RAYMOND H JR/F G 82 0 425 L 26/Bl M 1278 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 132 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessllent No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SlB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 02399 WATKINS WILSON M 2030 BROAD STREET 09/17/97 585 RES $23,000 $9,360 40.70 THOMPKINS WOODROW C/PAMELA 0 27 3 153 2116 00179 lIVELY PROPS INC 2921 PILLAR LANE 01/30/97 547 RES $98,900 $35,600 36.00 THOMPSON DAVID N 039 0 215 00 0 l 16F 756 02702 NASSAR MICHELLE 2203 DOMINION CT 12/19/97 581 RES $75,500 $29,280 38.78 THOMPSON DAVID/HEATHER 017 3 056 00 0 1120 01615 GRANT CHRISTINE G/BYARS HELEN 1011 HOLDEN ST. 07/25/97 565 RES $39,500 $13,680 34.63 THOMPSON ELESTER/BERNICE 0 45 1 148 1219 00507 SEKlECKI STEPHEN E/SANDRA J 3120 FIELDSTONE CIR 02/14/97 548 RES $99,900 $36,800 36.64 THOMPSON lEROY 006 0 123 00 0 2397 01021 MATHEWS SYLVESTER/JENNIFER G 2527 DRAYTON DR 05/13/97 558 RES $66,000 $21,200 32.12 THOMPSON PAMELA J 94 o 120 l 22/Bl E/SEC lB 381 00323 ARRINGTON UTAH H 29 2921 RUNNING CREEK lANE 02/28/97 550 RES $79,900 $27,800 34.79 THOMPSON PAMELA 0 016 2 108 00 0 l B 966 00782 ST KITTS llC 226 KITTS DRIVE 03/31/97 553 RES $62,900 $22,800 36.25 THORNHIll ROBERT J OUT OF 030 0 242 03 0 l 30 BL H 765 00649 SPEARS JAMES E 1809 CENTRAL AVENUE 04/28/97 555 RES $63,500 $15,200 23.94 THORNHILL YOLANDA l 6 Bl A 1773 01727 BROOKS JOHN W/JEANIECE 2014 WESTFIELD ST 08/04/97 586 RES $65,057 $26,360 40.52 THORSTAD DONALD/BABBITT L l 055 4 189 00 0 l 5C SEC II 1737 02293 RIGGS lElON M/KIMBERLY W 27 3119 WDINBORGH DR 10/01/97 572 RES $108,000 $40,000 37.04 THURMOND GARY EUGENE/DEANNA W 024 2 068 00 0 L 3B 467 02956 FLEMING FRANCIS A JR ET Al 1111 MAGNOLIA DR 12/23/97 580 RES $69,000 $24,000 34.78 TIMMERMAN ROBERT GIll 013 4 156 00 0 l 27/E 1558 00723 MIllS BOONREUN 3041 LIBBY DRIVE 04/18/97 555 RES $48,000 $22,440 46.75 TIPBOONCHOO CHOB 107 0 667 00 0 L 5 Bl G 2080 01339 BRUCH lIlLIAN H 3513 WRIGHTSBORO RD 06/05/97 560 RES $165,000 $32,480 19.68 TIPPERARY SALES INC 544 00563 BROYLES DOUGLAS SCOTT 450 FOREST HILLS DR 03/13/97 551 RES $74,307 $26,680 35.91 TITLEY SHARON K 031 4 0 47 78 0 UN A/PAR E/BL 3 520 . . . . . . . . . . . o u . . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 133 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 00917 SVEDRRES EDWARD V/MARGARETTA 2030 BATTLE RD 05/31/97 556 RES $24,000 $11,440 47.67 TOBIN JOHN K 719 01002 JERNIGAN CONST CO INC 2141 PEPPER lOGE DR 03/03/97 549 RES $77,900 $25,920 33.27 TOINES EDDIE D/LINDA B 143 183 l 20/BL A/UN 1 B 2130 00877 NORDAHL HOMES INC 1005 COEARVIEW CIR 04/01/97 554 RES $70,900 $27,600 38.93 TOlVER ALTON C 432 00353 NORMAN WILLIAM H JR/MARY P 4444 WINDSOR SPRING ROAD 03/07/97 551 RES $20,000 $8,400 42.00 TOMLIN ROGER B L 13 BL M SEC VI 1674 01110 SKALKO LOUISE 1404 SPRINGFIELD CT 06/03/97 561 RES $69,000 $28,400 41.16 TOMLINSON DAVID ET AL 041 1 082 00 0 L 6/Bl B 1287 02164 ALEXANDER HOMES 2701 BRICK RUN PL 10/09/97 573 RES $92,900 $37,800 40.69 TONG WALTER 1751 00521 lOGUE ELIZABETH C 3105 JENNIFER COURT 02/17/97 549 RES $36,000 $18,160 50.44 TOPKEN PETE W 97 3 298 L 8/BL A/SEC II 671 00173 lOGUE ELIZABETH C 2670 CROSS CREEK RD 01/20/97 547 RES $46,000 $23,600 51.30 TOPKEN PETER W 130 248 l 9 BL Z 662 01972 NORDAHL HOMES INC 3435 MONTE CARLO DR 08/29/97 569 RES $79,900 $32,000 40.05 TORBERT TONYA C L 3 BL 0 419 02811 JACKSON BARBARA H 526 TUBMAN ST 05/13/97 557 RES $40,900 $12,840 31.39 TOUCHSTONE JAMES/SHIRLEY 035 1 259 00 0 L 38 1105 02433 FISHBURNE DONALD A/SARAH V 2712 WELLINGTON DR 07/25/97 565 RES $169,000 $75,320 44.57 TOWNER CHARLES E JR/SUSAN B 25 4 130 248 00699 HARRIS GEORGE E/lINDA 2 2503 HANOVER STREET 04/18/97 555 RES $52,000 $23,200 44.62 TOWNLEY BRUCE/ELISABETH 131 o 160 00 0 Bl B 631 01136 . INTRONA ROBERT P S/CHRISTINE 2306 WILLIAM ST 12/09/97 579 RES $188,000 $64,080 34.09 TRAMMELL SCOTT S 034 4 058 00 0 239 01245 HORTON DONNIE J 809 MITCHELL ST 05/30/97 559 RES $85,000 $44,000 51.76 TRANTHAM FRED A/BARBARA A 7 86 L 48 BL B SEC I 310 00422 ST KITTS 204 KITT'S DRIVE 01/31/97 547 RES $57,577 $22,800 39.60 TREDORE JAMES A 030 0 242 03 0 L 19/E 2172 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 134 Sample Seller Land Diet, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SlB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 02255 INGLETT SANDRA BURTON 1402 COLONY PLACE DR 09/30/97 572 RES $49,000 $19,840 40.49 TREFZ PAUL 12 430 UNIT 1402 1453 30010 1823 WALTON WAY COM $285,490 $94,520 33.11 TREFZ/TREFZ 35 4 457 0.51 Appraisal 30011 2733 WASHINGTON RD COM $383,170 $126,880 33.11 TREFZ/TREFZ INC 13 3 19 0.70 Appraisal 02798 RICHMOND BUILDERS INC 2775 DAVIS MIl~ RD 12/05/97 578 RES $87,900 $34,000 38.68 TRIMBLE CARDELL 177 0 053 00 0 l 7 BL K 2231 02677 MEYBOHM REALTY INC WALTON SQUARE OFF PK 12/31/97 582 COM $125,000 $52,400 41.92 TROTTER WILLIAM A III UN 7/8 BlDG 3527 131 02486 ALLISON JOAN P 1707 GOSHEN ROAD 11/24/97 577 RES $81,000 $33,200 40.99 TROWEll BRIAN A/DANA J MAP 198 0 PARCEL 048 l 7 Bl G S C II-A 1389 02281 CLIFFORD WILMA 1822 CATALINA DR 09/30/97 572 RES $37,900 $13,360 35.25 TUCKER JERRY 859 01321 KELLEY JOHN W 842 HEARD AVE 06/06/97 560 RES $257,000 $57,800 22.49 TUCKER MICHAEL C/LYNN M 035 3 348 00 0 L 4 178 00857 BARBEE JACKIE L SR/MARILYN 3938 OLD SAVANNAH RD 04/04/97 553 RES $87,900 $25,640 29.17 TUCKER PRINESS 184 0 059 2395 00880 DOSS WILLIAM TRAVIS/JUANITA F 2862 lUMPKIN RD 03/27/97 554 RES $83,900 $28,440 33.90 TUFT WILEY R 084 3 025 00 028 0 00 370 02348 LIFSEY GROUP INC 3039 BREEZE HILL DR 10/10/97 574 RES $130,900 $49,000 37.43 TURENR ROY LIELVERTA W 095 o 252 05 l 23 BL G SECT III 612 02628 PRUETT BETTY L 3003 JASMINE Pl 10/31/97 575 RES $47,900 $19,800 41.34 TURNELL PETER B II 85 3168 L 22 BL H SEC II 890 02893 HINKLE CORNELIA 4004 BRIDLE PATH RD 05/06/97 557 RES $59,000 $16,000 27.12 TURNER ANITA J 196 o 060 594 00016 MURPHY ZANE E/VIVIAN E 3807 CREIGHTON PLACE 01/07/97 544 RES $58,000 $22,200 38.28 TURNER JANICE G 170 0 046 00 0 4B 238 02354 WILLIAMS BERRY J 15 10/10/97 574 RES $42,000 $18,360 43.71 TURNER LATANYA D/ROBERT E 084 3 071 00 0 Bl C 268 . . . . . . . . . . . n . . . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 135 Sample Seller land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SlB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 01582 LANZAFAME ANGELA R 2421 DEODARA DRIVE 07/21/97 564 RES $89,900 $35,480 39.47 TURNER VERONICA M MAP 14 PARCEL 094 L 13 BL C PH I 779 02385 JOHN C WEAVER HOMEBUILDERS IN 66 OAKRIDGE PLANTATION 09/30/97 572 RES $86,000 $34,400 40.00 TUSSEY GEORGE T 270 0 062 00 0 SECT I 0.83 9 02129 FREDERICKS RAY 1908 COLONY PARK RD 09/26/97 571 RES $51,900 $18,560 35.76 TUTEN PHllLIP/PADAGETT MARIAN 1374 01475 GLENN BILL 1820 COVINGTON.PlACE 06/27/97 562 RES $63,500 $27,000 42.52 TUTT FREDA A 170 166 L 56 BL 0 SEC V 1940 01881 HANLY MARK GERRARD/KIM CARLEN 5 2923 STRATFORD DR 08/22/97 568 RES $97,500 $40,000 41.03 TWIGGS ALICE W 018 3 039 00 0 Bl E 779 00872 RASCAL ENTERPRISES INC 86 02/25/97 554 RES $11,200 $2,480 22.14 TYLER JAMES III/ROSITA 169 71 0.52 158 02314 INDIGO PROPS L P 2200 CENTRAL AVE 09/26/97 571 COM $89,000 $41,800 46.97 TYLER ROBERT W 44 2 252 l 4 BL EL 2058 00524 ST KITT'S llC 216 KIlT'S DR 02/21/97 549 RES $58,900 $22,800 38.71 TYLER TRUDI 030 0 242 03 0 l 25/G 715 00634 HARLEY JOHN J 1625 NEWBERRY ST 04/17/97 555 RES $20,000 $12,440 62.20 USRY BRAD/THOMAS ROBERT 45 2 249 L 130 1224 00296 PRIEST LOIS E 129 1627 NEWBERRY ST 03/13/97 552 RES $20,000 $7,840 39.20 USRY CAROLYN/BRADLEY H 45 2 250 969 00453 LIVINGSTON JAMES E JR/MARION PEACH ORCHARD RD 02/07/97 548 RES $120,000 $41,800 34.83 USRY DELOIS R 133 1 /2 9.00 540 00297 MOSLEY C GLENN 1503 ST LUKE STREET 03/26/97 552 IND $78,000 $26,040 33.38 VAGOVIC PETER P/JULIA 0 MAP 36 3 PARCEL 90 1650 00238 INGRAM JOHN GREGORY/DONNA G 8 1642 PENDLETON RD 03/20/97 552 RES $73,700 $27,560 37.39 VAl DEN VIVIAN L 057 1 130 00 0 L R 702 01088 SECURITYlAND l DEV CORP OS/29/97 559 COM $650,000 $220,320 33.90 VAllATRA MEXICAN RESTAURANT 12 137 11 01847 MAXWELtTHOMAS- - - - - 2 1883 NEPTUNE DR 08/20/97 567 RES $55,000 $22,160 40.29 VAN BAKEL KEITH A 122 4 236 00 0 Bl A 1974 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 138 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 01223 NORDAHL HOMES INC 3203 MARS STRAND CIR 08/28/97 582 RES $101,900 $39,200 38.47 VANCISE CLYDE 184 o 218 L 19 BL E SEC 4 235 01221 C M S GROUP INC 1249 ALDEN DR 08/28/97 582 RES $21,900 $8,400 29.22 VANDINA THOMAS J/KATHEY V 323 0 050 L 48 PH 2 215 01299 TSAO NING CHENG/JULIE A 1402 WINDSONG WAY 05/30/97 559 RES $40,000 $18,800 42.00 VANDRA GIRDHAR 008 0 350 00 0 1518 01858 ALEXANDER HOMES INC 2521 COMMON TRACE 08/15/97 588 RES $101,900 $40,800 39.84 VANHORN ANDREW S/DAVID D 013 1 175 00 0 L 1 BL B 94 02518 PHILANGIAS DEVELOPMENT LC 311 NEVIS RIVE 11/20/97 577 RES $88,900 $22,800 34.08 VANHORN CHARLES A/MAE Y OUT OF 030 0 242 04 L 42 BL K 488 01598 LEISURE HOMES INC 323 ALEX LANE 07/21/97 584 RES $85,400 $28,200 40.08 VANSCOY PAMELA D MAP 12 2 PARCEL 17 L 10 1495 02970 MCCOY AUDREY/FREE CLAUDE G 1975 BATTLE ROW 12/29/97 580 RES $24,000 $11,800 49.17 VAUGHN JAMES G/LINDA J 35 1 354 L 27/BL M 2089 00253 WIn OPHELIA 3502 PEACH ORCHARD RD 03/25/97 552 RES $45,500 $11,400 25.05 VICTORY OUTDOORS ADVERTISING 144 0 002 00 0 ET AL 1338 01147 J F J ENTERPRISES INC 2218 TRAVIS RD 12/08/97 579 RES $77,400 $30,840 39.84 VIDIS DANIEL R/KERRIE JO L 18/A BL D 154 01874 RICHMOND BUILDERS INC 3114 CONNER CT 08/25/97 588 RES $73,900 $27,800 37.35 VINES JIMMY E JR/TRACY A 085 2 188 00 0 L 34 BL A 508 00834 MCCORKED ROBERT T/DENISE R 2144 REEDOLE AVE 03/27/97 553 RES $81,000 $24,520 40.20 VINSON JASON M 109 4 180 L 28 HILLSIDE 1357 00592 YINGLING SHIRLEY I/MOORE G L 2322 NEAL ST 02/28/97 549 RES $57,500 $20,580 35.78 VISINTAINER JOHN F/JUNE E 097 4 089 00 0 L 25/M 1848 .- 01940 D & H DEVELOPMENT INC 259 HUDSON TRACE 09/03/97 588 RES $88,500 $33,400 37.74 VIVIANO MARY T 12 1 58 L 9 2172 00199 BAYAZES STEPHEN 23 2541 2543 LYMAN ST 01/30/97 547 RES $19,800 $11,800 58.59 VUKOVICH ELZABETH 097 1 128 00 0 L A 1847 00247 PRICE CHARLES PRESTON 1081 WOODBERRY DRIVE 03/17/97 552 RES $14,900 $5,800 38.93 W S HARRIS & ASSOCIATES INC 214 242 L 2 BL A 1419 . . . . . . . . . . . o . . . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 137 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 02844 HERBERT HOMES INC 287 LAFAYETTE DR 05/15/97 557 RES $119,900 $49,400 41.20 WADDELL RONALD K 18 388 L 17/BL A 2288 01430 PILCHER DONAL JAMES 1825 JENKINS ST 07/01/97 582 RES $29,900 $10,780 35.99 WADLEY RANCE M/DAISY 35 4 428 1105 02445 PETERSON CONSTRUCTION INC 1205 PARAMOUNT COURT 07/29/97 585 RES $123,750 $50,000 40.40 WAITHE MARKLEY 215 227 L 10 BL C SEC I 545 01888 SKINNER DONALD H JR 1922 WARFIELD DR 08/25/97 588 RES $59,900 $23,280 38.88 WALDEN BECKY C 110 4 204 L 4 BL A 425 02521 JOHN C WEAVER HOME BUILDER IN 3052 GREY FOX DRIVE 11/14/97 577 RES $124,900 $49,840 39.74 WALDEN RICHARD M L 24-A 237 00897 FOREMAN JEFFREY L 1017 STEVENS CREEK RD 05/01/97 555 RES $47,500 $18,720 35.20 WALKER ANNE S 012 0 229 000 288 02739 ASKEW JAMES C 3805 CREST DR 11/28/97 578 RES $88,900 $32,800 37.74 WALKER CHERYL B 405 02911 HASAN A K 3 2434 BREAM AVE 12/12/97 580 RES $57,300 $21,080 36.79 WALKER EDDIE J 086 4 063 00 0 BL D 73 01719 GA CAROLINA RESTAURANT SUPPLY 525 BROAD ST OS/29/97 588 COM $49,100 $23,840 48.15 WALKER ELLIOTT SR 47 2 028 000 1258 01392 PROCTOR J L 1838 WALKER ST 08/11/97 580 RES $48,000 $14,920 32.43 WALKER FRANK JR 35 2 587 L8 2124 00084 LANE VIRGINIA G 3510 CORNWALL RD 01/13/97 545 RES $58,000 $22,120 38.14 WALKER GREGORY 107 140 L 19 BL A 2348 00533 NORDAHL. HOMES INC 3308 COBBLESTONE COURT 02/21/97 549 RES $88,900 $28,000 40.64 WALKER HELEN EASON 132 0 516 00 0 L 16/A 1083 00305 ASKIN 0 FRANKLIN JR/SPENCE J 9 CLANTON ROAD 02/04/97 550 RES $19,900 $8,040 40.40 WALKER KENDALL/CANDACE OUT OF M 189 P 005 395 02295 NORDAHL HOMES INC 3450 MONTE CARLO DR 09/23/97 572 RES $65,900 $25,800 38.85 WALKER KEVIN D 1430381090 L 1B 414 01804 MCCORMICK -FREDDINE- GIBSON 2508 DEXTER DR 05/14/97 561 RES $43,100 $18,480 42.88 WALKER LYDELL D 108 187 L 8 BL B 94 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 138 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 02230 COOLEY JURELL 2954 SHELBY DR 08/28/97 572 RES $52,000 $18,800 38.15 WALKER OSCAR 109 1 12 L 3 BL G 1985 00564 BRANDENBERG MARY FRANCES D 1010 MAGNOLIA DR 03/12/97 551 RES $56,935 $24,400 42.86 WALKER ROBERT L/BROWN C NOEL 019 2 023 L 6/BL C 562 00215 EMERY WILLIAM R/SANDI MAE 15 2632 CORNING STREET 03/25/97 552 RES $68,727 $28,680 42.98 WALKER SCOTT M/SUSAN E 141 0 383 00 0 BL F SEC IV-B 1253 01572 LIFSEY GROUP INC 2508 BLOSSOM COURT 07/10/97 564 RES $67,500 $26,800 39.70 WALKER SHARON D 095 o 204 L 21 DOGWOOD EST SID 510 00561 GRANTHAM DON A/CAROL W 11 RETREAT RD 03/14/97 551 RES $405,000 $108,000 28.17 WALLACE A STEPHENSON/MELANIE 24 195 L 8 1352 01698 GOODWIN MILDRED K 8 2915 DEEB PLACE 07/30/97 568 RES $40,000 $16,560 41.40 WALLACE MARILEE E 110 1 135 00 0 L F 433 03000 WYATT PHILLIP H R3802 CLANTON RD 12/30/97 581 RES $39,900 $15,960 40.00 WALLER STUART RAY/CAROL D 189 0 035 00 0 L 10 1.14 296 00071 JIM DAVIS CO INC 3103 CAWLEY COURT 01/20/97 545 RES $77,900 $30,800 39.54 WALSH COLLEEN M 033 3 236 00 0 L 11 2235 01417 BEAUDOIN JEANETTE 1017 STEVENS CREEK RD 06/30/97 562 RES $27,500 $11,520 41.89 WALSH MICHAEL J 012 0 158 00 0 UNIT A-119 685 01011 NORDAHL HOMES INC 2013 EWART COURT 05/16/97 558 RES $70,900 $27,200 38.38 WALSH TIMOTHY S/JESSICA H 130 0 775 00 6 L 7/BL A 287 01983 ALEXANDER HOMES INC 17 2534 CARRIAGE CREEK 08/29/97 569 RES $114,500 $48,200 40.35 WALTERS ROBERT L 013 1 191 BL B 819 00355 MOCK MARY S 2128 SIBLEY ROAD 03/20/97 552 RES $46,900 $19,040 40.80 WALTON VICTOR R MAP 55 4 PARCEL 022 L 3 BL A 946 30028 WALTON WAY COM $439,450 $181,200 36.68 WALTON WAY ASSOC LLC 46 1 59 0.92 Appraisal 00956 ST KITT LLC 220 KITT DR 05/05/97 556 RES $58,900 $22,800 38.71 WARDLAW DAVID 0 030 0 242 03 L 27 1465 01973 NORDAHL HOMES INC 3403 DANVERS AVE 08/29/97 589 RES $124,900 $46,400 37.15 WARING ROBERT L/ANN 0 L 2-14 428 . . . . . . . . . . . H . . . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 139 Sallple Seller Land D1st, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Dig8S t Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 00177 GARDEN CITY HOMES INC 2833 HARWOOD STREET 01/28/97 547 RES $115,900 $45,600 39.34 WARNER MICHAEL/VERA L 139 355 L 102 BL A PH II 713 01382 NORDAHL HOMES INC 3307 COBBLESTONE CT 05/30/97 560 RES $87,900 $28,000 41. 24 WARREN MARY M 132 506 L 8 BL A 1115 02017 WORRELL WALTER GLENN 1118 BENNOCK MILL RD 09/05/97 570 RES $15,000 $5,280 35.20 WARREN PETER R JR/JENNIFER L 257 o 004 00 0 479 01942 BARRETT REX M/RITA T 2003 BALD EALGE DR 08/29/97 569 RES $120,900 $48,400 40.03 WASHINGTON FRANKIE L/MARILYN 272 0 095 00 0 L 2 BL C PH I 871 00340 LIVEL Y C MILNER 1012 HUNTERS GLEN 03/17/97 551 RES $130,500 $53,600 41.07 WASHINGTON HENRY/CRYSTAL M 178 0 048 00 0 L 8 BL A 1524 02029 ALSTON CHARLES BERNARD 2504 SADDLE HORD COURT 08/06/97 570 RES $70,500 $29,800 41.99 WASHINGTON VALERIE L 129 572 L 47/BL J/PH III 790 00534 NORDAHL HOMES INC 3460 MONTE CARLO DR 02/21/97 549 RES $78,900 $28,000 35.49 WATKINS LOUIS/LINDA M 132 0 524 00 0 L 5/D 1094 02575 JOHNSON MABEL D 3420 DEANS BRIDGE ROAD 11/11/97 578 COM $145,000 $47,840 32.99 WATKINS MARGIE FAY 107 0 025 REEL 158 PAGE 700 0.57 997 00538 DAMRON JODY DEAN/CARLA BETH 02/17/97 549 COM $175,000 $73,680 42.10 WATSON PATRICK D 88 1 78 0.52 1406 01078 BUCK DANA ALAN SR/JOSEPH A JR 512 TUTTLE ST OS/29/97 558 RES $38,500 $10,240 26.60 WATTS CAROLYN 35 4 048 L 68 2398 00020 ALEXANDER V THOMAS 3373 RAVENWOOD DR 01/02/97 544 RES $78,000 $31,800 40.51 WATTS HEAULEN/CRYSTAL 18 0 106 L 2 BL J 2021 00326 BARGERON WARREN/PATRICIA 19 2103 ROSIER RD 03/04/97 550 RES $77 , 700 $30,000 38.61 WATTS RONALD A/OCHEANE L 132 2 158 00 0 L B 910 01898 GRIFFIN WILLIAM R/STRAUGHN M 2350/2352 FRANKLIN ST 08/29/97 588 RES $40,000 $18,040 40.10 WATWOOD DAVID E 097 4 338 00 0 L 25 BL E 1311 02744 CLARK MARY J 835 FLEMING AVE 10/31/97 578 RES $125,000 $28,760 21.41 WEATHERS BENNIE/BEVERLY 603 02475 DAVIS JAMES E JR 1213 REID ROAD 10/28/97 . 577 RES $45,250 $18,600 41.10 WEAVER ALVIN G/ROBBIE J OUT OF 032 4 041 00 0 L 2 1764 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 140 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 02491 SIMANSKI RICHARD/ALFORD LINDA 1204 KENDAL CT 11/21/97 577 RES $86,003 $32,000 37.21 WEAVER DONNA L 12 1 41 1288 01228 VARNADO SOLOMON G 14 2511 DRAYTON DR 08/27/97 562 RES $56,000 $21,200 37.86 WEAVER ROOSEVELT JR 094 0 112 00 0 BL E SEC 1-B 292 00796 THURMOND VERA B 1017 STEVENS CREEK ROAD 04/01/97 553 RES $30,700 $13,120 42.74 WEAVER SONYA B MAP 12 PARCEL 191 UNIT 154 BLDG 5 855 02845 UNDERWOOD ERNEST W/PEGGIE P 286 LAFAYETTE DR 05/15/97 557 RES $129,900 $57,980 44.62 WEBB WHITNEY L/KERY L 18 382 L 11/BL A 2281 02464 BLAIR RUBY/LUCIOUS 2205 SAGEMONT CT 10/28/97 574 RES $79,900 $31,600 39.55 WEBSTER ADAM 1889 30005 3250 DEANS BRIDGE COM $251,780 $101,480 40.31 WEEKS CARL 108 449 2.11 Appraisal 02410 WASHINGTON ROAD DEVELOPERS LL 232 CHARLESTOWNE WAY 07/25/97 584 RES $59,900 $25,000 41.74 WEEKS MELBA M L 16 BL B 2087 01808 BIGGERSTAFF ANNA M MARCHIONNE 1738 OAK ST 08/04/97 561 RES $75,000 $29,200 38.93 WEINSTEIN HARRIS L 381 01649 MCFARLAND THOMAS A 2931 KIPLING DR 08/01/97 585 RES $89,000 $38,200 42.92 WELBORN WALTER S/YOLANDA 18 3 15 1705 01809 CORNELIUS DAVID A/VOUGHT R G 1513 MONTE SANO 08/19/97 581 RES $62,000 $26,400 42.58 WELCH DENNIS J/MARY BETH 44 1 196 399 00377 KENNETH SMITH HOMEBUILDERS IN 1118 FOX DEN ROAD 02/27/97 550 RES $124,000 $51,600 41.61 WELLINGTON WINSOME H/LINCOLN 165 0 083 L 9 BL B SEC 2 2307 02002 GREENTREE LAND CO INC 15 3130 A GOOLSBY RD 09/15/97 570 RES $23,000 $5,320 23.13 WELMAN DAVID L/JESSICA 265 21 L 15 88 01921 JACK R NORDAHL BLDRS INC 1009 WALLIE CT 08/29/97 588 RES $74,900 $29,800 39.52 WELSH HECTOR E 154 0 331 00 0 L 13 BL B 1831 02765 BAIRD N DUDLEY 9 INDIAN COVE RD 12/02/97 578 RES $175,000 $57,600 32.91 WELSH TERESA MAGUIRE 25 4 198 1 0 BLDG B PH I 1223 02420 DAVIS VIRGINIA L 1910 OHIO AVE 07/25/97 585 RES $59,900 $24,440 40.80 WENDLING JACOB W 43 4 153 257 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 141 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 00500 RICHMOND BUILDERS INC 2058 BASSFORD DR 02/18/97 548 RES $92,900 $35,200 37.89 WESBY WILLIE JAMES 177 o 00 00 0 L 29/E 2090 02504 SNEAD ROBERT S/BETTY M 2941 ROLLING WOOD DRIVE 11/18/97 577 RES $57,900 $23,040 39.79 WESLEY FELICIA M 107 o 547 000 L 17 BL C 775 00241 LIFSEY GROUP INC 3305 BALKCOM DRIVE 03/18/97 552 RES $117,900 $48,800 41.22 WEST DANNY/DOROTHY 095 0 345 L 5 BL E SEC III-B 1365 00597 CUNIC BRADLEY K 2558 IVEY RD 02/28/97 549 RES $44,900 $15,800 35.19 WEST MARCUS M/PARKIE 98 1 97 L 88 2003 00572 ELLIS ROY T 1738 GOSHEN RD 03/08/97 551 RES $78,000 $37,800 48.21 WEST WILLIAM E JR/NANCY F 198 0 116 L 10/BL A 184 02711 C & R HOME BUILDERS INC 2408 RAMBLEWOOD DR 12/30/97 581 RES $91,900 $35,800 38.98 WESTMORELAND JACQUELINE 143 0 708 00 0 L 17 BL I 748 02888 ARCHWAY BUILDERS INC 4122 BURNING TREE LN 05/07/97 557 RES $91,200 $31,200 34.21 WHALEY EUGENE L JR/ROLINDA B 214/161 L 12/BL B/PH 1 10 00809 COSNAHAM MARTHA B 2502 PINEBLUFF COURT 03/25/97 553 RES $125,000 $49,600 39.68 WHALEY HELEN S 18 353 L 36 BL C 583 02014 ADAMS ALEX CLINTON/CYNTHIA D 2405 MOHICAN RD 09/11/97 570 RES $83,900 $33,400 39.81 WHALEY MORGAN N JR/JAMI A 26 2 039 429 01885 PHILANGIAS DEVELOPMENT LC 308 NEVIS DR 08/27/97 568 RES $59,900 $22,800 38.06 WHEELER CHARLOTTE A 030 0 242 03 03 L 40 BL K 931 00986 SIMONS MINNIE C 2021 EVERGREEN DR 05/02/97 556 RES $54,900 $17 ,640 32.13 WHEELER KEITH B/ELLA S 055 4 007 00 0 L 17A 2191 02514 FRONT LINES HOMES INC 2634 SPIRIT CREEK RD 11/20/97 577 RES $106,000 $36,000 33.98 WHEELER RHONDA FAYE/MICHAEL T 576 02525 ALLGOOD ANDREW R WHEELER RD 11/13/97 577 COM $475,000 $110,880 23.34 WHIGHAM JOHN A/REBECCA K 30 0 101 3 6.93 20 00932 MORETZ JOHN D/ET AL 3007 CROMWELL CT 04/25/97 556 RES $55,600 $19,080 34.32 WHIGHAM LULA B 118 0128 00 0 L 29 BL B 942 01057 EDENFIELD NETTIE-HOWELL 3512 POTOMAC DR OS/23/97 558 RES $86,500 $28,800 40.30 WHITAKER THOMAS N/JEANNE T 132 2/41 L 19/BL G/SEC IV 1659 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 142 Sample Seller Land Diet, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 01180 BARLOW & BARLOW CONSTRUCTION 2403 RAMBLEWOOD DR 11/26/97 579 RES $95,000 $37,800 39.79 WHITE ANTONIO D/CYNTHIA 14 30 728 00 0 691 02249 PARSON JOHN M/SALLY M 4235 RHENEY RD 10/01/97 572 RES $93,400 $38,800 39.40 WHITE BARBARA ANN L 6 1552 02238 STRENGTH DONALD HOWARD 6 111 BARTS DR 10/08/97 572 RES $58,000 $22,800 39.31 WHITE BETTY D 1755 30001 1543 GORDON HWY COM $383,990 $150,600 39.22 WHITE BROS AUTO SUPPLY 88 2 68 0.97 Appraisal 02540 SMITH CHARLES T/BARBARA ANN 707 RAVENEL ROAD 11/14/97 576 RES $187,900 $57,440 34.21 WHITE C DANIEL/REBECCA A MAP 24 0 PARCEL 181 L 21 BL A W o GATE 2088 00408 SUNTREE REAL ESTATE CO INC 3515 GARDENBROOK DR 02/07/97 547- RES $54,900 $21,600 39.34 WHITE CAROLYN D 120 0 538 00 0 L 10/D 1795 01987 JACK R NORDAHL BLDRS INC 3401 SADDLE HORN RUN 08/29/97 569 RES $74,900 $30,000 40.05 WHITE CYNTHIA D 129 0 001 11 0 L 25 BL J PH V 304 02635 LIVEL Y C MILNER 1105 WALTONS TRL 10/31/97 575 RES $129,500 $50,000 38.81 WHITE DAVE D/INGRID C 178 o 059 00 0 L 2 BL B 814 02359 WILLIAMS C MURRAY 2245 RALEIGH DR 10/21/97 574 RES $83,000 $23,240 38.89 WHITE FREDDIE ST 071 2 188 00 0 2H 88 02228 GLOVER FANNIE 1829 CARPENTER STREET 08/22/97 572 RES $49,900 $18,440 32.95 WHITE LONNIE/AMANDA 58 4 157 2005 02633 CLIETT RAYMOND 0 2577 RHODES DR 10/31/97 575 RES $37,000 $15,000 40.54 WHITE RHONDA R 98 1 103 L 93 785 00155 JOHN DEERE & CO 4049 GOSHEN LANE DR SOUTH 01/31/97 547 RES $115,775 $41,200 35.59 WHITE ROYCE L 198 126 L 12 BLK K SEC lIB 378 02197 TARVER ALMANETTIC CASEDRIC 3 105 BART'S DR 10/08/97 573 RES $59,900 $22,800 38.06 WHITE VIRGINIA A M 030 3 P 003 825 01244 KIRKLAND JACK C/ENNIS S 1103 GLENWOOD DiI 05/30/97 559 RES $76,500 $28,840 37.70 WHITE WILLIAM C/DIANE M 13 4 48 L 27 BL F SEC 2 304 00826 DOUGLAS TERENCE B/PATRICK 8 1218 MEIGS STREET 03/31/97 553 RES $59,900 $23,680 39.53 WHITEHEAD DOUGLAS J M 044 4 081 L 33 1474 . . . . . . . . . . . o . . . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 143 Sample Seller Land Dilt, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 01871 PHILANGIAS DEV LC 310 NEVIS DR 08/01/97 585 RES $60,900 $22,800 37.44 WHITEHEAD PAMELA D 030 0 242 03 0 2240 00399 LACKMAN NELL G 2241 KINGS WAY 03/27/97 553 RES $107,000 $53,400 49.91 WHITEHOUSE ALAN B/TINA S 44 2 81 45 01100 JUTCO INC 4134 BURNING TREE LN 08/20/97 561 RES $80,900 $31,600 39.08 WHITLEY LINDA G 214/174 L 18/BL B/PH 2 1084 . 01294 R D & D INC 8 2030 GREENLAND. RD 08/03/97 559 RES $13,850 $4,600 33.21 WIDENER JAMES D/HUTTO JANET L 191 17 1352 02832 RASCAL ENTERPRISES INC 88 03/17 /97 557 AGR $11,500 $5,440 47.30 WIDENER KEITH/BALINDA 222 60/61 L 23/24 0.75 2068 02825 D & H DEVELOPMENT INC 263 HUDSON TRACE 05/15/97 557 RES $98,155 $38,600 37.29 WIERSEMA KIMBERLY R 12 1/58 L 11 1768 00946 HOLMES ZELMON B L 11 BL D 04/15/97 556 RES $2,500 $1,200 48.00 WILDER GEORGE 61 2 169 1239 01107 YOUNG YU-SHIU 2 2251 WINSTON WAY 06/05/97 561 RES $81,900 $23,600 38.13 WILEY MICHAEL W/SANCHEZ ANA H 131 o 284 00 0 L 1/A 1258 02503 BUCKNER ARLENE R 3248 AMANDO CIRCLE 11/18/97 577 RES $32,000 $8,000 25.00 WILKENS VALERIE R 769 02580 SMITH DENNIS LEVERNE 718 STILLWATER DRIVE 10/31/97 576 RES $91,098 $34,200 37.54 WILKERSON EDNA D MAP 6 PARCEL 011 02 L 7 BL L SE 857 00127 HENDERSON CORETHA G 2573 LINNCOLNTON PARKWAY 01/28/97 548 RES $58,500 $22,240 38.02 WILKERSON TRISHIRO J/ROBBIE L 153 0 264 L 19 BLK M SEC 5 1810 02054 WASHINGTON ROAD DEVELOPERS 208 CHARLESTOWNE WAY 09/19/97 570 RES $64,650 $25,000 38.87 WILKINS LARRY D 011 o 222 01 0 L 4/B 1877 02750 BLUME DALLAS 848-B BENNOCK MILL RD 12/01/97 578 RES $4,951 $2,240 45.24 WILLIAMS ALLEN M 281 70 L 19 1 718 01027 DEAN MARGARET S/JORDAN MYRTLE 2248 DARLINGTON DR OS/20/97 558 RES $57,000 $22,680 39.79 WILLIAMS BILLY F 071 2 167 L 8/BL B 447 01183 PENNINGTON.fATRICIA A 2931 BRIDGEPORT DR 12/10/97 579 RES $69,000 $25,800 37.10 WILLIAMS C MURRAY 52 0 334 L 4/BL A/SEC I 720 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 144 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 01943 VETERANS REALTY DEV CORP 48 PARK PL CIR 09/03/97 589 RES $205,000 $99,200 48.39 WILLIAMS C MURRAY 23 275 L 23 BL A 897 02985 COLQUITT WILLIE J/DORIS J 3115 TATE RD 12/23/97 580 RES $54,000 $15,980 29.56 WILLIAMS C MURRAY 084 3 069 L 13/BL C 2354 00709 MAAS RAYMOND D/DALLAS A 3518 NORTH PINES DR 03/14/97 555 RES $68,700 $27,600 40.17 WILLIAMS CARNELL/LISA A 145 0 108 1101 01203 PHILLIPS RONALD G/EDITH H 2502 REESE AVE 06/10/97 581 RES $49,000 $19,520 39.84 WILLIAMS DEMETER IUS 98 2 262 L 22 BL D 2148 02735 COOK FRED R 2042 BROWN RD 11/26/97 578 RES $45,000 $11,200 24.89 WILLIAMS EDDIE 211 45 TRACT B 6.82 288 00051 GUILFOYLE DIANAH 0 2025 FERNWOOD CIRCLE 01/13/97 545 RES $60,000 $19,000 31.87 WILLI~ GLENN L/SHARAN D 110 2 109 L 18 BL C 1251 02383 OWENS PEGGY H 5 309 MEMORY DR 10/17 /97 574 RES $39,900 $14,400 36.09 WILLIAMS HUBERT H III M 087 1019 00 0 F 40 01592 LANE ROBERT P/ANNE R 2244 WOODBLUFF WAY 07/24/97 564 RES $142,500 $51,600 36.21 WILLIAMS JOE.C/MARIE L 018 0 346 00 0 L 43 BL C 1256 01305 FREDERICKS RAY 1815 CIDER LN 06/05/97 559 RES $51,900 $20,760 40.00 WILLIAMS KIMBERLY C 123 4 034 00 0 L 24 BL I 1889 01364 NORDAHL HOMES INC 1725 BROWN RD 05/30/97 560 RES $121,900 $54,000 44.30 WILLIAMS LARRY E/ALICE C L 1 1134 00277 MITCHELL CRAIG S/LISA L 3106 SUSSEX RD 03/21/97 552 RES $122,900 $49,800 40.38 WILLIAMS LAWRENCE D/PAIGE P 025 1 009 00 0 L 12 BL L SEC II 849 01186 LINDSAY PATRICIA G 2570 RICHMOND HILL RD 12/15/97 579 RES $83,900 $28,600 34.09 WILLIAMS LEE MARVIN PATRICK 1549 02227 WASHINGTON RD DEV LLC 230 CHARLESTON WAY 10/03/97 572 RES $62,000 $25,000 40.32 WILLIAMS LISA L 15 BL 15 2011 01373 SINGLETON CHRIS L/VELINDA D 3804 CHISUM CT 08/13/97 560 RES $97,000 $44,400 45.77 WILLIAMS MARSHA A/JOE L 140 882 L 18 BL C SEC IV 1470 01071 NORDAHL HOMES INC 3310 COBBLESTONE COURT 05/18/97 558 RES $79,900 $31,200 39.05 WILLIAMS MELINDA L 132 514 L 14/A 1958 . . . . . . . . . . . o o . . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 145 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 02928 CLARK MARGY SHEPPARD 205 WEST VINE LAND RD 10/31/97 580 RES $86,000 $31,000 38.05 WILLIAMS MELISSA LYNN 019 4 00400 0 568 00983 CHAPMAN JAMES R 4008 NUITE DR 05/02/97 556 RES $85,500 $36,000 42.11 WILLIAMS RANDY T/TAMIKO A 141 o 452 00 0 L 9 BL B 1573 00786 FRONT. LINE HOMES INC 2618 SPIRIT CREEK ROAD 03/27/97 553 RES $76,500 $30,400 39.74 WILLIAMS SABINE KARIN L 21 BL A WALTON HLL 791 01784 NORDAHL HOMES INC 1745 BROWN RD 07/28/97 587 RES $122,900 $55,200 44.91 WILLIAMS THOMAS EUGENE/JOANN L 8 201 02477 ENNIS BRENDA H 2329 TOBACCO RD 11/24/97 577 RES $89,900 $22,760 32.56 WILLIAMS TOBEY R/TERESA D 155 0 008 01 0 1797 02590 THRELKELD ROBERT/ANISA 3408 KERRY PLACE 11/07/97 576 RES $169,000 $69,000 40.83 WILLIAMS TOMMY/JANICE . 440 00523 LIVEL Y C MILNER 1101 WALTON TRAIL 02/24/97 549 RES $132,400 $51,600 38.97 WILLIAMS WILLIAM H 178 0 058 00 0 L 1/B 708 02847 POWELL JAMES DONALD 1304 WINDSON WAY 05/16/97 557 RES $43,900 $16,800 38.27 WILLIAMS YOLANDA A 006 0 344 00 0 UN 1304 2388 01974 MURPHY ZANE E/VIVIAN E 4008 ROYAL OAKS CT 08/29/97 569 RES $84,900 $30,400 35.81 WILLIAMSON RAY JR 198 0 272 00 0 L 48 BL D 438 02217 DOYLE LAVERNE T 2433 APRICOT LANE 10/10/97 573 RES $55,000 $22,000 40.00 WILLIFORD GORDON S 19 Z 079 L 17 BL B 105 00250 BRADFORD THOMAS EUGENE 4118 BIG OAK DRIVE 03/20/97 552 RES $170,800 $88,800 40.28 WILLIFORD KEITH 196 0 098 00 0 L 19 1298 02767 SMALLEY LARRY J 1108 MURPHY ST 12/02/97 578 RES $44,500 $11,580 25.98 WILLIS ADRIAN A 45 1 168 L 25 BL E SEC 2 1417 00378 VALLELLANES-SANTIAGO F ET AL 3575 MORGAN ROAD 02/28/97 550 RES $76,000 $29,800 39.21 WILLIS JOSEPHUS/BARBARA 124 o 210 L 9 2318 02987 COFIELD MARY SMITH 133 GARDNERS MILL RD 12/29/97 581 RES $81,250 $32,000 39.38 WILLIS RUTH J 11 3 219 L L36/BL L/SEC IV 73 00284 ALEXANDER MICHAEL -B- - - 2153 FAIRCREST AVENUE 03/08/97 550 RES $78,000 $38,000 48.15 WILLIS SANDRA A 143 354 L 7-7 1262 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 148 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 00887 JACK BOWLES BUILDERS INC HAMPSHIRE TOWNHOUSE APT 04/04/97 555 COM $1,540,000 $628,920 40.84 WILLOW RIDGE LIMITED PTRSHP 25 3 33 02 TRACT B 5.25 99 02713 CHANG YOUNG 29 3852 FAIRIIiGTON DR 12/31/97 581 RES $58,900 $27,440 48.59 WILSON ABRAHAM 152 209 BL I 770 00849 CLARK ROBERT L 04/07/97 553 RES $81,000 $33,000 40.74 WILSON ARTHUR J/MARGARET B 2027 02725 L P B PROPERTIES INC ET AL 15 MACCAULAY PL 11/24/97 577 RES $82,325 $33,400 40.57 WILSON CHERYLE D 12 1 139 L 87 2238 00202 CHASE EDRIS/ROBERT B 1416 TROUPE ST 02/28/97 550 RES $59,900 $21,080 35.19 WILSON CHRISTOPHER/HEARN D 044 4 233 01 0 131 00819 KNOX JEFFERSON B A/CATHERINE 2719 HILLCREST AVE 03/31/97 555 RES $304,000 $84,840 27.84 WILSON CLAY H/TAMERA H 33 4 109 1111 02221 C J SINGLETON CONST 2929 ARROWWOOD CIR 10/06/97 572 RES $117,000 $46,800 40.00 WILSON EDWIN R 2408 01383 NORDAHL HOMES INC 1003 CEDARVIEW CIR 08/13/97 280 RES $80,900 $30,400 37.58 WILSON FRANK 211 198 L 28 BL A 1838 01581 ARCHWAY BUILDERS INC 4124 BURNING TREE LN 07/11/97 564 RES $76,900 $33,800 43.89 WILSON GEORGE 214 180 L 13 BL B PH 1 213 00349 DHAB INC ROLLINS RD 03/13/97 551 RES $8,900 $3,240 36.40 WILSON LEROY SR 0.71 1872 02478 BROWN RONNIE 1008 PATRIOT DRIVE 11/24/97 577 RES $114,000 $51,800 45.26 WILSON MILTON/SYLVIA B 215 0 181 L 3 BL A SEC I 1789 00851 HENRY HELEN K 2225 MORNINGS IDE DR 04/07/97 553 RES $140,000 $51,200 38.57 WILSON PARIS JR 26 4 155 L 4 2126 02189 RHODES CYNTHAI B 2020 CHESTER AVE 10/07/97 573 RES $30,000 $13,~00 44.87 WILSON THOMAS J/KATIE R L 3/BL F 1099 02274 BRADDOCK W J/LOIS ELIZABETH 736 DON ROVER RD 10/03/97 572 RES $81,500 $29,380 38.02 WIMBERLY ANITA/FLIM JR 325 o 050 940 01682 DORN ATHENA R 2274 WHITE RD 08/01/97 585 RES $68,000 $18,800 27.85 WINFIELD WALTER C/GLORIA Y 057 H4 093 01 0 02 057 4 093 00 o 7 03 2117 41. . . . . . . . . . . u u . . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 147 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land ~ot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 00878 BRENNAN RICHARD J/NANCY J 1594A GOSHEN RD 03/20/97 554 RES $49,900 $21,400 42.89 WINGATE PAMELA 199 0 025 00 0 394 00705 MERRITT ROBERT M/ELIZABETH B 2444 DEODARA DRIVE 04/22/97 555 RES $90,000 $33,840 37.38 WINGROVE JAMES D/DONNA E MAP 14 PARCEL 80 L 2 BL B PH II 762 00231 NORDAHL HOMES INC 3408 DANVERS AVENUE 03/21/97 552 RES $122,900 $48,400 37.75 WINSTON GWENDOLYN L/ARCHIE C 143 0 679 00 0 L 3.13 598 00350 ARNOLD INEZ C/MORRIS D TRACT 14 SOUTH SIDE OF BENNO 03/18/97 551 RES $22,000 $6,380 28.91 WINTER ANGELA 257 0 027 00 0 5.10 1880 01177 LIFSEY GROUP 4519 RIDGE RUN DR 12/12/97 579 RES $132,500 $48,800 38.83 WIRTH ANTHONY J/CONNIE 180 00554 CLARK LAURA A/SCOTT A 928 HEARD AVE 03/17/97 551 RES $115,000 $40,400 35.13 WITCHER JENNIFER 1273 00701 KUO YA LOU 9 3038 BRIGHTON STREET 04/15/97 555 RES $51,150 $20,000 39.10 WITT OPHELIA M 110 3 140 00 0 L A 851 02151 WHISENHUNT CHILDRES INC 19 MACAULAY PLACE 09/28/97 571 RES $77,890 $33,400 42.99 WITTKE LYNN D/GRACE P L 89 1837 02886 STARNES SULLIE 1208 OAKDALE RD 12/23/97 581 RES $85,000 $26,200 40.31 WOLBERT ROBERT A/CATHY S 013 2 119 L 22/21 1743 01497 PRITCHETT CHARLES C 3403 MERRIMAC AVENUE 06/19/97 563 RES $79,900 $31,920 39.95 WOMACK JACK L II 132 2 92 L 18 SHANGRILA EST 155 02749 JACKSON MARY LEE 3655 KARLEEN RD 12/01/97 578 RES $78,900 $27,200 34.47 WOODARD MEACHELL/DWAYNE 697 00879 HUNTER CLAYTON M 2228 BIRNAM 03/28/97 554 RES $58,900 $24,800 42.11 WOODS KIMBERLY 0 057 3 201 00 0 384 00629 LIFSEY JAMES T/VIRGINIA B 2640 DRAYTON DRIVE 04/25/97 555 RES $55,600 $21,800 38.85 WOODS SELINA R/CATASHIA A 108 0 017 L 21 BL B SEC 1A 1584 00038 MCLOWERY ELROD 3107 EDINBURGH DR 01/08/97 545 RES $111,500 $46,800 41.79 WOOLWINE BERMAN J/MAYRA E 24 2 62 864 02015 E BLACKBURNCONSTCO INC 19 EAGLE POINTE DR 09/12/97 570 RES $155,000 $81,200 39.48 WOOTEN THOMAS E/MARY M 23 327 441 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 148 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 00989 HILLIARD DEBORAH Y 1588 B GOSHEN RD 05/02/97 558 RES $59,457 $27,000 45.41 WORKS DENNY E/CAROL ANNE 199 0 091 00 0 2232 00931 GERGUSON DONALD C/KAREN A 2322 WOODBINE RD 04/30/97 556 RES $99,985 $38,000 38.01 WORLEY DAVID B 20 3 98 933 02618 POLING RALPH 4426 WINDROW SPG RD 11/01/97 575 RES $16,000 $8,800 42.50 WREN DAVID 1379 01788 WILLIAMS JAN BARBARA 3018 LONSDALE DR 08/13/97 567 RES $67,900 $28,380 38.82 WREN JAMES E/MCMILLAN JESSICA 110 3 209 870 02426 NORDAHL HOMES INC 1759 BROWN ROAD 07/25/97 565 RES $117,900 $48,800 41.39 WRIGHT ANTHONY L 213 168 L 12 173 00184 NORDAHL HOMES INC 3827 DORSET ST 01/31/97 547 RES $121,900 $45,200 37.08 WRIGHT BETTY J 143/661 L 1-15 474 00692 MCINTYRE JUANITA B 7 1915 THIRD AVENUE 04/07/97 555 RES $20,000 $8,240 31.20 WRIGHT BRENDA D 72 3 182 00 0 BL R 319 01201 GILL ROBERT K/BEVERLY I 2343 RIDGE RD 08/24/97 581 RES $58,000 $22,280 38.41 WRIGHT GUY D/DEBRA A 85 I 31 BL G SEC III L 31 2128 00582 NORDAHL HOMES INC 3484 MONTE CARLO DR 02/28/97 550 RES $69,900 $29,200 41. 77 WRIGHT JASON R/LEWIS REBECCA 132 0 528 00 0 L 7/D 77 02033 FAVOR ANNIE RUTH MOON 3060 HAWTHORNE DR 08/29/97 570 RES $34,450 $13,780 39.94 WRIGHT MELVIN/EVELYN B 98 2 91 L 3/BL B SEC 2 944 02138 CLASSIC RENOVATIONS INC 2207 TODOR DR 09/18/97 571 RES $58,900 $19,800 33.62 WRIGHT SAMUEL E 86 4 72 1580 01783 MERCHANT HUBERT W 2223 MORNINGS IDE DR 06/30/97 567 RES $130,000 $44,800 34.46 WYATT DONALD W/SUSAN L 028 4 158 00 1176 00707 DAVIS FRANCES BATTEY 827 MILLEDGE RD B-2 04/03/97 555 RES $142,000 $48,520 34.17 WYNN MARGARET S 34 4/076 32 0 UN IT 2 BL B 720 02536 WASHINGTON ROAD DEVELOPERS LL 14 CHARLESTOWNE DRIVE 11/14/97 576 RES $66,600 $25,000 37.54 YANCEY PATRICIA M/CYRIL R OUT OF 011 0 222 01 0 L 7 BL A 2164 00095 WREN DONALD GORDON I 2118 CORSLEY STREET 01/17/97 546 RES $47,000 $18,840 40.09 YAWN WILLIAM M 122 3/32 L F 336 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 149 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessllent No. Taxpayer on Digest Map/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 02678 JUTCO INC 4131 BURNING TREE LN 12/30/97 582 RES $85,900 $31,600 38.79 YELVERTON TERRELL J/STEPHANIE 214/154 L 14 BL C 58 01197 WESCOTT RICHARD G M/MARGIE 1409 HABERSHAM DR 11/28/97 579 RES $83,500 $33,520 40.14 YONESAKI RONNIE D/JANET SUE 41 2 20 1831 02940 WATSON MITCHELL HOME BLDR INC 1119 FOX DEN RD 12/19/97 580 RES $143,900 $52,000 38.14 YOUNG ALVIN D/RUTH L 165 0 067 00 0 L 6/BL C SEC II 787 00756 BROWN CRAIG L 2338 HELSINKI DR 03/28/97 554 RES $50,000 $16,720 33.44 YOUNG EDGAR 82 258 978 00873 RASCAL ENTERPRISES INC 88 L 2 SECT I 01/13/97 554 AGR $10,995 $3,760 34.20 YOUNG JOHN/VICKIE 222 29 0.59 154 01924 WILLIAM J CROSBY BUILDERS INC 2027 MIMS RD 08/29/97 568 RES $81,100 $30,160 37.19 YOUNG STANLEY M/SHANA L 251 75 L 1 1880 02318 MEYBOKM ROBERT L/SINGH HARIND 10 HILLCREEK DR 10/13/97 574 COM $50,000 $13,800 27.60 YOUNG TERRELL L/KARYN G M 0300264000 1412 00510 WALKER ROBERT L 3218 EAST GERALD DR 02/11/97 549 RES $39,500 $17 , 480 44.25 YOUNG THAMETH 110 4 328 L 8/BL G SEC IV 145 01402 BANKS JAMES D/JUDITH W 1410 COLONY PLACE 06/30/97 562 RES $35,000 $18,640 47.54 YOUNGBLOOD JOHN H 120 438 325 30002 827 FIFTEENTH ST COM $339,480 $140,200 41.30 YOUNTS PROP INC 46 1 15 0.72 Appraisal 01882 FORE LORINDA JACKSON 3030 DEANS BRIDGE RD 07/18/97 586 COM $100,000 $61,840 61.84 YUN I W/PATEL ATEEOAHMED S 97 11149 144 97 1 136 154 02672 RASCAL ENTERPRISES INC 124 10/06/97 582 RES $17,900 $8,600 48.04 ZALE JOSEPH BIll/DEBORAH J 322 18 L 10 5.01 1451 02041 CHAMBERS PERRY N/LAURA A 4007 BURNING TREE LANE 09/15/97 570 RES $73,500 $34,800 47.35 ZIELINSKI LEONARD F 198 0 097 00 0 1132 02495 FICZERE JOHN B/NORMA J 203 WARREN ROAD 11/14/97 577 RES $66,000 $28,680 43.45 ZIMMERMAN GUY STEVEN 11 110 1179 01272 JACK R NORDAHL BLDRS INC 3503 SIDESADDLE CT 05/30/97 559 RES $72,900 $30,000 41.15 ZOLLICOFFER DEBBIE T 129 0 676 00 0 L 7 BL H 972 County: 121 RICHMOND 1998 SALES RATIO STUDY 150 Sample Seller Land Dist, Land Lot, Street Date Sold Deed Book Type Sale Assessment No. Taxpayer on Digest Ma~/Parcel, SLB Acreage Deed Page Prop Price Amount Ratio 02586 JAMES MORRIS CONSTRUCTION 2415 RAMBLEWOOD DR 11/07/97 576 RES $83,500 $35,000 41.92 ZUCKERMAN DANIEL A/JULIE 663 MEDIAN RATIO 38.98 . . . . . . . . . . .